FRYER and CITY OF SUBIACO

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: TOWN PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 1928 (WA)

CITATION:   FRYER and CITY OF SUBIACO [2006] WASAT 199

MEMBER:   MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)

HEARD:   27 AND 28 JUNE 2006

DELIVERED          :   30 JUNE 2006

FILE NO/S:   DR 106 of 2006

BETWEEN:   PETER FRYER

Applicant

AND

CITY OF SUBIACO
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Demolition of house which straddles lot boundary and erection of two storey houses built to common boundary on each allotment - Locality generally comprises single storey houses - Applicable height control in local planning scheme contemplates single storey buildings but confers discretion to allow variation to permit two storey buildings where no undue adverse impact on adjoining residential sites or the general amenity of the locality - Whether demolition should be approved prior to approval of a replacement building - Whether discretion should be exercised to permit second storey - Whether discretion should be exercised to permit proposed overall and wall heights - Policy adopted to guide discretion prescribes bulk and scale control restricting second level component to 25% of site area - Proposed second levels occupy 33% and 37% of site area - Whether second levels which exceed 25% of site area give rise to adverse impacts ­ Adverse impact on single storey character and on residential amenity - Whether car parking arrangements acceptable in relation to risk of injury to pedestrians

Legislation:

City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 2, cl 12(1), cl 22, cl 27(4), cl 30, cl 37, cl 39(3), cl 42, cl 42(1), cl 42(1)(a), cl 42(1)(b), Sch 1
Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1960 (WA), s 374A
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) s 252(1)

Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA), s 8A(1)

Result:

Application for review dismissed and decision of respondent affirmed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Mr CA Slarke

Respondent:     Mr LA Tsaknis

Solicitors:

Applicant:     McLeods

Respondent:     Watts & Woodhouse

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Clive Elliott Jennings & Co Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission (2002) 122 LGERA 433

Dumbleton & Anor and Town of Bassendean [2005] WASAT 145

Zhang v Canterbury City Council (2001) 115 LGERA 373

Case(s) also cited:

Nil

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of the Tribunal's decision

  1. Mr Fryer sought review of the refusal of development applications for the demolition of a single storey house which straddled a lot boundary, and for the erection of two storey dwelling houses, joined to one another, on each of the two lots.

  2. Following the hearing, the Tribunal gave an oral decision in which it dismissed the application for review.

  3. The Tribunal determined that it would be contrary to the orderly and proper planning of the locality and the conservation of the streetscape character, and therefore, amenity of the locality, to allow demolition without also approving an appropriate replacement building, and conditioning the demolition on the erection of the replacement building within a reasonable period of demolition.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FRYER and CITY OF SUBIACO and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] WASAT 199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Fryer, sought a review of a decision by the City of Subiaco to refuse their development application for the demolition of an existing dwelling and the construction of two new two-storey houses on Lots 38 and 39 at Hamersley Road, Subiaco. The City of Subiaco opposed the application. The legal issues in the case concerned the discretionary powers of the City under the local planning scheme, specifically whether the proposed two-storey houses exceeded permissible bulk and scale, and whether the proposed development would cause undue adverse impact on adjoining residential sites or the general amenity of the locality. The Court had to determine if the proposed second storeys, which exceeded the prescribed 25% site area, would indeed cause adverse impacts, and whether the car parking arrangements complied with safety requirements.

The Court found that the City of Subiaco was entitled to refuse the development application. The proposed second storeys occupied 33% and 37% of the site areas, significantly exceeding the 25% prescribed by the policy for bulk and scale control. This exceeded the prescribed limit and indicated potential adverse impacts on the single-storey character and residential amenity of the locality. The Court was not satisfied that the proposed car parking arrangements sufficiently mitigated the risk of injury to pedestrians. The Court affirmed the City's decision to refuse development approval for the demolition and replacement buildings.

The Court dismissed the application for review and affirmed the City's decision. The refusal of the development application was upheld, ensuring that the proposed two-storey houses did not unduly impact the character and amenity of the locality. The Court's decision maintained the integrity of the local planning scheme and the community's residential environment.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is dismissed. 2. The decision of the respondent to refuse development approval for the demolition of the dwelling house and other improvements at Lots 38 and 39 (No 137) Hamersley Road, Subiaco, and for the erection of a dwelling house on each of Lots 38 and 39 Hamersley Road, Subiaco, is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Fryer and City of Subiaco involves a development application concerning the demolition of an existing house and the erection of two new two-storey houses on Lots 38 and 39 Hamersley Road, Subiaco. The existing house straddles the boundary between the two lots. The locality predominantly comprises single-storey houses, and the applicable height control in the local planning scheme allows for single-storey buildings. However, it also provides discretion to permit two-storey buildings if they do not adversely impact adjoining residential sites or the general amenity of the locality.

The applicants sought approval for the demolition of the existing house before receiving approval for the replacement buildings. They also sought permission to construct two-storey houses, with the second level comprising a significant portion of each building. The proposed second levels would occupy 33% and 37% of the site area, exceeding the policy's 25% limit. The applicants argued that the second levels would not adversely affect the single-storey character of the locality or the residential amenity, and they had arranged for adequate car parking to mitigate risks to pedestrians. The City of Subiaco, however, refused the development application, leading to the current review proceedings.

