Details
- Case
- [2022] FedCFamC2G 757
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) filed an application against Adept Trolly Collection Services Pty Ltd and its director, Ms Ahlam Osman, for their failure to comply with a compliance notice issued under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The FWO alleged that Adept Trolly contravened s 716(5) by failing to comply with a compliance notice, and Ms Osman was involved in the contravention as an accessory under s 550. The parties agreed on the facts, and the primary issue was the appropriate penalty for the contraventions.
The Court considered the principles for determining penalties, including the need for deterrence and proportionality. The Court noted the lack of contrition and limited cooperation from the respondents but also took into account their agreement to facilitate the Statement of Agreed Facts, their limited capacity to pay, and their status as first-time contraveners. The Court decided that an appropriate deterrent penalty was 50% of the maximum penalty for each respondent. The penalty for Adept Trolly was set at $16,650, and for Ms Osman, it was set at $3,300.
The Court concluded that the declarations and orders should be in the terms set out in Annexure A to the FWO’s Submissions, with the penalties as determined. The respondents had submitted that they were in their current situation due to unfortunate circumstances and requested a reduced penalty and the ability to make payments over time. However, the Court found that the penalties as determined were appropriate in the circumstances.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Court has before it the following materials:(a)the Originating Application and Statement of Claim filed 28 September 2021;(b)the Defence filed 17 November 2021;(c)the Response filed 9 December 2021;(d)the Statement of Agreed Facts filed 3 March 2022;(e)the FWO’s Outline of Submissions on Penalty filed 22 April 2022 (“FWO’s Submissions”);(f)the Respondents’ Outline of Submissions on Penalty filed 6 May 2022 (“Respondents’ Submissions”);(g)the affidavit of Benjamin Arthur Abey affirmed 18 March 2022 (“Abey Affidavit); (h)the affidavit of Ms Osman affirmed 4 April 2022 (“First Osman Affidavit”); and(i)the affidavit of Ms Osman affirmed 18 May 2022 (“Second Osman Affidavit”).Agreed Facts The Statement of Agreed Facts provides as follows (original emphasis):A. THE APPLICATION1.On 28 September 2021, the Applicant, the Fair Work Ombudsman, filed an Application and Statement of Claim in this Court against the Respondents in respect of the First Respondent's contravention (“Contravention”) of s 716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) and the Second Respondent's involvement in the Contravention as an accessory pursuant to s 550 of the FW Act.B. ADMITTED CONTRAVENTIONS2.On the basis of the facts set out below, the First Respondent admits to contravening the following civil remedy provision of the FW Act: s 716(5) of the FW Act, by failing without reasonable excuse to comply with a Compliance Notice issued by Fair Work Inspector Benjamin Abey (“FWI Abey”) as a result of FWI Abey forming a reasonable belief that the Respondent contravened terms of the Cleaning Services Award 2010 (“the Award”) and the National Employment Standards.3.On the basis of the facts set out below, the Second Respondent admits that she was involved in the Contravention of s 716(5) of the FW Act within the meaning of s 550(2)(c) of the FW Act, and pursuant to s 550(1) of the FW Act, is taken to have contravened s 716(5) of the FW Act.C PARTIESThe Applicant4.The Applicant, is and was at all relevant times:(a)a statutory appointee of the Commonwealth appointed by the Governor-General by written instrument pursuant to s 687(1) of the FW Act;(b) a Fair Work Inspector (“FWI”) pursuant to s 701 of the FW Act; and(c)a person with standing to bring these proceedings and to apply for orders for contraventions of civil remedy provisions pursuant to s 539(2) of the FW Act.5.FWI Abey is and was at all relevant times a FWI appointed by the Applicant under s 700 of the FW Act.The First Respondent6.The First Respondent, Adept Trolly Collection Services Pty Ltd (ACN 619 203 717) (Adept Trolly), is and was at all relevant times:(a)a company incorporated under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and registered since 19 May 2017;(b)a “constitutional corporation” within the meaning of s 12 of the FW Act;(c)a “national system employer” within the meaning of s 14 of the FW Act;(d)based in Western Australia with a registered office located at 16 Egretta Drive, Waterford, in the State of Western Australia (Registered Office); and(e)an entity to which the FW Act applied in respect of its employees7.Adept Trolly was, at all relevant times, the operator of a trolley collection service located at Kmart sites in Launceston, Burnie and Devonport, in