Scutti v City of Wanneroo

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   SCUTTI -v- CITY OF WANNEROO [2018] WASCA 175

CORAM:   BUSS P

MURPHY JA

ALLANSON J

HEARD:   19 APRIL 2018

DELIVERED          :   12 OCTOBER 2018

FILE NO/S:   CACV 40 of 2017

BETWEEN:   CARMELA  SCUTTI

First Appellant

ANTONIO GUISEPPE SCUTTI

Second Appellant

PAOLA SCUTTI

Third Appellant

GIUSEPPE ALESSANDRO SCUTTI

Fourth Appellant

AND

CITY OF WANNEROO

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   LE MIERE J

Citation: SCUTTI -v- CITY OF WANNEROO [2017] WASC 70

File Number             :   GDA 14 of 2016


Catchwords:

Town planning - Determination of whether land injuriously affected by the making or amendment of a town planning scheme - Proper construction of Agreed Structure Plan - Whether land classified as a reserve under Agreed Structure Plan - Whether land reserved under a scheme - Whether incorporation of Agreed Structure Plan into scheme amounts to amendment of scheme - Whether land reserved for a public purpose - Whether scheme permits development for no purpose other than a public purpose - Whether scheme prohibits wholly or partially the furtherance of non‑conforming uses

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 174(1)

Result:

Appeal allowed

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

First Appellant : Mr M McCusker QC & Ms L Rowley
Second Appellant : Mr M McCusker QC & Ms L Rowley
Third Appellant : Mr M McCusker QC & Ms L Rowley
Fourth Appellant : Mr M McCusker QC & Ms L Rowley
Respondent : Mr G R Ritter QC & Ms K L Browne

Solicitors:

First Appellant : Rowley Legal
Second Appellant : Rowley Legal
Third Appellant : Rowley Legal
Fourth Appellant : Rowley Legal
Respondent : HopgoodGanim Lawyers

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Carson v Department of Environment and Planning (1985) 3 NSWLR 99

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Smorgon [1977] 16 ALR 721

Kettering Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council [2004] HCA 33; (2004) 78 ALJR 1022

Mandurah Enterprises v Western Australian Planning Commission [2008] WASCA 211

Martinez v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 528; (2009) 177 FCR 337

Re Shire of Mundaring; Ex parte Solomon [2007] WASCA 132

Scutti v City of Wanneroo [2017] WASC 70

Town of East Fremantle v Cornell [2005] WASCA 18

Western Australian Planning Commission v Southregal Pty Ltd [2017] HCA 7; (2017) 259 CLR 106

Wines v Shire of Harvey [2000] WASCA 39

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT:

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal against the decision of Le Miere J in Scutti v City of Wanneroo[1] (primary decision).

    [1] Scutti v City of Wanneroo [2017] WASC 70.

  2. The primary decision concerned an appeal by the appellants from a determination of the State Administrative Tribunal (Tribunal) that lot 1 (owned by the appellants) and lot 8 (owned by the first appellant) were not injuriously affected within the meaning of s 174 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act) by the making or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scutti v City of Wanneroo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASCA 175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in the case of Scutti v City of Wanneroo are the Scutti family, as appellants, and the City of Wanneroo, as the respondent. The central dispute revolves around the interpretation and application of the town planning scheme, specifically the Agreed Structure Plan (ASP6), and its effect on the classification and reservation of certain land. The matter was brought before the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The primary legal issues before the court were the proper construction of ASP6, whether it should be considered an Agreed Structure Plan under clause 9.8.2 of the Development Plan South (DPS2), and if so, whether the land in question was classified as a reserve under ASP6 and, consequently, under DPS2. Another issue was whether the incorporation of ASP6 into DPS2 constituted an amendment of DPS2, and if the scheme permits development for purposes other than public use. The court also had to determine if the scheme prohibited wholly or partially the furtherance of non-conforming uses.

The court found that ASP6 was indeed an Agreed Structure Plan under clause 9.8.2 of DPS2, and that the classification of land by reference to reserves, including Local Reserves such as Public Open Space, was binding and enforceable. The court held that the land in question was classified by ASP6 as a Local Reserve, and therefore, the provisions in ASP6 apply to the land as if they were incorporated into DPS2. This classification results in the land being treated as if it were reserved under DPS2, with corresponding development control procedures, rights, provisions, and procedures applying. The court concluded that the incorporation of ASP6 into DPS2 did not amount to an amendment of DPS2, and the scheme permits development for public purposes only.

