ESH19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

ESH19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 1438

File number(s): SYG 3104 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE GOODCHILD
Date of judgment: 19 December 2024
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Application for an extension of time to make an application reviewing a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) – whether there was a reasonable explanation for delay in filing – whether in the interests of administration of justice to grant extension – extension of time granted – Protection visa – a refusal to grant protection visa under section 65 of the Migration Act1958 – the Tribunal affirm delegate’s decision – applicant’s claim for protection grounded on claim to be member of particular social group, being homosexual – judicial review – jurisdictional error – whether reasonably open to find that the applicant has given inconsistent evidence – whether decision by Tribunal involved assumptions pre-conceptions or prejudgments – materiality of reasoning – writ of certiorari issued – writ of mandamus issued.
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss.36, 65, 477.

Statutory Declaration Act 1959(Cth).

Cases cited:

ASB17 v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 38; 268 FCR 271

AVQ15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 133; 266 FCR 83

AWU16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] FCA 513

CBY15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2020] FCA 878

DAO16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 2; 258 FCR 175

Djokovic v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services & Multicultural Affairs (2022) 289 FCR 21; [2022] FCAFC 3

Duwai v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCA 1141

ETA067vTheRepublic of Nauru (2018) 92 ALJR 1003

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2018) 264 CLR 123; [2018] HCA 34

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs (2024) 98 ALJR 610; [2024] HCA 12

Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259; [1996] HCA 6

Minister for Immigration and Border ProtectionvSZMTA (2019) 264 CLR 421

MZABP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 1391

MZZJOvMinister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] FCAFC 80

Singh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 195

Sundararaj v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 76

SZDGC v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 1638

SZLIH v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCA 108

SZRIQ v Federal Magistrates Court of Australia [2013] FCA 1284

SZSDA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 1319

SZTSU v Federal Circuit Court of Australia [2015] FCA 224

Tu’uta Katoa v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] HCA 28

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 243
Date of last submission/s: 9 April 2024
Date of hearing: 9 April 2024
Place: Brisbane
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Silva
Solicitor for the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ESH19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 1438
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of ESH19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involved an application by the applicant for an extension of time to make an application reviewing a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal). The Tribunal had affirmed the delegate's decision not to grant the applicant a Protection visa under section 65 of the Migration Act 1958. The primary legal issue before the court was whether there was a reasonable explanation for the delay in filing the application for judicial review and whether it was in the interests of the administration of justice to grant an extension. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the Tribunal's decision involved jurisdictional errors, such as making unreasonable assumptions, preconceptions, or prejudgments, and whether these errors were material.

The court examined the principles governing the exercise of discretion to grant an extension of time under section 477(2) of the Migration Act. It noted that the application for judicial review was filed one day outside the 35-day statutory time limit. However, the court found that the applicant had provided a reasonable explanation for the delay, and granting the extension was in the interests of the administration of justice. The court then turned to the merits of the applicant's claim for judicial review, focusing on the Tribunal's assessment of the applicant's credibility and the materiality of any errors in the Tribunal's reasoning.

In its reasoning, the court highlighted that the Tribunal had made adverse credibility findings on every aspect of the applicant's claims, with no flexibility or understanding shown for any part of the applicant's case. The court held that such adverse credibility findings on every claim were unreasonable, and no rational or logical decision-maker would have concluded in the same way. The court also found that the Tribunal's decision involved jurisdictional errors, as it had made unreasonable assumptions, preconceptions, or prejudgments that were material to the outcome. Consequently, the court granted the application for judicial review, issuing a writ of certiorari to quash the Tribunal's decision and a writ of mandamus to compel the Minister to reconsider the applicant's application for a protection visa.

