EUI19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

EUI19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 594

File number(s): ADG 497 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment: 24 April 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review application – decision of Immigration Assessment Authority – citizen of Pakistan – whether error in interpreting or applying the law – whether error in interpreting the term “new information” – whether failure to consider whether information met relevant requirements before finding that there were not exceptional circumstances – whether it was not reasonably open to not find exceptional circumstances to consider certain information – whether error in interpreting or applying law concerning seeking new information at interview – whether error in interpreting or applying the terms “real chance” and “well-founded fear” of persecution and “ real risk” of significant harm – whether failure to consider a relevant consideration – whether failure to consider decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal in referred material – whether failure to consider a psychologist’s report – whether failure to consider whether applicant might suffer relevant harm because of inability to get necessary psychological treatment if returned to Pakistan – whether findings legally unreasonable or made without a logically probative basis – whether legally unreasonable not to find exceptional circumstances in relation to various information – whether unreasonable not to seek new information whether at interview or otherwise about applicant’s role as eldest son of an elder in the community when issue not considered by the delegate – whether legally unreasonable to exclude the possibility that the applicant was personally targeted by the Taliban – whether legally unreasonable not to find that the applicant had a real chance of suffering relevant harm in the reasonably foreseeable future – whether legally unreasonable to exclude a real chance that the applicant might suffer relevant harm because of inability to obtain necessary psychological treatment if returned to Pakistan – whether jurisdictional error – writs issued.  
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) Pt 7AA, Div 3, ss 5H, 5J, 36, 473CB, 473DA, 473DB, 473DC, 473DD, 473GA, 473GB, 476

Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No 1) Rules 2024 (Cth), rr 11, 12

Cases cited:

AAZ19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 407

ABJ17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 950; (2018) 260 FCR 295

APH17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] FCA 23

Applicant M190 of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1362

Applicant S270/2019 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] HCA 32; (2020) 94 ALJR 897; (2020) 383 ALR 194

Applicant VEAL of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2005] HCA 72; (2005) 225 CLR 88; (2005) 80 ALJR 228; (2005) 222 ALR 411

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCAFC 184; (2003) 236 FCR 593; (2003) 75…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EUI19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 594
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of EUI19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs, the applicant, a Pakistani citizen, challenged the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority to affirm the Delegate's refusal to grant him a Subclass 866 Special Humanitarian visa. The applicant argued that the Authority erred in its interpretation and application of the law, specifically in relation to the consideration of new information, the assessment of exceptional circumstances, and the evaluation of his claims concerning the risk of persecution and significant harm if returned to Pakistan.

The legal issues before the court included whether the Authority erred in failing to consider certain new information provided by the applicant, whether the Authority's interpretation and application of the terms "real chance" and "well-founded fear" of persecution and "real risk" of significant harm were correct, and whether the Authority failed to consider relevant material, such as a psychologist's report and the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Additionally, the court examined if the Authority's findings were legally unreasonable or made without a logically probative basis.

The court found that the Authority did not commit jurisdictional error by declining to consider the new information provided by the applicant, as it was not satisfied that exceptional circumstances justified its consideration. The court also found that the Authority's findings regarding the applicant's claims were not legally unreasonable, as they were based on an evident and intelligible basis. The court held that the Authority's interpretation and application of the relevant statutory terms were correct, and that the Authority had considered all relevant material in making its decision.

Ultimately, the court dismissed the applicant's judicial review application and affirmed the Authority's decision to refuse the grant of a Subclass 866 Special Humanitarian visa to the applicant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

