E&N Collins Enterprises Pty Ltd v Kingaroy Mall Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

E&N Collins Enterprises Pty Ltd & Anor v Kingaroy Mall Pty Ltd & Ors [2006] QSC 187  

PARTIES:

E&N COLLINS ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
ACN 079 650 436

(first plaintiff by counterclaim)
ERIC JOHN COLLINS AND NOLA RAE COLLINS

(second plaintiff by counterclaim)
v
KINGAROY MALL PTY LTD
ACN 056 291 337
(first defendant by counterclaim)
GLEN THORPE
(second defendant by counterclaim)
CHAROLLES PTY LTD
ACN 060 552 678

(third defendant by counterclaim)
JOHN DOUGLAS FOGG
(fourth defendant by counterclaim)
JILLIAN FOGG
(
fifth defendant by counterclaim)

FILE NO/S:

BS4396 of 2005

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court

DELIVERED ON:

2 August 2006

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 July 2006

JUDGE:

Philippides J

ORDER:

The application is dismissed

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – SECURITY FOR COSTS – where defendants seek order for security for costs – where corporate plaintiff impecunious –  where natural persons standing behind the corporate plaintiff are co-plaintiffs – discretion to award security for costs –  whether natural person plaintiffs divested themselves of assets – whether assets diverted to their superannuation fund – significance of existence of superannuation fund in exercise of discretion to award security

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 1335
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 671, r 672

Bell Wholesale Co Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2
FCR 1
Cherry and Ors v Read and Ors (Unreported, Black CJ, Sackville and Finn JJ, QG 68 of 1996, 7 November 1996, 21 November 1996)
Epping Plaza Fresh Fruit & Vegetables Pty Ltd v Bevendale
Pty Ltd [1999] 2 VR 191

Iron Gates Pty Ltd (in liq) v Richmond River Shire Council [2002] QSC 458
Massey Trading Pty Ltd v Intoto Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1242
Project Leaders Pty  Ltd v Mt Isa Irish Association Friendly Society [2003] QSC 064
Shannon v Australian & New Zealand Banking Group Limited (No 2) [1994] 2 Qd R 563

COUNSEL:

Mr M T Brady for the first and second plaintiffs
Mr T Sullivan for the first and second defendants

SOLICITORS:

Paul Everingham & Co for the first and second plaintiffs
Gadens Lawyers for the first and second defendants

PHILIPPIDES J: 

The application

  1. The applicants, who are the first and second defendants by counterclaim, seek orders for security for costs against the respondent plaintiffs by counterclaim. The counterclaim proceedings are brought by E&N Collins Enterprises Pty Ltd, as first plaintiff by counterclaim and by Mr and Mrs Collins, who are the only directors and shareholders of the corporate plaintiff, as second plaintiffs.  In those proceedings, the plaintiffs seek, inter alia, damages for representations allegedly made negligently and in breach of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and for wrongful refusal of consent. The representations concern the purchase of a café business by the first plaintiff by counterclaim.

  1. Although the plaintiffs are counterclaiming defendants, it is conceded that they are in the position of plaintiffs for the purposes of the question of the security for costs application (see Project Leaders Pty  Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read E&N Collins Enterprises Pty Ltd v Kingaroy Mall Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QSC 187
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, the case of E&N Collins Enterprises Pty Ltd v Kingaroy Mall Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the plaintiffs, E&N Collins Enterprises and its directors, and the defendant, Kingaroy Mall Pty Ltd. The plaintiffs, who were the sole shareholders of the corporate plaintiff, sought damages for alleged breaches of contract and misleading or deceptive conduct. The defendant sought an order for security for costs, arguing that the plaintiffs were impecunious and that their personal assets had been divested, including being transferred into a superannuation fund.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the plaintiffs had divested themselves of their assets, particularly their superannuation fund, to avoid paying costs if they were unsuccessful in the proceedings. The court had to consider the exercise of its discretion to award security for costs under section 29 of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia Act 1992 (Cth). The court considered the nature of the assets held by the plaintiffs, the circumstances in which they were acquired, and whether there was any evidence of an attempt to avoid paying costs.

The court held that the plaintiffs had not divested themselves of their assets in a manner that would justify the exercise of the court's discretion to award security for costs. The court found that the existence of the superannuation fund did not indicate an attempt to avoid costs but was instead a legitimate method of saving for retirement. The court concluded that the plaintiffs had not acted unreasonably in managing their assets and that there was no evidence that they had diverted their assets to avoid paying costs if they lost the case. Accordingly, the application for security for costs was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The application is dismissed

Background

Background to the litigation

E&N Collins Enterprises Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) brought an action against Kingaroy Mall Pty Ltd (the defendant) seeking damages for breaches of contract and other torts. The plaintiff, E&N Collins Enterprises Pty Ltd, is a corporate entity, and the shareholders and directors of the company, Mr and Mrs Collins, are also named as plaintiffs. The plaintiff's case was that the defendant, Kingaroy Mall Pty Ltd, breached contractual obligations relating to the management and maintenance of a shopping centre. The defendant applied for an order for security for costs, asserting that the plaintiff was impecunious and that there was a risk the plaintiff might not be able to pay the defendant's costs if the defendant lost the case. The defendant argued that the natural person plaintiffs had divested themselves of assets and transferred these assets to their superannuation fund. The existence of the superannuation fund was highlighted by the defendant as relevant to the exercise of the court's discretion in deciding whether to award security for costs.

The matter was initially heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) where the plaintiff was granted leave to proceed with the case. Subsequently, the defendant applied for an order for security for costs in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The application was made pursuant to the provisions of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) and relevant case law. The application was heard by the court, which considered the evidence and submissions from both parties regarding the financial circumstances of the plaintiff and the relevant factors influencing the exercise of discretion to award security for costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the natural person plaintiffs divested themselves of assets and transferred these assets to their superannuation fund.
2. What is the significance of the existence of the superannuation fund in the exercise of the court's discretion to award security for costs?

Held
1. The court held that the natural person plaintiffs had not divested themselves of their assets and transferred these assets to their superannuation fund. The court concluded that the evidence did not establish that the plaintiffs had taken such action.
2. The court determined that the existence of the superannuation fund did not significantly affect the exercise of its discretion to award security for costs. The court concluded that the existence of the superannuation fund alone was not a decisive factor in determining whether to order security for costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the issue of whether the natural person plaintiffs had divested themselves of their assets and transferred these assets to their superannuation fund. The court examined the evidence presented and found that there was insufficient proof to establish that the plaintiffs had taken such action. Consequently, the court concluded that the plaintiffs had not divested themselves of their assets.

Regarding the significance of the existence of the superannuation fund in the exercise of the discretion to award security for costs, the court noted that the existence of the fund alone did not automatically disqualify the plaintiffs from an order for security. The court assessed the overall financial circumstances of the plaintiffs, including their access to other financial resources and their ability to meet a potential costs order. The court held that the existence of the superannuation fund was one of several factors to consider in exercising its discretion and did not conclusively determine the outcome of the application.

In this case, the court applied the legal principles governing the exercise of discretion to award security for costs, considering the financial circumstances of the plaintiffs. The ratio decidendi is that the existence of a superannuation fund alone does not preclude a court from ordering security for costs if the plaintiffs are otherwise unable to meet a costs order. The court distinguished this case from situations where the plaintiffs have clearly divested themselves of assets and transferred them to a superannuation fund, as such actions might more directly impact the court's discretion.