In conclusion, the court granted the application for an extension of time to lodge the application for judicial review and allowed the application for judicial review itself. The court quashed the Tribunal's decision and mandated the Minister to reconsider the applicant's application for a protection visa, ensuring that any reconsideration would be free from the jurisdictional errors identified in the Tribunal's reasoning.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, the application for an extension of time will be granted. For the reasons set out below, the applicant’s amended application seeking judicial review of the decision of the Tribunal made on 22 October 2019 will be granted.RELEVANT FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY The applicant was born in Perak, Malaysia on 10 August 1975. He is a citizen of Malaysia, who first arrived in Australia on 16 October 2006 as the holder of a Subclass 976 Visitor visa. He was 32 years of age when he arrived in Australia. The applicant became an unlawful non-citizen on 17 January 2007. The applicant was located by the Australian authorities on 12 June 2019 and detained at Villawood Immigration Detention Centre. The applicant applied for a protection visa on 28 June 2019. The applicant participated in an interview with a delegate of the Department of Home Affairs, (“the delegate interview”) on 17 July 2019 in relation to his claims. The applicant was represented by his migration agent. A transcript of the audio recording of the delegate interview was adduced into evidence in these proceedings on the applicant’s behalf. On 6 August 2019, the delegate refused to grant the applicant’s Protection visa on the basis that the applicant did not satisfy s.36(2) of the Act which required that the applicant be a non-citizen of Australia in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations and is not a person in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations. On 13 August 2019, the applicant filed an application with the Tribunal for a review of the delegates decision to refuse to grant the applicant a Protection visa under s.65 of the Act. The applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 11 October 2019 to give evidence and present arguments. The hearing was conducted with the assistance of an interpreter in the Punjabi language. The applicant was represented by a migration agent. A transcript of the audio recording of the Tribunal hearing was adduced into evidence in these proceedings on the applicant’s behalf. On 22 October 2019, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the Applicant a Protection visa.PRELIMINARY ISSUE – EXTENSION OF TIME TO LODGE THE APPLICATION FOR JUDICAL REVIEW The decision of the Tribunal was made on 22 October 2019. The applicant filed his application for judicial review on 27 November 2019. This was 36 days after the decision and one day outside the 35-day time limit imposed by s.477(1) of the Act. The Affidavit of the Applicant’s former solicitor dated 27 November 2019, which was lodged with the Court at 4:57pm (AEDT) on 26 November 2019, provides (at [3]) that:3.The application was filed within the 35day period; however, the court has considered that it is an out of time applicant on the basis that it was filed after 4.30apm on the 26 November 2019. The principles applicable to the Court’s exercise of discretion to grant an extension of time are well established. Pursuant to s.477(2) of the Act, the Court may extend the time for the making of an application if satisfied that it is necessary to do so in the interests of the administration of justice.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I will consider the eight particulars in the order they were presented in the Amended Application. After having done so I will address the materiality of the errors together.INCONSISTENCIES IN EVIDENCEWritten Evidence – the Statutory Declaration Before considering the particulars, it is necessary to say something about what is referred to by the Tribunal as “the written evidence” – a document titled “Statutory Declaration” signed by the applicant, dated 21 June 2019 and submitted with his protection visa application on 27 June 2019. The Statutory Declaration of 34 numbered paragraphs is in English. It contains in script the last name of the applicant at the bottom of each page. This is presumably the applicant’s signature. There is no translation jurat at the foot of the document. There is no evidence the declaration was observed by a person prescribed for the purposes of the Statutory Declaration Act 1959 (Cth). It is dated on the last page. There is no evidence it was translated to the applicant before he signed it. The Tribunal says this at [63]:63.The Tribunal notes that from time to time the applicant has explained inconsistencies discussed below by stating that there must have been interpretation mistakes. It is prepared to accept that there might have been some difficulties arising from the use of a telephone interpreter during the detention interviews. However it notes that when it asked the applicant at the commencement of the hearing if his written statement made with his visa application was correct, he claimed that everything in the statement was true. Despite this his oral evidence to the Tribunal was clearly inconsistent with a number of those written claims. Overall while the Tribunal accepts that there might have been the occasional inconsistency arising because of an interpretation mistake, it does not accept that interpretation problems have been the cause of all of the inconsistencies in his case. It also notes the applicant has not made submissions about particular interpretation errors such that the Tribunal is prepared to accept they explain the problematic nature of his evidence, discussed below.[Emphasis added] The Tribunal then records the ‘problematic nature’ of the applicant’s evidence in eight discreet areas at paragraphs [64] to [72]. Of these eight areas, paragraphs [64], [65], [68], [69] and [70] reference the applicant’s written statement. At paragraph [64] of the decision, the Tribunal formed the view that:64. … the applicant was genuinely in a long-term homosexual relationship in Malaysia, he would remember the particulars of that relationship, or at least be reasonably consistent in his claims. The Tribunal finds it concerning that the applicant’s evidence regarding these claims is so inconsistent to be vague. One of the points of comparison made by the Tribunal in drawing this “inconsistency” in paragraph 18 of the Statutory Declaration where the applicant states “My attraction to males first developed at the age of 14…”. During the Tribunal hearing the applicant denied saying that and said, “the 14 is wrong”. At paragraph 20 of the Statutory Declaration the applicant states he was in a relationship with a Muslim man which lasted approximately 10 years. Before the Tribunal the applicant states “... this thing about the years is wrong”. The applicant’s oral evidence concerning the duration of the relationship in the protection visa interview and before the Tribunal was four to five years.