Evolution Precast Systems Pty Ltd v Chubb Insurance Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Evolution Precast Systems Pty Ltd v Chubb Insurance Australia Limited [2020] FCA 1690

File number: NSD 706 of 2020
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 24 November 2020
Catchwords: INSURANCE – defence costs – construction of policy – whether insured entitled to payment of defence costs prior to determination that third party claim is covered by policy – whether defence costs clause conditional upon a claim made against insured falling within general insuring clause – whether clause requires that the putative liability of insured is not within exclusions
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd v Certain Underwriters at Lloyd’s of London Subscribing to Policy Number B105809GCOM0430 [2019] NSWCA 271

Australasian Correctional Services Pty Limited v AIG Australia Limited [2018] FCA 2043

Bank of Queensland Ltd v Chartis Australia Insurance Limited [2012] QSC 319

Charter Reinsurance Co Ltd v Fagan [1997] AC 313

CIC v Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1995) 8 ANZ Ins Cas 61-232

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority (NSW) (1982) 149 CLR 337

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd (2014) 251 CLR 640

Fitzpatrick v Job (2007) 14 ANZ Ins Cas 61-731

Hawkins v Bank of China (1992) 26 NSWLR 562

HDI Global Specialty SE v Wonkana No. 3 Pty Ltd [2020] NSWCA 296

John Connell Holdings Pty Ltd v Mercantile Mutual Holdings Ltd (1999) 10 ANZ Ins Cas 61-454

John Wyeth & Brothers Ltd v Cigna Insurance Company of Europe SA/NV [2001] Lloyd’s Rep IR 420

Karenlee Nominees Pty Ltd v ACN 004 312 234 Ltd (1994) 8 ANZ Ins Cas 61-236

Major Engineering Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd (2011) 35 VR 458

Onley v Catlin Syndicate Ltd (2018) 360 ALR 92

Power v Markel Capital Ltd (2007) 14 ANZ Ins Cas 61-742

Reardon Smith Line v Hansen-Tangen [1976] 3 All ER 570

Rich v CGU Insurance Ltd; Silbermann v CGU Insurance Ltd (2005) 214 ALR 370

Sherlex Pty Ltd v Thornton [2003] QCA 461

Travelers Insurance Company Ltd v Advani [2012] EWHC 623 (QB)

Weir Services Australia Pty Ltd v AXA Corporate Solutions Assurance (2018) 359 ALR 314

Wesfarmers Federation Insurance Ltd v Wells [2008] NSWCA 186

White v Overland [2001] FCA 1333

Wilkie v Gordian Runoff Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 522

Birds J, Lynch B, Paul S, MacGillivray on Insurance Law (14th ed, Thomson Reuters, 2018)

Derrington DK and Ashton RS, The Law of Liability Insurance (3rd ed, LexisNexis Butterworths, 2013)

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 76
Date of hearing: 12 November 2020
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Williams SC with Mr M Newton
Solicitor for the Applicant: Johnson Winter & Slattery
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M Jones SC with Mr E Ball
Solicitor for the Respondent: Meridian Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 706 of 2020
BETWEEN:

EVOLUTION PRECAST SYSTEMS PTY LTD ABN 17 608 136 518

Applicant

AND:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Evolution Precast Systems Pty Ltd v Chubb Insurance Australi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1690
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Evolution Precast Systems Pty Ltd v Chubb Insurance Australia Limited involved a dispute over whether Evolution was entitled to payment of defence costs prior to determining whether the third-party claim against Evolution was covered by the insurance policy issued by Chubb. The dispute arose from claims made against Evolution in relation to the Opal Tower Development in Sydney, which experienced structural issues leading to evacuation of its residents. Evolution sought advance payment of defence costs from Chubb, but Chubb declined, asserting that the claims against Evolution were not within the policy’s cover due to a professional liability exclusion.

The legal issues before the court were whether Chubb was obligated to pay Evolution’s defence costs under the policy and whether the defence costs clause was conditional on the claim falling within the general insuring clause but not within the exclusions. Specifically, the court needed to interpret Clause 5.3 of the policy, which dealt with the insurer’s right to defend claims, and determine whether Chubb was required to pay defence costs before it was established that the claims against Evolution were covered by the policy.

The court reasoned that Clause 5.3 did not impose a condition that the claim must fall within the general insuring clause but not within the exclusions for Chubb to be obligated to pay defence costs. The court held that the insurer’s obligation to pay defence costs was not dependent on the claim being within the exclusions, and therefore, Chubb was not obliged to pay the defence costs unless and until there was a judicial determination that the exclusion applied. Consequently, the court found that Chubb was not presently obliged to pay the defence costs incurred by Evolution.

In light of the court’s decision, it ordered that Chubb was not required to pay the defence costs incurred by Evolution, and Evolution was to pay Chubb’s costs of the application. This decision clarified the obligations of the insurer regarding defence costs in the context of insurance policies with exclusions, emphasizing that the insurer’s duty to pay defence costs is not contingent on the exclusions being applicable.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In relation to the following question raised for determination:

Is Chubb presently obliged by Extension clause 4.1 of the Policy to pay Defence Costs:

(i) that have been incurred by the Applicant; and

(ii) as and when they are incurred by the Applicant,

unless and until there is:

…

(iv) a judicial determination that Exclusion clause 3.13 applies?

Answer, “No”.

