CITATION: Macleay Nominees v. Belle Property East [2001] NSWSC 743 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2997/01 HEARING DATE(S): 27 August, 2001 JUDGMENT DATE:
27 August 2001PARTIES :
Macleay Nominees Pty Ltd (ACN 089 254 697) [Plaintiff]
Belle Property East Pty Limited (ACN 086 898 786) [Defendant]JUDGMENT OF: Palmer J
COUNSEL : V.R. Gray [Plaintiff]
T. Alexis [Defendant]SOLICITORS: Gye Associates [Plaintiff]
Gells Lawyers [Defendant]CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS - STATUTORY DEMAND - Whether debtor has genuine offsetting claim against creditor - debtor claims unliquidated damages for economic loss - how can amount of claim be quantified for purposes of s.459H(2) - Held: "genuine offsetting claim" for purposes of s.459H(1) and (2) Corporations Act means claim on a cause of action advanced in good faith, for an amount claimed in good faith - "good faith" means arguable on basis of facts asserted with sufficient particularity to satisfy the Court that the claim is not fanciful - in an offsetting claim for economic loss the plaintiff must adduce evidence to show how the loss is said to arise and how it is calculated - if no such evidence adduced, Court cannot find genuine offsetting claim. - STATUTORY DEMAND - ORDER SUBJECT TO CONDITIONS - Plaintiff's offsetting claim genuine but tenuous - Court has discretion under s.459M whether to impose conditions upon an order setting aside statutory demand - held: as a condition of setting aside the statutory demand the Court requires the plaintiff to commence and prosecute diligently proceedings to establish its claim and to pay a substantial sum into Court to abide result of proceedings. LEGISLATION CITED: Corporations Act 2001 - s.459G, s.459H, s.459M CASES CITED: Jesseron Holdings Pty Ltd v Middle East Trading Consultants (1994) 12 ACLC 490 DECISION: Statutory demand set aside upon conditions.
1 This is an application by the plaintiff under s.459G of the Corporations Act 2001 (“CA”) to set aside a statutory demand served by the defendant on the plaintiff. In that statutory demand the defendant claims a debt amounting to a total of $121,618.64. The debt is said to arise in respect of advertising fees, expenses and sales commissions earned by the defendant from the sale of a number of units in the plaintiff's development in a building at 77 Macleay Street, Potts Point. 2 The question in these proceedings is whether the plaintiff has shown a genuine offsetting claim for the purposes of CA s.459H(1)(b). The plaintiff says that it does have such an offsetting claim and that the amount of that claim exceeds the amount of the statutory demand so that the statutory demand should be set aside. 3 The plaintiff has advanced several claims, some of which I would have held not to have been genuine. In the circumstances, however, I need deal only with the principal claim put forward by the plaintiff because that claim is said to result in an amount which will be owing to the plaintiff far in excess of the amount of the statutory…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Macleay Nominees Pty Ltd v Belle Property East Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2001] NSWSC 743
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Macleay Nominees Pty Ltd brought an action against Belle Property East Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia, seeking to set aside a statutory demand issued by Belle. Belle, in turn, argued that it had a genuine offsetting claim against Macleay, which it claimed would negate the debt stated in the demand. The dispute centred on whether Belle's claim for unliquidated damages for economic loss could be considered a genuine offsetting claim under section 459H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The crux of the legal issues before the Court was the interpretation and application of section 459H(2) of the Corporations Act, which requires that a genuine offsetting claim must be quantifiable for the purposes of determining whether it can be set off against the debt claimed in a statutory demand.
The Court held that a genuine offsetting claim, for the purposes of section 459H(1) and (2) of the Corporations Act, meant a claim on a cause of action that was advanced in good faith and for an amount claimed in good faith. The term "good faith" was interpreted to mean that the claim must be arguable on the basis of facts asserted with sufficient particularity to satisfy the Court that the claim was not fanciful. In this context, the Court further clarified that for an offsetting claim for economic loss, the plaintiff must provide evidence demonstrating how the loss is said to arise and how it is calculated. The Court found that, in the absence of such evidence, it could not consider the claim to be a genuine offsetting claim. The Court then turned to its discretion under section 459M of the Act, which allows the Court to impose conditions upon an order setting aside a statutory demand.
The Court determined that while Belle's offsetting claim was genuine, it was tenuous. Consequently, the Court exercised its discretion under section 459M to set aside the statutory demand, subject to conditions. The primary condition imposed was that Belle must commence and prosecute diligently its proceedings to establish its claim for damages. Furthermore, Belle was required to pay a substantial sum into Court, the amount of which would be determined by the outcome of the proceedings. This approach balanced the need to protect creditors from unfair demands while also ensuring that genuine claims are not unjustly dismissed.
The Court held that a genuine offsetting claim, for the purposes of section 459H(1) and (2) of the Corporations Act, meant a claim on a cause of action that was advanced in good faith and for an amount claimed in good faith. The term "good faith" was interpreted to mean that the claim must be arguable on the basis of facts asserted with sufficient particularity to satisfy the Court that the claim was not fanciful. In this context, the Court further clarified that for an offsetting claim for economic loss, the plaintiff must provide evidence demonstrating how the loss is said to arise and how it is calculated. The Court found that, in the absence of such evidence, it could not consider the claim to be a genuine offsetting claim. The Court then turned to its discretion under section 459M of the Act, which allows the Court to impose conditions upon an order setting aside a statutory demand.
The Court determined that while Belle's offsetting claim was genuine, it was tenuous. Consequently, the Court exercised its discretion under section 459M to set aside the statutory demand, subject to conditions. The primary condition imposed was that Belle must commence and prosecute diligently its proceedings to establish its claim for damages. Furthermore, Belle was required to pay a substantial sum into Court, the amount of which would be determined by the outcome of the proceedings. This approach balanced the need to protect creditors from unfair demands while also ensuring that genuine claims are not unjustly dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi