Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited [2012] APO 106

Patent Application:                2009329824

Title:Apparatus and method for manufacturing a cable bolt

Patent Applicant:                   DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited

Opponent:  Garford Pty Ltd

Delegate:  Dr S. D.Barker

Decision Date:  3 October 2012

Hearing Date:  Written submission filed on 10 August, further submissions in response filed 17 August

Catchwords:  PATENTS – extension of time serve evidence in support – evidence has been served and completed – explanation of the delay – nature and significance of evidence – extension allowed – costs awarded against opponent

Representation:  Patent applicant:  Spruson & Ferguson

Opponent:Shelston IP

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2009329824

Title:Apparatus and method for manufacturing a cable bolt

Patent Applicant:                   DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited

Date of Decision:                   3 October 2012

DECISION

I grant an extension of time to serve evidence in support until 14 August 2012.

I direct that the time serving evidence in answer shall be three months from the date of issue of this decision.

I award costs against Garford Pty Ltd.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited is the applicant for patent application 2009329824.  A notice of opposition to the grant of the patent was filed by Garford Pty Ltd (the opponent) on 14 July 2011, and a statement of grounds and particulars was served on 14 October 2011.  Evidence in support of the opposition was initially due on 14 January 2012, but the opponent sought and was granted an extension of time for serving evidence until 14 April 2012.  A second extension of time until 14 July 2012 was sought to file evidence in support, which was also allowed.

  1. On 16 July 2012 the opponent served a statutory declaration of Allan Clifford Wightley as part of its evidence in support, and also requested a third extension of time of two months from 14 July 2012 until 14 September 2012.  The applicant objected to the extension, and written submissions in relation to the extension were filed by both parties on 10 August 2012.  The opponent also filed submissions in response to the applicant’s submissions on 17 August 2012. 

  2. Importantly, in the intervening period between written submissions the opponent served and completed their evidence in support with the statutory declaration of Dr Andrei Lozzi on 14 August. 

    Reasons for the extension of time

  3. The reason for the extension of time was given as:

    “1.In the time since the last extension request, the Opponent has completed a statutory declaration of Allan Wightley, an independent expert witness. Mr Wightley's evidence provides an account of relevant common general knowledge, and includes a detailed review of the prior art on which we rely in this opposition, together with the opposed specification and claims. Mr Wightley's declaration, with annexures, is a significant declaration of several hundred pages, which took a considerable amount of time to prepare, including numerous meetings with Mr Wightley and background research. Mr Wightley's declaration has been served on the attorneys for the Applicants.

    2.We…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garford Pty Ltd v DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] APO 106
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Garford Pty Ltd opposed the patent application 2009329824 by DYWIDAG-Systems International Pty Limited. The dispute involved the patentability of the apparatus and method for manufacturing a cable bolt. The Australian Patent Office, represented by Dr. S. D. Barker, was tasked with deciding whether to grant an extension of time for Garford Pty Ltd to serve evidence in support of their opposition. The court was required to assess the reasons provided for the delay in serving the evidence, the nature and significance of the evidence, and the public interest in determining the opposition on its merits.

The court examined the submissions and statutory declarations provided by both parties. It found that although the opponent had completed and served the statutory declaration of their first expert, Allan Clifford Wightley, on 16 July 2012, the explanation for the delay in securing a second expert, Dr Andrei Lozzi, was inadequate. The court noted that the opponent had not provided a clear rationale for why Dr Lozzi's services were not secured earlier. Despite this, the court acknowledged that the evidence provided by Dr Lozzi, once served, had some additional significance over the evidence of Mr Wightley, as it provided a proposed solution to a problem faced by a person skilled in the art.

Considering the public interest, the court determined that the evidence, while corroborating Mr Wightley’s evidence, also provided some additional information. The court weighed the competing considerations, finding that the nature and significance of the evidence outweighed the inadequate explanation for the delay. The court granted the extension of time for the opponent to serve evidence in support until 14 August 2012, and directed that the time for serving evidence in answer would be three months from the date of issue of this decision.

In relation to costs, the court decided not to follow the usual practice of awarding costs to the prevailing party. Given the deficiencies in the explanation provided by the opponent for the delay in securing the second expert, the court awarded costs against Garford Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established