Freeman and City Of Subiaco

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FREEMAN and CITY OF SUBIACO [2008] WASAT 303



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2008] WASAT 303
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No:DR:365/200821 NOVEMBER 2008
Coram:MR R EASTON (SENIOR SESSIONAL MEMBER)29/12/08
32Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application for review dismissed
B
PDF Version
Parties:IAIN ROBERT FREEMAN
VIVIANA FREEMAN
CITY OF SUBIACO

Catchwords:

Town planning ­ Development application ­ Condition of development approval ­ Requirement for proposed two­storey development to be converted to a loft ­ Streetscape policy ­ Locality generally contains houses with single­storey appearance when viewed from the street ­ Proposal retains existing character house ­ Presumption of single­storey residential  ­ Two­storey development restricted to 20% of site area ­ Two­storey development does not include loft development ­ Preference for two­storey development to be in the middle third of the site ­ Backyards ­ Wall height ­ Overall height ­ Adjacent ­ Adjoin ­ Bulk ­ Scale ­ Overshadowing ­ Solar access ­ Daylight ­ Privacy ­ Non­complying proposals ­ Clause 42A of TPS 4 ­ A proposal that falls within discretion allowed by the Scheme is not  non­complying ­ Undue adverse impact ­ Amenity

Legislation:

City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 12(4), cl 22, cl 23, cl 27, cl 27(4), cl 27(4)(h), cl 28, cl 28(3), cl 28(3)(a), cl 28(3)(b), cl 37, cl 39(3), cl 41(2), cl 41(2)(f), cl 41(2)(g), cl 42A, cl 42(1), cl 42(1)(a), cl 42(1)(b), cl 45(3), cl 45(4)
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1)

Case References:

Aspen Pty Ltd v State Planning Commission (unreported, WATPAT, No 13 of 1988, 21 October 1988)
Camberwell Corporation v Waldmann (1945) 72 CLR 250
Clive Elliott Jennings & Co Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2002] WASCA 276; (2002) 122 LGERA 433
Dumbleton and Town of Bassendean [2005] WASAT 145
Fryer and City of Subiaco [2006] WASAT 199
Geneff v Shire of Perth [1967] WAR 124
Goldin v Minster for Transport (2002) 121 LGERA 101
Marshall v Western Australian Planning Commission (1995) 15 SR (WA) 170
Mayor, Councillors and Citizens of the City of Wellington v Mayor Councillors and Burgesses of the Borough of Lower Hutt [1904] AC 773
Nicholls and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 40
Sunbay Developments Pty Ltd and Shire of Kalamunda [2006] WASAT 74
Tooth and City of Subiaco [2005] WASAT 317
TTH 28 Pty Ltd and City of Subiaco [2008] WASAT 200


Orders

1. The application for review is dismissed.,2. The decision of the respondent made on 11 September 2008 to grant conditional development approval for additions to an existing dwelling at No 207 Heytesbury Road, Subiaco is affirmed.

Summary

The applicants had applied to build additions to a residence in Heytesbury Road, Subiaco.  The City of Subiaco approved the application but imposed a condition requiring the two-storey addition to be converted into a loft style development with a maximum wall height of 3.6 metres.  That…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Freeman and City Of Subiaco and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASAT 303
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Freeman brought an application for review of the City of Subiaco’s decision to grant conditional development approval for alterations to a property at Subiaco. The City had required that a proposed two-storey development be converted to a loft, and Freeman sought to have the condition removed. Freeman argued that the streetscape policy of the City, which generally requires houses to have a single-storey appearance when viewed from the street, was not applicable to the proposed development as it retained the existing character of the house. The City argued that the proposed two-storey development did not comply with the streetscape policy and that the condition requiring the conversion to a loft was necessary to avoid undue adverse impact on the amenity of the area.

The court was required to decide whether the streetscape policy applied to the proposed development and whether the condition requiring the conversion to a loft was justified. The court considered the relevant policy documents, including the streetscape policy, and the character of the locality. The court also considered the impact of the proposed development on the amenity of the area, including overshadowing, solar access, and privacy.

The court found that the streetscape policy applied to the proposed development as the locality generally contains houses with a single-storey appearance when viewed from the street. The court also found that the proposed development did not comply with the streetscape policy as it proposed a two-storey development that was not converted to a loft. However, the court found that the condition requiring the conversion to a loft was not justified as it would result in undue adverse impact on the amenity of the area. The court found that the proposed development retained the existing character of the house and did not result in overshadowing, loss of solar access, or loss of privacy. The court also found that the preference for two-storey developments to be in the middle third of the site, and the restriction on the height of walls and the overall height of the development, were sufficient to protect the amenity of the area.

The application for review was dismissed, and the decision of the City of Subiaco to grant conditional development approval for the proposed development was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is dismissed. 2. The decision of the respondent made on 11 September 2008 to grant conditional development approval for additions to an existing dwelling at No 207 Heytesbury Road, Subiaco is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Freeman, sought to make alterations and additions to an existing single-storey dwelling located at No 207 Heytesbury Road in Subiaco. The locality predominantly consists of houses with a single-storey appearance when viewed from the street. The applicants proposed a two-storey development, which included a loft, to the rear of the existing dwelling. The proposed development was to be located in the middle third of the site and was restricted to 20% of the site area. The local streetscape policy dictated that two-storey developments should be avoided unless they were in the middle third of the site and did not include loft developments. The proposal aimed to retain the existing character of the house and did not include any loft development. The applicants argued that their proposal did not fall within the discretionary powers allowed by the Scheme and therefore should not be considered non-complying. The City of Subiaco granted conditional development approval for the proposed additions on 11 September 2008, subject to certain conditions. The applicants subsequently sought a review of this decision, arguing that the conditions imposed were unreasonable and that the decision should be overturned. The applicants contended that the conditions imposed by the City of Subiaco, including the requirement for the proposed two-storey development to be converted to a loft, were unreasonable and not in accordance with the relevant planning policies. The applicants argued that the proposal retained the existing character of the house and did not fall within the discretionary powers allowed by the Scheme. The applicants further argued that the conditions imposed would have an undue adverse impact on their amenity. The City of Subiaco defended the decision, arguing that the conditions imposed were reasonable and in accordance with the relevant planning policies. The City of Subiaco contended that the proposal did fall within the discretionary powers allowed by the Scheme and that the conditions imposed were necessary to ensure that the development did not have an undue adverse impact on the amenity of neighbouring properties. The City of Subiaco further argued that the conditions imposed were necessary to ensure that the development did not result in any overshadowing, loss of solar access, or loss of privacy for neighbouring properties.

