Adbooth Pty Ltd and City of Perth

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read
JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM
:  DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT 
:  PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION 
:  ADBOOTH PTY LTD and CITY OF PERTH
[2007] WASAT 76
MEMBER 
:  MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)
MR J JORDAN (MEMBER)
MS R MOORE (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)
HEARD 
:  28 FEBRUARY TO 2 MARCH 2007
DELIVERED  : 2 APRIL 2007
FILE NO/S 
:  DR 295 of 2006
BETWEEN  : ADBOOTH PTY LTD

Applicant

AND

CITY OF PERTH

Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - General commercial advertising attached to public telephone booths and pedestals - 30 sites in Perth, East Perth and Northbridge - Standard telephone services advertising is exempt under Federal law from requirement to obtain development approval under State law - Standard telephone services advertising installed or will be installed at all sites - Amenity impact - Whether development acceptable having regard to the preservation of the amenities of the locality - Whether, having regard to the character of the area, the amenity of the area will be enhanced or, at the very least, not diminished - Correct approach to determination of amenity impact -

[2007] WASAT 76

Whether amenity impact of general commercial advertising is to be determined by comparison with amenity impact of standard telephone services advertising - Whether amenity impact of standard telephone services advertising is the same as amenity impact of general commercial advertising such that amenity impact of the proposed development is neutral - Whether proposed development acceptable in consequence of commercial character of city - Whether there is a difference in character between general commercial advertising and commercial advertising associated with on-site business - Significance of general commercial advertising on bus shelters - Signage policy contemplates that commercial signage will generally be restricted to commercial advertising associated with on-site businesses - Whether signs satisfy development standards and other policy controls in signs policy and precinct plans

Legislation:

City of Perth City Planning Scheme No 2

, cl 36(1), cl 37, cl 37(b), cl 37(c), cl 37

cl 39, cl 43, cl 43(3), cl 43(4), cl 43(4)(h), cl 54, cl 56, Sch 1
City of Perth Planning Scheme No 26 - East Perth Redevelopment (Normalised)
Area
City of Perth Signs Policy, cl 2.4, cl 3, cl 5, cl 9.11
City of Perth King Street Heritage Design Guidelines
Land Administration Act 1997 (WA), s 55(1), s 55(2)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 162(1), s 238(3)(a)(i), s 238(4)
s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 46(1)
Telecommunications (Low-impact Facilities) Determination 1997 (Cth), s 3.1

Result:

Leave granted to withdraw proceedings in relation to 11 out of 41 sites
Application for review dismissed

Development approval refused

Category: B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr AR Beech SC with Ms BA Moharich

[2007] WASAT 76

Respondent : Mr A Roberts

Solicitors:

Applicant : Lavan Legal
Respondent : McLeods

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Adbooth Pty Ltd and City of Perth [2006] WASAT 343
Busen Pty Ltd and City of Subiaco [2007]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adbooth Pty Ltd and City of Perth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 76
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Adbooth Pty Ltd and the City of Perth arose over a development application submitted by Adbooth to install advertising on public telephone booths and pedestals at 30 sites in Perth, East Perth, and Northbridge. The City of Perth refused to approve the application, leading to Adbooth seeking judicial review in the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia. The central legal issues the tribunal had to decide included whether the proposed general commercial advertising would be acceptable from an amenity perspective, whether the amenity impact of such advertising was neutral compared to standard telephone services advertising, and whether the proposed development was acceptable given the commercial character of the city.

The tribunal considered the arguments presented by both parties, including the City's contention that the general commercial advertising would diminish the amenity of the area, and Adbooth's argument that the advertising would enhance or at least not diminish the area's amenity. The tribunal examined the relevant town planning policies and development standards, particularly focusing on the amenity impact of the proposed advertising. It also evaluated whether the proposed development should be assessed differently because of its commercial nature and whether there was a significant difference between general commercial advertising and advertising associated with on-site businesses. The tribunal concluded that the proposed development would not significantly impact the amenity of the area, given the commercial character of the city and the nature of the proposed advertising.

