Frugtniet v Tax Practitioners Board

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Frugtniet v Tax Practitioners Board [2013] FCA 752

Citation: Frugtniet v Tax Practitioners Board [2013] FCA 752
Appeal from: Frugtniet v Tax Practitioners Board [2013] AATA 188
Parties: RUDY NOEL FRUGTNIET v TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD
File number: VID 267 of 2013
Judge: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 30 July 2013
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal – from Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether notice of objection to competency filed in appeal pursuant to s 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) is competent – whether Federal Court Rules 2011 provide for notice of objection to competency in an appeal from the Administrative Appeals Tribunal
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal – from interlocutory decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether decision by Tribunal to refuse an application for stay is a decision to which s 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act applies – whether appeal is competent – appeal from interlocutory decision of the Administrative Appeal Tribunal is not competent
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for amendment to pleadings – policy considerations relevant to whether to allow amendment to pleading – whether to allow amendment to pleadings part way through the hearing  
Legislation:

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act1977 (Cth)
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic)
Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (UK)
Tax Agent Services Act 2009 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Philip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170
Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175
Commissioner of Taxation v Beddoe (1996) 68 FCR 446
Director General of Social Services v Chaney (1980) 47 FLR 80

Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2002] VSC 140

Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2005] VSC 332
Frugtniet v Law Institute of Victoria Ltd [2012] VSCA 178
Garrett v Foster's Wine EstatesLimited [2007] FCA 253
Geographical Indications Committee v The Honourable Justice O’Connor (2000) 64 ALD 325
In Re the Will of F B Gilbert (dec.) (1946) 46 SR (NSW) 318
Kowalski v Repatriation Commission (2009) 259 ALR 444
Law Institute of Victoria Limited v Frugtniet (Legal Practice) [2011] VCAT 596
Yao v Secretary, Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations [2010] FCA 18

Date of hearing: 19 April 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 38
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mr D Brown, Australian Government Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 267 of 2013

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
BETWEEN:

RUDY NOEL FRUGTNIET
Applicant

AND:

TAX PRACTITIONERS BOARD
Respondent

JUDGE:

MURPHY J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 JULY 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is dismissed.

2.The Applicant pay the Respondent’s costs.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Frugtniet v Tax Practitioners Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 752
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Frugtniet was the appellant, and the Tax Practitioners Board was the respondent. The appellant appealed a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that had rejected his challenge to a decision of the Tax Practitioners Board to terminate his registration as a tax agent. The Federal Court heard the appeal. The court needed to decide if the appeal was competent, and if not, whether the appellant should be granted leave to amend his Notice of Appeal to make it competent. The court also needed to decide whether the AAT's refusal to grant a stay of its proceedings was a decision from which an appeal lay under section 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth).