The matter of Freeman and City of Subiaco originated from a development application submitted by the applicant, Freeman, for additions to an existing dwelling at No 207 Heytesbury Road, Subiaco. The City of Subiaco, acting as the local planning authority, granted conditional development approval on 11 September 2008. Freeman, dissatisfied with certain conditions imposed as part of the approval, sought a review of the decision. This review process led to the matter being brought before the court. The key procedural step involved in this case was the applicant's application for review of the decision made by the City of Subiaco. The court was tasked with examining whether the decision was lawful, reasonable, and procedurally fair. No substantive legal issues or outcomes were discussed at this stage, as the focus was on the procedural legitimacy of the decision-making process. This was not the first-instance hearing of the matter, nor was it an appeal against a prior decision; instead, it was a judicial review application challenging the conditions attached to the development approval. The court's role was to assess the procedural fairness and legality of the decision, rather than the merits of the development proposal itself.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proposed two-storey development must be converted to a loft to comply with the streetscape policy.
2. Whether the proposed two-storey development is in accordance with the restriction that such developments must be limited to 20% of the site area.
3. Whether the proposed two-storey development is located in the middle third of the site as preferred by the streetscape policy.
4. Whether the proposed two-storey development will have an undue adverse impact on the amenity of the locality, including factors such as overshadowing, solar access, daylight, privacy, bulk, scale, and wall height.
5. Whether the proposed development, as conditionally approved, complies with Clause 42A of TPS 4 and is not a non-complying proposal.
6. Whether the proposed development, which falls within the discretion allowed by the Scheme, will result in an undue adverse impact on the amenity of the locality.

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed two-storey development must be converted to a loft to comply with the streetscape policy, appeal dismissed.
2. The court determined that the proposed two-storey development is in accordance with the restriction that such developments must be limited to 20% of the site area, appeal dismissed.
3. The court found that the proposed two-storey development is not located in the middle third of the site as preferred by the streetscape policy, appeal dismissed.
4. The court held that the proposed two-storey development will not have an undue adverse impact on the amenity of the locality, appeal dismissed.
5. The court concluded that the proposed development, as conditionally approved, complies with Clause 42A of TPS 4 and is not a non-complying proposal, appeal dismissed.
6. The court held that the proposed development, which falls within the discretion allowed by the Scheme, will not result in an undue adverse impact on the amenity of the locality, appeal dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Freeman and City of Subiaco dealt with a development application concerning a proposed two-storey addition to an existing single-storey house at 207 Heytesbury Road, Subiaco. The City of Subiaco had granted conditional approval for the development, which the applicant subsequently appealed. The key issues in this case revolved around compliance with the streetscape policy, adherence to restrictions on two-storey developments, the location of the development on the site, potential adverse impacts on the locality's amenity, and compliance with specific clauses in the Town Planning Scheme No. 4.

The court began by examining whether the proposed two-storey development must be converted to a loft to comply with the streetscape policy, which generally favoured single-storey appearances for houses viewed from the street. The policy suggested that a loft conversion would better retain the existing character of the locality. The court considered the nature of the proposed development and determined that converting it to a loft was not mandatory, provided the overall appearance remained consistent with the streetscape policy. The applicant’s proposal, which retained the existing single-storey appearance from the street, was deemed compliant with the policy.

Next, the court assessed whether the proposed two-storey development adhered to the restriction that such developments must be limited to 20% of the site area. The applicant's proposal fell within this limit, and the court found it complied with this specific condition, thereby upholding the decision of the City of Subiaco.

Another issue was whether the proposed development was located in the middle third of the site, as preferred by the streetscape policy. The court examined the site layout and determined that the proposed two-storey development was appropriately situated within the middle third of the site, aligning with the policy’s preference.

The court also evaluated whether the proposed development would have an undue adverse impact on the amenity of the locality. Factors such as overshadowing, solar access, daylight, privacy, bulk, scale, and wall height were scrutinized. The court concluded that the development would not significantly affect these aspects adversely, thus supporting the conditional approval.

Additionally, the court considered whether the proposed development, as conditionally approved, complied with Clause 42A of Town Planning Scheme No. 4 and was not a non-complying proposal. The court noted that the proposal fell within the discretion allowed by the Scheme and therefore did not constitute a non-complying proposal. The court upheld the decision to grant conditional approval, finding that the applicant's development did comply with the scheme's requirements.

Lastly, the court examined whether the proposed development, which was within the discretion allowed by the Scheme, would result in an undue adverse impact on the amenity of the locality. After thorough analysis, the court concluded that the development would not have such an impact, affirming the decision to grant conditional approval.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a proposed two-storey development that adheres to the streetscape policy, complies with site area restrictions, is appropriately located on the site, and does not adversely impact the locality’s amenity, is not a non-complying proposal and can be conditionally approved. The court upheld the City of Subiaco's decision, dismissing the application for review and affirming the conditional approval.