All references to statutory provisions in these Reasons for Judgment are, unless otherwise indicated, references to the Migration Act and to the provisions therein as they were at the time of the Authority Decision.BACKGROUND TO THE AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATIONApplicant’s details and claims EUI19:(a)is a citizen of Pakistan: CB 3;(b)arrived in Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival on 27 May 2013: CB 260;(c)was advised on 4 July 2016 that the s 46A bar had been lifted: CB 24; and(d)lodged an application for the SHE Visa on 12 December 2016: CB 26-79; EUI19’s claims were set out in a statutory declaration signed 23 November 2016 (“November 2016 Statutory Declaration”) provided with his SHE Visa application and, in summary, his claims were as follows: CB 71-79:(a)he was a Turi Pashtun Shia from Parachinar in the Kurram District;(b)he was involved in a fight with some Sunni students whilst studying at a Parachinar university. He was upset by the language directed at him by the Sunni students so he stopped attending classes. His enrolment was ultimately cancelled due to his non-attendance;(c)his father, a village elder, was threatened by the Taliban because he did not permit them to use his tractor or his farmland;(d)in 2007 an explosive destroyed EUI19’s uncle’s shop. EUI19’s father worked at the shop and EUI19 believes the explosive was intended to harm his father;(e)in 2011 EUI19 was attacked by the Taliban. He was shot in the foot and his toe was amputated. EUI19’s family limited their activities after the shooting. EUI19’s father decided that EUI19 should leave Pakistan;(f)in May 2013 EUI19 travelled in a military convoy from Parachinar to Islamabad. He left Pakistan via Lahore airport;(g)he feared being kidnapped or killed by the Taliban. They want to harm him because he is a Shia, a Turi tribe member, and due to his familial connection with his father. He would be identified if the Taliban detained him because they would look at his identity card; and(h)he did not believe he could relocate within Pakistan because the Taliban had strong networks throughout the country.Delegate’s Decision In relation to the Delegate’s Decision:(a)on 11 September 2019 EUI19 attended the Delegate Interview: CB 103-105;(b)on 18 September 2019 EUI19 provided a post-hearing submission together with further supporting evidence and country information: CB 110-251;(c)on 2 October 2019 EUI19 provided further medical evidence in support of EUI19’s case: CB 252-256;(d)on 18 October 2019 the Delegate refused to grant EUI19 the SHE Visa: CB 260-272; and(e)the Delegate relevantly found that EUI19 would face a real chance of serious harm if he returned to his home area in Parachinar in the Kurram District, but found it was reasonable for EUI19 to relocate to any of three other identified cities in Pakistan (Lahore, Rawalpindi, or Islamabad): CB 269 and 271.Authority Decision On 22 October 2019 the matter was referred to the Authority: CB 273-275. On 12 November 2019 EUI19 provided submissions (“November 2019 Submissions”), country information, and a statutory declaration (“November 2019 Statutory Declaration”) to the Authority: CB 285-305. On 21 November 2019 the Authority affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 308-325.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In relation to the Delegate’s Decision:(a)on 11 September 2019 EUI19 attended the Delegate Interview: CB 103-105;(b)on 18 September 2019 EUI19 provided a post-hearing submission together with further supporting evidence and country information: CB 110-251;(c)on 2 October 2019 EUI19 provided further medical evidence in support of EUI19’s case: CB 252-256;(d)on 18 October 2019 the Delegate refused to grant EUI19 the SHE Visa: CB 260-272; and(e)the Delegate relevantly found that EUI19 would face a real chance of serious harm if he returned to his home area in Parachinar in the Kurram District, but found it was reasonable for EUI19 to relocate to any of three other identified cities in Pakistan (Lahore, Rawalpindi, or Islamabad): CB 269 and 271.Authority Decision On 22 October 2019 the matter was referred to the Authority: CB 273-275. On 12 November 2019 EUI19 provided submissions (“November 2019 Submissions”), country information, and a statutory declaration (“November 2019 Statutory Declaration”) to the Authority: CB 285-305. On 21 November 2019 the Authority affirmed the Delegate’s Decision: CB 308-325. In the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)had regard to the review material given by the Secretary under s 473CB: CB 309 at [3], and the November 2019 Submissions insofar as they contained arguments against the findings of the Delegate: CB 309 at [5];(b)did not consider:(i)the new information provided