The court found that the appellant's appeal was not competent because the Federal Court Rules 2011 do not permit an appeal from an interlocutory decision of the AAT. The court noted that the AAT's refusal to grant a stay was not a decision from which an appeal lay under section 44 of the AAT Act, because it was an interlocutory decision. Therefore, the court found that the appeal was not competent and dismissed it. The court also refused the appellant's application to amend the Notice of Appeal. The court found that allowing the amendment would not have cured the defect in the appeal, and that it was not in the interests of justice to allow the amendment at that stage of the proceedings.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The Applicant pay the Respondent’s costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons I set out below, I refuse the application for amendment and dismiss the appeal.THE FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY Because of the nature of the hearing before me, no submissions were advanced by either party as to the merits of the termination decision. However, some understanding of the background to that decision assists in dealing with the appeal. On 30 May 2008 the applicant applied for registration as a tax agent to the former relevant regulatory body, the Tax Agents Board of Victoria (“the TABV”). The TABV’s regulatory responsibilities were later assumed by the Board. His application was deferred until he had obtained acceptable work experience and was approved on 1 January 2010. It is uncontroversial that the applicant holds a Bachelor of Laws and a Master of Laws but is not, and never has been, an Australian legal practitioner. He unsuccessfully applied for admission to legal practice in 2001, and again in 2004. At a meeting of the Tax Practitioners Board on 16 January 2013 the Board considered the applicant’s registration as a tax agent and resolved to terminate his registration on the basis that he had ceased to meet the requirement that he was a fit and proper person. The Board notified the applicant of the termination decision by letter dated 15 February 2013 (“the notification letter”). A perusal of the notification letter, and of the decisions of the various courts and tribunals to which the letter refers, indicates various matters which the Tax Practitioners Board took into account in terminating the applicant’s registration, including the following:(a)The Board received three complaints regarding the applicant’s conduct from his clients. These were put to the applicant and the Board considered that he failed to adequately address the complaints in his response.(b)In investigating the complaints the Board learned that, at the time of his application for registration as a tax agent in 2008, the applicant had not disclosed to the TABV that he had been refused admission to practice as a lawyer in 2001 and 2004. The Board of Examiners refused him admission as it was not satisfied that he was a fit and proper person for admission to legal practice. The applicant appealed to the Supreme Court of Victoria against the refusal to admit him to legal practice on both occasions, and each time the Court dismissed the appeal. (c)In Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2002] VSC 140 (“Frugtniet 1”) Pagone J dismissed the appeal from the first refusal to admit the applicant to legal practice. His Honour noted at [15] that it was not his task to make a positive finding that the applicant was not a fit and proper person, and he refused the appeal on the basis only that the applicant failed to satisfy him that he was such a person. At [12] to [14] his Honour said that he was not satisfied that the applicant properly explained his failure to inform the Board of Examiners about his criminal convictions and also about criminal charges which he faced but of which he was acquitted.(d)In Frugtniet v Board of Examiners [2005] VSC 332 (“Frugtniet 2”) Gillard J dismissed the appeal from the second refusal to admit the applicant to legal practice. At [17] his Honour set out the applicant’s history of criminal convictions and criminal charges, and the history of the applicant’s disclosure of such convictions and charges to various bodies, including the Board of Examiners. In summarising his Honour’s recounting of this history I note the following:(i)4 January 1978 - while living in the United Kingdom the applicant was convicted at the Crown Court in Leeds of 15 counts of handling stolen goods, forgery, obtaining property by deception and theft. He pleaded guilty to the charges. He asked the court to take into account seven additional charges. He was sentenced to a total period of imprisonment of four years and he served two years.(ii)27 December 1989 - the applicant was charged with obtaining property by deception, it being alleged that the credit card facilities at the State Bank of Victoria had been tampered with. The charges were not proceeded with because a State Bank witness would not cooperate with the police. The magistrate discharged the applicant at committal.(iii)21 and 22 May 1992 - the applicant, who was working at his wife's travel agency, gave evidence on oath before the Travel Agent’s Licensing Authority in relation to his wife's Travel Agent’s Licence. He stated that he had never had a criminal conviction in England or elsewhere. His wife lost her licence and appealed to the AAT.(iv)20 November 1992 - the applicant gave evidence on oath before the AAT. He rejected as “outrageous” and “scandalous” the proposition that he had been convicted of a number of charges in the UK in 1978.