The court's final orders were that the classification of the appellants' land as a Local Reserve by ASP6 does not directly have the force of law, but the requirement that the land be treated as if it were reserved under DPS2 does have the force of law. Consequently, the provisions in DPS2 dealing with applications for planning approval in respect of land reserved for Public Open Space are applicable.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In our view:1.ASP6 is an Agreed Structure Plan within the meaning of cl 9.8.2 of DPS2.2.The words 'imposes a classification on the land included in it' in cl 9.8.2 mean, in effect, 'classifies land included in the Agreed Structure Plan'.3.The words 'by reference to' in cl 9.8.2 bear their ordinary meaning.[101] In other words, cl 9.8.2 contemplates the classification of land in the Agreed Structure Plan by reference to reserves, zones or Residential Density Codes.[101] DPS2 cl 1.9.3.4.The word 'reserves', in cl 9.8.2 of DPS2, includes Local Reserves, and that term includes a reserve for Public Open Space.5.The Local Structure Plan of ASP6 shows the 'distribution' of Public Open Space in the area of land comprising Cell 4. The ordinary meaning of 'distribution' includes 'arrangement; classification'.[102] In our view, cl 2 of ASP6 and the Local Structure Plan classified land (including the appellants' land) by reference to a Local Reserve, being Public Open Space. In this regard, we do not accept the City's submissions that ASP6 merely involves an 'allocation', leaving cl 9.8.2 and cl 9.8.3 of DPS2 with 'no work to do'.[102] Macquarie Dictionary (6th ed revised, 2013).6.It follows that, in our view, ASP6 'imposes a classification' on the appellants' land 'by reference to' (relevantly) a 'reserve', being a Local Reserve, within the meaning of the chapeau of cl 9.8.2 and cl 9.8.3(e) of ASP6. Accordingly:(a)the provisions in ASP6 classifying the land (in effect) as a Local Reserve apply to the land as if they were incorporated into DPS2 and are binding and enforceable in the same way,[103] subject to the observation referred to in point 7 below;(b)the development control procedures apply as if the land was correspondingly reserved under DPS2;[104](c)the rights, provisions and procedures, and the obligations of the City regarding compensation, apply as if the land was correspondingly reserved under DPS2;[105] and(d)the provisions in DPS2 (including cl 2.3.1) which provide that Local Reserves are delineated on the Scheme Map apply with necessary changes.[106]7.The effect of cl 9.8.2 and cl 9.8.3 is that the land is classified as if it was correspondingly reserved under DPS2. Further, the effect of cl 9.8.2 and cl 9.8.3 is that the provisions of ASP6 apply to the land as if those provisions were incorporated in DPS2. Whether or not cl 9.8.2 and cl 9.8.3 operate in this regard as 'deeming provisions',[107] they undoubtedly invite attention to the purpose for which that particular statutory language is used.[108] Section 5 of the Interpretation Act 1984 (WA) provides, relevantly, that in every written law 'amend' means 'replace, substitute, in whole or in part, add to or vary'. By s 9 of the Interpretation Act, where a word is defined in a written law, other parts of speech and grammatical forms of that word have corresponding meanings. It cannot be inferred that the language of 'as if' in cl 9.8.2 and cl 9.8.3 is designed to bring about an 'amendment' to DPS2 within the meaning of s 173(1) or the chapeau to s 174(1) of the PD Act. There can be no 'amendment' to DPS2 within s 173(1) or s 174(1), save in accordance with s 75 of the PD Act. Clause 9.8.2 effectively recognises this insofar as it distinguishes between reserves, zones and Residential Density Codes applying to control the use of land in an Agreed Structure Plan 'as if [they] were incorporated into' DPS2, and 'an amendment to' DPS2.8.The evident purpose of incorporating the provisions of an Agreed Structure Plan into DPS2 in accordance with cl 9.8.2 and cl 9.8.3 is to provide a 'policy framework'[109] for all future development of the land zoned in the Urban Development Zone until DPS2 itself is amended. 9.The classification of the appellants' land as a reserve by ASP6 does not directly have the force of law, because the land is not directly reserved by DPS2, or by an amendment to DPS2. However, the requirement that the land be treated as if it were reserved under DPS2, does have the force of law.[110] 10.As the land is to be treated as if it were a Local Reserve for the purposes of the provisions of DPS2, those provisions in DPS2 dealing with applications for planning approval in respect of land reserved for Public Open Space are applicable. [103] DPS2 cl 9.8.2(a), cl 9.8.3(f).[104] DPS2 cl 9.8.3(c).[105] DPS2 cl 9.8.3(e).[106] DPS2 cl 9.8.2(b).[107] As to 'deeming provisions' generally, see Pearce DC and Geddes RS, Statutory Interpretation in Australia (8th ed, 2014) [4.45] - [4.46].[108] Cf Martinez v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 528; (2009) 177 FCR 337 [29].[109] See the definition of 'structure plan' in DPS2 sch 1.[110] See PD Act s 68, s 87(4).