in the Statutory Declaration and the November 2019 Submissions. It was not satisfied that there were exceptional circumstances to justify considering that new information: CB 309-311 at [6]-[12]. In making that finding, the Authority found that EUI19 had had “ample opportunity” to present his claims: CB 310 at [9], and that aspects of the narrative presented in the new information were “highly unlikely”: CB 311 at [10], “speculative”: CB 311 at [10], and unsupported by “any evidence”: CB 311 at [11]; and(ii)two news articles EUI19 provided to the Authority. The Authority expressly noted that the articles predated the Delegate’s Decision: CB 311 at [13], and was otherwise not satisfied that there were exceptional circumstances to justify considering them: CB 311-312 at [13]-[15];(c)EUI19 asked for an opportunity to explain the content of the November 2019 Statutory Declaration in an interview. Having regard to the statutory scheme, the fact that EUI19 had already advanced claims and evidence with the assistance of a migration agent, and the lack of particularity about what further evidence he was intending to submit, the Authority declined to exercise its power under s 473DC(3) to interview EUI19: CB 312 at [16]-[18];(d)the Authority made the following findings in relation to EUI19’s claims:(i)EUI19 is a practising Shia Muslim from the Turi tribe and of Pashtun ethnicity: CB 314 at [24];(ii)on return to Pakistan EUI19 will very likely resume living with his family in Parachinar in the Kurram District: CB 314 at [24];(iii)EUI19 got into a fight with Sunni students and was subsequently dismissed from his college for non-attendance. EUI19 was not of any adverse interest to any person by reason of this incident: CB 314-315 at [26];(iv)EUI19’s father was a village elder and may have been the subject of threats by the Taliban in 2007. EUI19’s uncle’s shop was partially destroyed due to a bomb blast. However, despite the threats from the Taliban and the bomb blast, the family farm continues to operate and is successful enough that it can meet the living expenses of multiple people including EUI19, his wife, and his daughter: CB 315 at [28];(v)EUI19 was the subject of an incident where he was shot at and which required one of his toes to be amputated. The Authority was not satisfied that EUI19 was identified and targeted by the Taliban, but instead found that he was the subject of a random opportunistic attack. It also did not accept that EUI19’s family remained at home and barely worked on the farm after the attack: CB 316 at [30];(vi)was not satisfied that EUI19 was known or targeted by the Taliban, nor was it satisfied that he had an adverse profile with the Taliban or with any other group while in Pakistan: CB 316 at [31];(vii)did not accept that EUI19 is at risk of harm because of his family’s profile. It considered the chances of EUI19 facing any harm or being the subject of any interest to the Taliban or other extremists groups for reasons of his father or family’s profile or as a result of the past incidents to be no more than remote: CB 316 at [31]; (viii)accepted that Shias living in the Kurram District encountered sectarian violence and attacks at the hands of militants whilst EUI19 was living in Parachinar, but a review of country information led it to conclude that the security situation in EUI19’s home area had significantly improved since EUI19’s departure: CB 316-318 at [32]-[38];(ix)was not satisfied that EUI19 will be perceived as pro-Iran or pro-United States of America or that he would be targeted on return by militant groups such as the Taliban: CB 319 at [39];(x)found that the chance of EUI19 facing any harm due to his Pashtun ethnicity, Shia religion, or the fact that he was a Shia Pashtun from Parachinar, to be no more than remote: CB 321 at [45];(xi)found the chances of EUI19 facing any harm by reason of his residence in Australia, as a returned asylum seeker, or encountering any violence while travelling to his village in Parachinar to be remote: CB 321 at [49];(xii)was not satisfied that there was a real chance EUI19’s foot injury would threaten his capacity to subsist now or in the foreseeable future: CB 322 at [52];(xiii)found that the chance of EUI19 being targeted or killed in bombings or shootings to be remote: CB 323 at [55]; and(xiv)there are healthcare facilities in Parachinar for EUI19 to access should he require them, such that he does not have a well-founded fear of persecution by reason of his mental or physical health conditions: CB 323-324 at [57]-[58]; and(e)the Authority concluded, on the basis of those findings, that EUI19 did not meet: (i)section 36(2)(a): CB 324 at [60]; or (ii)section 36(2)(aa): CB 325 at [65].AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATIONGround 1