Ultimately, the tribunal ruled that the proposed development was acceptable and dismissed the application for review. The tribunal granted Adbooth leave to withdraw proceedings in relation to specific sites, effectively withdrawing the proceedings for those sites. This decision highlights the importance of considering the local context and character when assessing the amenity impact of proposed developments in urban commercial areas.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 46(1) of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) the applicant has leave to withdraw the proceedings in relation to the following sites and the proceedings are hereby withdrawn in relation to those sites: o Barrack Street, Perth (Site 3); o 113 Claisebrook Road, East Perth (Site 6); o 1 Francis Street, Perth (Site 7); o 62 Hill Street, Perth (Site 14); o 57 James Street, Perth (Site 17); o 17 Murray Street, Perth (Site 19); o Nelson Crescent, East Perth (Site 26); o 160 Pier Street, Perth (Site 28); o 554 Wellington Street, Perth (Site 39); o 640 Wellington Street, Perth (Site 40); and o 641 Wellington Street, Perth (Site 41). 2. The application for review is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Adbooth Pty Ltd, a company authorised to install advertising on public telephone booths and pedestals, applied to the City of Perth for development approval to install advertising at 30 sites across Perth, East Perth, and Northbridge. The proposed advertising was general commercial advertising, not associated with any on-site business. The City of Perth refused the development application on the basis that it would have an unacceptable amenity impact, contrary to the City's signs policy and precinct plans, which generally restrict commercial signage to advertising associated with on-site businesses.

The City's signs policy and precinct plans contemplate that commercial signage will generally be restricted to commercial advertising associated with on-site businesses. The policy and plans provide that signs must satisfy development standards and other policy controls, including those relating to the preservation of the amenities of the locality. The City of Perth considered that the proposed general commercial advertising would not satisfy these standards and controls, and would have an unacceptable amenity impact.

Adbooth Pty Ltd sought review of the City's decision under the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). Adbooth submitted that the City of Perth should not have considered the amenity impact of the proposed advertising by comparing it to the amenity impact of standard telephone services advertising, which is exempt from development approval under Federal law. Instead, Adbooth submitted that the amenity impact of general commercial advertising should be determined on its own merits, having regard to the character of the area and the proposed development. Adbooth also submitted that the proposed development was acceptable in consequence of the commercial character of the city, and that there was no material difference between general commercial advertising and commercial advertising associated with on-site businesses.

The case of Adbooth Pty Ltd and City of Perth originated as a development application concerning the installation of general commercial advertising on public telephone booths and pedestals at 30 sites in Perth, East Perth and Northbridge. The City of Perth, acting as the decision-maker, initially assessed the application under the relevant planning schemes and development standards. Adbooth Pty Ltd subsequently sought review of the City's decision by the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) in Western Australia, contesting the City's refusal to approve the development application on the basis of amenity impact. The matter came before the SAT as a first instance review under the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). During the proceedings, Adbooth argued that the general commercial advertising should be considered acceptable due to the commercial character of the city, and that there was no significant difference between the proposed advertising and commercial advertising associated with on-site businesses. They also contended that the signs would satisfy the development standards and policy controls outlined in the relevant signage policy and precinct plans. Prior to the final hearing, Adbooth made an application to withdraw the proceedings in relation to certain sites, which was granted by the Tribunal, resulting in the withdrawal of the proceedings for those specific sites. Ultimately, the Tribunal dismissed the application for review, concluding that the proposed development was not acceptable due to its potential amenity impact.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed installation of general commercial advertising on public telephone booths and pedestals in Perth, East Perth, and Northbridge is exempt from development approval under State law due to its classification as standard telephone services advertising under Federal law.
2. Whether the proposed development is acceptable considering the preservation of the amenities of the locality, and whether the amenity of the area will be enhanced or, at the very least, not diminished.
3. What is the correct approach to determining the amenity impact of the proposed development, and whether it should be compared to the amenity impact of standard telephone services advertising.
4. Whether there is a difference in the amenity impact between general commercial advertising and standard telephone services advertising, and if the proposed development's amenity impact is neutral.
5. Whether the proposed development is acceptable due to the commercial character of the city, and if there is a difference in character between general commercial advertising and commercial advertising associated with on-site businesses.
6. What is the significance of general commercial advertising on bus shelters and whether the proposed development complies with the signage policy that generally restricts commercial signage to advertising associated with on-site businesses.
7. Whether the proposed signs satisfy the development standards and other policy controls in the signs policy and precinct plans.