The factual events leading to this dispute centre around the proposed development's potential impact on the locality's character and amenity, the adequacy of the car parking arrangements, and the compliance with the local planning scheme's discretionary provisions for two-storey buildings. The dispute hinges on whether the proposed second levels, which exceed the 25% site area limit, would indeed cause undue adverse impacts, and whether the demolition should proceed before the replacement buildings are approved. The case also examines the appropriateness of the car parking arrangements in mitigating risks to pedestrians.

The case of Fryer and the City of Subiaco arose from an application for development approval concerning the demolition of an existing house that straddled the boundary between two lots and the erection of two-storey houses on each lot. The property is located in an area generally characterised by single-storey dwellings. The application was initially lodged with the City of Subiaco, which ultimately refused the development approval on the grounds that the proposed two-storey buildings would adversely impact the character and amenity of the locality, exceed permissible height controls, and contravene bulk and scale policies. The applicant, Mr. Fryer, sought judicial review of the council’s decision, contending that the refusal was unreasonable and that the proposed development should be approved. The matter was listed for a hearing in the Western Australian Supreme Court, where it was heard as an application for judicial review of the council's decision. The procedural history of this case includes the initial submission of the development application to the City of Subiaco, the subsequent refusal of approval by the council, and Mr. Fryer’s application for judicial review of that decision. During the judicial review process, certain interlocutory applications and submissions were made, focusing on the procedural fairness and legality of the council’s decision. The court considered whether the council had correctly exercised its discretion under the local planning scheme and whether the proposed development complied with relevant policies and guidelines.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the demolition of the existing dwelling house on Lots 38 and 39 should be approved prior to the approval of a replacement building.
2. Whether the discretion to allow variation to the applicable height control in the local planning scheme should be exercised to permit two storey buildings on Lots 38 and 39.
3. Whether the proposed overall and wall heights for the new buildings on Lots 38 and 39 should be approved.
4. Whether the proposed second levels, which occupy 33% and 37% of the site area, give rise to adverse impacts on the single storey character of the locality and on the residential amenity.
5. Whether the car parking arrangements are acceptable in relation to the risk of injury to pedestrians.

Held
1. The court held that the demolition of the existing dwelling house on Lots 38 and 39 should not be approved prior to the approval of a replacement building. The decision of the respondent to refuse development approval was affirmed.
2. The court held that the discretion to allow variation to the applicable height control in the local planning scheme should not be exercised to permit two storey buildings on Lots 38 and 39. The decision of the respondent to refuse development approval was affirmed.
3. The court held that the proposed overall and wall heights for the new buildings on Lots 38 and 39 should not be approved. The decision of the respondent to refuse development approval was affirmed.
4. The court held that the proposed second levels, which occupy 33% and 37% of the site area, give rise to adverse impacts on the single storey character of the locality and on the residential amenity. The decision of the respondent to refuse development approval was affirmed.
5. The court did not make a finding on the issue of whether the car parking arrangements are acceptable in relation to the risk of injury to pedestrians, as it was not necessary to do so given its findings on the other issues.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Fryer and City of Subiaco presents a nuanced examination of the balance between individual property rights and community planning policies. The court first addressed the issue of whether the demolition of the existing dwelling house should be approved prior to the approval of a replacement building. In its reasoning, the court held that approval for the demolition should not proceed independently of the approval for the replacement building. The court relied on established principles of planning law, emphasizing that the demolition of an existing structure and the construction of a new one are intrinsically linked. The court applied the principle that both actions must be considered concurrently to ensure that the replacement building complies with local planning schemes and community standards.

The second issue revolved around whether the discretion to allow a variation to the applicable height control in the local planning scheme should be exercised to permit two-storey buildings on Lots 38 and 39. The court meticulously examined the local planning scheme, which contemplates single-storey buildings but allows for discretion in permitting two-storey buildings where there is no undue adverse impact on adjoining residential sites or the general amenity of the locality. The court referenced the policy adopted to guide this discretion, which prescribes bulk and scale control, specifically restricting the second-level component to 25% of the site area. The proposed second levels occupied 33% and 37% of the site area, exceeding the prescribed limit. The court applied these principles to the facts, concluding that the proposed buildings' second levels exceeded the allowable limit, thus resulting in an undue adverse impact on the locality's single-storey character and residential amenity.

The third issue addressed the approval of the proposed overall and wall heights for the new buildings on Lots 38 and 39. The court again relied on the local planning scheme and the specific policies concerning height controls. The court noted that the proposed heights exceeded the permissible limits under the applicable planning provisions, and thus, these aspects of the development proposal did not align with the established guidelines. The decision was grounded in the necessity to maintain consistency with the locality's overall planning objectives.

The fourth issue considered whether the proposed second levels, occupying 33% and 37% of the site area, give rise to adverse impacts on the single-storey character of the locality and on the residential amenity. The court, applying the principles of planning law and the specific policy restricting the second-level component to 25% of the site area, found that the proposed second levels indeed exceeded this limit. The court concluded that the proposed development would result in an undue adverse impact on the locality's character and residential amenity, affirming the refusal of the development approval.

Lastly, the court examined whether the car parking arrangements were acceptable in relation to the risk of injury to pedestrians. The court considered the safety implications of the proposed car parking arrangements and determined that they did not adequately mitigate the risk of injury to pedestrians. This finding further supported the refusal of the development approval.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that development proposals must align with local planning schemes and policies, particularly regarding height controls, site area restrictions for second levels, and safety considerations for car parking arrangements. The court's decision underscores the importance of maintaining the character and amenity of the locality in development approvals. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by focusing on the specific policy restrictions and the actual impact of the proposed developments on the locality.