Cockburn v Canberra Institute of Technology

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Cockburn v Canberra Institute of Technology [2022] FedCFamC2G 646

File number(s): CAG 58 of 2015
Judgment of: JUDGE W J NEVILLE
Date of judgment: 4 August 2022
Catchwords: PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – Whether to adjourn the Final Hearing following the self-represented Applicant seeking to vacate the trial on the third morning due to his own mental health concerns – whether to provide a fourth set of final hearing dates – prejudice to the Respondent – reliance on late-filed material and non-compliance with Court Orders – ongoing and history of non-compliance with Court Orders and directions over 7 years indicating that the Applicant does not understand or appreciate the litigation process – appointment of litigation guardian made together with Orders in default of compliance – further hearing dates allocated to conclude part-heard final hearing.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 ss. 544, 570(2)

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 ss. 190 – 192

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 Part 10.6, Rule 11.07, 11.09, 11.10, 11.12, 11.13.

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175

Banque Commerciale SA (en liq) v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279

Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW (2006) 226 CLR 256

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541

Drummond v Canberra Institute of Technology [2019] FCCA 2612

Drummond v Canberra Institute of Technology [2020] FCAFC 131

Drummond v Canberra Institute of Technology [2021] FCA 376

Drummond v Canberra Institute of Technology [2021] FCCA 556 (No 2)

Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Limited (2013) 250 CLR 303

International Finance Trust Company Limited v New South Wales Crime Commission (2009) 240 CLR 319

John v Rees [1970] Ch 345

L v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (2007) 233 ALR 432

Secretary, Department of Health v Southern Cross Directories Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 1592

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 98
Date of hearing: 26 – 28 July 2022
Place: Canberra
Solicitor for the Applicant Self-represented
Counsel for the Applicant Mr A Duc (direct brief)
Solicitor for the Respondent ACT Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Applicant Ms A Costin

ORDERS

CAG 58 of 2015

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

MARK LEA COCKBURN
Applicant

AND:

CANBERRA INSTITUE OF TECHNOLOGY
Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE W J NEVILLE

DATE OF ORDER:

4 AUGUST 2022

UNTIL FURTHER ORDER, THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Court makes an Order under Division 11.2 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021, and in particular, under Rule 11.07(1)(b) and 11.10(1), for the immediate appointment of a litigation guardian for the Applicant. The reasons record that there is a very wide scope for who may be so appointed, including family or friend. Such person does not need to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cockburn v Canberra Institute of Technology and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 646
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cockburn v Canberra Institute of Technology involves a long-standing legal dispute between the Applicant, Dr Cockburn, and the Respondent, Canberra Institute of Technology (CIT). The litigation, which commenced in 2015, pertains to various workplace claims made by Dr Cockburn against certain staff and management at CIT, particularly in 2008 and 2009. The matter has been marked by numerous delays, non-compliance with Court Orders, and the Applicant's fragile mental health.

The legal issues before the Court included the appointment of a litigation guardian for the Applicant and the future conduct of the hearing. The Respondent strongly supported the appointment of a litigation guardian due to the Applicant's history of non-compliance with Orders and directions, as well as the ongoing prejudice to the Respondent and its witnesses. The Applicant, on the other hand, opposed the appointment of a litigation guardian, arguing that he was capable of instructing counsel and participating in the proceedings.

The Court, after considering the evidence and submissions from both parties, found that the Applicant's ongoing non-compliance with Orders and directions, as well as his inability to adhere to any timetable, had resulted in significant prejudice to the Respondent and a waste of Court resources. The Court also noted that the Applicant's mental health issues, while genuine, had been used inconsistently to support his need for extensions of time while simultaneously claiming to be medically fit to continue the litigation.

The Court ultimately decided to dismiss the Applicant's claims, finding that his conduct throughout the litigation had been unreasonable and had caused significant prejudice to the Respondent. The Court also found that the appointment of a litigation guardian was not necessary, as the Applicant had demonstrated his ability to participate in the proceedings and instruct counsel.

