Fair Work Ombudsman v Carnarvon Cleaners Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v Carnarvon Cleaners Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 277

File number: PEG 60 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE LADHAMS
Date of judgment: 18 April 2023
Catchwords:  INDUSTRIAL LAW – appropriate penalty for admitted contraventions of ss 45, 535(1) and 535(4) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – where recommended penalty agreed between the parties
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 45, 535, 539, 546, 550, 557, 682

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) reg 3.32

Cases cited:

Andreou v Berkeley Challenge Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 738

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2017) 254 FCR 68; [2017] FCAFC 113

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson & Anor (2022) 175 ALD 383; [2022] HCA 13

Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (2015) 258 CLR 482; [2015] HCA 46

David Armstrong v VK Holdings Pty Limited (unreported, Chief Industrial Magistrates Court, Sydney, 28 November 1997)

Fair Work Ombudsman v EA Fuller & Sons Pty Ltd [2013] FCCA 5

Fair Work Ombudsman v Extrados Solutions Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 815

Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 557

Fair Work Ombudsman v HSCC Pty Ltd [2020] FCA 655

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lohr (2018) 158 ALD 457; [2018] FCA 5

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lufra Investments Pty Ltd [2011] FMCA 263

Fair Work Ombudsman v NSN (t/a New Shanghai Charlestown) (2017) 275 IR 148; [2017] FCA 1301

Fair Work Ombudsman v Zucco Farming Pty Ltd [2019] FCCA 1277

Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14; [2007] FCA 1080

Singtel Optus Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2012) 287 ALR 249; [2012] FCAFC 20

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd (1991) ATPR 41-076; [1990] FCA 521

Volkswagen Aktiengesellschaft v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2021) 284 FCR 24; [2021] FCAFC 49

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 93
Date of last submission: 3 February 2023
Place: Perth
Counsel for the Applicant Ms E Luck
Solicitor for the Applicant: Office of the Fair Work Ombudsman
Counsel for the Respondents Mr A Mossop
Solicitor for the Respondents: 3D HR Legal
Table of Corrections
19 April 2023 In the cover sheet, Counsel for the Applicant has been changed from ‘Ms A Clemens’ to ‘Ms E Luck’.

ORDERS

PEG 60 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

CARNARVON CLEANERS PTY LTD (ACN 134 865 008)

First Respondent

MARGARET HERLYSHA SEATON

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE LADHAMS

DATE OF ORDER:

18 April 2023

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The first respondent contravened the following civil remedy provisions:

(a)s 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Act), by failing to pay Ching Mei ‘Emma’ Tung, Dennis Burgiel, Georgia Nicks, Haru Suzuki, Jie ‘Jay’ Wang, Kirsty Rogers,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Carnarvon Cleaners Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 277
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) initiated legal proceedings against Carnarvon Cleaners Pty Ltd, a contract cleaning business operating in Carnarvon, Western Australia, for multiple contraventions of the Fair Work Act. The primary dispute centred on the company's failure to comply with various provisions of the Fair Work Act and the Cleaning Services Award 2010, leading to significant underpayments of employee entitlements. The court was required to determine whether Carnarvon Cleaners had contravened the Fair Work Act, establish the nature and extent of the contraventions, and decide on appropriate penalties for the identified breaches.

The court considered several legal issues, including the interpretation and application of the Fair Work Act and the Cleaning Services Award 2010, the appropriate method for calculating penalties, and the principles guiding the imposition of penalties under the Fair Work Act. It was necessary to ascertain whether the contraventions should be treated individually or aggregated, and whether the recommended penalties were appropriate in all the circumstances. The court also examined the submissions of both parties regarding the contraventions and the proposed penalties.

The court found that Carnarvon Cleaners had contravened various provisions of the Fair Work Act, including failure to maintain accurate employee records, making records that were false or misleading, and underpaying employees. The court accepted the submissions of the FWO regarding the identified contraventions and agreed that the recommended penalties were appropriate. The court adopted a structured approach to determining the appropriate penalty, considering the steps outlined in relevant case law. After reviewing the evidence and submissions, the court concluded that the agreed penalties were suitable and imposed them accordingly.

