Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

[2007] HCATrans 802

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Sydney  No S224 of 2007

B e t w e e n -

MAMDOUH HABIB

Applicant

and

NATIONWIDE NEWS PTY LTD

Respondent

Application for special leave to appeal

GLEESON CJ
HEYDON J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT SYDNEY ON FRIDAY, 14 DECEMBER 2007, AT 2.01 PM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR B.W. WALKER, SC:   May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friend, MR C.A. EVATT, for the applicant.  (instructed by Peter Erman Solicitor)

MR G.O’L REYNOLDS, SC:   May it please the Court, I appear for the respondent with my learned friend, MR A. LEOPOLD, SC.  (instructed by Blake Dawson Waldron)

GLEESON CJ:   Yes, Mr Walker.

MR WALKER:   May it please the Court.  Your Honours, in a defamation action under the law as it applied at the time of this trial and under the amendments which have been introduced, the role of a jury is important, if anything, more important now.  In the importance of the role of the jury it is a single fact that there are certain questions being matters of fact which, unlike usual matters of fact, not only do not lend themselves to evidence but areas where evidence is prohibited.  One of them is the extent of the general knowledge available to the ordinary reasonable reader being a decision which, subject to an important qualification, is committed to the jury.  Certainly it is committed to the jury without the benefit of evidence. 

This is a case where notwithstanding that clear‑cut rule which was in no way purported to be tested by these proceedings, something worse than inadmissible evidence was given about the extent of general knowledge available to the ordinary reasonable reader.  The something worse was the ipse dixit of counsel from the Bar table.

GLEESON CJ:   How do the jurors deal with those issues without people making competing assertions to them about what they should decide?

MR WALKER:   The jury may be invited to consider the question whether X, Y and Z be within general knowledge, but there may not be assertions by counsel for this reason in principle.  Assertions by counsel, shorn of any evidentiary basis, are in the usual case beyond the capacity of counsel properly to convey to the court and, if there is a jury, may lead in an extreme case to a discharge application succeeding or, in other cases may lead to what might be called a judicial admonishment by special direction.  Where there is no evidence capable of being given, but the issue is one which still falls to be argued so as to decide what is conveyed and whether that is defamatory, then because there cannot be evidentiary basis supplied by counsel’s own assertion, counsel cannot make assertions at all.

GLEESON CJ:   How do they argue about it between themselves?

MR WALKER:   What counsel can do is, in a case where there is a controversy, raise with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] HCATrans 802
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd* concerned a defamation claim brought by Mr. Habib against Nationwide News Pty Ltd. Mr. Habib alleged that articles published by Nationwide News in *The Australian* newspaper defamed him. The matter came before the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the defence of qualified privilege was available to Nationwide News in respect of the defamatory publications. This involved considering the circumstances in which the articles were published and whether the recipients of the information had a corresponding interest or duty to receive it.

The High Court ultimately found that the defence of qualified privilege was not established. The reasoning focused on the nature of the publications and the lack of a sufficiently established reciprocal duty or interest between the publisher and the recipients of the information. The court applied established principles of defamation law concerning the defence of qualified privilege, particularly the requirement for a duty or interest to publish and a corresponding duty or interest to receive the information. The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the judgment of the Full Federal Court and ordering that the appeal to the Full Federal Court be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd revolves around a defamation claim brought by Mamdouh Habib, an Australian citizen, against Nationwide News Pty Ltd, the publisher of various media outlets including newspapers and magazines. The core of the case concerns the handling of an issue of general knowledge by counsel during the trial, which the applicant argues was inappropriate and prejudicial. The article in question, published in The Australian newspaper, discussed Mr. Habib's participation in the City to Surf race, implying that his participation was suspicious given his background. The applicant's argument is that the article, if read in a certain way, could be defamatory, suggesting that Mr. Habib had deceived the public by participating in the race despite his alleged clinical depression.

The trial judge directed the jury to consider whether certain propositions were within the general knowledge of an ordinary reasonable reader. The applicant's counsel argued that Mr. Habib's participation in the race, despite suffering from clinical depression, was not within general knowledge and should not have been asserted by the respondent's counsel as a fact. The applicant's counsel contended that this assertion by the respondent's counsel was a serious error, as it improperly influenced the jury's consideration of the issue. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge's directions but differed on whether the matter was within general knowledge, leading to the applicant seeking special leave to appeal to the High Court.

The applicant's argument before the High Court focused on the principle that certain issues, such as the extent of general knowledge available to the ordinary reasonable reader, are for the jury to decide without the benefit of evidence. Counsel's role, according to the applicant, is to invite the jury to consider the issue without providing any assertions as facts. The applicant argued that the respondent's counsel had crossed this line by asserting facts directly to the jury, which prejudiced the trial's fairness. The applicant submitted that the High Court should address this issue to clarify the proper conduct of counsel when dealing with such matters before a jury.