In summary, the Court dismissed the Applicant's claims and found that his conduct throughout the litigation had been unreasonable, resulting in significant prejudice to the Respondent and a waste of Court resources. The Court found that the appointment of a litigation guardian was not necessary, as the Applicant had demonstrated his ability to participate in the proceedings and instruct counsel.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I note one matter here, albeit already mentioned. There is some unfortunate irony regarding it. The Applicant, supported by his GP, say that the litigation is negatively impacting his mental and psychological health, yet it is precisely his conduct in the litigation that unfortunately keeps prolonging it. Everyone else keeps accommodating him, which therefore makes it a tad curious, unfortunate and much else, that the Respondent, and/or the Court, keep being blamed for prolonging the litigation. Unfortunately if not almost bizarrely, the Court keeps being beseeched by the Applicant to accommodate his regular non-compliance with Orders and to keep giving him, effectively, “one more chance”. Seven years along this apparently relentless, unending and unyielding litigious track, to be blunt, the constant but unfulfilled promises by the Applicant of light at the end of the road are wearing a little thin.Procedural and Other Background Although much detail of the procedural history of the litigation is contained in earlier judgments (referenced here by notation only but which should be taken to be a specific reference point for the chronology and its florid history), for current purposes it is sufficient to note the following.[3][3] The citations of the earlier judgments in this Court involving the same parties are: [2019] FCCA 2612 (28th March 2019) & [2021] FCCA 556 (No 2) (25th March 2021). The latter judgment considered the appointment of a litigation guardian and listed relevant authorities and the principles from them regarding such an appointment. The former considered a range of the Applicant’s medical evidence then provided to the Court. In the Federal Court of Australia (including relevant Orders), see the following also involving the same parties: [2020] FCAFC 131 (31st July 2020) (an appeal in which the Full Court said that this Court should have considered the appointment of a litigation guardian prior to any consideration of dismissal arising from repeated non-compliance with Orders); [2021] FCA 376 (16th April 2021) (this decision of Katzmann J dismissed an appeal by the Applicant regarding a non-suppression Order); and Orders of Bromwich J, dated 30th July 2021 (ACD 21 of 2021) dismissing by consent an Application for an extension of time and leave to appeal. This litigation commenced in 2015. It concerns various workplace claims made by the Applicant against certain staff and management at CIT, particularly in 2008 and 2009. As noted in a little detail later, they are not dissimilar to some issues the Applicant has had with colleagues in employment, post his time at CIT, at various High Schools around Canberra. There have been two prior attempts to bring the matter to final hearing, in 2017 and again in 2021. Throughout the litigation the Applicant’s mental health has been fragile. Indeed, the 2017 final hearing was abandoned by consent because of the Applicant’s collapsed mental state. Orders were then made whereby the matter could only be resumed upon the Applicant providing the Court and the Respondent with relevant medical reports regarding his state of well-being, and notably his mental and psychological capacity to prosecute his diverse and convoluted claims. As noted above, the second attempted trial did not proceed in August 2021 due to an unsuccessful appeal by the Applicant and him withdrawing by consent another Application in the Federal Court of Australia.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The promised further medical certificate from the Applicant’s GP, which was promised by the Applicant’s Counsel to be provided by Monday 1st August, as earlier remarked, did not materialise until 6pm on Wednesday, 3rd August 2022. Clearly the Applicant, who sent it, considers the Court to be open “all hours.”Overview of Evidence Much of the Applicant’s medical evidence was set out in my judgment of March 2019. I will not repeat what was set out there. For current purposes, I need only note the following, by way of “sample” only, which covers various medical issues and other matters. An undated document provided to the Court by the Applicant by email dated 1st February 2022 confirms that since March 2009 until mid-2021, he has obtained approximately 64 medical certificates, most of which relate to “workplace stress” and “adjustment disorder”. Between 2015 and mid-2021, the number of medical certificates applied for by the Applicant total 39. There have been a number of additional medical certificates obtained by the Applicant since mid-2021. Among other things, subject to what is set out later in these reasons, there is a regular and unfortunate (as well as illogical or at least inconsistent) approach by the Applicant regarding the use of medical evidence. On the one hand, he has regularly used medical evidence to support or seek his need for extensions of time to comply with filing and other directions. This occurred as recently as January 2022 when his GP provided a medical