the State of Tasmania (“the Business”).The Second Respondent8.The Second Respondent, Ms Ahlam Osman (Ms Osman), is and was at all relevant times:(a) a natural person capable of being sued;(b)the sole director and company secretary of Adept Trolly since 19 May 2017;(c) a person who was:i.responsible for the overall operation, management and control of Adept Trolly; andii.responsible for ensuring Adept Trolly complied with its legal obligations under the FW Act; and(d)a person whose conduct (engaged in on behalf of Adept Trolly and within the scope of her actual or apparent authority) is taken to be that of Adept Trolly under s 793(1) of the FW Act.D.ADMITTED FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH A COMPLIANCE NOTICE IN CONTRAVENTION OF SECTION 716(5) OF THE FW ACTThe Investigation9.Following a request for assistance made to the Applicant by Mr Abdul Kamal in November 2017, FWI Abey commenced an investigation into Adept Trolly, in December 2018 (“Investigation”).10.As a result of the Investigation, FWI Abey formed a belief that, at all relevant times between 5 June 2017 and 8 April 2018 (“the Relevant Period”):(a) Adept Trolly employed 5 employees to work at the Business, namely:i. Sandeep Narang (full-time cleaning employee);ii. Ayaz Khan (full-time cleaning employee);iii. Nicholas Hay (part-time cleaning employee);iv. Abdul Kamal (part-time cleaning employee); andv.Joshua Pendeerada (part-time cleaning employee) (collectively, the Employees).(b)the Award, a modern award under the FW Act, covered and applied to Adept Trolly in respect of the Employees;(c)the Employees were not paid all of their minimum entitlements under the Award during the Relevant Period.11.By reason of the matters admitted in paragraph 10 above, FWI Abey formed a reasonable belief within the meaning of s 716(1)(b) of the FW Act that Adept Trolly, during the Relevant Period in respect of one or more of the Employees:(a) contravened the following terms of the Award:i. Clause 16.1 – minimum wages;ii. Clause 16.2 – junior rates;iii. Clause 12.4(b)(iii) – part-time allowance;iv. Clause 27.1(a) – shift work penalty rate;v. Clause 27.2(a) – Saturday penalty rate;vi. Clause 27.2(b) – Sunday penalty rate;vii. Clause 27.3 – public holiday penalty rate;viii.Clause 28.2 – overtime worked from midnight Sunday to midnight on Saturday;ix. Clause 28.3 – overtime on Sunday; and(b)contravened the following provision of the National Employment Standards:i. s 116 of the FW Act - payment for absence on public holiday;(together, the Admitted Contraventions).The Compliance Notice12.On 13 May 2021, at 11:16am, an agent of AAC Process Servers & Investigations (ABN 30 431 977 102) on behalf of FWI Abey, gave Adept Trolly a compliance notice in respect of the Admitted Contraventions pursuant to s 716(2) of the FW Act (“Compliance Notice”), by personally serving the Compliance Notice on Ms Osman at the Registered Office.13.Pursuant to s 716(2) of the FW Act, the Compliance Notice required Adept Trolly to:(a)take action by 2 July 2021 to remedy the direct effects of the Admitted Contraventions in respect of the Employees, by (Specified Action):i.making a payment to each of the Employees of the following outstanding amounts:1. Nicholas Hay – $1,012.97;2. Ayaz Khan – $20,352.77;3. Sandeep Narang – $5,492.60;4. Abdul Kamal – $8,646.12; and5. Joshua Pendeerrada – $6,997.64.ii.calculating and paying to the Employees’ superannuation funds any additional superannuation contributions required to be paid by clause 18.2 of the Cleaning Services Award 2020 in respect of the amounts referred to in paragraph 10(a)(i);iii.making a schedule that set out the additional superannuation contributions referred to in paragraph 10(a)(ii) above (Schedule); and(b)produce reasonable evidence to the Applicant of its compliance with the Compliance Notice by 9 July 2021, by producing the Schedule and proof that full payment has been made to the Employees of the payments required to be made at paragraphs 10(a)(i) and (ii).14. The Compliance Notice met the requirements of s 716(3) of the FW Act.Failure to comply with the Compliance Notice15. Adept Trolly admits that it did not:(a) take the Specified Action by 2 July 2021, or at all; and(b)produce to the Applicant reasonable evidence of compliance with the Compliance Notice by 9 July 2021, or at all.16.Adept Trolly admits that by reason of the matters admitted in paragraph 15 above, it failed without reasonable excuse to comply with the Compliance Notice and thereby contravened s 716(5) of the FW Act.E. ACCESSORIAL LIABILITY OF MS OSMAN17.By reason of the matters admitted in paragraph 8 above, at all material times Ms Osman was responsible for ensuring that Adept Trolly complied with the Compliance Notice.18.By reason of the matters admitted in paragraphs 8, 12, 15 and 17 above, Ms Osman:(a)had actual knowledge of the Compliance Notice that was given to Adept Trolly; (b)had actual knowledge that Adept Trolly failed to comply with the Compliance Notice; and(c)was an intentional participant in Adept Trolly’s failure to comply with the Compliance Notice.19. By reason of the matters admitted in paragraphs 17 and 18 above, Ms Osman:(a)was involved, within the meaning of s 550(2)(c) of the FW Act, in the contravention of Adept Trolly admitted in paragraph 16 above; and(b)pursuant to s 550(1) of the FW Act, she is taken to have committed that contravention.SubmissionsFWO Submissions
