Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Ltd [2014] APO 37

Patent Application:                2009329824

Title:Apparatus and method for manufacturing a cable bolt

Patent Applicant:                   DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Ltd

Opponent:  Garford Pty Ltd

Delegate:  Greg Powell

Decision Date:  5 June 2014

Hearing Date:  2 April 2014, in Sydney

Catchwords:  PATENTS - section 59 – opposition to the grant of a patent – whether the invention is novel – invention novel – whether the claimed invention involves an inventive step – opponent has not discharged onus to show that invention was obvious in light of common general knowledge either alone or in combination with a document – evidence supplied by opponent infected by hindsight – whether the claims are clear – claims clear – whether the claims are fairly based – some claims found to lack fair basis – opposition successful on issue raised by Hearing Officer – no award of costs

Representation:  Patent applicant:  Mr Chris Burgess of Counsel, assisted by Greg Gurr of Spruson & Ferguson

Opponent:Mr Hamish Bevan of Counsel, assisted by Stuart Smith of Shelston IP

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2009329824

Title:Apparatus and method for manufacturing a cable bolt

Patent Applicant:                   DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Ltd

Date of Decision:                   5 June 2014

DECISION

Claims 18–23 lack fair basis.  The opposition is otherwise unsuccessful.

The applicant is given 60 days to file amendments.

No costs awarded.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. Application 2009329824 in the name of DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Ltd (“DSI”) was filed on 22 December 2009 as PCT/AU2009/001689.  It was advertised accepted on 14 April 2011.  A notice of opposition to the grant of a patent was filed by Garford Pty Ltd (“Garford”) on 14 July 2011.

  2. Evidence in support was completed on 14 August 2012 following a number of extensions, with the final one being granted following a decision by the Commissioner’s delegate (see Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited [2012] APO 106). Evidence in answer was completed on 11 December 2012. Evidence in reply was served on 21 June 2013, once again after a number of extensions with, again, the last extension being granted following a decision by the Commissioner’s delegate (see Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited [2013] APO 43). The matter was heard on 2 April 2014. Following the hearing, further submissions were made on matters that I raised during the course of the hearing.

    The Opposition

  3. The grounds for opposition set out in the Statement of Grounds and Particulars (“SGP”) were that the claimed invention lacked novelty, lacked inventiveness, was secretly used and did not satisfy subsection 40(3) of the Act in that the claims were not clear.  At the hearing, Garford indicated that its focus was on lack of inventiveness, lack of novelty for claims 18 and 19 only and lack of clarity.

    Onus of Proof

  4. The request for examination in relation to this patent application was filed on 20 January 2011. As…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] APO 37
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Garford Pty Ltd opposed the grant of a patent to DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Ltd (DSI) for an apparatus and method for manufacturing a cable bolt. The dispute centred on the novelty, inventiveness, clarity, and fair basis of DSI's patent claims. The primary legal issues were whether the invention was novel and involved an inventive step, whether the claims were clear and fairly based on the specification. The court found that claims 18–23 of the patent lacked fair basis as they described a method applicable to apparatus without accumulators, which were essential to the invention. However, the opposition was unsuccessful on the grounds of novelty and inventiveness. The court concluded that the invention was novel as it was not disclosed in the Garford Patent, and it involved an inventive step as the evidence did not show that the person skilled in the art would have combined the known elements in the way claimed. The court also found the claims clear, with the words “substantially continuously” providing a workable standard for the intended use. DSI was given 60 days to file amendments to the patent claims. No costs were awarded.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established