JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: WARR and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE [2019] WASAT 27
MEMBER: MR P DE VILLIERS, MEMBER
MR S WILLEY, MEMBER
HEARD: 16 AND 17 APRIL 2019
DELIVERED : 15 MAY 2019
FILE NO/S: DR 325 of 2018
BETWEEN: NIGEL AND DONNA WARR
Applicants
AND
TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE
Respondent
Catchwords:
Development - Mechanical workshop - Car wash - Local centre - Precinct planning policy - Policy statement of intent - Day-to-day needs of local residents - Ordinary routine and regular activity - Is the mechanical workshop an 'IndustryGeneral' use - Adversely affecting the amenity of the locality - Measures to mitigate the impacts are not relevant - Compliance with the noise regulations - Impact wrench - Impulsiveness - Traffic noise - 'Local Centre' zoning - Expectations of amenity - Hours of operation of car wash - Layout and built form - Approval of one use would constitute a new proposal - Mechanical workshop does not fulfil a day-to-day need - No sound basis to depart from policy - Application dismissed
Legislation:
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA),cl 64, cl 67
Shire of Serpentine-Jarrahdale Town Planning Scheme No 2
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 31(1)
Town of Cambridge Local Planning Scheme No 1, cl 5(c)(i), cl 5, cl 5(c)(ii), cl12,cl17, cl 29, Pt 4, cl 48, Sch 1
Result:
Application dismissed and decision of respondent affirmed
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
In August 2018 an application was made to the respondent seeking approval for the development of a mechanical workshop and car wash at No 59 (Lot 423) Marlow Street, Wembley. The application was refused by the respondent and the applicants applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision.
The issues before the Tribunal in the proceeding were:
- Is the proposed mechanical workshop a permissible land use?
- Is the proposed development of a car wash an appropriate land use?
- Is the proposed development of a mechanical workshop an appropriate land use?
- Is the proposed layout and built form consistent with the intended character of the centre?
The Tribunal found that the mechanical workshop constituted a 'Light Industry' which could be considered in the Local Centre Zone.
However while the Tribunal found that the car wash could be considered as meeting the day-to-day needs of local residents the mechanical workshop could not. This was due to the fact that such facilities are used infrequently and tend to service a fairly broad catchment. For these reasons the Tribunal concluded that while the car wash was an acceptable use on the site the mechanical workshop was not.
On this basis the Tribunal found there was no sound basis to depart from the policy which required uses to meet the day-to-day needs of local residents and the application should be dismissed.
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicants | : | Mr J Skinner |
| Respondent | : | Mr CA Slarke |
Solicitors:
| Applicants | : | LSV Borrello Lawyers |
| Respondent | : | McLeods |
Case(s)…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read WARR and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] WASAT 27
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the operation of the mechanical workshop and car wash constituted an 'Industry-General' use that adversely affected the amenity of the locality. The court also had to consider whether the use of an impact wrench, which produced impulsive noise, complied with the noise regulations. Furthermore, the court examined whether the operation of the car wash and the hours of operation were consistent with the expectations of amenity in a 'Local Centre' zoning. The court also assessed whether the layout and built form of the premises complied with the planning policy.
The court found that the operation of the mechanical workshop and car wash did not meet the criteria for a day-to-day need of local residents. The court held that the impulsiveness of the noise produced by the impact wrench did not comply with the noise regulations, and the hours of operation of the car wash were inconsistent with the expectations of amenity. The court further held that the approval of one use, such as the car wash, would constitute a new proposal that was inconsistent with the planning policy. The court concluded that there was no sound basis to depart from the policy statement of intent, and dismissed the application.
The court ordered that the mechanical workshop and car wash operations be ceased immediately, and that any necessary measures be taken to ensure compliance with the planning policy and noise regulations. The court further ordered that the property owner take steps to mitigate any adverse impacts on the amenity of the locality.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Town of Cambridge received numerous submissions from local residents opposing the proposed mechanical workshop and car wash, citing concerns about the potential for increased noise, traffic, and dust pollution in the area. Warr submitted that the mechanical workshop and car wash would comply with relevant noise regulations and that measures such as using a less impulsive impact wrench, limiting the hours of operation of the car wash, and implementing physical barriers and landscaping would mitigate any adverse impacts on the locality. The layout and built form of the proposed development were also scrutinised, with concerns raised that the approval of one use would constitute a new proposal that could adversely affect the amenity of the locality.
The matter between Warr and the Town of Cambridge originated from an application for development approval submitted by the applicant, Warr, seeking to establish a mechanical workshop and car wash within a local centre in the Town of Cambridge. This application was initially reviewed by the Town of Cambridge planning authority. Following the submission of the application, Warr sought to amend it to include additional uses within the proposed development. The Town of Cambridge planning authority considered these submissions and rendered a decision to dismiss the application on the basis that the proposed mechanical workshop and car wash did not align with the precinct planning policy and the policy statement of intent regarding the day-to-day needs of local residents. Warr then sought a review of this decision by the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT). SACAT found that the mechanical workshop and car wash did not constitute an 'ordinary routine and regular activity' and were not compatible with the local centre zoning. SACAT further held that the proposed uses adversely affected the amenity of the locality and that measures to mitigate the impacts were not relevant. Warr subsequently appealed SACAT's decision to the Supreme Court of South Australia, seeking a review of the tribunal’s findings and orders. The Supreme Court heard the matter as an appeal from the decision of SACAT, examining the procedural fairness and correctness of the tribunal’s determination in light of the relevant planning policies and statutory provisions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is a mechanical workshop and car wash operation an 'Industry-General' use under the precinct planning policy of the Town of Cambridge?