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed installation of general commercial advertising on public telephone booths and pedestals is not exempt from development approval under State law despite its classification as standard telephone services advertising under Federal law.
2. The court found that the proposed development is acceptable considering the preservation of the amenities of the locality, and that the amenity of the area will be enhanced or, at the very least, not diminished.
3. The court held that the correct approach to determining the amenity impact of the proposed development is not to compare it to the amenity impact of standard telephone services advertising.
4. The court found that there is a difference in the amenity impact between general commercial advertising and standard telephone services advertising, and that the proposed development's amenity impact is not neutral.
5. The court concluded that the proposed development is acceptable due to the commercial character of the city, and that there is a difference in character between general commercial advertising and commercial advertising associated with on-site businesses.
6. The court held that the significance of general commercial advertising on bus shelters is not determinative of the proposed development's compliance with the signage policy, which generally restricts commercial signage to advertising associated with on-site businesses.
7. The court found that the proposed signs do not satisfy the development standards and other policy controls in the signs policy and precinct plans.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Adbooth Pty Ltd and City of Perth, the court addressed several complex issues surrounding the proposed installation of general commercial advertising on public telephone booths and pedestals across various sites in Perth, East Perth, and Northbridge. The primary issue was whether the proposed installation, classified as standard telephone services advertising under Federal law, exempted it from development approval under State law. The court clarified that while standard telephone services advertising is exempt from such requirements, the proposed development's general commercial advertising did not automatically fall under this exemption. The court examined the legal principles and authorities relevant to the distinction between the two categories of advertising, ultimately determining that the proposed development did not qualify for exemption under State law.

The court also assessed whether the proposed development was acceptable considering the preservation of the amenities of the locality. The decision hinged on whether the amenity of the area would be enhanced or, at the very least, not diminished by the installation of general commercial advertising. The court adopted a thorough approach in determining the amenity impact of the proposed development, emphasizing that it should not be compared to the amenity impact of standard telephone services advertising. This nuanced approach underscored the need to consider the specific context and nature of the proposed development. The court found that there was a difference in the amenity impact between general commercial advertising and standard telephone services advertising, leading to the conclusion that the proposed development's amenity impact was not neutral and would not preserve the area's amenities.

Furthermore, the court explored whether the proposed development was acceptable due to the commercial character of the city. The distinction between general commercial advertising and commercial advertising associated with on-site businesses was pivotal in this analysis. The court noted that while the commercial character of the city could justify some advertising, general commercial advertising did not align with the policy of restricting commercial signage to on-site business advertising. This consideration was integral to the court's assessment of the development's compatibility with the area's character.

Another significant aspect of the court's reasoning involved the significance of general commercial advertising on bus shelters and its compliance with the signage policy. The policy generally restricts commercial signage to advertising associated with on-site businesses, and the court found that the proposed development did not conform to this policy. The court underscored the importance of adhering to the established signage policy to maintain the visual integrity and character of the locality.

Finally, the court examined whether the proposed signs satisfied the development standards and other policy controls in the signs policy and precinct plans. This involved a detailed review of the specific standards and controls applicable to the proposed development. The court concluded that the proposed signs did not meet the required standards and policies, further supporting the decision to dismiss the application for review.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the proposed installation of general commercial advertising on public telephone booths and pedestals, while exempt from development approval under Federal law as standard telephone services advertising, does not automatically qualify for exemption under State law. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of assessing the amenity impact, character compatibility, and adherence to signage policies in determining the acceptability of such developments. The court's approach to comparing amenity impacts and its adherence to established policy controls provide a clear framework for future similar cases.