ECL19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
66 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
ECL19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 764
File number(s):
ADG 405 of 2019
Judgment of:
JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment:
27 May 2025
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Judicial review application – decision of Immigration Assessment Authority – citizen of Sri Lanka – whether proper consideration given to whether exceptional circumstances existed to justify considering new information – whether assessment of whether new information was credible personal information – whether legally unreasonable to fail to utilise powers to obtain information from the applicant or other sources – whether legally unreasonable determinations concerning the applicant’s credibility and alleged failure to raise issues – whether jurisdictional error – writs issued
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ECL19 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:
The applicant, ECL19, a citizen of Sri Lanka, sought judicial review of the decision of the Migration Review Authority to affirm the decision of the delegate to refuse his application for a Subclass 866 Special Humanitarian Entry visa. ECL19 contended that the Authority erred in failing to consider new information provided by him and in making legally unreasonable determinations concerning his credibility and alleged failure to raise issues in a timely manner. The court was required to determine whether the Authority properly considered whether exceptional circumstances existed to justify considering the new information, whether the Authority properly assessed the credibility of the new information, and whether it was legally unreasonable for the Authority to fail to utilise its powers to obtain information from the applicant or other sources.
The court found that the Authority had considered the new information provided by ECL19 but was not satisfied that exceptional circumstances existed to justify its consideration. The court found that the Authority had properly assessed the credibility of the new information and had not erred in finding that it was not reliable. The court found that it was not legally unreasonable for the Authority to fail to utilise its powers to obtain information from the applicant or other sources as the applicant had not demonstrated that such information would have been available to him or that it would have been relevant to his application.
The court dismissed the application and affirmed the decision of the Authority.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
ECL19 made the following claims:(a)ECL19 claimed to be a Sri Lankan citizen, and a Tamil from the Northern Province. His uncle (“Uncle S”) was a member of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (“LTTE”);(b)after the end of the civil war in May 2009, Uncle S was detained along with his immediate family by the Sri Lankan Government for approximately six months. Upon Uncle S’ release, he and his family resided in ECL19’s family home in the central north of Sri Lanka for around six months before they returned to their home in the north east of Sri Lanka;(c)the Sri Lankan Army (“SLA”) visited ECL19’s family home regularly and asked questions of ECL19’s family about their association with the LTTE. His parents were taken to the SLA camp for questioning around three to four times during 2010-2011;(d)ECL19 travelled to India using his genuine Sri Lankan passport to attend a wedding from around August to September 2011. This passport remains in Sri Lanka;(e)when ECL19 was leaving Sri Lanka to go to the wedding in India, the Sri Lankan immigration authorities enquired about his travel and told him that he had to return; (f)between 2010 and 2012 ECL19’s family received a number of anonymous phone calls from unknown persons speaking Singhalese. ECL19 recalls receiving one such phone call around ten days before he was attacked on 14 November 2012;(g)ECL19’s mother’s brother-in-law (“Uncle P”), was also a member of the LTTE and was regularly taken for questioning and tortured by the authorities. ECL19 does not know where Uncle P is now;(h)in June 2012 the Sri Lanka authorities visited ECL19’s family home and his mother went with them voluntarily in order to produce her National Identity Card. ECL19 stated that he and his father went with her voluntarily to support her, and were there for around four hours. While there the Sri Lanka authorities asked ECL19 questions about Uncles S and P, for approximately one hour;(i)on one occasion in around August 2012 ECL19 was taken for questioning by the SLA with his parents, for around half a day and he was questioned on his own about Uncle S and his links to the LTTE. While he was not harmed during this time he felt threatened;(j)in August 2012 the Sri Lankan authorities visited ECL19’s family home. At that time they came through the whole village doing a sweep for mines;(k)on 14 November 2012 ECL19 was approached at night near his home by two unknown men on a motorbike. The man on the back got off the motorbike and spoke Singhalese. He attacked ECL19 with a rod and sword before leaving. ECL19 was assisted to get to a hospital where he received medical treatment including seven stitches to his knee;(l)ECL19 asserted that the unidentified people that attacked him on 14 November 2012 were from the Sri Lankan Government and suggested that this was a common practice to intimidate and harass in a secretive way, and is likely to happen to him again if he returns to Sri Lanka;(m)ECL19 then stayed with his mother’s sister (“Aunt”) in a nearby suburb;(n)while ECL19 remained with the Aunt, the CID went to his parents’ house looking for him on two occasions. His mother also received threatening phone calls (in Tamil) asking where he was;(o)the Aunt’s husband organised for him to leave Sri Lanka by boat to go to Australia and he departed on 10 May 2013;(p)since ECL19 arrived in Australia the Sri Lankan authorities have visited his family home in Sri Lanka looking for him several times. In around June-July 2013, his father went missing. His mother reported his father as being missing to the police;(q)ECL19 fears returning to Sri Lanka as he believes he will be attacked again due to familial links (through his Uncles S and P) and imputed links to the LTTE;(r)Uncle S joined the LTTE when he was very young and lost his leg while fighting in the war. ECL19 asserted that Uncle S held a senior position but was unsure of the specifics of his position and rank in the LTTE as he was young at the time;(s)Uncle S was released about a month earlier than Uncle P, and lived with ECL19’s family upon release;(t)the Sri Lankan authorities visited ECL19’s home for the first time after Uncles S and P were released from detention;(u)Uncle P fought with the LTTE and was a lieutenant, but ECL19 wasn't sure of any other details. Uncle P was also detained in 2009 at a farm. Uncle P went missing with ECL19’s father;(v)in February 2013 the Sri Lanka authorities came to ECL19’s home but he was not there. ECL19 stated that he was living with his Aunt during this time and regularly visited his parents, and his mother also visited him there;(w)ECL19 stated that his father and Uncle P went missing when trying to come to Australia, soon after ECL19 arrived in Australia in May 2013. His family made a missing person’s report with the police about one and half months after ECL19’s father went missing;(x)ECL19 stated he did not tell anyone about his missing relatives while he was in immigration detention or in his written application, as he thought his father would eventually make contact;(y)ECL19 fears returning to Sri Lanka as he believes he may have problems again. He said as it has happened before, it is likely to happen again and suggested that the country had not progressed. He stated that even though the government has changed, the SLA and police were still operating in the same area, and ECL19 saw on the news that incidents involving torture continued;(z)ECL19’s mother and younger brother moved in with the Aunt after ECL19’s father went missing and eventually moved to another house in the same city in 2017, and are currently waiting for ECL19’s sister to sponsor them so that they can relocate to Canada; and(aa)ECL19 fears harm on the basis of his ethnicity, past experiences with the Sri Lankan authorities and actual or imputed political opinion arising from his ethnicity, gender, residence in the north of Sri Lanka and familial relationships with former LTTE members.Procedural background
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
The procedural background prior to the making of the Amended Judicial Review Application is as follows:(a)ECL19 arrived in Australia on 26 May 2013: CB 78. He had an accelerated processing interview (“AP Interview”) on 15 June 2013 and an induction interview (“Induction Interview”) on 10 July 2013: CB 144;(b)on 26 June 2017 ECL19 applied for the SHE Visa: CB 21-70;(c)the Delegate interviewed ECL19 on 8 February 2019 (“SHE Visa Interview”): CB 73;(d)on 4 September 2019 the Delegate refused to grant ECL19 the SHE Visa: CB 78-93;(e)on 10 September 2019 the Delegate’s Decision was referred to the Authority: CB 98-100;(f)on 27 September 2019 ECL19 provided submissions and new information to the Authority: CB 110-130; and(g)on 18 October 2019 the Authority Decision was to affirm the Delegate’s Decision: CB 134-154.AUTHORITY DECISION In the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)considered an email from ECL19’s representative which enclosed a submission which contained discussion on why ECL19 did not agree with the Delegate’s Decision and a number of other documents;(b)found that to the extent that the discussion reiterated and addressed claims made to the Delegate that this was not new information and was already considered in the review;(c)found that sources (a)-(g) were not before the Delegate and were new information. In relation to the sources (a) – (d) these were provided in support of the claim made in the submission that “if the applicant and the members of his family unit, who are Australian citizen, are compelled to return to Sri Lanka, this raises the applicant's profile”. This claim was not before the Delegate and was new information and there were no exceptional circumstances to justify the consideration of the new information;(d)with respect to an item of new information which the Authority described as a letter from a Member of Parliament (“MP’s Letter”): CB 135 at [4(e)] found as follows: CB 136 at [7]:Source (e) appears to have been provided in support of the identity and character of the applicant and “the reality in [the applicant’s] community, that should he return, along with his Australian family members, there are serious and imminent risks to their life (sic)”. It has been contended that source (e) “was not readily available during the applicant’s application and interview and was only obtained recently, after seeking [the community advocacy service’s] assistance”. Source (e) is undated. It states his mother’s address as the family home. He stated at the protection visa interview that she had moved from this address some time after his arrival in Australia in 2013. The applicant was clearly advised by the delegate at the commencement of the protection visa interview that it was extremely important to provide the Department with complete and accurate