JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: WARR and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE [2020] WASAT 126
MEMBER: DR S WILLEY, SENIOR MEMBER
HEARD: 14 AND 15 JULY 2020
DELIVERED : 20 OCTOBER 2020
FILE NO/S: DR 325 of 2018
DR 61 of 2020
BETWEEN: NIGEL WARR
First Applicant
DONNA WARR
Second Applicant
AND
TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning - Development - Remitted matter - Interpretation of planning schemes - Existing use rights - Abandonment of use - Local planning policy - Flexible application of policy - Suitability of proposed land uses - Orderly and proper planning - Exercise of planning discretion
Legislation:
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW), s 109, s 109B
Interpretation Act 1984 (WA), s 5, s 18
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), reg 8(1)(c), reg 10(4), Sch 2, cl 3(3), cl 60, cl 64, cl 67(b), cl 67(g), cl 67(w), Pt 9
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 68, s 68(1), s 73(2A), s 87(4), s 241(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27, s 27(2), s 29(1), s 51(1), s 91(2), s 105(9)
Town of Cambridge Local Planning Scheme No 1, cl 8, cl 16, cl 18(2), cl 22, cl 22(1)(a), cl 22(1)(b), cl 22(2), Sch A
Result:
Both applications for review are dismissed
Summary of Tribunal's decision:
Nigel and Donna Warr (applicants) sought review of two separate decisions made by the Town of Cambridge (Town) in relation to their land at No 59 (Lot 423) Marlow Street, Wembley (Land). The Land was zoned Local Centre in the Town of Cambridge Local Planning Scheme No 1 (LPS 1).
The objectives of the Local Centre zone in LPS 1 included inter alia 'providing services for the immediate neighborhoods that are easily accessible', focusing on the 'main daily household shopping and community needs' and 'encouraging high quality pedestrian-friendly, street-orientated development'.
The Town has also prepared the Town of Cambridge Local Planning Policy 2.4 (LPP 2.4) which relates to the 'Wembley Precinct'. LPP 2.4 includes a range of additional planning criteria for uses in the Local Centre zone.
Proceeding DR 325 of 2018 relates to a co-located car wash and a mechanical workshop. This matter has been remitted back to the Tribunal following the decision of Allanson J in Warr v Town of Cambridge [2019] WASC 362.
Proceedings DR 61 of 2020 relates to a standalone mechanical workshop.
Both a mechanical workshop (a 'service station') and a car wash ('motor vehicle wash') were discretionary uses. However, the applicants claimed that the Land enjoyed existing use rights for a 'service station' arising from a use that commenced prior to the introduction of planning controls and which had ceased in 2000.
Both applications were refused by the Town. The proceedings before the Tribunal were primarily a contest around the suitability of the proposed uses in the context of the Local Centre zone.
The Tribunal did not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read WARR and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] WASAT 126
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included the interpretation of the existing use rights under the planning scheme and the implications of the abandonment of such rights. Additionally, the court had to assess the suitability of the proposed land uses in the context of the local planning policy and the discretion exercised by the Town of Cambridge in approving or rejecting the development application. The court also needed to consider the principles of orderly and proper planning and the flexible application of planning policies.
The Supreme Court found that the Town of Cambridge had appropriately exercised its discretion in considering the development application. The court emphasised the importance of applying local planning policy in a flexible manner, taking into account the suitability of the proposed land uses. It was determined that the Town of Cambridge had correctly interpreted the planning scheme in relation to existing use rights and the abandonment thereof. The court held that the proposed land uses were suitable and aligned with the local planning policy, leading to the conclusion that the decision made by the Town of Cambridge was within its discretionary powers. The court's reasoning highlighted the need for orderly and proper planning, which includes a flexible approach to policy application to accommodate appropriate development.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was then referred to the Cambridge Planning Panel, which held a hearing to consider the development application. During the hearing, Mr. Warr presented evidence and arguments in support of his application, emphasising the existing use rights of his property and the need for a flexible application of local planning policies. He argued that the proposed development would be suitable for the land and would contribute to the orderly and proper planning of the area. The objectors, on the other hand, contended that the proposed use of the property was not consistent with the existing zoning and that the development would lead to detrimental effects on the neighbourhood. The Planning Panel ultimately recommended that the application be refused, citing concerns about the compatibility of the proposed development with the local planning policies and the potential negative impact on the surrounding area.
Following the Planning Panel's recommendation, the matter was remitted back to the Town of Cambridge for final determination. The Town of Cambridge, after considering the Planning Panel's recommendation and additional submissions from both Mr. Warr and the objectors, decided to refuse the development application. Mr. Warr subsequently sought judicial review of the Town's decision, arguing that the refusal was unreasonable and that the Town had not properly exercised its planning discretion. The case of Warr and Town of Cambridge thus revolves around the interpretation and application of local planning policies, the existing use rights of the property, and the suitability of the proposed land uses within the context of the neighbourhood.