(v)14 May 1997 - the applicant was charged with five counts of obtaining financial advantage by deception by selling “blacklisted” airline tickets through his wife's travel agency.(vi)24 November 1997 - the applicant appeared at Broadmeadows Magistrates’ Court in relation to the above five charges. Four of the charges were withdrawn. The applicant pleaded guilty to the fifth charge and was fined $1000 without the conviction being recorded.(vii)1997 - the applicant was charged with three counts of perjury in relation to the evidence he gave on 21 and 22 May 1992 before the Travel Agent’s Licensing Authority and on 20 November 1992 before the AAT. (viii)May 1998 - the perjury charges were heard in the County Court of Victoria before Judge Jones and a jury. The applicant relied on the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (UK) which, in the words of Gillard J: provides that convictions recorded in the UK expired after 10 years and became spent convictions for the purposes of that Act. It followed that the accused (here the applicant) was to be treated as a person who had not committed or been charged with any of the offences.Division 3 of part VIIC of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) was also relevant, insofar as it applied to the disclosure of foreign convictions that are spent. Judge Jones apparently ruled that the effect of these Acts is that a person is not required in Australia to disclose to a Commonwealth authority the fact that he has been convicted of an offence that is spent, but that neither Act applied in Victoria to the Travel Agent’s Licensing Authority or the AAT. This finding was critical to the applicant’s defence of the perjury charges and Gillard J found that the applicant knew and understood that the effect of Judge Jones’ ruling was that he could not rely on either Act in dealings with Victorian authorities.The applicant gave evidence that he honestly believed that the provisions of both Acts applied. The jury acquitted him of the charges.(ix)March 1998 - the applicant was charged with six counts of theft and three counts of attempted theft. It was alleged that while working as an employee of the ANZ Bank he had given personal details of accounts to an accomplice who then stole money from those accounts. (x)26 October 1999 - the applicant applied to the Migration Agents Registration Authority for re-registration as a migration agent for the year October 1999 to October 2000. He completed a document in which he was asked to state, amongst other things, whether he was the subject of any criminal charges still pending before a court. The applicant stated that he was not and supported the document with a statutory declaration in which he stated that the information he had provided was complete, correct and up to date in every detail: Frugtniet 2 at [46]. Gillard J held in at [47] that “on no view could that answer be correct” because at that time he was facing nine charges arising from his employment at the ANZ Bank. Gillard J considered that the applicant admitted as much in the hearing before him.(xi)March 2000 - The accomplice pleaded guilty to the charges concerning theft from the ANZ Bank and gave evidence against the appellant. The applicant was acquitted. (xii)Between April 1998 - July 2000 - following dismissal from the ANZ Bank the applicant studied law, worked in his migration agency, and also had another job. It was alleged that during this period he obtained monies from Centrelink by deception, by claiming Job Search Allowance and Newstart allowance when he was working.(xiii)August 2001 - having completed his law degree the applicant applied to the Board of Examiners for admission to legal practice. He filed a letter of disclosure with the Board disclosing only the conviction at Broadmeadows Magistrates’ Court in 1997 and no other criminal convictions or charges. On 28 August 2001 he filed an affidavit with the Board of Examiners deposing there was nothing else to disclose.(xiv)October 2001 - the Board of Examiners rejected his application. In May 2002, as I have said, Pagone J dismissed the appeal from that rejection.(xv)April 2003 - the applicant was charged with defrauding the Commonwealth by receiving Centrelink payments to which he was not entitled from March 1998 - November 2000. (xvi)May 2004 - the Centrelink charges were dismissed.(xvii)July 2004 - the applicant again applied for admission to legal practice and filed a number of documents in support of his application. He appeared before the Board and gave evidence on oath, and also gave evidence in the appeal before Gillard J(e)In refusing the applicant’s appeal Gillard J noted at [68] of his judgment that:[The applicant’s] pattern of conduct raises a substantial question mark concerning his honesty and his character and reputation. He is a person who does not appear to have learned from his experiences during 1989 to 2000. He carries a very heavy burden of persuading this Court that he is a person of good character and reputation and a fit and proper person to practice law. He has not discharged that burden. The way he has presented himself to this Court shows a man who is loose with the truth and is prepared to distort the truth if he thinks it will help him. Often he was asked questions which he failed to answer and went off on some tangent seeking to minimise his criminality in the past. The evidence does not persuade me that the appellant has learned from his past experience, or that he is a person motivated to tell the truth.