Gray v Cash Converters International Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 85 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gray v Cash Converters International Limited [2014] FCA 420

Citation: Gray v Cash Converters International Limited [2014] FCA 420
Parties: JULIE GRAY v CASH CONVERTERS INTERNATIONAL LIMITED ACN 069 141 546, SAFROCK FINANCE CORPORATION (QLD) PTY LTD ACN 098 566 520 and CASH CONVERTERS PERSONAL FINANCE ACN 110 275 762
JULIE GRAY v CASH CONVERTERS INTERNATIONAL LIMITED ACN 069 141 546, CASH CONVERTERS PTY LTD ACN 009 288 804 and JA-KE HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 072 118 720
File numbers: NSD 2089 of 2013

NSD 2090 of 2013

Judge: FARRELL J
Date of judgment: 2 May 2014
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – application to strike out statement of claim – representative proceedings – whether proceedings properly constituted under s 33C of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether all group members must have a claim against all defendants – whether Philip Morris (Australia) Ltd v Nixon  to be preferred to Bray v F Hoffman-La Roche Ltd – what constitutes ratio decidendi – whether accessorial liability claims available in the context of representative proceedings

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – application to strike out statement of claim – representative proceedings – alleged breaches of Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) s 12CB(1) – accessorial liability of one defendant common to all group members – principle in Yorke v Lucas – whether knowledge of particular dealings necessary – where allegation relates to system or practice – whether knowledge pleaded – whether pleadings of knowledge adequately particularised

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – application  to strike out statement of claim  – representative proceedings – whether sufficient factual foundation for pleading of common intention – relevance of common intention to question of whether a fee is “ascertainable” pursuant to the Credit (Commonwealth Powers) Act 2010 (NSW) – whether pleading adequately particularised

Legislation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)
Competition and Consumer Legislation Amendment Act 2011 (Cth)
Competition and Consumer Legislation Amendment Bill 2011 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Credit (Commonwealth Powers) Act 2010 (NSW)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Amendment Bill 1991 (Cth)
National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Trade Practices Amendment (Australian Consumer Law) Act (No 2) 2010 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Addenbrooke Pty Ltd v Duncan (No 2) [2013] FCA 820
Auskay International Manufacturing & Trade Pty Ltd v Qantas Airways Ltd (2008) 251 ALR 166
Australian Automotive Repairers’ Association v NRMA Insurance Ltd [2002] FCA 1568
Australian Communications and Media Authority v Mobilegate Ltd A Company Incorporated in Hong Kong (No 8)(2010) 275 ALR 293
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Albert [2005] FCA 1311
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2000] NSWSC 316
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Black on White Pty Ltd (2001) 110 FCR 1
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Excite Mobile Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 350
Banque Commerciale SA (En Liquidation) v Akhil Holdings Limited

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gray v Cash Converters International Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 420
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gray v Cash Converters International Limited involves a representative proceeding where Ms. Gray, on behalf of herself and others, has brought claims against Cash Converters International Limited and Safrock Finance Limited. The dispute centers on the alleged unlawful conduct in relation to personal loans and cash advances provided by the defendants. The legal issues at hand revolve around the enforceability of certain fees, the adequacy of disclosure of these fees, and the nature of liability claims, both principal and accessorial, in representative proceedings. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues the court needed to address include whether accessorial liability claims can be maintained in representative proceedings, the nature of the disclosure obligations concerning certain fees, and the potential for claims to be struck out due to embarrassment in pleading. The court considered whether the statement of claim should be amended or struck out due to the complexity of managing both principal and accessorial liability claims, particularly in the context of the Cash Advances Action where the alleged primary contraveners are not parties to the proceedings.

The court concluded that it is at least arguable that accessorial liability claims can be maintained in representative proceedings, even though there may be practical difficulties in managing such claims. The court found that the statement of claim was not sufficiently embarrassing to warrant striking it out at this early stage. The court also examined the disclosure obligations related to fees and found that while certain fees were disclosed, there were allegations that additional fees were charged without proper notice or entitlement. The court decided to give Ms. Gray leave to re-plead the statements of claim to address these issues, with submissions sought from the parties regarding the appropriate orders for costs.

