Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Excite Mobile Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Excite Mobile Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 350

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Excite Mobile Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 350
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v EXCITE MOBILE PTY LTD (ACN 128 229 498), OBIE BROWN, DAVID SAMUEL and FIONA SMART
File number: SAD 328 of 2011
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 18 April 2013
Catchwords:

CONSUMER LAW – unconscionable conduct, misleading or deceptive conduct, and false or misleading representations, undue coercion – representations that certain letters and telephone calls sent and made to consumers by the first respondent were sent and made by an independent debt collector engaged by the first respondent – representations in those letters and telephone calls that the purported independent debt collector had engaged a lawyer, that legal action against the consumer was contemplated, and that such legal action would be likely to result in certain harsh orders being made against the consumer – whether such representations were false or misleading concerning the existence, exclusion or effect of any condition, warranty, guarantee, right or remedy – whether such representations amounted to misleading or deceptive conduct – whether such representations amounted to unconscionable conduct – whether such representations amounted to undue coercion in connection with the payment for goods or services by a consumer

CONSUMER LAW – unconscionable conduct – conduct whereby telemarketers engaged by the first respondent called consumers and obtained their agreement to an oral contract for the provision of mobile telecommunications services – unusual terms of the contract, such as a term that meant that only a small monetary amount’s worth of mobile phone services could be used each day without incurring extra charges, were not properly explained, or explained at all – no time was afforded by the telemarketers to the consumer for reflection on the explanation of the terms – once the mobile phone and a letter containing a more detailed explanation of the terms of the contract was subsequently delivered to the consumer, the oral contract could only be cancelled by paying a fee – opening the packaging containing the mobile phone incurred a further “damage” fee – whether sales process of the first respondent amounted to unconscionable conduct

CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct and false or misleading representations – representations made by the first respondent to consumers that there was mobile phone coverage at the consumers’ home addresses – whether the first respondent represented that goods or services have performance characteristics they do not have – whether the representations amounted to misleading or deceptive conduct

CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct and false or misleading representations – representations that a telephone number provided to consumers was operated by an independent telecommunications complaints body – representations that certain telephone calls were made by representatives of an independent telecommunications complaint body - whether such representations were false or misleading concerning the existence, exclusion or effect of any condition, warranty, guarantee, right or remedy – whether…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Excite Mobi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 350
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed a lawsuit against Excite Mobile Pty Ltd, a company that provides mobile telecommunications services, alleging misleading and deceptive conduct in its telemarketing practices. The court found that Excite Mobile and its directors, Mr Brown, Mr Samuel, and Ms Smart, contravened the Trade Practices Act (TPA) by engaging in misleading and deceptive conduct in connection with the supply of goods and services. Specifically, Excite Mobile promoted its mobile services through telemarketing calls by representatives in India, Pakistan, and the Philippines, offering customers a "gift" of a phone and holiday vouchers to entice them into a 24-month contract. However, the telemarketing calls did not clearly explain the cap on the daily allowance for calls and text messages, which led to additional charges for customers who exceeded the cap.

The court examined the legal issues surrounding the TPA's provisions on unconscionability, false and misleading conduct, and coercion. The key question was whether Excite Mobile's conduct was misleading and deceptive, as defined under the TPA. The court found that Excite Mobile's conduct was misleading because the telemarketing calls did not clearly explain the cap on the daily allowance, which led to additional charges for customers who exceeded the cap. The court also found that Excite Mobile's conduct was unconscionable because it took advantage of the customers' lack of understanding of the contract terms.