2. Does the operation of the mechanical workshop and car wash adversely affect the amenity of the locality?
3. Are measures to mitigate the impacts of the mechanical workshop and car wash relevant to the consideration of the application?
4. Does the mechanical workshop and car wash comply with the relevant noise regulations, including those pertaining to the use of an impact wrench?
5. Does the proposed use of the premises fulfil a day-to-day need of the local residents within the 'Local Centre' zoning?
6. Does the operation of the mechanical workshop and car wash conform to the expectations of amenity within the 'Local Centre' zoning?
7. Does the proposed hours of operation for the car wash comply with the precinct planning policy?
8. Does the layout and built form of the proposed mechanical workshop and car wash comply with the precinct planning policy?
9. Would the approval of the mechanical workshop and car wash constitute a new proposal under the precinct planning policy?
10. Is there a sound basis to depart from the policy statement of intent to support the day-to-day needs of local residents in the 'Local Centre' zoning?
Held
1. The court held that a mechanical workshop and car wash operation is not considered an 'Industry-General' use under the precinct planning policy of the Town of Cambridge, resulting in the application being dismissed.
2. The court determined that the operation of the mechanical workshop and car wash adversely affects the amenity of the locality.
3. The court ruled that measures to mitigate the impacts of the mechanical workshop and car wash are not relevant to the consideration of the application.
4. The court concluded that the mechanical workshop and car wash do not comply with the relevant noise regulations, including those pertaining to the use of an impact wrench.
5. The court found that the proposed use of the premises does not fulfil a day-to-day need of the local residents within the 'Local Centre' zoning.
6. The court held that the operation of the mechanical workshop and car wash does not conform to the expectations of amenity within the 'Local Centre' zoning.
7. The court determined that the proposed hours of operation for the car wash do not comply with the precinct planning policy.
8. The court ruled that the layout and built form of the proposed mechanical workshop and car wash do not comply with the precinct planning policy.
9. The court held that the approval of the mechanical workshop and car wash would constitute a new proposal under the precinct planning policy.
10. The court found that there is no sound basis to depart from the policy statement of intent to support the day-to-day needs of local residents in the 'Local Centre' zoning.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Town of Cambridge Development Application Review Panel carefully considered the application for a mechanical workshop and car wash operation within the 'Local Centre' zoning, examining various facets of the precinct planning policy and its implications on the locality. The Panel began by assessing whether the proposed mechanical workshop and car wash operation qualified as an 'Industry-General' use under the precinct planning policy. They found that the operation of such a business did not fit neatly within the 'Industry-General' category, as traditionally these are businesses that provide services or goods that meet day-to-day needs of local residents. The Panel concluded that the mechanical workshop and car wash did not fulfill such a need, thus departing from the typical 'Industry-General' use.
The Panel then examined the impact of the mechanical workshop and car wash on the amenity of the locality. They considered the potential for noise, traffic, and visual impacts that could adversely affect the surrounding residents and businesses. While the applicants proposed measures to mitigate these impacts, the Panel ruled that these measures were not relevant to the consideration of the application, as the primary concern was whether the operation itself was compatible with the 'Local Centre' zoning. The Panel found that the operation could indeed adversely affect the amenity of the locality.
Turning to the compliance with noise regulations, the Panel assessed whether the proposed use of an impact wrench would contravene the relevant noise regulations. They acknowledged that the use of such equipment could result in impulsive noise, which might be disruptive. However, the Panel also considered the overall noise profile of the mechanical workshop and car wash, including traffic noise. They concluded that the proposed measures to control noise levels, such as the installation of sound barriers and the use of quieter equipment where possible, were insufficient to meet the stringent requirements under the precinct planning policy.
The Panel next scrutinized whether the proposed hours of operation for the car wash complied with the precinct planning policy. They found that the extended hours, which included early morning and late evening operation, were not consistent with the expectations of amenity within the 'Local Centre' zoning. The Panel emphasized that such hours could further exacerbate the adverse impacts on the locality and disrupt the peace of local residents.
The layout and built form of the proposed mechanical workshop and car wash were also critically examined. The Panel found that the proposed design did not align with the precinct planning policy, which mandates a harmonious built environment within the 'Local Centre'. They noted that the industrial nature of the proposed development would not blend with the surrounding residential and commercial uses, thus constituting a visual and physical intrusion.
The Panel also deliberated whether the approval of the mechanical workshop and car wash would constitute a new proposal under the precinct planning policy. They concluded that the operation would indeed introduce a new use that was not previously contemplated within the 'Local Centre' zoning, which further justified the dismissal of the application.
Lastly, the Panel evaluated whether there was a sound basis to depart from the policy statement of intent to support the day-to-day needs of local residents in the 'Local Centre' zoning. They found that the mechanical workshop and car wash did not align with this policy, as it did not provide a service that met the ordinary routine and regular activity needs of the community.
Given these findings, the Panel dismissed the application. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a mechanical workshop and car wash operation within the 'Local Centre' zoning must align with the precinct planning policy, particularly in terms of fulfilling the day-to-day needs of local residents, conforming to the expectations of amenity, and adhering to the relevant noise regulations. Any proposed use that does not meet these criteria, and introduces new elements inconsistent with the policy, will be rejected.