In light of the above, the court did not strike out any part of the statement of claim but instead allowed Ms. Gray to re-plead it, with specific directions to be provided. The court also invited submissions on the appropriate costs orders to be made. This decision reflects the court's approach to balancing the procedural fairness in managing complex representative actions while ensuring that all claims are adequately addressed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept Ms Gray’s submission that despite the reservations expressed by Hill and Sackville JJ it is at least arguable that accessorial liability claims are available in the context of representative proceedings. There may well be practical issues to be managed in the conduct of proceedings involving both principal and accessorial liability claims and they arise in both the Personal Loans Action and the Cash Advances Action. I acknowledge that the issues of management are likely to be greater in the Cash Advances Action because the accessorial liability claims relate to the conduct of alleged primary contraveners who are not parties. However, at this early stage of the proceedings I do not consider that the statement of claim should be struck out or any other steps taken to separate the proceedings on that basis: I am supported in this view by the discussion at [4.640] of Class Actions in Australia and Goldberg J’s decision in Williams v FAI Home Security in which he declined to strike out a statement of claim in a representative proceeding in which claims were made for both principal and accessorial liability.CONCLUSION Having regard to the matters raised in these reasons, I will seek submissions from the parties as to the appropriate nature of the orders to be made. Rather than striking out individual paragraphs of the statement of claim, I am inclined simply to give Ms Gray leave to re-plead the statements of claim having regard to these reasons by a date to be specified. I will also seek submissions on the appropriate costs orders to be made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The principles stated by Cash Converters are uncontentious:8. In Shelton v National Roads & Motorists Assn Ltd (2004) 51 ACSR 278 at [18], Tamberlin J explained the concept of “embarrassment” with respect to pleadings as follows:“Embarrassment in this context refers to a pleading that is susceptible to various meanings, or contains inconsistent allegations, or in which alternatives are confusingly intermixed, or in which irrelevant allegations are made that tend to increase expense.”9. A pleading which is internally inconsistent is embarrassing: see Spiteri v Nine Network Australia [2008] FCA 905 at [23].10. A pleading may be struck out as embarrassing if it simply asserts a conclusion to be drawn from the facts not stated and is not saved by using the words ‘[i]n the premises’ to introduce the conclusion: Trade Practices Commission v David Jones (Australia) Pty Ltd (1985) 7 FCR 109 at 114; Davids Holdings Pty Ltd v Coles Myer Ltd (1993) ATPR 41-227.11.The pleading should enable the respondent to know, with sufficient clarity, the case which it is required to meet: Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658 at 664.“nAdmin” and “Administration Fee” disclosure Because the parties have agreed that the pattern of the three personal loans the subject of Ms Gray’s claim is the same (see [4]) (and the manner in which the claims are pleaded for the three personal loans follows the same pattern), for simplicity I will refer only to the First Gray Personal Loan. The First Gray Personal Loan of 7 March 2011 provides:Deferred Establishment FeeThe loan term is 2 years (24 months).If the Borrower pays out the loan before the full term, a deferred establishment fee will be charged. The deferred establishment fee will vary depending upon the date on which the loan is fully repaid. If the loan is fully repaid within 7 months, the fee will be 60% of the principal amount but this will be reduced to 35% if paid by direct debit to encourage good fiscal management. If the loan is repaid after 7 months but within 12 months, the fee will be 50% of the principal amount but this will be reduced to 30% if paid by direct debit to encourage good fiscal management. If the loan is repaid after 12 months but within 18 months, the fee will be 40% of the principal amount but this will be reduced to 25% if paid by direct debit to encourage good fiscal management. If the loan is repaid after 18 months there will be no deferred establishment fee. Cash Converters say that when, on 8 March 2011, Ms Gray made the election to repay the First Gray Personal Loan by signing the Personal Loan Early Repayment Election form she acknowledged the “deferred establishment fee”. Indeed, it is not in dispute that the “deferred establishment fee” was disclosed because Ms Gray pleads it as an express terms of the contracts ([8](a), [30](g) and [52](g) of the statement of claim). At [12]-[14] of the statement of claim, Ms Gray claims that, purporting to act on the direct debit arrangement for the First Gray Personal Loan, Safrock deducted “nAdmin” and “Administration Fees” between 17 March and 13 October 2011. She says that Safrock had no entitlement to do so under that contract. She further claims that between 8 March and 13 October 2011, Safrock charged an annual percentage rate of 48% on the “purported outstanding balances” of the loan account which included the “nAdmin” and “Administration Fee”, which Ms Gray paid. Ms Gray then claims, at [15], that for those reasons, the conduct was unconscionable and in contravention of s 12CB(1) of the ASIC Act because: (a) Safrock had no contractual right to require payment of the “nAdmin” and the “Administration Fee” under the First Gray Personal Loan; (b) Safrock gave no notice to Ms Gray of the debiting of those fees or the charging of interest on them; and (c) Safrock engaged in conduct recklessly and without due regard to whether those fees were properly payable.