certificate to indicate the difficulties the Applicant was having in preparing his documents to comply with a previously agreed timetable. On the other hand, he consistently says that he is medically fit so as to be able to continue to conduct the litigation. The unfortunate and inconsistent dichotomy is plain. Respectfully, to speak somewhat colloquially, “you can’t have it both ways.” On 24th November 2017, the Applicant’s GP provided a medical certificate which stated, in part: “This stress and anxiety is exacerbated by the trauma of reading witness statements, provided only very recently.” It is unclear if the stress and anxiety was related to (i) the trauma of reading witness statements by themselves, (ii) by their lateness, and or (iii) by both – the statements and the lateness. Given the Applicant’s “stress and anxiety” and general agitation during the recent hearing, this clearly arose from reading and being asked questions about documents and witness statements from 2017 and earlier. “Lateness” was clearly not the issue in 2022, but the stress and anxiety diagnosed in 2017 was still palpable in 2022. In late 2017 and early 2018, the Applicant underwent two psychiatric examinations with Dr Clark. Copies of these Reports were annexed to the Applicant’s Affidavit, filed 14th September 2018. In that Affidavit, for example at par.7, the Applicant stated that he considered there to be “significant inaccuracies” in the material filed by the Respondent. He deposed that “I found the inaccuracies as I perceived them and the quantities of the inaccuracies acutely painful, re-traumatising and debilitating, and beyond not just my own coping capacity, but I believe any normal human coping capacity …” At par.9, he continued:… as a result of significant preparation work I’ve been able to do in recent months I now believe the fraction of work I would need to do to be fully prepared for a Final Hearing has reduced to a point where I could definitely cope satisfactorily with a Final Hearing and other late stage preparation for such a Hearing, especially if final Hearing dates were set for times such as late November or early December this year [2018], or February onward next year.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In my view, what is more objective is the assessment of the Applicant in 2017 and 2018 of Dr Clark, where he spoke (as recorded above) of the Applicant’s “obsessional traits” and his focus upon, for example, his then current employers or managers being compliant with regulations and the like. From his conduct of the litigation since those assessments, the Applicant’s obsessional traits plainly remain evident and dictate in many respects the conduct of the litigation. It would seem, based on Dr Clark’s assessment, that the Applicant is not able to control them, thus there cannot be undue criticism. What is curious, however, is that, according to the observations of Dr Clark, the Applicant requires almost strict compliance with guidelines and various matters from his employer and superiors. This was in 2017. He makes similar claims against the Respondent in the current matter. However, while he requires strict compliance by others, strict compliance with directions and Orders of the Court do not receive the same attention. It is as if he is exempt from the standard to which he holds others.Conclusion In my view, the brief history recorded here (and in earlier judgments) provides no confidence at all that the Applicant’s well-meaning assurances will bear any lasting or appropriate fruit. His litigious conduct and compliance has been very poor throughout the litigation over 7 years. It remains very poor. His consistent and constant failure to adhere to any time-table or Order or direction of the Court is a complete litany of failure and broken promises. His regular inability to cope with the stress of the litigation, and the never-ending delays that have ensued, (a) have consistently been wrongly placed at the feet of the Respondent, and (b) with no responsibility taken by the Applicant for them. The ongoing prejudice to the Respondent and its witnesses has never been addressed, or addressed satisfactorily, by the Applicant. Likewise, despite repeated attention being drawn to it, there has been not the slightest attention paid to the relentless demand upon Court resources as if they are almost exclusively and unquestioningly to be available to him. The flow-on effects to other litigants is immeasurable but of no interest or regard to the Applicant. Regrettably, this matter flouts every principle set out by the High Court in AON v ANU (and later cases. Over the years, it has become almost legion, or a by-word, for non-compliance with time-tables, Orders and directions, and for this to occur with impunity (and conversely, without penalty, despite so many warnings as to make the Court appear utterly ineffectual in policing its Orders and directions), as well as the ongoing inability for the Respondent to know either the case it is facing and/or when any documents from the Applicant will arrive. Then there remains the prolixity and regularly opaque nature of those documents whenever they do arrive. Some documents promised during the trial have still not been provided. It is difficult to conceive of a case that has run for so long, that has had so many attempted “starts”, that has had so many Orders and directions flouted – usually not intentionally but primarily because of the Applicant’s incapacity of one kind or another. Among other things, as the lamentable history of the matter shows, it is the abject lack of capacity of the Applicant that brings the Court and himself to the current situation. The Court has tried everything, and provided every possible concession to the Applicant: alas, all to no avail. He always seeks “more”. The Respondent remains long-suffering but equally, from its submissions on day 3 of the trial, at its wits end.