protection claims as early as possible, including during the interview, and that it was his responsibility to raise his claims for protection. The applicant was also cautioned that if his application was refused he may not have another chance to provide further information to support his claims. The determinative issues which the source details were raised in his protection visa statement which the same community advocacy service had assisted him to prepare, and I do not accept that he could not have sought out this or a similar type of document earlier. It is personal information however I have serious concerns about its reliability. In relation to the specific circumstances of the applicant, it does not specifically indicate that the signatory has actual knowledge of such events; rather it refers to the applicant’s mother being known to the signatory and appears to be a narration of statements provided by her to the signatory. This is particularly evident in the paragraph which details the visits after the applicant departed, and the statements “I was told” and “[the applicant’s mother] told me”. Furthermore, the details regarding the “frequent visits to the family home” have been expressed in general terms and makes no mention of how frequent these visits were or when they have occurred. In light of the foregoing, I am not convinced of its corroborative value. Having regard to all of the evidence, I am not satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances to justify the consideration of this new information.(e)in relation to sources (f) – (g) these pre-date the Delegate’s Decision and were found to be general country information not personal information: CB 136 at [8]. Source (f) was a report on the treatment of Tamils of “exactly persons such as [the applicant]”, which the Authority was not satisfied was contemporary evidence of the prevalence of arbitrary detention and torture: CB 137 at [9]. Source (g) was an extract from a broader report which ECL19 contended refuted the Delegate’s findings in relation to the Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1979 (Sri Lanka) (referred to in the Authority Decision as the “PTA”), systemic discrimination and human rights violations/incidents, but the Authority was not satisfied that it materially added to the existing information, and found that there were no exceptional circumstances to justify consideration of sources (f) or (g), and nor was s 473DD(b) met: CB 137 at [10];(f)accepted the following:(i)ECL19’s identity;(ii)that ECL19’s mother’s brother Uncle S and mother’s brother-in-law Uncle P were members of the LTTE and Uncle S was injured and had his leg amputated;(iii)that at the end of the civil war in May 2009, Uncles S and P were detained separately in different camps by the Sri Lankan authorities for approximately 6 months before being detained after which Uncle S lived with ECL19 and Uncle P lived close by;(iv)that when Uncle S was living with ECL19’s family Uncle S and ECL19 were questioned by the Sri Lankan authorities on a number of occasions which led to tension and Uncle S leaving ECL19’s family home and the SLA subsequently questioning ECL19’s parents about Uncle S’s whereabouts;(v)that ECL19 departed Sri Lanka in 2011 using his passport and went to India for a wedding and returned after one month;(vi)that between 2010 and 2012 on a number of occasions ECL19’s parents were harassed, threatened and questioned about their knowledge and connections with the LTTE at the family home and on at least one occasion questioned at the SLA camp but were released without charge;(vii)that on 14 November 2012 ECL19 was stopped and attacked by two unknown men on a motorbike and was treated for the injuries sustained in the attack;(viii)that ECL19 left Sri Lanka illegally and has applied for asylum and would very likely return to Sri Lanka on temporary travel document and would be returning after a prolonged residence in a western country and that Sri Lankan authorities may know or infer that he has made claims for protection in Australia;(ix)on return to Sri Lanka ECL19 may be charged under the Immigrants and Emigrants Act 1948 (Sri Lanka) for departing Sri Lanka other than via an approved port of departure; and(x)that ECL19 would likely return to the North of Sri Lanka as failed asylum seeker and may be the subject of some monitoring by the Sri Lankan authorities for a period and may face some reintegration issues in finding employment and accommodation and social stigma;(g)did not accept that:(i)Uncles S and P held positions of seniority or a rank in the LTTE;(ii)ECL19 was stopped by immigration when going to India and told he had to return nor that at the time of his departure and return in 2011 he was of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities;(iii)beyond any initial suspicions for being Tamil, ECL19 and his parents were otherwise of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities;(iv)ECL19 was a truthful witness about the claims regarding receiving threatening calls from unknown individuals, and found that there was no country information which supported the claim that the calls were made by the Sri Lankan government or people acting on their behalf;(v)people went to ECL19’s family home and sought his whereabouts or that his family received threatening calls from unknown people, and found that these were contrived to enhance his protection claims;(vi)the attack and physical assault on ECL19 was undertaken by the Sri Lankan government or people acting on their behalf, and rather found it was an opportunistic attack and the identities of the perpetrators were and remain unknown;(vii)ECL19 was of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities or any groups or