(f)The Tax Practitioners Board considered that in his application for registration as a tax agent in 2008 the applicant had not properly disclosed the refusal of the Board of Examiners to admit him to legal practice. The section 37 documents in the AAT file available to me include the applicant’s Application for Registration as a Tax Agent and Schedule of Personal Details dated 30 May 2008. Question 14 of the Application enquired:Have you had membership or registration with a professional body or registration board, (including a Tax Agents’ Board), refused, cancelled or suspended in the last 10 years?The applicant responded in the negative. Before the Board the applicant submitted that an application for admission to practice as a barrister and solicitor was not an application for membership or registration with a professional body or registration board. Question 17 of the Application enquired:Is there any other matter which may effect your eligibility for registration?Question 18 of the Schedule of Personal Details enquired:Is there any other matter of which you are aware, which may have an effect on whether the Board would regard you as a fit and proper person or of good fame, integrity and character? Notwithstanding the history set out above the applicant responded in the negative to both of these questions. The applicant declared that the particulars shown in the Application and in the Schedule were to the best of his knowledge and belief, true and correct in every detail.(g)In investigating the client complaints the Tax Practitioners Board also became aware of events that had occurred after 2008. In the termination decision the Board relied on these events too. The Board referred to the decision of Law Institute of Victoria Limited v Frugtniet (Legal Practice) [2011] VCAT 596 where Judge Jenkins, Vice President of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal, decided that in May 2010 the applicant had knowingly and intentionally or wilfully misrepresented himself and misled a barrister and a magistrate to believe that he was a lawyer and was entitled as of right to appear before the Magistrates’ Court. His Honour ordered that the applicant be made a disqualified person under Division 3 of Part 2.2 of the Legal Profession Act 2004 (Vic) for a period of three years. In Frugtniet v Law Institute of Victoria Ltd [2012] VSCA 178 the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria relevantly upheld the decision and orders.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 44(1) of the AAT Act provides as follows:A party to a proceeding before the Tribunal may appeal to the Federal Court of Australia, on a question of law, from any decision of the Tribunal in that proceeding.(Emphasis added.) In the Notice of Appeal the applicant raises the following three purported questions of law from the decision of the AAT: 1.The Tribunal failed to take relevant considerations into account in that the Applicant’s written submissions dated 13 March 2013, in conjunction with the oral submissions made including the affidavit of the Applicant’s Accountant David Fu dated 11 March 2013.2.The Tribunal erred in pre-determining the central issue to be determined in the substantive hearing that the applicant had been found to be a person who was not fit and proper and who failed to make disclosure of same [sic] to the respondent in his application for registration.3.The Tribunal erred in asking the Applicant to comment on findings in proceedings before the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT) in April 2011. The Notice of Appeal seeks also that the Court make findings of fact, and alleges that: The Tribunal’s findings of fact that the applicant failed to disclose his applications of 2002 and 2005 to the Board of Examiners and the Supreme Court and that the applicant was not a fit and proper person pre-supposed that the applicant was required to disclose those applications under the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936, likewise erroneously concluded that the applicant had been found to be not a fit and proper person were not reasonably open as a matter of law.The Objection to Competency The appeal to this Court was filed on 9 April 2013. The accompanying interlocutory application for a stay was listed for hearing on 19 April 2013. On 16 April 2013 the respondent filed and served a Notice of Objection to Competency of the appeal. In response to this objection, the applicant first argues that the Notice of Objection is itself incompetent. In this regard he relies on the judgment of Perram J in Yao v Secretary, Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations [2010] FCA 18 (“Yao”). In that case the respondent filed a notice of objection to the competency of an appeal from the AAT, in circumstances not dissimilar to those now before me. Perram J made a finding that the notice of objection was itself incompetent, doing so on the basis that the Federal Court Rules 2000 did not provide for the filing of such a notice in an appeal from the AAT. Before me, the applicant seeks a similar finding. However, the Federal Court Rules 2011 (“the Rules”) (which came into operation on 1 August 2011) now allow for the respondent to file a notice of objection to the competency of an appeal from the AAT. Division 33.2 of the Rules relates to appeals from the AAT. Rule 33.30 which appears in that Division provides as follows:33.30 Notice of objection to competency of appeal(1)A respondent who objects to the competency of an appeal must, within 14 days after being served with a notice of appeal, file a notice of objection to competency:(a) in accordance with Form 68; and(b) that, briefly but specifically, states the grounds of the objection.(2) The applicant carries the burden of establishing the competency of an appeal.…(5) If the Court decides that an appeal is not competent, the appeal is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.