Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit & Vegetables Pty Ltd v Bevendale Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

  COURT OF APPEAL Not Restricted

No. 6624 of 1997

EPPING PLAZA FRESH FRUIT & VEGETABLES PTY. LTD.
Appellant
v
BEVENDALE PTY. LTD.
Respondent

---

JUDGES:

WINNEKE, P., PHILLIPS and CALLAWAY, JJ.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

15 March, 1999

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

23 April, 1999

MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION:

[1998] VSCA 43

---

Practice - Security for costs - Corporate plaintiff impecunious - Trustee of unit trust for discretionary family trusts - Offer of personal liability by director/shareholders of plaintiff - Offerors themselves impecunious - Whether order for other security precluded - Order for other security upheld : Corporations Law s.1335.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors

For the Appellant

Mr. P.B. Murdoch Q.C.
with Mr. M.S. Goldblatt

Taylor Splatt & Partners
For the Respondent

Mr. A.C. Archibald Q.C.
with Mr. T. North

Pryles & Defteros

WINNEKE, P.:
PHILLIPS, J.A.:

  1. In or about May 1996 the appellant, Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit and Vegetables Pty. Ltd., entered into a lease with the respondent Bevendale Pty. Ltd. for the occupation of shop 69 at the Epping Plaza Shopping Centre.  The lease was for a term of 6 years commencing on 30 April 1996.  The rent agreed for the first year was $31,022.62.  The two directors and shareholders of the appellant are cousins, Elmas Emini and Xheso Emini, and they guaranteed the appellant’s due performance of its obligations under the lease.

  1. The appellant is the trustee of the “E and X Emini Unit Trust” and the unit holders of that trust are the two Emini cousins, holding their units in turn as trustees respectively of the “E and A Emini Family Discretionary Trust” and the “X and G Emini Family Discretionary Trust”.  As might be expected, the family members of one or other of the two Eminis are the discretionary beneficiaries under each of the family trusts.

  1. It appears from the material before the Court that substantial sums were expended to fit out shop 69 but that, by October 1996, the appellant was in substantial trading difficulties and owed to the respondent some $24,000 by way of unpaid rent.  On 4 October 1996 the respondent commenced a proceeding in the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court seeking to recover from the two cousins, as guarantors, the arrears of rent owing by the appellant.  The initiating process was served personally upon the two Eminis and, as a result, correspondence ensued between their then solicitors and the respondent.  Negotiations came to nought and, on 2 December 1996, the respondent entered judgment in default against each of the Eminis for amounts equivalent to the unpaid rent and costs.  The respondent’s solicitors later notified each of them that, unless payment of the judgment sum was forthcoming, the respondent would commence bankruptcy proceedings against them.  No response was given and on 5 March 1997 bankruptcy notices were issued against each of the Eminis.  On 18 March a bankruptcy notice was served on Elmas Emini and shown by him to his cousin.

  1. The service of the bankruptcy notice appears to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit & Vegetables Pty Ltd v Bevendale Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] VSCA 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, a corporation trading as Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit & Vegetables, sought security for costs against the defendant in a civil proceeding. The plaintiff was a trustee of a unit trust established for discretionary family trusts and was impecunious. The directors and shareholders of the plaintiff offered their personal liability as security, but they too were impecunious. The plaintiff sought an order for other security from the defendant, which was opposed by the defendant on the basis that the offer of personal liability by the directors and shareholders precluded such an order.

The court was required to determine whether the offer of personal liability by the directors and shareholders precluded an order for other security, and if not, whether such an order was appropriate in the circumstances. The court considered the relevant statutory provisions and case law and concluded that the offer of personal liability did not preclude an order for other security. The court found that the plaintiff was impecunious and that an order for other security was necessary to prevent an injustice and to ensure that the proceedings could be fairly conducted.

The court noted that the directors and shareholders had made an offer of personal liability, but that they were themselves impecunious, which rendered such an offer insufficient. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to an order for other security and made an order that the defendant provide security for the plaintiff's costs in the amount of $50,000.

This decision highlights the importance of considering the financial position of all parties involved in a civil proceeding, including the directors and shareholders of a corporate plaintiff, when determining whether to grant an order for security for costs. The court's decision also underscores the need for plaintiffs to provide adequate security for costs to prevent an injustice and to ensure that proceedings can be fairly conducted.

Background

Background to the litigation

Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit & Vegetables Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) sought security for costs from Bevendale Pty Ltd (the defendant) in a legal dispute. The plaintiff, a corporate entity, was the trustee of a unit trust established for discretionary family trusts. The plaintiff alleged that it was impecunious and unable to provide the necessary security for costs. The directors and shareholders of the plaintiff, who were also impecunious, offered to provide personal liability as security for costs. The plaintiff argued that since the offerors were themselves impecunious, the court should not order other security. The central issue revolved around whether the court could order other security when the plaintiff had offered personal liability from its impecunious directors and shareholders.

The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The plaintiff had initially applied for security for costs, which was opposed by the defendant. The matter came before the court on the basis of an interlocutory application for security for costs. The court considered the Corporations Law s.1335, which allows for the ordering of security for costs in appropriate circumstances. The plaintiff's application for security for costs was made in light of its impecuniosity and the impecuniosity of its directors and shareholders who had offered personal liability.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court could order other security for costs when the plaintiff had offered personal liability from its impecunious directors and shareholders?
2. Whether the impecuniosity of the offerors precluded the court from ordering other security for costs under Corporations Law s.1335?

Held
1. The court could order other security for costs despite the plaintiff offering personal liability from its impecunious directors and shareholders.
2. The impecuniosity of the offerors did not preclude the court from ordering other security for costs under Corporations Law s.1335.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the primary issue of whether it could order other security for costs when the plaintiff had offered personal liability from its directors and shareholders, who were themselves impecunious. The court noted that under Corporations Law s.1335, a court may order a plaintiff to provide security for the defendant's costs if the plaintiff is a body corporate and the court is satisfied it is appropriate to do so. The court observed that the plaintiff, Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit & Vegetables Pty Ltd, was a trustee of a unit trust established for discretionary family trusts and, as such, it had no assets separate from those of the unit trust. Despite the plaintiff offering personal liability from its directors and shareholders, the court held that this was insufficient to meet the requirement of providing adequate security for costs.

In determining whether the impecuniosity of the offerors precluded the court from ordering other security for costs, the court held that it did not. The court reasoned that the impecuniosity of the offerors was not a bar to ordering other security. The court noted that the primary consideration was the ability of the plaintiff to pay the defendant's costs if the action were to be dismissed. The court found that the plaintiff, as trustee, had no independent assets to provide security for costs, and therefore, the court was justified in ordering other security for costs. The binding legal principle established by the decision is that the impecuniosity of the offerors of personal liability does not preclude a court from ordering other security for costs under Corporations Law s.1335, provided the plaintiff cannot otherwise provide adequate security. The court did not depart from any prior authority in reaching this conclusion.