The court made several declarations and orders, including declarations that Carnarvon Cleaners had contravened specific sections of the Fair Work Act and the Cleaning Services Award 2010, and ordered the company to pay pecuniary penalties for the identified contraventions. The court also ordered Carnarvon Cleaners to make amends to the affected employees for the underpayments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons explained below, I accept that declarations should be made in respect of the admitted contraventions and I agree that the recommended penalties are appropriate penalties in all the circumstances. FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND CONTRAVENTIONS OF FAIR WORK ACT Most of the facts summarised in this judgment are based on the facts agreed between the parties in the amended statement of claim filed on 1 February 2022, the substituted defence filed on 11 October 2022 and the substituted reply filed on 14 October 2022. I have also had regard to the two affidavits filed in this proceeding, namely, the affidavit of Peta Williams filed on 10 November 2022 on behalf of the Ombudsman and the affidavit of Ms Seaton filed on 3 February 2023. Where appropriate, I have referred to the affidavit evidence in the consideration of the appropriate penalty below. Unless otherwise indicated, I accept the evidence of Ms Williams and Ms Seaton. Carnarvon Cleaners is a company incorporated under the provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) which operates a contract cleaning business, servicing approximately 41 premises in and around Carnarvon in the State of Western Australia. Ms Seaton, as the sole director and person responsible for the overall operation, direction and management of Carnarvon Cleaners, was responsible for making decisions regarding business operations, including decisions regarding the employment of employees and entitlements, and ensuring that Carnarvon Cleaners complied with its legal obligations under the Fair Work Act. At all relevant times: (a)Carnarvon Cleaners was bound by the Fair Work Act and the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) (Fair Work Regulations); and (b)the Award applied to Carnarvon Cleaners’ employment of it its employees. In around August 2018 the Ombudsman commenced an audit of Carnarvon Cleaners (Assessment) to assess its compliance with the Fair Work Act and fair work instruments during the period from 1 November 2017 to 30 November 2018 (Assessment Period). During the Assessment Period Carnarvon Cleaners employed 23 employees on a part-time basis and 13 employees on a casual basis. Based on the duties that they performed, the employees were categorised under the Award as Cleaning Services Employee Level 1 (CSE 1) employees, Cleaning Services Employee Level 2 (CSE 2) employees or Cleaning Services Employee Level 3 (CSE 3) employees. A different rate of pay applied to each of the three levels of employee. During the Assessment Period Carnarvon Cleaners underpaid 35 of its employees a total amount of $114,538.30 in respect of the contraventions admitted by Carnarvon Cleaners in this proceeding. The nature of the underpayments can be described as follows:(a)Pursuant to cl 12.5(a) of the Award, casual employees were entitled to a casual loading of 25% for all hours worked, in addition to the ordinary hourly rates and rates payable for shift, weekend and overtime work that apply to full-time employees. Carnarvon Cleaners did not pay the full casual loading entitlement to 13 casual employees. (b)Pursuant to cl 12.4(b)(iii) of the Award, part-time employees were entitled to an allowance of 15% for all hours worked, in addition to the ordinary hourly rates and rates payable for shift, weekend and overtime work that apply to full-time employees. Carnarvon Cleaners did not pay two of its part-time employees the correct part-time allowance to which they were entitled.(c)Pursuant to cl 27.3 of the Award, employees were entitled to be paid at a rate of double time and one half of their ordinary rates for all hours worked on public holidays. Carnarvon Cleaners did not pay 10 of its employees the full amounts of the public holiday penalty rates to which they were entitled.(d)Pursuant to cll 12.5 and 28.6 of the Award, overtime was payable on all hours worked in excess of 7.6 hours per day, five days per week or 38 hours per week. Pursuant to cl 28.2, the rate of overtime payable to each employee was time and a half of the employee’s ordinary rate for the first two hours of overtime worked from midnight Sunday to midnight Saturday, and double time for all overtime worked after the first two hours of overtime from midnight Sunday to midnight Saturday. Carnarvon Cleaners failed to pay 13 employees their proper overtime entitlements in respect of the first two hours of overtime worked from midnight Sunday to midnight Saturday, and it failed to pay seven employees their proper overtime entitlements in respect of overtime that they worked after the first two hours of overtime from midnight Sunday to midnight Saturday. (e)Pursuant to cl 29.4 of the Award, part-time employees were entitled to an annual leave loading of 17.5%, calculated on the employee’s ordinary time rate of pay, in addition to payment for annual leave prescribed by the National Employment Standards. Carnarvon Cleaners underpaid 10 employees their annual leave loading. (f)Pursuant to cl 17.1 of the Award, Carnarvon Cleaners was required to pay a broken shift allowance of 0.458% of the standard rate per day up to a maximum of 2.29% of the standard rate per week to any of its employees who worked in two separate periods of duty on any day, with a maximum spread of 13 hours, and where the break between periods exceeded one hour. Carnarvon Cleaners underpaid two employees their broken shift allowance.