First Equilibrium Pty Ltd v Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd (In Liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

First Equilibrium Pty Limited v Bluestone Property Services Pty Limited (in liq) [2013] FCAFC 108

Citation: First Equilibrium Pty Limited v Bluestone Property Services Pty Limited (in liq) [2013] FCAFC 108
Appeal from: Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd (in liq) v First Equilibrium Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 876
Parties: FIRST EQUILIBRIUM PTY LIMITED  v BLUESTONE PROPERTY SERVICES PTY LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)
File number: NSD 1819 of 2013
Judges: GORDON, GRIFFITHS AND FARRELL JJ
Date of judgment: 18 September 2013
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – winding up – judgment creditor applied to wind up appellant company on the grounds of insolvency – appellant’s asserted counter-claim not bona fide and on substantial grounds – respondent had standing as a creditor in accordance with s 459P(1)(b) Corporations Act2001 (Cth) – appellant found to be insolvent having regard to evidence of its financial position – appellant had no mutual credits or mutual dealings for the purposes of s 553C(1) Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Legislation: Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Abadeen Group Pty Ltd v Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 386
Abadeen Group Pty Ltd v Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 137

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Plymin (2003) 46 ACSR 126
Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd (in liq) v First Equilibrium Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 876

Brown & Ors v Hodgkinson & Ors [2009] NSWSC 262

Commercial Union Assurance Co of Australia Ltd v Ferrcom Pty Ltd (1991) 22 NSWLR 389
CVC Investments Pty Ltd v P & T Aviation Pty Ltd (1989) 18 NSWLR 205
Endeavour Film Management Pty Ltd v Fox Studios Australia Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 831
Eyota Pty Ltd v Hanave Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACSR 785
GraywinterProperties Pty Ltd v Gas & Fuel Corporation Superannuation Fund (1996) 70 FCR 452
Gye v McIntyre (1991) 171 CLR 609

In the Matter of First Equilibrium Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 1625

Kirrak Pty Ltd v Compass Scaffolding & Plant Hire Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 1002
Macleay Nominees Pty Ltd v Belle Property East Pty Ltd [2001] NSWSC 743
Mac-Jordan Construction Ltd v Brookmount Erostin Ltd (in receivership) [1992] BCLC 350
Product People (International) Pty Ltd v Box Seat Company Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2013] FCA 277
Re Kolback Group Ltd (1991) 4 ACSR 165
Roadships Logistics Ltd v Tree (as trustee for the Tree Superannuation Fund) (2007) 64 ACSR 671
Southern Cross Interiors Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2001) 53 NSWLR 213
Tokich Holdings Pty Ltd v Sheraton Constructions (NSW) Pty Ltd (in liq) [2004] NSWSC 527
Troutfarms Australia Pty Ltd v Perpetual Nominees Ltd [2013] VSCA 176

Date of hearing: 18 September 2013
Date of last submissions: 18 September 2013
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 45
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr M Cashion SC with Mr J Baird
Solicitor for the Appellant: Avondale Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr WG Muddle SC with Mr P Newton
Solicitor for the Respondent:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read First Equilibrium Pty Ltd v Bluestone Property Services Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCAFC 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

First Equilibrium Pty Ltd appealed against an order that dismissed its claim that Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd (In Liq) did not have standing to apply to wind up First Equilibrium pursuant to s 459P(1)(b) Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The appeal was dismissed. Bluestone had standing as a creditor in accordance with s 459P(1)(b) of the Corporations Act. This was because the Judgment Debt was a debt owed by First Equilibrium to Bluestone. First Equilibrium did not have mutual credits or mutual dealings with Bluestone for the purposes of s 553C(1) of the Corporations Act. Therefore, First Equilibrium was not protected from being wound up by Bluestone. Furthermore, First Equilibrium was insolvent having regard to evidence of its financial position. First Equilibrium’s counter-claim was not bona fide and on substantial grounds. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed and First Equilibrium ordered to pay Bluestone’s costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Paragraph 1 of the Orders made in NSD 542 of 2013 on 6 September 2013 be set aside.