The court ordered that Excite Mobile and its directors, Mr Brown, Mr Samuel, and Ms Smart, contravened the TPA by engaging in misleading and deceptive conduct in connection with the supply of goods and services. The court found that Excite Mobile's conduct was misleading because the telemarketing calls did not clearly explain the cap on the daily allowance, which led to additional charges for customers who exceeded the cap. The court also found that Excite Mobile's conduct was unconscionable because it took advantage of the customers' lack of understanding of the contract terms. The court adjourned the matter for further directions on a date convenient to the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons which appear below, I have found each of those contraventions against Excite Mobile and on the part of Mr Brown, Mr Samuel and Ms Smart proved. It is agreed between the parties that the decision as to what, if any, orders should be made as a result of those findings should be addressed at a separate and later stage of the proceedings. Accordingly, I now invite each of the parties, within 21 days, to propose how and when the further hearing contemplated should be conducted, unless they are able to agree about that. The matter will also be adjourned for further directions on a date convenient to the parties.BACKGROUNDOverview of Excite Mobile, Lime India and Lime Australia Excite Mobile is a company that supplies mobile telecommunications services and related equipment. From at least 24 December 2008 to 4 November 2010 Excite Mobile promoted its services through telephone marketing (telemarketing) calls by representatives of Lime India Private Limited (Lime India) and other call centres in India, Pakistan and the Philippines. Excite Mobile has made no appearance to date. The Australian Securities and Investment Commission (ASIC) is in the process of deregistering Excite Mobile, but has deferred the process following a request from the ACCC pending the outcome of this proceeding. Lime Australia Pty Ltd (Lime Australia) is a registered company in Australia. Prior to the establishment of Excite Mobile, Lime Australia conducted its primary business as a mobile phone plan dealer. This involved soliciting customers to an independent carrier, in exchange for a commission. On the establishment of Excite Mobile, Lime Australia became responsible for Excite Mobile’s accounting and for the contracting of Lime India. Lime India is a company based in India. Lime India provided services to Excite Mobile including making telemarketing calls to potential customers, attending to the customer service issues of Excite Mobile’s customers, attempting to collect unpaid accounts purportedly owed to Excite Mobile by customers, and entering information in relation to dealings with Excite Mobile’s customers into an electronic database, for and on behalf of Excite Mobile. Excite Mobile provided Lime India with the scripts to be used in the telemarketing calls and directed the telemarketers to follow the scripts. Roles of Mr Brown, Mr Samuel and Ms Smart Mr Brown and Mr Samuel were the founders and directors of Excite Mobile and were also its sole shareholders at all material times. Mr Brown was a director and secretary, and Mr Samuel was the other director. They were also the directors of Lime Australia – Mr Brown from 27 June 2002 and Mr Samuel from 10 October 2003. They, together with Mr Sundeep Grover, were also the directors of Lime India. Ms Smart became involved in Excite Mobile through Mr Brown, with whom she is in a relationship.Nature of package offered Excite Mobile contracted with customers to provide mobile telecommunication services through the Optus network. Potential customers were contacted by telemarketers who offered the customer an enticement to contract, namely the “gift” of a phone and holiday vouchers. The contracts offered were on a 24 month plan. The plans consisted of a minimum monthly fee, for which customers would receive a set daily allowance for calls and text messages, depending upon the size of their contract. The most commonly selected contract was the $33 per month plan, for which customers received a daily allowance for calls and text messages capped at $2.20. Any costs incurred outside of the cap would be added to the monthly bill. UNDISPUTED EVIDENCEThe telemarketing calls