individuals at the time of his departure in 2013;(viii)the claims ECL19 made about the disappearance of his father and uncle or that they are missing; (ix)ECL19’s past or present circumstances would lead to a real chance of any adverse interest or consequence for him on return to Sri Lanka or that would he be perceived on return to have had any role in the LTTE or Tamil separatist activities;(x)would face a real chance of harm as someone with familial links to former LTTE members or because of any actual or imputed pro-LTTE, pro-Tamil, pro-Tamil separatism or anti-Sri Lankan government political opinion, on his return to Sri Lanka now or in the reasonably foreseeable future;(xi)ECL19 would receive a custodial sentence for departing Sri Lanka illegally or that the conditions of detention for a brief period at the airport, a fine and the costs associated with regular court appearances, if required amount to serious harm;(xii)any investigation, prosecution and punishment would amount to persecution for the purpose of ss 5H(1) and 5J(1);(xiii)returning to the North of Sri Lanka as a failed asylum seeker amounted to serious harm or that ECL19 would face a real chance of persecution now or in the reasonably foreseeable future; and(xiv)ECL19 has a well-founded fear of persecution or met the requirements of the definition of refugee in s 5H(1) or s 36(2)(a); and(h)found that ECL19’s father and Uncle P had disappeared after ECL19’s arrival in Australia (“Missing Relatives Claim”). Based on the lateness in raising the Missing Relatives Claim, inconsistencies in ECL19’s evidence and the lack of any corroborative evidence, the Authority found that he had not been a truthful witness regarding these claims, and was not satisfied that his father or Uncle P had gone missing: CB 144-145 at [43]-[48].CONSIDERATIONGrounds of the Amended Judicial Review Application
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the Authority Decision the Authority:(a)considered an email from ECL19’s representative which enclosed a submission which contained discussion on why ECL19 did not agree with the Delegate’s Decision and a number of other documents;(b)found that to the extent that the discussion reiterated and addressed claims made to the Delegate that this was not new information and was already considered in the review;(c)found that sources (a)-(g) were not before the Delegate and were new information. In relation to the sources (a) – (d) these were provided in support of the claim made in the submission that “if the applicant and the members of his family unit, who are Australian citizen, are compelled to return to Sri Lanka, this raises the applicant's profile”. This claim was not before the Delegate and was new information and there were no exceptional circumstances to justify the consideration of the new information;(d)with respect to an item of new information which the Authority described as a letter from a Member of Parliament (“MP’s Letter”): CB 135 at [4(e)] found as follows: CB 136 at [7]:Source (e) appears to have been provided in support of the identity and character of the applicant and “the reality in [the applicant’s] community, that should he return, along with his Australian family members, there are serious and imminent risks to their life (sic)”. It has been contended that source (e) “was not readily available during the applicant’s application and interview and was only obtained recently, after seeking [the community advocacy service’s] assistance”. Source (e) is undated. It states his mother’s address as the family home. He stated at the protection visa interview that she had moved from this address some time after his arrival in Australia in 2013. The applicant was clearly advised by the delegate at the commencement of the protection visa interview that it was extremely important to provide the Department with complete and accurate protection claims as early as possible, including during the interview, and that it was his responsibility to raise his claims for protection. The applicant was also cautioned that if his application was refused he may not have another chance to provide further information to support his claims. The determinative issues which the source details were raised in his protection visa statement which the same community advocacy service had assisted him to prepare, and I do not accept that he could not have sought out this or a similar type of document earlier. It is personal information however I have serious concerns about its reliability. In relation to the specific circumstances of the applicant, it does not specifically indicate that the signatory has actual knowledge of such events; rather it refers to the applicant’s mother being known to the signatory and appears to be a narration of statements provided by her to the signatory. This is particularly evident in the paragraph which details the visits after the applicant departed, and the statements “I was told” and “[the applicant’s mother] told me”. Furthermore, the details regarding the “frequent visits to the family home” have been expressed in general terms and makes no mention of how frequent these visits were or when they have occurred. In light of the foregoing, I am not convinced of its corroborative value. Having regard to all of the evidence, I am not satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances to justify the consideration of this new information.