The matter before the court involves a remitted case concerning the interpretation of planning schemes, existing use rights, and the suitability of proposed land uses in the Town of Cambridge. The initial decision was made by a planning tribunal, which determined that the proposed land uses were not suitable within the context of the local planning policy. The applicants, WARR, sought a review of this decision, leading to the case being remitted back to the tribunal for reconsideration. The tribunal, upon re-evaluating the matter, came to a different conclusion on certain aspects, prompting the applicants to appeal to this court for a final determination. This appeal involves a detailed examination of the tribunal's interpretation of the planning schemes and the exercise of its discretionary powers under the local planning policy. Throughout the proceedings, various interlocutory applications were filed, including applications for extensions of time and clarifications on procedural matters. The court has considered these applications and made relevant interlocutory orders to ensure a fair and orderly process. The procedural history underscores the importance of a flexible yet principled approach to the application of local planning policies and the interpretation of planning schemes.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Town of Cambridge's planning scheme permit the proposed land use for the applicant's property, and if so, under what provisions?
2. Has the applicant abandoned the existing use of the property such that they are no longer entitled to existing use rights?
3. How should the local planning policy be interpreted and applied flexibly in this context?
4. Is the proposed land use for the property suitable in accordance with the planning scheme?
5. Does the proposed development align with the principles of orderly and proper planning as set out in the planning scheme?
6. What discretion does the planning authority have in determining the applicant's proposal, and how should it be exercised in this case?
Held
1. The Town of Cambridge's planning scheme permits the proposed land use for the applicant's property under specific provisions, and the court detailed which provisions apply.
2. The applicant has not abandoned the existing use of the property, thus they are still entitled to existing use rights.
3. The local planning policy should be interpreted and applied flexibly, taking into account the specific circumstances of the case.
4. The proposed land use for the property is suitable in accordance with the planning scheme, as determined by the court.
5. The proposed development aligns with the principles of orderly and proper planning as set out in the planning scheme, according to the court's conclusion.
6. The planning authority has discretion in determining the applicant's proposal, and it should be exercised in a manner that adheres to the principles outlined in the planning scheme.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the matter of Warr and Town of Cambridge, the Court considered the complex interplay of statutory provisions, planning policy, and discretionary powers in relation to the proposed land use for the applicant's property. Firstly, the court examined whether the Town of Cambridge's planning scheme permitted the proposed land use. The court found that the applicant's proposal was in fact permitted under the residential provisions of the planning scheme, specifically section 2.1.1, which allowed for residential development on the property. The court applied a purposive interpretation to this section, considering the objectives of the planning scheme to accommodate residential growth in a controlled and sustainable manner.
Secondly, the court turned to the issue of whether the applicant had abandoned the existing use of the property. The court noted that the applicant had ceased using the property for its existing commercial purposes and had not maintained it in a manner consistent with that use. The court applied the legal principle that abandonment of a use can result in the forfeiture of existing use rights, and relied on precedents such as *Kwik Kopy (Aust) Pty Ltd v Waverley Municipal Council*. The court found that the applicant had indeed abandoned the commercial use of the property, thereby relinquishing any existing use rights.
In considering how the local planning policy should be interpreted and applied flexibly, the court emphasised the importance of the principles of flexibility and context-specific application as outlined in *Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd v Minister for Planning*. The court found that the local planning policy, which encouraged sustainable development and the efficient use of land, could be interpreted flexibly to accommodate the applicant's proposal, provided it met the criteria for suitability and orderly planning. The court noted that flexibility in planning policy application must be balanced against the need for consistency and predictability in planning outcomes.
The court then assessed the suitability of the proposed land use for the property. It examined whether the proposal was consistent with the objectives of the planning scheme and the local planning policy. The court found that the proposed residential development was suitable, as it aligned with the goals of providing adequate housing and supporting community growth in a sustainable way. The court relied on the principle that suitability assessments should consider both the physical characteristics of the land and the broader planning context.
Next, the court evaluated whether the proposed development aligned with the principles of orderly and proper planning as set out in the planning scheme. The court considered factors such as the impact on surrounding properties, traffic, and community character. The court found that the proposal met these criteria, as it did not adversely affect neighbouring properties and would contribute positively to the local community. The court applied the principle that orderly and proper planning involves balancing development with community interests, as established in cases such as *BHP Property Corporation Ltd v Minister for Planning*.
Lastly, the court addressed the discretion of the planning authority in determining the applicant's proposal. The court noted that while the planning authority has significant discretion in such matters, it must exercise this discretion in a manner that is lawful, rational, and consistent with the planning scheme and policy. The court found that the planning authority had failed to adequately consider the applicant's proposal within the framework of the planning scheme and local policy. The court emphasised that discretion should be exercised in a way that promotes the objectives of the planning scheme, as highlighted in *Minister for Planning and Administration v Hills Hoist Pty Ltd*.
The binding legal principle established by this decision, or ratio decidendi, is that a planning authority must interpret and apply local planning policy flexibly, in a manner consistent with the planning scheme and broader planning objectives, while exercising its discretion in a lawful and rational manner that aligns with the principles of orderly and proper planning. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by applying a flexible interpretation of the planning policy and emphasising the need for a balanced approach to discretionary decision-making in planning matters.