PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – appeal from orders dismissing an originating application without determining the substantive merits of the appellant’s claims – where appellant applied for an adjournment of a trial for reasons including the impact of the litigation on his existing mental illness – where primary judge vacated the trial dates and dismissed all extant applications subject to a conditional grant of leave to have the proceedings reopened – where the conditions on the grant of leave required the appellant to file medical evidence about his mental competency – where primary judge concluded the appellant would be unable to adequately conduct the proceedings should the matter be relisted and so dismissed the originating application “on a final basis” – where primary judge had no regard to the provisions of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) providing for the appointment of a litigation guardian, whether the discretion of the primary judge miscarried – appeal allowed
In paragraph 29, “informality” has been replaced by “formality”.
ORDERS
ACD 73 of 2019
BETWEEN:
MARK DRUMMOND
Applicant
AND:
CANBERRA INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY
Respondent
JUDGES:
FLICK, KATZMANN AND CHARLESWORTH JJ
DATE OF ORDER:
24 JULY 2020
THE COURT NOTES:
1.The concession given by Counsel on behalf of the Canberra Institute of Technology that in making the orders on 28 November 2017 and in his judgment and orders of 20 September 2019 the discretion of the primary Judge miscarried in that no consideration was given to the provisions of…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Drummond v Canberra Institute of Technology and more:
The Federal Circuit Court of Australia heard an appeal by Dr Drummond against the Canberra Institute of Technology (CIT) regarding orders dismissing an originating application without determining the substantive merits of his claims. Dr Drummond sought an adjournment of the trial due to the impact of the litigation on his existing mental illness. The primary judge vacated the trial dates and dismissed all extant applications, subject to a conditional grant of leave to reopen the proceedings. The conditions required Dr Drummond to file medical evidence about his mental competency. The primary judge concluded that Dr Drummond would be unable to adequately conduct the proceedings if the matter was relisted, and dismissed the originating application "on a final basis".
The legal issues before the court were whether the primary judge's discretion miscarried and whether the primary judge had failed to consider the provisions of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) providing for the appointment of a litigation guardian. The court had to determine whether the primary judge's decision to dismiss the originating application was appropriate and whether the court should set aside the November 2017 orders that provided the framework for dealing with Dr Drummond's application to reopen.
The court found that the primary judge's discretion had miscarried, as counsel for CIT conceded during the course of argument. The court also found that the primary judge had not considered the provisions of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) providing for the appointment of a litigation guardian. The court allowed the appeal by consent and set aside the November 2017 orders. Short reasons were provided for the making of these orders, including the concession by counsel for CIT that the discretion of the primary judge had miscarried.
In conclusion, the court allowed the appeal by consent and set aside the November 2017 orders that provided the framework for dealing with Dr Drummond's application to reopen. The court found that the primary judge's discretion had miscarried and that the primary judge had not considered the provisions of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) providing for the appointment of a litigation guardian. The court's decision highlights the importance of considering the provisions of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) when dealing with applications to reopen proceedings and the need for the court to exercise its discretion appropriately.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
These were the findings Dr Blanch made on examination of Dr Drummond’s mental state:Mr Drummond was casually dressed man who looks stated age. He was well groomed and engaged well in the review process. He reports a positive mood and his affect was mood congruent, warm and reactive. He does not have any speech deficits or thought form abnormality. He describes a difficult last several years with issues in both his personal and professional worlds. He recognises that his family concerns are being adequately addressed and he has returned to teaching, a profession that he loves. He does not have any suicidal thoughts and he was able to work on the development of a safety plan. There is no evidence of any psychotic phenomena. Mr Drummond has no cognitive deficit scoring 29/30 on an MMSE and there was no deficit on a frontal assessment battery. Mr Drummond has good insight into his past mental health difficulties and his judgement with respect to his mental health care is not impaired.(Emphasis added.) The second report related to a review Dr Blanch conducted on 14 February 2019 in conformity with the Court’s order for three-monthly reviews. In that report, Dr Blanch said, amongst other things:There is no evidence of any obvious delusional content nor any perceptual disturbances. Mr Drummond does not have any cognitive deficits. Mr Drummond has good insight into his mental health and his judgement with respect to his mental health care is not impaired.Mr Drummond continues to have a good understanding of the case that he is presenting and he is supported by a barrister in doing so.In my opinion Mr Drummond has a history of Depression that is currently in remission. On 14 March 2019 the parties appeared before the Circuit Court on Dr Drummond’s application to reopen the proceeding. Apparently oral submissions were made but the primary judge also made the following order for written submissions:UNTIL FURTHER ORDER, THE COURT ORDERS THAT:1.Within 14 days of the date of these Orders, being by 28 March 2019, the parties are to file