2. The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 30 October 2020, the Chief Justice made orders for the expedition of the hearing of a separate question in issue between the parties in these proceedings concerning the applicant’s entitlement to the payment of defence costs pursuant to a policy of insurance issued by the respondent, Chubb Insurance Australia Limited (Chubb). The relative urgency arises because the applicant, Evolution Precast Systems Pty Ltd (Evolution), is presently a cross-respondent in two significant pieces of litigation in the Supreme Court of New South Wales arising out of the damage sustained to the building known as “Opal Tower” in Sydney. It claims advance payment of the defence costs cover from Chubb in relation to those proceedings. For its part, Chubb has declined to make any payment of defence costs in relation to the action and asserts that it is not obliged to do so on the basis that the claims made against Evolution are not within the policy’s cover by reason of its professional liability exclusion. The background facts and questions to be determinedThe policy of insurance It is not in dispute that Evolution entered into a Broadform Liability Insurance policy with Chubb (the Policy) on or around 1 February 2018 in respect of its liability for, inter alia, property loss arising in the course of its business in the period from 1 February 2018 to 1 February 2019. The policy limits were $20,000,000 per claim and in total. The insured’s business was identified in the policy schedule as being, “Principallly [(sic.)] Pre Cast Panel Manufacturer & Delivery, Installers, Property Owners and any other activity incidental thereto”. The general insuring clause provided:Insuring Agreement1.1Chubb shall indemnify the Insured against all sums which the Insured shall become legally liable to pay as Compensation in respect of:a) Personal Injuryb) Property Damagec) Advertising Injuryfirst happening during the Policy Period within the Policy Territory as a result of an Occurrence in connection with the Business. Relevant to that clause are the following definitions:2.4 Business means:All activities and operations of the Business stated in the Schedule and that shall include: … 2.5 Compensation meansMonies paid or payable by judgment or settlement together with any liability on the Insured’s part to pay legal costs and expenses (other than Defence Costs).2.7 Defence Costs meansAll reasonable legal costs and expenses incurred by Chubb or by the Insured with the written agreement of Chubb:a) in defending or appealing a claim against the Insured; andb) for legal representation of the Insured at any coronial inquest or other fatal accident inquiry.2.12 Occurrence meansAn event including continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same general conditions which results in Personal Injury or Property Damage or Advertising Injury neither expected nor intended from the standpoint of the Insured. All events of a series consequent on or attributable to one source or original cause are deemed one Occurrence.2.19 Property Damage meansa) physical damage to, destruction of or loss of tangible property including the loss of use thereof at any time resulting therefrom;b) loss of use of tangible property which has not been physically damaged or destroyed, provided such loss of use is caused by physical damage of other tangible property.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 5.3 concerned the manner in which Chubb might exercise its right to defend claims against Evolution:5.3Right to defend, assistance and co-operation of the Insureda) In respect of any Occurrence covered under this Policy, Chubb has the right, if it so elects, to defend any suit against the Insured seeking Compensation or reimbursement of expenses for an Occurrence and to bring any cross claim in the name of the Insured even if any of the allegations of the suit are groundless, false or fraudulent, and may make such investigation and settlement of any claim or suit as it deems expedient; but Chubb is not obligated to pay any claim or judgment or to defend any suit after Chubb’s liability under this Policy in respect of the claim has been exhausted.b) If the cost of any Occurrence and Defence Costs are not likely to exceed the Deductible, Chubb may elect not to defend the suit. In these circumstances and, subject to the provisions of this Policy, the Insured is responsible for the handling and payment of the claim and its Defence Costs up to the amount of the Deductible.c) The Insured must co-operate with Chubb and comply with the terms and conditions of this Policy, and assist as necessary in enforcing any right to contribution or indemnity from any person, corporation or organisation.The Opal Development and the making of claims On around 29 October 2015, the building company, Australia Avenue Developments Pty Ltd (AA Developments) entered into a contract with Icon Co (NSW) Pty Ltd (Icon) pursuant to which Icon agreed to design and construct a high rise, mixed residential and commercial development known as Opal Tower Development at Sydney Olympic Park (the Opal Tower Development). On 31 August 2016, Icon and Evolution entered into a subcontract pursuant to which Evolution agreed to provide pre-cast concrete works, including design, manufacture and installation services for pre-cast wall panels in relation to the Opal Tower Development. That agreement is referred to in these reasons as the “Evolution Subcontract”. Evolution performed its obligations under that agreement in the period between September 2016 and November 2017. It is a matter of public knowledge that in around late 2018 some not insignificant cracking commenced or was first observed in the structure of the Opal Tower Development, which resulted in the evacuation of its residents. On 27 February 2019, AA Developments and its parent company, Ecove Pty Ltd, commenced an action in the Supreme Court of New South Wales against Icon and others for loss and damage arising from the cracking. This is referred to as the “Developer Proceedings”. One of the defendants in the action was WSP Structures Pty Ltd (WSP), which had been the structural and civil consulting engineers engaged by Icon in relation to the project. Subsequently, on 26 July 2019, Terry Walter Williamson and Helen Therese Williamson commenced a separate proceeding, also in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, against the Sydney Olympic Park Authority. That action was brought on their own behalf and as a representative proceedings under Part 10 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) on behalf of other persons who owned one or more units in the Opal Tower Development as at 24 December 2018. Those proceedings are referred to as the “Representative Proceedings”. WSP is also a defendant in those proceedings.