(g)Pursuant to cl 24.2 of the Award, part-time and casual employees were required to be rostered on for a minimum engagement period of one to four hours, depending on the size of the total cleaning area at each site and were entitled to be paid for the full minimum engagement period even if they were not required to work for the full minimum engagement period. Carnarvon Cleaners underpaid 35 of its employees by paying them only their rostered hours, which were less than the minimum engagement period hours.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present proceedings, the only allegation of a contravention of s 45 in relation to a failure to pay a leading hand allowance related to an employee who was classified as a CSE 3 employee. The change of position by the Ombudsman is appropriate and the orders made in this matter reflect the change in the Ombudsman’s position.CONCLUSION Based on the facts agreed between the parties in the pleadings, the evidence before the Court and the consideration of the relevant legislation and authorities, I consider that it is appropriate to make the declarations and orders agreed between the parties. Accordingly, I make those declarations and orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Carnarvon Cleaners contravened s 535(4) of the Fair Work Act by making and keeping employee records required to be made and kept under s 535(1) of the Fair Work Act and reg 3.32(c) of the Fair Work Regulations that it knew to be false or misleading.CONSIDERATION OF APPROPRIATE PENALTYApproach to determining appropriate penalty Section 546(1) of the Fair Work Act allows the Court to order that a person pay a pecuniary penalty that the Court considers to be appropriate if the Court is satisfied that the person has contravened a civil remedy provision. Sections 45, 535(1) and 535(4) of the Fair Work Act are all civil remedy provisions. The primary purpose of imposing a penalty is deterrence: Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Pattinson & Anor (2022) 175 ALD 383; [2022] HCA 13 (Pattinson) at [15]. As mentioned above, the recommended penalties in this matter have been agreed between the Ombudsman and the respondents. It is appropriate for the Court to accept the recommendation of the parties and impose penalties in the amounts recommended if the Court is satisfied of the accuracy of the agreement as to facts and consequences and that any penalty proposed by the parties is an appropriate penalty in all the circumstances: Commonwealth of Australia v Director, Fair Work Building Industry Inspectorate (2015) 258 CLR 482; [2015] HCA 46 at [58]. The steps that the Court will ordinarily take in determining an appropriate penalty were summarised in Fair Work Ombudsman v NSN Pty Ltd (t/as New Shanghai Charlestown) (2017) 275 IR 148; [2017] FCA 1301. The five steps summarised at [36] of that judgment are:(a)identify the separate contraventions;(b)consider whether each separate contravention should be dealt with independently or with some degree of aggregation for contraventions arising out of the same course of conduct;(c)consider whether there should be further adjustment to ensure that, to the extent of any overlap between groups of contravention, there is no double penalty imposed; (d)consider the appropriate penalty for each final individual group of contraventions; and(e)consider the overall penalties arrived at and apply the totality principle, making adjustments as necessary. Each of these steps is considered below.What were the contraventions? The contraventions were identified in the Ombudsman’s submissions and agreed to by the respondents. I respectfully adopt the identification of contraventions as set out in the Ombudsman’s submissions with minor modifications. The contraventions fall into three main categories:(a)contraventions of s 535(1) of the Fair Work Act (Record Keeping Contraventions);(b)contraventions of s 535(4) of the Fair Work Act (False or Misleading Contraventions); and(c)contraventions of s 45 of the Fair Work Act (Underpayment Contraventions). The Record Keeping Contraventions comprise Carnarvon Cleaners’ failure to make and keep records for the following five employees:(d)Mr Chilcott, from 20 February 2015 to around October 2018;(e)Ms Dryden, from 12 July 2012 to around October 2018; (f)Mr Greg Morton, from 27 April 2017 to around October 2018; (g)Mr Nathan Burnell, from 4 September 2015 to around October 2018; and (h)Mr Shane Morton, from 23 May 2015 to around October 2018.