Decision
Reasons for decision
Having particular regard for the need for deterrence, both specific and general, and bearing in mind the lack of contrition and limited, and somewhat inevitable, cooperation, this is nevertheless not a case in which a high range penalty of the order sought by the FWO is appropriate. Further, and in any event, the Respondents are entitled to some discount by reason of their agreement to facilitate the Statement of Agreed Facts, their not unlimited capacity to pay (and in the application of the totality principle ensuring that any penalty is not crushing), and their status as first time contraveners. In all the circumstances, the Court is of the view that an appropriate deterrent penalty is one to be set at 50% of the maximum penalty for each of the Respondents. The penalty to be imposed upon: (a)Adept Trolly will be $16,650; and (b)Ms Osman will be $3,300.Conclusion And Orders The Court has concluded that there ought to be declarations and orders essentially in the terms set out in Annexure A to the FWO’s Submissions, with the appropriate penalties being as set out at [73] above.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Respondents submitted that:(a)they have admitted to the contraventions outlined in the Statement of Agreed Facts;(b)they are in this situation today due to a number of unfortunate circumstances and events taking place during the FWO's investigation and in particular a lack of on-site supervision; and(c)they request a reduction of penalty and to make payments over time due to the financial circumstances explained in the First Osman Affidavit filed in this Court on 4 April 2022.ConsiderationPrinciples relevant to determination of penalty The appropriate steps to be considered in fixing an appropriate penalty were summarised in Fair Work Ombudsman v NSH North Pty Ltd (t/as New Shanghai Charlestown) [2017] FCA 1301; (2017) 275 IR 148; (2017) 69 AILR 102-890 (“New Shanghai Charlestown”) at [36] per Bromwich J, citing Agreed Penalties Case at [64] per French CJ, Kiefel, Bell, Nettle and Gordon JJ; Kelly at [30] per Tracey J and Australian Ophthalmic Supplies at [23] per Gray J, [71] per Graham J and [102] per Buchanan J. In this matter, where there is only a single contravention of a civil remedy provision by each Respondent, not all of the steps relating to the course of conduct or common elements referred to in the above judgments apply and, consequently, the appropriate steps in this matter are:(a)first, to identify each separate contravention involved. A contravention of each separate obligation imposed by the FW Act is a separate contravention of a civil remedy provision for purposes of s 539(2) of the FW Act;(b)second, to consider the appropriate penalty in respect of each contravention; and(c)third, to consider the overall penalties arrived at and apply the totality principle, to ensure that the penalties for each respondent are appropriate and proportionate to their conduct viewed as a whole, making such adjustments as are necessary.Contravention In this case there is a single contravention of s 716(5) of the FW Act by Adept Trolly, and Ms Osman is taken to have also committed that contravention by reason of her involvement therein: FW Act, s 550(1) and (2)(c).Maximum penalties Section 539 of the FW Act sets out the maximum penalties that may be imposed for contraventions of civil penalty provisions by reference to penalty units. Section 4AA of the Crimes Act defined a “penalty unit” as $222 at the time the Respondents failed to comply with the Compliance Notice. Penalty units are defined by s 12 of the FW Act to have the same meaning as in s 4AA of the Crimes Act. Section 546(2)(a) of the FW Act provides that the maximum penalty for an individual is the maximum number of penalty units referred to in the relevant item in column 4 of the table in section 539(2) of the FW Act. Item 33 relates to s 716(5) of the FW Act, providing in column 4 that the maximum penalty is 30 penalty units. Accordingly, the maximum penalty for Ms Osman is $6,660. Section 546(2)(b) of the FW Act provides that the maximum penalty for a body corporate is five times the maximum number of penalty units referred to in the relevant item in column 4 of the table in s 539(2) of the FW Act or 150 penalty units. Accordingly, the maximum penalty for Adept Trolly is $33,300.