CERINI and CITY OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   CERINI and CITY OF VINCENT [2023] WASAT 74

MEMBER:   MS C BARTON, MEMBER

HEARD:   25, 26 AND 31 MAY 2023

DELIVERED          :   17 AUGUST 2023

FILE NO/S:   DR 92 of 2022

BETWEEN:   GRAHAM VICTOR CERINI

Applicant

AND

CITY OF VINCENT

Respondent


Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Exercise of planning discretion - Approved advertising sign - Digital sign - Billboard - Third party advertising - Advertisement - Innominate use - History of time-limited approvals - Whether condition imposing time limit should be deleted - Desired future character and amenity of the locality - Change in future character of the locality - Whether consistency with local signage policy - Application of policy - Whether cogent reason to depart from policy - Vehicular access - Consent authority for driveway or crossover - Commercial zone - Whether consistency with zone objectives

Legislation:

City of Busselton Local Planning Scheme No. 21, cl 4.5.2, cl 4.42, cl 37(2)
City of Vincent Local Planning Scheme No. 2, cl 16(1), cl 18(4), cl 18(4), cl 18(4)a)
Evidence Act 1906 (WA)
Local Government (Uniform Local Provisions) Regulations 1996 (WA), reg 4, reg 12(1)
Main Roads Act 1930 (WA), s 6
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 1, cl 3(5), cl 60, cl 67(2), cl 67(2)(b), cl 67(2)(i), cl 67(2)(m)(i), cl 67(2)(n), cl 67(2)(n)(ii), cl 76(2), cl 76(4)(c), cl 77(2)(a)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 87(4), s 257A(3)
Public Works Act 1902 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 17, s 18, s 27, s 27(1), s 29(3), s 32(1), s 32(2)(a), s 32(2)(b)
State Planning Policy 7.3 Residential Design Codes Volume 1

Result:

Application for review dismissed
Respondent's decision affirmed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr J Skinner
Respondent : Mr A Roberts

Solicitors:

Applicant : Thomson Geer - Perth
Respondent : Castledine Gregory

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Adbooth Pty Ltd and City of Perth [2007] WASAT 76

Alcock and Town of Claremont [2013] WASAT 83

Austral Bricks (WA) Pty Ltd and Shire of Serpentine-Jarrahdale [2023] WASAT 40

Caratti Holding Co Pty Ltd and City of Belmont [2021] WASAT 105

Carrooda Pty Ltd and City of Gosnells [2022] WASAT 15

Coffs Harbour Environment Centre Inc v Coffs Harbour City Council (1991) 74 LGRA 185

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 24 ALR 577; (1979) 2 ALD 60

Empire Securities Pty Ltd & Ors and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 98

Grace and City of Nedlands [2010] WASAT 53

JAG Traffic Pty Ltd and City of Cockburn [2022] WASAT 99

Koltasz Smith & Partners v Western Australian Planning Commission (2000) 23 SR (WA) 266

Land Alliance Pty Ltd and City of Belmont [2005] WASAT 100

Marshall v Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226

Minister for Immigration Local Government & Ethnic Affairs v Gray (1994) 50 FCR 189

Permanent Trustee Australia Ltd v City of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CERINI and CITY OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] WASAT 74
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Cerini, sought to have condition 1 of the current approval for the signs on the subject site, which sets the term of approval to expire on 21 October 2029, deleted. The City of Vincent, the respondent, refused the application. Cerini commenced proceedings in the Tribunal to review the respondent's decision. The central issue for the Tribunal to determine was whether the time limit condition should be deleted. The Tribunal considered whether the signs were consistent with the provisions of the Signage Policy and its objectives, and whether there were cogent reasons or a sound basis to depart from the policy.

The Tribunal found that the Signage Policy should be afforded significant weight in making its decision, based on the criteria established in relevant authorities. The Tribunal noted that the signs did not comply with the deemed-to-comply standards for freestanding and hoarding signs in the Signage Policy, and thus had to be assessed against the objectives of the Signage Policy. The respondent provided evidence that the signs were inconsistent with the objectives of the Signage Policy, as they were not suitably designed and located to enhance the amenity of the surrounding locality, did not relate to services and products available on the subject site, and, on occasion, advertised alcohol. The Tribunal concluded that there were cogent reasons to maintain the time limit condition, as it was necessary to ensure that the signs were consistent with the objectives of the Signage Policy and the desired future character and amenity of the locality.

