Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read WILLIAMSON and CITY OF SUBIACO and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] WASAT 165
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court needed to address included whether the proposed development complied with the City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4, specifically clauses 27, 41, 42A, and 78. The court also needed to consider the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2013) and the policy requiring protection of the southern neighbour's solar access. The primary concern was whether the proposed two-storey development would be in conflict with the streetscape policy, which generally preferred single-storey residential buildings and restricted two-storey developments to 15% of the site area, preferably in the middle third of the site. Other factors considered were wall height, overall height, bulk, scale, character, trees, surrounding development, overshadowing, and non-complying proposals.
The court found that the proposed development did not align with the streetscape policy of the City of Subiaco, which aimed to protect the character of the locality. The tribunal determined that the two-storey development would not only vary the character of the existing streetscape but also overshadow the southern neighbour, thus infringing on their solar access. The court concluded that the development application did not meet the requirements set out in the planning scheme and the design codes. Consequently, the application for review was allowed, leading to the overturning of the City of Subiaco's refusal of the development application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Application for review allowed
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Williamson proposed a two-storey dwelling that exceeded these restrictions in terms of area, location, height, and bulk. The proposed building was designed to have a wall height and an overall height that was higher than permitted under the local precinct policies. The design also conflicted with the character of the street, which includes trees that contribute to the aesthetic of the neighbourhood. The proposal was considered non-compliant with Clauses 27, 41, 42A, and 78 of the Town Planning Scheme, as well as the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2013). Moreover, the proposed development would have adversely affected the solar access of a southern neighbour, which the policy aims to protect. The application was ultimately refused by the City of Subiaco, leading to Mr Williamson lodging an application for review.
The matter before the court involves a review of a decision made by the City of Subiaco regarding a development application submitted by the applicant, Williamson. The City of Subiaco had refused the development application, citing non-compliance with several policies outlined in the City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4, particularly those relating to streetscape, precinct policies, and the protection of neighbouring properties' solar access. Williamson subsequently sought a review of the council's decision under relevant planning legislation. The case was heard in the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia, marking this as an appeal from the initial decision of the City of Subiaco. Prior to this appeal, Williamson had made several attempts to modify the development proposal to align with the council's streetscape policies, which included guidelines on building height, bulk, scale, and character. Despite these efforts, the City of Subiaco maintained its refusal, leading to the current application for review. The procedural steps leading up to this hearing include the submission and refusal of the development application, subsequent negotiations and modifications by Williamson, and finally, the application for judicial review by the applicant. The court's role is to assess the legality and merits of the City of Subiaco's decision in refusing the development application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the proposed two-storey development comply with the City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4, specifically clauses 27, 41, 42A, and 78, in relation to the percentage of the site area that can be used for two-storey development?
2. Is the proposed two-storey development appropriately located on the site, according to the requirement that it should be in the middle third of the site?
3. Does the proposed two-storey development comply with the height restrictions outlined in the Town Planning Scheme and the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2013)?
4. Does the proposed development's bulk, scale, and character align with the streetscape policy and existing character of the locality?
5. Does the proposed development appropriately consider the preservation of trees that contribute to the street's character?
6. Does the proposed development comply with the policy aimed at protecting the solar access of the southern neighbour?
7. How should the court balance the conflicting needs within the streetscape policy, particularly in terms of the proposed development's impact on the amenity of the area?
8. Does the proposed development comply with the 50% threshold for overshadowing, as stipulated in the Town Planning Scheme?
Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed two-storey development does not comply with clause 27 of the City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4, which restricts two-storey development to 15% of the site area.
2. The court held that the proposed two-storey development is not appropriately located on the site, as it does not comply with the requirement to be in the middle third of the site.
3. The court found that the proposed two-storey development does not comply with the height restrictions outlined in the Town Planning Scheme and the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2013).
4. The court determined that the proposed development's bulk, scale, and character do not align with the streetscape policy and existing character of the locality.
5. The court concluded that the proposed development does not appropriately consider the preservation of trees that contribute to the street's character.
6. The court held that the proposed development does not comply with the policy aimed at protecting the solar access of the southern neighbour.
7. The court found that the proposed development does not appropriately balance the conflicting needs within the streetscape policy, particularly in terms of the proposed development's impact on the amenity of the area.
8. The court concluded that the proposed development does not comply with the 50% threshold for overshadowing, as stipulated in the Town Planning Scheme.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning in Williamson and City of Subiaco revolves around several key issues concerning compliance with the City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4 and the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2013). The court meticulously examined the proposed two-storey development against these legislative frameworks and determined that the development did not meet several critical requirements.
Firstly, the court scrutinized the proposed development's compliance with clauses 27, 41, 42A, and 78 of the Town Planning Scheme, which restrict the percentage of site area that can be used for two-storey development to 15%. The court found that the proposed development exceeded this limit, which was a significant factor in its refusal of the development application. This decision was based on the explicit provisions of the Town Planning Scheme, which clearly outline the permissible limits for two-storey developments in the locality.
Secondly, the court evaluated the placement of the proposed two-storey development on the site. According to the Town Planning Scheme, two-storey developments are preferred to be in the middle third of the site. The court found that the proposed development did not adhere to this requirement, which further contributed to the decision to refuse the application. The rationale here was rooted in the need to maintain consistency with the existing urban fabric and to avoid disproportionately large developments near the street.
In terms of height restrictions, the court reviewed the compliance with the Town Planning Scheme and the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2013). The proposed development's height was scrutinized, and the court determined that it exceeded the allowable limits. This finding was crucial as it directly contravened established height restrictions designed to preserve the character and scale of the locality.
The court also considered the bulk, scale, and character of the proposed development in relation to the streetscape policy and the existing character of the locality. The proposed development's design was found to be disproportionate and incongruous with the surrounding single and two-storey dwellings, thus failing to align with the locality's character. This assessment was pivotal, as it underscored the importance of maintaining visual harmony within the streetscape.
Further, the court addressed the preservation of trees that contribute to the street's character. The proposed development was found to inadequately consider the preservation of these trees, which are integral to the street's aesthetic and ecological value. This non-compliance was deemed significant, given the policy's emphasis on maintaining the natural and visual character of the area.
Another critical aspect was the policy aimed at protecting the solar access of the southern neighbour. The court determined that the proposed development did not sufficiently protect this access, thereby violating a key policy designed to safeguard neighbouring properties' rights to sunlight.
Balancing the conflicting needs within the streetscape policy was also a focal point of the court's reasoning. The court had to weigh the developer's interests against the preservation of the area's amenity. The proposed development's impact on the overall amenity of the area was deemed detrimental, tipping the balance against approval.
Lastly, the court examined the 50% threshold for overshadowing as stipulated in the Town Planning Scheme. The court found that the proposed development exceeded this threshold, leading to a significant loss of sunlight for the neighbouring property. This non-compliance was a decisive factor in the refusal of the development application.
In conclusion, the court's decision was guided by a thorough analysis of the proposed development against the City of Subiaco Town Planning Scheme No 4 and the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2013). The refusal of the development application was based on multiple non-compliances with key provisions, including site area usage, location within the site, height restrictions, streetscape character, tree preservation, solar access protection, and overshadowing thresholds. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a development must strictly adhere to the stipulated provisions of the Town Planning Scheme to be approved, with a particular emphasis on preserving the locality's character, protecting neighbouring properties' rights, and maintaining the area's amenity.