(e)in relation to sources (f) – (g) these pre-date the Delegate’s Decision and were found to be general country information not personal information: CB 136 at [8]. Source (f) was a report on the treatment of Tamils of “exactly persons such as [the applicant]”, which the Authority was not satisfied was contemporary evidence of the prevalence of arbitrary detention and torture: CB 137 at [9]. Source (g) was an extract from a broader report which ECL19 contended refuted the Delegate’s findings in relation to the Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1979 (Sri Lanka) (referred to in the Authority Decision as the “PTA”), systemic discrimination and human rights violations/incidents, but the Authority was not satisfied that it materially added to the existing information, and found that there were no exceptional circumstances to justify consideration of sources (f) or (g), and nor was s 473DD(b) met: CB 137 at [10];(f)accepted the following:(i)ECL19’s identity;(ii)that ECL19’s mother’s brother Uncle S and mother’s brother-in-law Uncle P were members of the LTTE and Uncle S was injured and had his leg amputated;(iii)that at the end of the civil war in May 2009, Uncles S and P were detained separately in different camps by the Sri Lankan authorities for approximately 6 months before being detained after which Uncle S lived with ECL19 and Uncle P lived close by;(iv)that when Uncle S was living with ECL19’s family Uncle S and ECL19 were questioned by the Sri Lankan authorities on a number of occasions which led to tension and Uncle S leaving ECL19’s family home and the SLA subsequently questioning ECL19’s parents about Uncle S’s whereabouts;(v)that ECL19 departed Sri Lanka in 2011 using his passport and went to India for a wedding and returned after one month;(vi)that between 2010 and 2012 on a number of occasions ECL19’s parents were harassed, threatened and questioned about their knowledge and connections with the LTTE at the family home and on at least one occasion questioned at the SLA camp but were released without charge;(vii)that on 14 November 2012 ECL19 was stopped and attacked by two unknown men on a motorbike and was treated for the injuries sustained in the attack;(viii)that ECL19 left Sri Lanka illegally and has applied for asylum and would very likely return to Sri Lanka on temporary travel document and would be returning after a prolonged residence in a western country and that Sri Lankan authorities may know or infer that he has made claims for protection in Australia;(ix)on return to Sri Lanka ECL19 may be charged under the Immigrants and Emigrants Act 1948 (Sri Lanka) for departing Sri Lanka other than via an approved port of departure; and(x)that ECL19 would likely return to the North of Sri Lanka as failed asylum seeker and may be the subject of some monitoring by the Sri Lankan authorities for a period and may face some reintegration issues in finding employment and accommodation and social stigma;(g)did not accept that:(i)Uncles S and P held positions of seniority or a rank in the LTTE;(ii)ECL19 was stopped by immigration when going to India and told he had to return nor that at the time of his departure and return in 2011 he was of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities;(iii)beyond any initial suspicions for being Tamil, ECL19 and his parents were otherwise of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities;(iv)ECL19 was a truthful witness about the claims regarding receiving threatening calls from unknown individuals, and found that there was no country information which supported the claim that the calls were made by the Sri Lankan government or people acting on their behalf;(v)people went to ECL19’s family home and sought his whereabouts or that his family received threatening calls from unknown people, and found that these were contrived to enhance his protection claims;(vi)the attack and physical assault on ECL19 was undertaken by the Sri Lankan government or people acting on their behalf, and rather found it was an opportunistic attack and the identities of the perpetrators were and remain unknown;(vii)ECL19 was of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities or any groups or individuals at the time of his departure in 2013;(viii)the claims ECL19 made about the disappearance of his father and uncle or that they are missing; (ix)ECL19’s past or present circumstances would lead to a real chance of any adverse interest or consequence for him on return to Sri Lanka or that would he be perceived on return to have had any role in the LTTE or Tamil separatist activities;(x)would face a real chance of harm as someone with familial links to former LTTE members or because of any actual or imputed pro-LTTE, pro-Tamil, pro-Tamil separatism or anti-Sri Lankan government political opinion, on his return to Sri Lanka now or in the reasonably foreseeable future;(xi)ECL19 would receive a custodial sentence for departing Sri Lanka illegally or that the conditions of detention for a brief period at the airport, a fine and the costs associated with regular court appearances, if required amount to serious harm;(xii)any investigation, prosecution and punishment would amount to persecution for the purpose of ss 5H(1) and 5J(1);(xiii)returning to the North of Sri Lanka as a failed asylum seeker amounted to serious harm or that ECL19 would face a real chance of persecution now or in the reasonably foreseeable future; and(xiv)ECL19 has a well-founded fear of persecution or met the requirements of the definition of refugee in s 5H(1) or s 36(2)(a); and(h)found that ECL19’s father and Uncle P had disappeared after ECL19’s arrival in Australia (“Missing Relatives Claim”). Based on the lateness in raising the Missing Relatives Claim, inconsistencies in ECL19’s evidence and the lack of any corroborative evidence, the Authority found that he had not been a truthful witness regarding these claims, and was not satisfied that his father or Uncle P had gone missing: CB 144-145 at [43]-[48].CONSIDERATIONGrounds of the Amended Judicial Review Application