2. The appeal is dismissed.

3. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal, to be taxed in default of agreement and to be paid out of the assets of the appellant.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, the appeal fails. These reasons for judgment will first consider the facts and then address each of the grounds in turn.FACTS Equilibrium was incorporated on 30 June 1992. Mr Justin Brown is the sole director and shareholder of Equilibrium. Bluestone was incorporated on 18 November 1999. Mr Lance Hodgkinson is the sole director and is also a shareholder of Bluestone. Mr Brown (through Equilibrium – then known as Abadeen Group Pty Limited) and Mr Hodgkinson (through Bluestone) were property developers. They were involved in a number of substantial property developments including what were known as the Oxford Street Development, the Chevron Development and the Cammeray Development: see Abadeen Group Pty Ltd v Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 137 at [4]. In late 2005, Mr Brown wanted to sell out of the Cammeray Development. There was a meeting held at the Lord Dudley Hotel in Paddington. Mr Brown, Mr Hodgkinson and a third man, Mr Daniel Hausman (who had an interest in the development), attended. Mr Brown wrote on a single sheet of paper what was proposed and each signed it. Mr Brown claimed the document gave rise to, or evidenced, an enforceable agreement. Some of the payments contemplated by the document (totalling $600,000) were made. Other aspects of the transactions recorded on the document were not implemented. Mr Brown commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against Mr Hodgkinson, Mr Hausman and their companies to enforce the terms of the document. Bluestone served a cross-claim seeking to recover the $600,000. The trial judge concluded that there was no enforceable agreement and that Equilibrium was liable to repay the $600,000 to Bluestone as money had and received: Brown & Ors v Hodgkinson & Ors [2009] NSWSC 262 at [88]-[89]. Bluestone obtained judgment in the Supreme Court of New South Wales in April 2009 for $600,000 to which interest and costs have been added (the Judgment Debt). An appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal: Abadeen Group Pty Ltd v Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 386. Equilibrium has paid Bluestone approximately $294,000 in partial satisfaction of the Judgment Debt but it has not sought or obtained an order setting aside the balance of the Judgment Debt. Nor has it sought a stay of the judgment. Bluestone served three statutory demands on Equilibrium. In each statutory demand, the debt was the amount of the Judgment Debt then outstanding. The first statutory demand was served by Bluestone on Equilibrium (then known as Abadeen) on 23 September 2010. It claimed the whole of the Judgment Debt. Equilibrium’s application to set it aside was dismissed by Ball J in February 2011: see Abadeen. His Honour found that the offsetting claims asserted by Equilibrium were not genuine claims which attracted the operation of s 495H of the Act. In the course of those reasons for judgment, Ball J was required to consider three “offsetting claims” asserted by Equilibrium. The third claim considered by his Honour was “said to arise in relation to the Oxford Street Development”: see Abadeen at [44]. In general terms, the claim concerned a Unit Sales Agreement dated 15 August 2006 between Sharlotte Pty Limited (Sharlotte) and Bluestone under which Sharlotte agreed to sell and Bluestone agreed to purchase Sharlotte’s units in the 282 Oxford Street Unit Trust for $450,000. Sharlotte was another company entity owned by Mr Brown. The sum of $450,000 has not been paid but by a Deed of Assignment dated 1 October 2010, Sharlotte allegedly assigned to Equilibrium its right, title and interest in the debt due by Bluestone. The consideration for the assignment was expressed to be $1.