The matter of Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd came before the High Court of Australia as an application for special leave to appeal. This case originated in a defamation action brought by Mamdouh Habib against Nationwide News Pty Ltd. The applicant, Mamdouh Habib, sought special leave to appeal against the decision of the Court of Appeal, which had dismissed his appeal from the trial judgment. The primary issue in the case concerned the adequacy of trial judge directions intended to mitigate any prejudice that may have resulted from counsel’s address to the jury. The Court of Appeal had split on the question, with a majority finding the directions sufficient and a dissenter finding them inadequate. The trial judge had ruled that certain assertions made by defence counsel during their address to the jury constituted an inappropriate assertion of general knowledge, but had not deemed this sufficiently prejudicial to warrant a new trial. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial judge’s ruling, with a majority agreeing that the trial judge's directions were sufficient to address any potential prejudice. The High Court ultimately dismissed the application for special leave to appeal, finding that the case did not present a suitable issue for the grant of special leave and did not warrant it in the interests of justice.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the trial judge's assessment of what constitutes general knowledge for the purposes of the jury's determination in a defamation case properly within the judge's domain, or should it be left solely to the jury?
2. Can counsel for the parties provide assertions about general knowledge to the jury, or must they only invite the jury to consider the matter without offering their own opinions?
3. What are the appropriate judicial directions to address potential prejudice when counsel provides assertions about general knowledge to the jury without evidentiary support?
4. Did the trial judge err in his assessment of the content of counsel's address to the jury and in the redirection provided to the jury?
5. Did the Court of Appeal correctly determine the issue of general knowledge and the nature of the repair work in relation to counsel's address to the jury?
6. Does the case present an opportunity to clarify the limits of counsel's role in addressing issues of general knowledge to the jury in the absence of admissible evidence?

Held
1. The trial judge's assessment of what constitutes general knowledge for the purposes of the jury's determination in a defamation case is properly within the judge's domain, but counsel cannot make assertions about general knowledge to the jury.
2. Counsel cannot provide assertions about general knowledge to the jury; they can only invite the jury to consider the matter without offering their own opinions.
3. The appropriate judicial direction is to prevent counsel from providing assertions about general knowledge to the jury without evidentiary support, and to address potential prejudice if such assertions are made.
4. The trial judge erred in his assessment of the content of counsel's address to the jury and in the redirection provided to the jury.
5. The Court of Appeal did not correctly determine the issue of general knowledge and the nature of the repair work in relation to counsel's address to the jury.
6. This case presents an opportunity to clarify the limits of counsel's role in addressing issues of general knowledge to the jury in the absence of admissible evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Habib v Nationwide News Pty Ltd, the primary issue revolved around the proper role of counsel in addressing issues of general knowledge to the jury in the context of a defamation case, particularly where such issues are not amenable to evidence. The court considered whether the trial judge's assessment of what constitutes general knowledge should be left to the jury, the extent to which counsel can assert opinions about general knowledge, and the appropriate judicial directions to address potential prejudice when counsel provides unsupported assertions about general knowledge to the jury.

The court began by examining the principle that certain questions, such as the extent of general knowledge available to the ordinary reasonable reader, are matters of fact to be determined by the jury. However, these questions cannot be supported by evidence, placing a unique responsibility on counsel. Counsel is permitted to invite the jury to consider whether a proposition is within general knowledge but is not allowed to assert such propositions as facts. The court held that assertions by counsel, without evidentiary support, are beyond the proper capacity of counsel and could potentially lead to judicial admonishments or even a successful application for discharge.

The trial judge's role in this context was to determine whether there was an occasion for counsel to raise certain issues in the absence of the jury, particularly when the assertions by counsel crossed the line from inviting the jury to consider a matter to making unsupported assertions. The court observed that the trial judge should rule on whether it is possible for the jury to consider a certain proposition as within general knowledge when there is a capacity issue.

In this case, the trial judge was found to have correctly assessed that a particular proposition regarding the impact of clinical depression on athletic performance was not within general knowledge. However, the trial judge erred in his redirection provided to the jury regarding the nature of the repair work. The Court of Appeal majority incorrectly determined that the proposition was within general knowledge and also misconstrued the nature of the repair work. The minority, represented by Justice Handley, correctly identified the trial judge's error but did not address the repair work issue.

The High Court ultimately concluded that the case did not present an issue suitable for a grant of special leave, as it was highly fact-specific and did not advance the law in a manner that would serve the interests of justice. The application for special leave to appeal was dismissed with costs. This decision underscores the importance of distinguishing between inviting the jury to consider an issue and making unsupported assertions, while also highlighting the trial judge's role in ensuring that counsel does not overstep the boundaries in addressing issues of general knowledge to the jury.