The Tribunal dismissed the application and affirmed the respondent's decision. The Tribunal found that the signs did not meet the deemed-to-comply standards for freestanding and hoarding signs in the Signage Policy and were inconsistent with the objectives of the Signage Policy. The Tribunal considered that there were cogent reasons to maintain the time limit condition to ensure that the signs were consistent with the objectives of the Signage Policy and the desired future character and amenity of the locality. The Tribunal did not find it necessary to depart from the Signage Policy, as the signs did not meet the deemed-to-comply standards and were inconsistent with the objectives of the Signage Policy.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 22 October 2021, the applicant sought to alter the 2018 amendment by deleting condition 1 but on 17 May 2022 the respondent refused the application (respondent's decision). On 2 June 2022, the applicant commenced proceedings in the Tribunal to review the respondent's decision pursuant to cl 76(2) of Sch 2 to the Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA) (LPS Regulations). Consequently, the application falls within the Tribunal's review jurisdiction. For the reasons that follow, I find that the application that is the subject of this review proceeding should be dismissed and the respondent's decision affirmed. The subject site is formally described as Lot 116 on Deposited Plan 2360, being the whole of the land in Certificate of Title Volume 1193 Folio 707.[3][3] Notice of determination dated 17 May 2022. The subject site has an area of 641m2 and is located on the north­eastern corner of the intersection of Newcastle Street and Loftus Street, which is a signalised intersection.[4] It has an 11-metre frontage to Newcastle Street and a 28.7 metre frontage to Loftus Street, with a truncation provided at the intersection of Newcastle and Loftus Streets.[5] Apart from the signs and associated landscaping, required as a condition of approval, the subject site is vacant.[4] Respondent's SIFC, para 3; Applicant's SIFC, para 2.[5] Respondent's SIFC, para 3; Applicant's SIFC, para 2. The subject site abuts No 590 (Lot 12) Newcastle Street, West Perth, to the east (590 Newcastle Street). The property at 590 Newcastle Street has a lot area of 934m2 and contains a single storey brick and tile commercial building.[6] At its rear (northern) boundary, the subject site abuts No 65 (Lot 800) Kingston Avenue, West Perth (65 Kingston Avenue). The property at 65 Kingston Avenue has an area of 769m2 and is currently vacant.[7] Development approval for the erection of the signs on the subject site was first granted by the respondent on 26 August 2003, subject to a condition limiting the approval to 3 years.[8] The respondent subsequently granted further time-limited approvals for the signs as follows:[9]1)3-year time limit on 9 March 2004;2)3-year time limit on 8 August 2006;3)5-year time limit on 23 February 2010; and4)5-year time limit on 21 October 2014.[8] Respondent's SIFC, para 6; Applicant's SIFC, para 4.[9] Respondent's SIFC, para 7; Applicant's SIFC, para 4. In 2017, the applicant sought to amend the 2014 approval to delete the condition imposing the 5-year time limit. On 6 March 2018, the respondent decided not to delete the condition but amended it to provide that the 2014 approval was valid until 21 October 2029.[10] [10] Respondent's SIFC, para 9; Applicant's SIFC, para 4. The 2014 approval and the 2018 amendment together comprise the current approval for the signs (current approval). Relevantly, condition 1 of the current approval provides:This approval for the billboard signs is valid until 21 October 2029. The key issue for determination by the Tribunal is:1)Whether condition 1 of the current approval for the signs on the subject site, under which the term of approval expires on 21 October 2029 (time limit), should be deleted?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Any departure from government policy must be cautious and sparing, occurring only where there is a cogent reason or sound basis to do so, which itself is grounded in planning law or principle.[91][91] Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634 at 644­5; Marshall v Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226 at [182]. In Land Alliance Pty Ltd and City of Belmont [2005] WASAT 100 at [51], the Tribunal adopted the criteria set out in Permanent Trustee Australia Ltd v City of Wanneroo (1994) 11 SR (WA) 1 (Permanent Trustee) for determining the weight to be given to a policy.[92] The criteria include whether the policy is based on sound planning principles, is public (as opposed to secret) and whether it was conceived after considerable public discussion. The length of time that the policy has been in operation and whether it has been continuously applied are also relevant criteria. The weight attached to a policy may be influenced by the extent of public consultation that preceded it and whether it originated from a political or departmental process.[93][92] Cited with approval in Sharon Property Pty Ltd and Presiding Member of the Metro Inner-North Joint Development Assessment Panel [2021] WASAT 63 at [361].[93] Marsh and Commissioner of Police [2018] WASAT 139 at [27] and [38]-[39]. It follows from these authorities that I must consider the provisions of the Signage Policy in making my decision, but those provisions cannot be applied inflexibly so as to replace the exercise of my discretion. I am entitled to depart from the Signage Policy if there are cogent reasons or a sound basis for doing so having regard to the relevance of the planning principles that find expression in its provisions. I will next consider whether the signs are consistent with the provisions of the Signage Policy, and its objectives. The respondent says that the Signage Policy is relevant to my determination and, having regard to the criteria in Permanent Trustee, should be afforded significant weight.[94] The respondent contends that deletion of the time limit would be inconsistent with cl 3.2 of the Signage Policy because it would, in effect, extend the current approval beyond the current expiry date of 21 October 2029. The respondent further contends that the dimensions of the signs do not comply with the deemed-to-comply standards for freestanding and hoarding signs in cl 10.5 of the Signage Policy.[94] Respondent's closing submissions, para 132. Because the deemed-to-comply standards are not met, the respondent says that the signs must be assessed against the objectives of the Signage Policy (in accordance with cl 6.1 of the Signage Policy). Relying on the evidence of Ms Butterworth and Mr Corbellini, it is the respondent's position that the signs are inconsistent with the objectives of the Signage Policy because they are not suitably designed and located to enhance the amenity of the surrounding locality (contrary to objective 2),[95] do not relate to services and products available on the subject site (contrary to objective 3), and, on occasion, advertise alcohol (contrary to objective 8).[96] [95] Witness statement of Amanda Jane Butterworth dated 14 April 2023, paras 82; Substituted witness statement of John Corbellini dated 5 May 2023, para 102.[96] Substituted witness statement of John Corbellini dated 5 May 2023, JC10.