Axent Holdings Pty Ltd v Compusign Australia Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Axent Holdings Pty Ltd v Compusign Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 1102

File number: VID 1408 of 2016
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 18 September 2017
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for security for costs – application dismissed
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Amcor Limited v Barnes [2015] VSC 90

Angas Securities Limited v Savills (SA) Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 868

Attorney-General (Botswana) v Aussie Diamond Products Pty Ltd [2009] WASC 299

Baygol Pty Limited v Huntsman Chemical Co Australia Pty Limited t/a RMAX [2004] FCA 1248

Bell Wholesale Co Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2 FCR 1

Concrete Mining Structures Pty Ltd v Cellcrete Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2016] FCA 360

Christou v Stanton Partners Australasia Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 176

Farmitalia Carlo Erba SrL v Delta West Pty Ltd (1994) 28 IPR 336

Hii v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (No 3) [2016] FCA 58; 238 FCR 304

Madgwick v Kelly [2013] FCAFC 61; 212 FCR 1

Mecrus Pty Ltd v Industrial Energy Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 103; 327 ALR 523

Probiotec Limited v The University of Melbourne [2008] FCAFC 5; 166 FCR 30

Treloar Constructions Pty Limited v McMillan [2016] NSWCA 302

Date of hearing: 4 September 2017
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 68
Counsel for the Applicant: S K Gatford
Solicitor for the Applicant: Comlaw Barristers and Solicitors
Counsel for the Respondents: C H Smith
Solicitor for the Respondents: Rankin & Co

ORDERS

VID 1408 of 2016
BETWEEN:

AXENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 096 387 370) T/A AXENT GLOBAL

Applicant

AND:

COMPUSIGN AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 070 157 925)

First Respondent

HI-LUX TECHNICAL SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 006 654 691)

Second Respondent

COMPUSIGN SYSTEMS PTY LTD (ACN 161 950 205)

Third Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

COMPUSIGN AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 070 157 925)
(and another named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Claimant

AND:

AXENT HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 096 387 370) T/A AXENT GLOBAL

Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

KENNY J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 SEPTEMBER 2017

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The second respondent’s application for security for costs be dismissed.

2.The second respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application to the date of this order, but reserving to the applicant the ability to submit that Rule 40.13 ought not apply and also as to the most appropriate method of assessment of such costs.

3.On or before 25 September 2017 the applicant file and serve short submissions on costs (limited to two pages) as to the issues identified in order 2 above.

4.On or before 2 October 2017 the second respondent file and serve any submissions in reply to the submissions in order 3 above (also limited to two pages).

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Axent Holdings Pty Ltd v Compusign Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCA 1102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Axent Holdings Pty Ltd v Compusign Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) involved a dispute over an application for security for costs made by Hi-Lux, a party to the litigation, which was dismissed by the court. The core of the dispute lay in Axent’s claim that Compusign respondents infringed certain patent claims through the sale and manufacture of variable speed limit signs and lane use signs. In addition to direct infringement, Axent alleged various forms of contributory infringement, including authorizing and inducing others to use their systems in a way that infringed the patent. The respondents, however, had admitted to certain aspects of the importation, manufacture, and sale of these products, though they contested other allegations of infringement.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Hi-Lux was entitled to an order for security for costs from the respondents. The court needed to assess whether the threshold criteria for such an order were met, considering the financial standing of Axent and the prospects of Hi-Lux being awarded costs. Hi-Lux had requested that Axent provide financial information to support its ability to pay any costs awarded against it. The respondents, in turn, argued against the admissibility and reliability of the financial information provided by Axent, asserting that it was vague and not based on sufficient expertise.

The court found that the confidential financial information provided by Axent was not admissible due to its vagueness and lack of a clear basis for the conclusions drawn. Despite Hi-Lux bearing the onus of proving the threshold criteria for an order of security for costs, the court concluded that the financial information presented was insufficient to meet that burden. Consequently, the application for security for costs was dismissed, and Hi-Lux was ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the application. The court also outlined a schedule for further submissions on the assessment of these costs, ensuring that both parties had the opportunity to present their views within a limited scope.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second respondent’s application for security for costs be dismissed.