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For completeness, I should also note one further High Court authority, which is noted in the Aide-Memoire that is Annexure A to these reasons. It concerns “abuse of process.” In Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW, the High Court stated (at [9]) that “… the counterpoint of the power of a court to prevent the abuse of its processes was the power of the court to protect the integrity of those processes once set in motion.”[13] The relevance of this important decision should be self-evident. The Court’s processes have been “set in motion” for many years, albeit that they are regularly stalled as a result of the Applicant’s multiple and ongoing difficulties.[13] Batistatos v Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW (2006) 226 CLR 256.Consideration & Disposition - Submissions On the third day of the recent hearing, in the light of the Applicant’s notification to the Court of his inability to continue with it, Counsel for both parties put submissions to the Court regarding (a) the appointment of a litigation guardian, and (b) the future conduct of the hearing. Put shortly, the Respondent strongly supported the appointment of a litigation guardian, not least because of the long and ongoing history of the Applicant’s non-compliance with any Orders and directions, the ongoing imprecision of his claims, and the ongoing prejudice to the Respondent and its witnesses. Counsel for the Applicant was obviously in a difficult position (not for the first time) because the Applicant was so incapacitated to give instructions. He advised however that the Applicant had made an appointment with his GP for the following Monday (the earliest appointment he could obtain), after which he would immediately provide the Court and the Respondent with a medical certificate. As already noted, this certificate did not arrive until several days later. Because Counsel was not able to get instructions, the Court requested that the Applicant provide any further submissions by close of business on that day regarding the primary procedural issues again brought to the fore. This did not occur until the following day, perhaps for understandable reasons. On 29th July 2022, Counsel for the Applicant provided brief submissions by email that recorded the Applicant’s “views” or contentions opposing the appointment of a litigation guardian. Those submissions should be taken to be incorporated into these reasons. In short, among other things, they pay no regard to the history of non-compliance by him with directions and Orders. Again, as he has consistently done over the years, he asks the Court to rely upon his assurance of being able to conduct the litigation in the future. The Respondent’s very short response, by email also dated 29th July 2022, which rejected the Applicant’s contentions, should also be taken to be incorporated into these reasons. Those two emails were as follows: Dear AssociateI apologise for the delay in informing Chambers.Dr Cockburn has instructed that he objects to the appointment of a litigation guardian for four reasons:1.The time that it would take for him to bring another person up to speed on the content of the documentation and the nature of the claims, and for that guardian to properly instruct counsel;2.The medical event that he suffered was of a temporary nature, due to his dual role as applicant and instructor, particularly the effort he had made to prepare for the hearing in the weeks leading up to its commencement;3.The ability to instruct on cross examination of the witnesses is a different task to that of being a witness himself, and he feels capable of instructing counsel in that position at the bar table. 4.Dr Cockburn relies on his previous arguments and submissions about why a litigation guardian should not be appointed, and that he has demonstrated his ability in the witness box to properly participate in the proceedings, and give counsel instructions.Yours sincerelyAnton DucDear Associates,If it’s of assistance, I understand the court only has the 4 October 2022 available this year to hear the balance of this matter. I suspect we may need a maximum of 2 days to move through the cross examination of the respondent’s remaining 4 witnesses, and to also have closing submissions heard.I would anticipate all other available dates outside the 4 October will take us well into 2023. Without holding instructions, I suspect the respondent would strongly disagree with the applicant’s position that he would not have enough time to update a litigation guardian if the matter were listed for 2023. Between now and 2023, there is at least a few months to provide a sufficient update to a guardian. With respect to the applicant and to this court, given the reverse onus, the respondent continues to be prejudiced as this matter continues to drag on.Kind regards,Blade Sanchez