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Excite Mobile contracted with customers to provide mobile telecommunication services through the Optus network. Potential customers were contacted by telemarketers who offered the customer an enticement to contract, namely the “gift” of a phone and holiday vouchers. The contracts offered were on a 24 month plan. The plans consisted of a minimum monthly fee, for which customers would receive a set daily allowance for calls and text messages, depending upon the size of their contract. The most commonly selected contract was the $33 per month plan, for which customers received a daily allowance for calls and text messages capped at $2.20. Any costs incurred outside of the cap would be added to the monthly bill. UNDISPUTED EVIDENCEThe telemarketing calls The telemarketing calls were to progress in a three-part sequence. A script was provided to the telemarketers and the telemarketers were instructed by Excite Mobile to follow it. During the first stage, an unsolicited telephone call was to be made to potential customers on their personal phone numbers. After a generic greeting, the script starts:Well! Guess what, you have been selected to receive a mobile phone absolutely at $0 upfront costs from Excite Mobiles which would be working on the most trusted mobile network in Australia and that’s none other than OPTUS with no Application, Activation, or Delivery Fee. You would be receiving NEW Best Seller “ZTE – T6 Mobile [sic] which has 2 mega pixel camera, FM Radio, MP3 Player and ring tones, Expandable memory card to support up to 4GB, Bluetooth 1.2 with stereo headset support, Speakerphone and many more great features.It does not stop here, because you would really be glad to know, that as a warm gesture for all our customers who sign up with us today, they would also be receiving holiday vouchers, which entitles 2 people, for a free accommodation for 7 days in any of the 200 hotels, over a period of one year. So if you observe with Excite Mobiles, you not only pay a low monthly access fee of only $22 but also in return if you break it down further every day you would be getting up to $2.20c worth of calls to be used completely which means UPTO $66 every single month,.. Isn’t that neat!!!(emphasis in original) The ACCC provided 10 examples of telemarketing calls and / or mobile contracts that were selected as follows. The first and last customers of Excite Mobile were chosen. The remaining eight customers were selected by choosing the last customer of every second month in which there was a recording available. The scripted explanation of the cap set out above was not included in any of the 10 examples referred to. Instead the telemarketers simply said words to the effect of “[f]or only $33 you get $66 worth of calls.” During the second stage of the telemarketing call, the telemarketers obtained personal information from the customers, including the customer’s address, full name, bank account number / credit card details and identification details such as a licence number.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Smart’s evidence was apparently given in a direct and frank way. She did not shy away from the conduct she obviously undertook on behalf of Excite Mobile. I have no reason not to accept her evidence.CONSIDERATION It is convenient first to briefly advert to the concepts of unconscionability, false and misleading conduct, and coercion as they appear in the TPA. The following material is not contentious. On the topic of unconscionability, s 51AB of the TPA provides:(1)A corporation shall not, in trade or commerce, in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods or services to a person, engage in conduct that is, in all the circumstances, unconscionable.(2)Without in any way limiting the matters to which the court may have regard for the purpose of determining whether a corporation has contravened subsection (1) in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods or services to a person (in this subsection referred to as the consumer), the court may have regard to:(a)the relative strengths of the bargaining positions of the corporation and the consumer;(b)whether, as a result of conduct engaged in by the corporation, the consumer was required to comply with conditions that were not reasonably necessary for the protection of the legitimate interests of the corporation;(c)whether the consumer was able to understand any documents relating to the supply or possible supply of the goods or services;(d)whether any undue influence or pressure was exerted on, or any unfair tactics were used against, the consumer or a person acting on behalf of the consumer by the corporation or a person acting on behalf of the corporation in relation to the supply or possible supply of the goods or services; and(e)the amount for which, and the circumstances under which, the consumer could have acquired identical or equivalent goods or services from a person other than the corporation.(3)A corporation shall not be taken for the purposes of this section to engage in unconscionable conduct in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods or services to a person by reason only that the corporation institutes legal proceedings in relation to that supply or possible supply or refers a dispute or claim in relation to that supply or possible supply to arbitration.(4)For the purpose of determining whether a corporation has contravened subsection (1) in connection with the supply or possible supply of goods or services to a person:(a)the court shall not have regard to any circumstances that were not reasonably forseeable at the time of the alleged contravention; and(b)the court may have regard to conduct engaged in, or circumstances existing, before the commencement of this section.(5)A reference in this section to goods or services is a reference to goods or services of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use or consumption.(6)A reference in this section to the supply or possible supply of goods does not include a reference to the supply or possible supply of goods for the purpose of re‑supply or for the purpose of using them up or transforming them in trade or commerce.(7)Section 51A applies for the purposes of this section in the same way as it applies for the purposes of Division 1 of Part V.