2. The second respondent pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application to the date of this order, but reserving to the applicant the ability to submit that Rule 40.13 ought not apply and also as to the most appropriate method of assessment of such costs.

3. On or before 25 September 2017 the applicant file and serve short submissions on costs (limited to two pages) as to the issues identified in order 2 above.

4. On or before 2 October 2017 the second respondent file and serve any submissions in reply to the submissions in order 3 above (also limited to two pages).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In light of the events as they unfolded at the hearing, however, only the application for security for costs made by Hi-Lux falls for determination at this time. The application for security for costs made by the Compusign respondents has been adjourned to a date to be fixed. For the reasons set out below, I would dismiss the application made by Hi-Lux.BACKGROUND The hearing of Axent’s claim for infringement (on liability only) and the cross-claim for revocation has been set down for 27 November 2017 for five days. Mediation is fixed for 3 November 2017. Axent has alleged that the Compusign respondents’ sale and manufacture of variable speed limit signs and lane use signs infringe the claims of the patent in suit. Each of the respondents has made relevant admissions in relation to the importation, manufacture or sale of their variable speed limit sign products and lane use sign products. As, however, its position statement on infringement discloses, Axent alleges different types of infringing conduct. Thus, Axent further alleges (at paragraphs 21–22) that the respondents have:a.instructed, further or alternatively, directed, procured or induced, others to use their systems so as to infringe each of the claims of the patent;b. authorized others to infringe each of the claims of the patent;c.joined in a common design with others to infringe each of the claims of the patent; andd.contravened section 117 of the Patents Act.Axent alleges that “[t]his is through [the respondents] providing detailed specifications for their sign systems, operating and maintenance manuals and other documentation to United Group Infrastructure (UGL)”. Further, Axent alleges, in paragraph 23 of its position statement, that:a.each individual supply, as well as being an act of primary infringement – and also to the extent that it is not: if, for example, a controller is not supplied (which Axent denies, as each sign contains a CPU) – is an infringement of the kind listed in paragraph 20; andb.subsequent acts of repair and replacement in whole or in part of a signage system are both a primary infringement and a separate act of infringement of the kind listed in paragraph 20, as they amount to authorization to the relevant third party for them or another to engage and/or continue to engage in use of the signage system, which is a separate act of primary infringement; andc.servicing and maintenance of a signage system or the giving instructions or assistance to a third party to do this is also a separate act of infringement of the kind listed in paragraph 20, as it amounts to authorization to the relevant third party for them or another to engage and/or continue to engage in use of the signage system, which is a separate act of primary infringement. For completeness, I note that Axent further states that there are three other issues relevant to the respondents’ liability for patent infringement: (1) whether any of the infringing acts are statute-barred; (2) the precise period for which the patent was in a state of lapse due to Axent’s failure to pay a renewal fee; and (3) whether the amendment of the patent ought to affect Axent’s ability to recover damages.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I interpolate here that Hi-Lux objected to the admissibility of confidential annexure CL-9, on the basis that Mr Fontaine was not shown to have the appropriate expertise to express an admissible opinion about the valuation of assets under s 76 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (Evidence Act) and the evidence was vague and did not indicate the basis for the stated conclusions. In any event, so Hi-Lux submitted, Mr Fontaine should have given that evidence directly and be subject to cross-examination. All parties took advantage of the exception to the hearsay rule in interlocutory proceedings set out in s 75 of the Evidence Act, as they were entitled to do. One might reasonably expect the sole director of Axent would have first-hand knowledge of some of the facts asserted in confidential annexure CL-9, although perhaps not all. One might also infer from the nature of some of the asserted facts that they constitute or depend on opinions about the value of assets and other matters, the basis of which is not disclosed. I am inclined to the view therefore that confidential annexure CL-9 is not admissible, as counsel for Hi-Lux submitted. Even if it were admissible I would attach little, if any, weight to it. This is because I accept, as Hi-Lux submitted, that confidential annexure CL-9 contains broadly-stated conclusions, the bases for which are not explained. The inclusion of a statement of this kind by the company’s director as an annexure to an affidavit sworn by the company’s solicitor (on information and belief) can scarcely be regarded as persuasive, even acknowledging that Hi-Lux bore the substantive onus with respect to its application, including that the threshold issue was satisfied. It was in this context that counsel for Hi-Lux sought to tender annexure RRR-4 to Mr Rankin’s first affidavit, the admissibility of which was the subject of initial objection by Ms Gatford, counsel for Axent. The background to the provision of this information can be briefly stated. Hi-Lux’s solicitors wrote to the solicitor for Axent on 7 February 2017 raising the concern that Axent would be unlikely to be able to satisfy an adverse costs order. Hi-Lux’s solicitors requested the provision of any information that would establish that Axent had sufficient assets to meet an adverse costs order. Axent’s solicitor replied on 13 February 2017 advising that Axent did not agree to provide any security for costs, and that it would disclose financial information on a confidential basis. On 27 February 2017 Hi-Lux was provided with a confidential Management Report dated 18 October 2016, for the financial year ended 30 June 2016 (management report). This document was produced in confidential annexure RRR-4 to Mr Rankin’s first affidavit initially to explain Axent’s response to Hi-Lux’s concerns. This much appears in email correspondence in annexure F to the affidavit of Mr Leonidas sworn in response to the Compusign respondents’ application). Amongst other things, in an email to Mr Leonidas dated 15 August 2017, the respondents’ solicitor relevantly stated:The second respondent relies upon both affidavits of Mr Rankin.The first and third respondents also rely upon both affidavits of Mr Rankin – the practical reality being that the material in both affidavits will be before the Court on the second respondent’s application. The financial statement is, however, put before the Court solely in order to disclose the response that Axent advanced as to why it should not be liable to provide security for costs. It does not form part of the respondents’ positive case.Should your client notify us either in their answering materials, or at the hearing, or otherwise, that it does not seek to rely upon its 2015/2016 financial statement in answer to the respondents’ application, then the respondents would not tender that statement (contained in Confidential Annexure RRR-4). If Axent seeks to rely on that financial statement, then the issue is moot in any event. If it seeks to rely on a financial statement that is inconsistent with the 2015/1016 financial statement, then that is something that it may need to justify during the hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Hi-Lux is entitled to security for costs from Axent.
2. The admissibility of confidential annexure CL-9 and the financial statement provided by Axent.
3. The appropriate method and assessment of costs related to Hi-Lux's application.