and serve: a.One page of submissions addressing the medical evidence submitted by the Applicant in light of the Orders made on 20 September 2018; and b.One page of submissions addressing the principles in AON Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175 (and related cases). THE COURT NOTES THAT: 2.The Court intends to decide the matter on the basis of the oral submissions made today and the written submissions to be filed on a “Show Cause” basis, with the purpose being to provide the parties the opportunity to establish why the Applicant’s long running Application should not be dismissed. On 20 September 2019 his Honour ordered that “on a final basis”, “all extant [a]pplications be dismissed”.The September 2019 reasons The Circuit Court’s September 2019 reasons for decision outlined the background to the proceeding, including the orders made in November 2017. The primary judge summarised the conduct of the proceedings to that date as follows:6.For much of the protracted litigation, the Applicant has been self-represented. Mainly, but not only, because of issues related to his mental health, there have been multiple occasions, over a long period of time, when the Applicant has been unable to comply with various filing deadlines contained in Orders. A number of these Orders were made by consent – but still there was no compliance with them by the Applicant. More recently, for certain parts of the conduct of the matter, the Applicant has retained the services of experienced Counsel.7. On multiple occasions, as just noted, the Applicant sought, and was granted, extensions of time in relation to the filing of various documents.8.On 19th April 2017, the Court made Orders fixing the matter for final hearing (over 4 days) commencing on 28th November 2017.9. On 15th August 2017, the Respondent filed an Application in a Case seeking Orders to strike out many parts of Mr Drummond’s Amended Statement of Claim dated 2nd July 2017. In written submissions, filed 5th September 2017, the Respondent pointed out, not for the first time, that most if not all of Mr Drummond’s complaints related to events that occurred prior to 1st July 2009. In my view, fairly, the Respondent pointed out the constant delay by the Applicant in filing material and the ongoing prejudice to the Respondent and its potential witnesses. Among other complaints, the Respondent pointed out also how large tracts of the Applicant’s pleadings were embarrassing and in some instances scandalous. Other parts of the pleadings were vague, significantly general and ambiguous. I generally agree with and accept these characterisations.10. In 2017, the Applicant sought leave to re-plead. Similar leave had previously been granted to him in 2016 and again pursuant to Orders made on 19th April 2017.11. On 24th November 2017, the Court received correspondence from the Applicant in which he sought an adjournment of the final hearing. In support of that request, the Applicant provided certain medical evidence in relation to the impact the proceedings were having on his mental health. The Respondent opposed any adjournment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
During the course of argument, counsel for CIT properly conceded that the discretion of the primary judge had miscarried. Orders were then made by consent, giving effect to the concession, including an order allowing the appeal by consent. It was foreshadowed that short reasons would be provided for the making of those orders. These are those reasons.The November 2017 orders and the September 2019 decisionThe November 2017 orders The orders made on 28 November 2017 (the November 2017 orders) were somewhat unusual. They were in the following terms:1) The Hearing listed for 4 days commencing on 28 November 2017 be vacated.2) All outstanding Applications be dismissed. 3)The Applicant is at conditional liberty to seek that the matter be re-opened within 6 months of the date of today’s Orders, being by close of business on 28 May 2018. 4)The Applicant may only seek to re-open the matter pursuant to Order 3 should the following occur:a)At the time of filing the Application to Re-Open, the Applicant is to file detailed medical evidence regarding his ability to conduct the litigation;b)At intervals of every 3 months for the duration of the litigation, the Applicant is to continue to provide (by way of filing with the Court) medical evidence that he is fit and able to conduct the litigation; and c)If the foregoing steps are complied with, the Applicant is required to provide the Court with a medical certificate, 5 days prior to any hearing date, demonstrating that he is fit and able to conduct the litigation. 5)Neither party may file anything in relation to this matter during the period stipulated in Order 3, namely until 28 May 2018, without the prior leave of the Court. 6)By consent, the Costs of both sides in relation to the preparation for trial be reserved. No reasons were given and no reference was made in the orders themselves to the source of the power the Circuit Court was exercising. The orders were preceded by the following note: A.On 24 November 2017 the Court received correspondence from the Applicant requesting an adjournment of the trial listed for 4 days commencing on 28 November 2017;B. The Applicant provided significant medical evidence in relation to the impact that the proceedings were having on his mental health;C. The Respondent strongly opposed the request to adjourn the Hearing;D. There have been multiple adjournments and extensions of time granted in this matter due to, amongst other things, the Applicant’s inability to comply with timetables and provide documents;E. The Court e-mailed the parties with a proposal to deal with the Applicant’s situation and the future conduct of the matter; accordingly … The proposal mentioned in para E of the note corresponded with the orders the Circuit Court made. The November 2017 orders were not merely matters of background to the orders Dr Drummond wanted the Court to set aside. They provided the very framework from which the Circuit Court proceeded to deal with Dr Drummond’s application to reopen. Thus, while Dr Drummond’s notice of appeal did not expressly challenge the November 2017 orders, leave was granted at the hearing to enable him to do so.The application for leave to reopen