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In late 2005, Mr Brown wanted to sell out of the Cammeray Development. There was a meeting held at the Lord Dudley Hotel in Paddington. Mr Brown, Mr Hodgkinson and a third man, Mr Daniel Hausman (who had an interest in the development), attended. Mr Brown wrote on a single sheet of paper what was proposed and each signed it. Mr Brown claimed the document gave rise to, or evidenced, an enforceable agreement. Some of the payments contemplated by the document (totalling $600,000) were made. Other aspects of the transactions recorded on the document were not implemented. Mr Brown commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against Mr Hodgkinson, Mr Hausman and their companies to enforce the terms of the document. Bluestone served a cross-claim seeking to recover the $600,000. The trial judge concluded that there was no enforceable agreement and that Equilibrium was liable to repay the $600,000 to Bluestone as money had and received: Brown & Ors v Hodgkinson & Ors [2009] NSWSC 262 at [88]-[89]. Bluestone obtained judgment in the Supreme Court of New South Wales in April 2009 for $600,000 to which interest and costs have been added (the Judgment Debt). An appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal: Abadeen Group Pty Ltd v Bluestone Property Services Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 386. Equilibrium has paid Bluestone approximately $294,000 in partial satisfaction of the Judgment Debt but it has not sought or obtained an order setting aside the balance of the Judgment Debt. Nor has it sought a stay of the judgment. Bluestone served three statutory demands on Equilibrium. In each statutory demand, the debt was the amount of the Judgment Debt then outstanding. The first statutory demand was served by Bluestone on Equilibrium (then known as Abadeen) on 23 September 2010. It claimed the whole of the Judgment Debt. Equilibrium’s application to set it aside was dismissed by Ball J in February 2011: see Abadeen. His Honour found that the offsetting claims asserted by Equilibrium were not genuine claims which attracted the operation of s 495H of the Act. In the course of those reasons for judgment, Ball J was required to consider three “offsetting claims” asserted by Equilibrium. The third claim considered by his Honour was “said to arise in relation to the Oxford Street Development”: see Abadeen at [44]. In general terms, the claim concerned a Unit Sales Agreement dated 15 August 2006 between Sharlotte Pty Limited (Sharlotte) and Bluestone under which Sharlotte agreed to sell and Bluestone agreed to purchase Sharlotte’s units in the 282 Oxford Street Unit Trust for $450,000. Sharlotte was another company entity owned by Mr Brown. The sum of $450,000 has not been paid but by a Deed of Assignment dated 1 October 2010, Sharlotte allegedly assigned to Equilibrium its right, title and interest in the debt due by Bluestone. The consideration for the assignment was expressed to be $1. The relevant clauses of the Unit Sales Agreement included: 2 SALE AND TRANSFER OF UNITS2.1In consideration of the agreement by Bluestone to pay the sum of $450,000.00 contained in this deed, Sharlotte agrees to sell all its interest in the Sale Units in the Trust to Bluestone and to transfer to Bluestone those 50 units (free of Encumbrances and other third party rights and interests).2.2Bluestone shall pay the total consideration payable to Sharlotte in the following manner:2.2.1As to the sum of $400,000.00 by cheque or cheques drawn as directed by Sharlotte on 15 November 2006.2.2.2As to the sum of $50,000.00 by cheque or cheques drawn as directed by the Sellers on 31 March 2007.2.2.3If the sums referred to in 2.2.1 and 2.2.2 are not paid by their respective dates for payment, Bluestone shall pay interest on the sum which remains unpaid from the due date for payment until the date of payment of the sum at the rate of fifteen per centum (15%) per annum.2.2.4If the sums referred to in 2.2.1 and 2.2.2 together with any interest due are not paid within six (6) weeks of their respective due dates for payment, Sharlotte may by notice in writing to Bluestone terminate this Deed.…3 TRANSFER FORMS3.1On the date of this Deed, Sharlotte shall deliver to Bluestone a duly executed transfer of Sale Units sold to Bluestone to be held in escrow by Bluestone until completion.3.2Sharlotte shall comply with the requirements of clause 12 of the Trust Deed in relation to the transfer of the Sale Units.…6 BENEFICIAL INTEREST IN SALE UNITS 6.1Sharlotte and Bluestone agree that the beneficial interest in the Sale Units shall be transferred to Bluestone as at the date of this deed.…. (Emphasis added.)“Completion” was defined in cl 1.2 to mean “in respect of the Sale Units, the transfer from Sharlotte to Bluestone of title to the Sale Units”. Completion has not occurred.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.