Held
1. Whether Hi-Lux is entitled to security for costs from Axent: The court concluded that Hi-Lux is not entitled to security for costs from Axent. Consequently, the application for security for costs made by Hi-Lux was dismissed.
2. The admissibility of confidential annexure CL-9 and the financial statement provided by Axent: The court determined that confidential annexure CL-9 was not admissible, as it contained broadly-stated conclusions without explained bases. The financial statement, provided in confidential annexure RRR-4, was deemed not to form part of Axent's positive case and was subject to Axent's reliance on it.
3. The appropriate method and assessment of costs related to Hi-Lux's application: The court ordered that Hi-Lux file and serve short submissions on costs by 25 September 2017, and Axent to respond by 2 October 2017, with both parties limited to two pages. The method and assessment of such costs were reserved for further consideration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application for security for costs brought by Hi-Lux against Axent, focusing on the ability of Axent to satisfy any adverse costs order. The court found Hi-Lux's application was not supported by sufficient evidence to warrant granting security for costs. In dismissing the application, the court noted the objections to the admissibility of confidential annexure CL-9, which was excluded due to its lack of specific basis and the inadmissibility of the opinion expressed within it. The financial statement provided in confidential annexure RRR-4 was not considered part of Axent's case but was instead used to illustrate Axent's position on its financial capacity to meet costs. The court's decision on costs, including the method of assessment, was deferred pending further submissions from both parties. This case establishes that in assessing an application for security for costs, the court will closely scrutinize the admissibility and weight of financial information provided by the parties and may dismiss the application if the evidence does not sufficiently support the granting of security for costs.