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Counsel submitted that the Tribunal made adverse credibility findings about every aspect of the claims made by the applicant, construing everything against the applicant, with no flexibility or understanding shown for any aspect of the applicant’s case. It is said by the applicant that this is the critical aspect that satisfied the criteria that no rational or logical decision maker could have concluded and that other rational or logical decision makers could have found adverse credibility findings on some matters, but none would have found adverse credibility findings of every claim made by the applicant.ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL DECISION The Tribunal’s reasons are over 15 pages and spans 83 paragraphs. At paragraphs 3 to 21 of its reasons, the Tribunal records the applicant’s background and claims. Under the heading “Hearing on 11 October 2019”, paragraphs 22 to 54 summarise the evidence the applicant gave during the hearing before a Senior Member of the Tribunal. Paragraphs 55 to 59 of the reasons record the criteria for the issue of a protection visa. At paragraphs 60 to 79 in its reasons, under the heading “CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE” the Tribunal stated (at [62]):62.As set out in the delegate’s decision record, provided to the Tribunal by the applicant, there are number of inconsistencies in the applicant’s evidence. In the circumstances of this case, the Tribunal finds that those inconsistencies raise significant concerns as to whether the applicant’s claims are genuine. Having considered all of the evidence before it, for the following reasons, the Tribunal does not accept that the applicant is homosexual or that he has had a homosexual relationship in Malaysia, or Australia, or that he was beaten or threatened because of his sexual orientation or relationship in Malaysia, or Sikhism, or that he has a well-founded fear of persecution in Malaysia for one or more of the 5 reason set out in the Act. At paragraph [63] of its reasons, the Tribunal noted that from time to time the applicant has explained inconsistencies by stating that there must have been interpretation mistakes. I will deal with this separately below. It then gave eight reasons for the conclusion expressed at [62]. All of those reasons are separately challenged by the applicant, and I will deal with them in turn. The finding at [62] led the Tribunal to reject every material aspect of the applicant’s narrative about his homosexuality in Malaysia, and about what happened to him as a consequence, which formed the foundation for his claims for protection. At [73] the Tribunal summarised its view:73.Overall the Tribunal has formed the view that the numerous inconsistencies about significant issues cast serious doubt on the applicant’s claims to be homosexual and to have been in a homosexual relationship with Dan in Malaysia. The Tribunal does not accept these claims. It has formed the view the applicant has manufactured claims to be homosexual and to have had a homosexual relationship with Dan for the purpose of making a protection visa application. It does not accept he will identify as homosexual or have homosexual relationships if he returns to Malaysia.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In order to properly assess the fact-finding process embarked upon by the Tribunal, although lengthy, it is convenient to reproduce in full the dispositive paragraphs of the Tribunal’s reasons the subject of the particulars of the ground of review and also to reproduce the accounts given by the applicant from the relevant parts of his written evidence, the delegate interview and the Tribunal hearing.CONSIDERATIONParticular (i): At [64] the finding of inconsistency between what he said in his written claims and later in his oral evidence, about the dates and the duration of the relationship and when he realised that he was gay. Paragraph [64] of the reasons is as follows: 64.First, the Tribunal finds the applicant’s evidence regarding his first awareness of his attraction to men to be inconsistent. In his written application he indicated that he first developed an attraction to men at age 14. In his oral evidence to the delegate he indicated that it was in 2000 2001 (age 25 or 26), although he also said it was when he was 28 or 29. He indicated to the Tribunal that it was when he was 26 or 27 and it was while he was working on the farm. In his written claims he indicated that he was in a relationship with Dan for 10 years. In his oral evidence to the delegate he indicated that he was in the relationship for 4 ½ years. However, he told the Tribunal that he first met Dan in 2004 2005 and they had a sexual relationship for 4 or 5 years. He then indicated that he met him in 2004. He clarified later and indicated he met him when he was 25 or 27 (2000 2002) but also indicated that he met him when he was 24 or 25, or 26 or 28. When it was put to the applicant that his evidence about meeting Dan and the duration of the relationship was inconsistent, he merely indicated that it was a long time ago. The Tribunal is of the view that, if the applicant was genuinely in a long-term homosexual relationship in Malaysia, he would remember the particulars of that relationship, or at least be reasonably consistent in his claims. The Tribunal finds it concerning that the applicant’s evidence regarding these claims is so inconsistent to be vague … Paragraph [64] of the reasons highlight purported inconsistencies of the applicant’s evidence as to the dates concerning his first awareness of his attraction to men, when he first met Dan and the duration of his relationship with Dan. The Tribunal made an adverse credibility finding against the applicant because it was of the view that if the applicant was genuinely in a long-term homosexual relationship in Malaysia, he would remember the particulars of that relationship or at least be reasonably consistent in his claims. I have referred earlier in these reasons to my concern with respect to any reliance upon or weight to be attributed to the applicant’s Statutory Declaration. Those concerns are equally applicable here. This is what is recorded in the in the Statutory Declaration: 18.My attraction to males first developed at the age of 14, however given the extremely conservative views towards homosexuality, I feared coming out. All accusations of homosexuality that were made against me were strenuously denied.…20.Despite my fears of coming out I maintained a covert homosexual relationship with a Muslim man named Dan Mohamad, which lasted approximately 10 years.