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Minister’s submissions in relation to ground 3 were as follows:(a)particulars (a) to (d) appear to overlap substantially with grounds 1 and 2 addressed above. The Minister relies upon its submissions on grounds 1 and 2 as to why the Authority’s new information findings and conclusions were not legally unreasonable;(b)as for particular (e), it is not entirely clear what EUI19 means when he says the Authority “was legally unreasonable to exclude a real chance that the applicant might suffer relevant harm because he may be unable to get necessary psychological treatment if returned to Pakistan”: EUI19’s Outline of Submissions at [58]. To the extent that EUI19 cavils with the Authority’s findings in relation to EUI19 having access to healthcare facilities, the Authority’s reasoning at CB 323-324 at [53]-[57] and 324-325 at [63] sets out the basis for its findings, namely that:(i)the evidence before it did not specify EUI19’s need for ongoing treatment;(ii)but in any event, based on the country information before it, the Authority was satisfied that EUI19 had access to ongoing treatment;(iii)EUI19 would not be prevented from accessing mental or other healthcare services in Pakistan for any reason; and(iv)EUI19 had support from his family; and(c)whether a person has a well-founded fear of persecution is principally concerned with the persecutory actions of third parties: CSV15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 699 at [30]-[31], the Authority’s findings were entirely rational and reasonable in light of the lack of the evidence that EUI19 would be denied treatment (or that he required it in the first place).Consideration – ground 3 In relation to ground 3:(a)it is unnecessary to consider particular (a) to ground 3 in the alternative to particular (c) of ground 1 because particular (a) of ground 3 is duplicitous in circumstances where jurisdictional error has already been found on the basis of unreasonableness in relation to part of particular (c) of ground 1 (which was material for the same reasons as in particular (b) of ground 1): see [35]-[36] above, and insofar as jurisdictional error was found in particular (c) of ground 1 there is an equivalent jurisdictional error in particular (a) to ground 3;(b)it is unnecessary to consider particular (b) to ground 3 in the alternative to particular (d) of ground 1 in circumstances where the Court has found, at [43] above, that there was an evident and intelligible basis for the Authority not interviewing EUI19;(c)particular (c) to ground 3 simply seeks to revisit the relevant factual finding by the Authority as to the alleged personal targeting of EUI19 by the Taliban and as such seeks to engage in impermissible merits review of the Authority Decision: Wu Shan Liang, CLR at 272 per Brennan CJ, Toohey, McHugh and Gummow JJ;(d)it is unnecessary to consider particular (d) to ground 3 in the alternative to particular (e) of ground 1 in circumstances where the Court has found at [52] above that there was an evident and intelligible basis for the Authority to make the findings that it did with respect to whether there was a real chance that EUI19 would suffer relevant harm in the reasonably foreseeable future, and that its findings were not findings which no reasonable decision-maker could make and were not therefore illogical or irrational or lacking in an intelligible justification; and in the circumstances what is sought both in particular (e) to ground 1 and in particular (d) to ground 3 is impermissible merits review of the Authority Decision: Wu Shan Liang, CLR at 272 per Brennan CJ, Toohey, McHugh and Gummow JJ; and (e)it is unnecessary to consider particular (e) to ground 3 in the alternative to particular (c) of ground 2 in circumstances where the Court has found at [75]-[76] above that:(i)the factual premise underpinning particular (c) of ground 2 was not made out, and(ii)where in any event the Psychologist’s Report does not: (A)specify EUI19’s need for ongoing treatment;(B)outline EUI19’s prognosis or any treatment plan or medication that he needs for his mental health conditions; and (C)make apparent what mental health services EUI19 would require in the future, and if so, for how long.