JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
TITLE OF COURT : THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)
CITATION: DREXEL LONDON (a firm) -v- GOVE (BLACKMAN) [2009] WASCA 181
CORAM: McLURE JA
LE MIERE J
KENNETH MARTIN J
HEARD: 6-8 MAY 2009
DELIVERED : 21 OCTOBER 2009
FILE NO/S: CACV 16 of 2007
BETWEEN: DREXEL LONDON (a firm)
Appellant
AND
SHARON LEE GOVE (BLACKMAN)
First RespondentBARNABY PIERRE COLIN WOOD
Second RespondentPAUL CHARLES BLACKMAN
Third RespondentKYLE THEODORE PETERS
Fourth RespondentMICHAEL ANTONY KUBA
Fifth RespondentSHELLEY MERRILYN GOLLAN
Sixth RespondentMARYANNE FIORE
Seventh RespondentMIA LEE FARINOSI
Eighth RespondentTINA ELIZABETH D'CASTRO (ACKERMAN)
Ninth RespondentJULIETTE CHLOE VIRGINIE WOOD
Tenth RespondentIAN ROBERT MICHEL REGNARD
Twelfth RespondentDANNIELLE DORISSE ELIZABETH BECKWITH
Thirteenth RespondentNIGEL KENNETH GILES
Fourteenth RespondentNEIL ALEXANDER GRANT
Fifteenth RespondentROBYN LESLEY DREXEL
Sixteenth RespondentTHE OWNERS OF THE OLD SOAP FACTORY (STRATA TITLE PLAN 11175)
Seventeenth RespondentHALPERN GLICK PTY LTD (ACN 008 729 204)
Eighteenth Respondent
FILE NO/S :CACV 20 of 2007
BETWEEN :CITY OF FREMANTLE
Appellant
AND
SHARON LEE GOVE (BLACKMAN)
First RespondentBARNABY PIERRE COLIN WOOD
Second RespondentPAUL CHARLES BLACKMAN
Third RespondentKYLE THEODORE PETERS
Fourth RespondentMICHAEL ANTONY KUBA
Fifth RespondentSHELLEY MERRILYN GOLLAN
Sixth RespondentMARYANNE FIORE
Seventh RespondentMIA LEE FARINOSI
Eighth RespondentTINA ELIZABETH D'CASTRO (ACKERMAN)
Ninth RespondentJULIETTE CHLOE VIRGINIE WOOD
Tenth RespondentDEAN DAVID HOLM GRAHAM
Eleventh RespondentIAN ROBERT MICHEL REGNARD
Twelfth RespondentDANNIELLE DORISSE ELIZABETH BECKWITH
Thirteenth RespondentNIGEL KENNETH GILES
Fourteenth RespondentNEIL ALEXANDER GRANT
Fifteenth RespondentROBYN LESLEY DREXEL
Sixteenth RespondentMARC DREXEL
Seventeenth RespondentDREXEL LONDON (a firm)
Eighteenth Respondent
FILE NO/S :CACV 114 of 2007
BETWEEN :SHARON LEE GOVE (BLACKMAN)
First Appellant
BARNABY PIERRE COLIN WOOD
Second AppellantPAUL CHARLES BLACKMAN
Third AppellantKYLE THEODORE PETERS
Fourth AppellantMICHAEL ANTONY KUBA
Fifth AppellantSHELLEY MERRILYN GOLLAN
Sixth AppellantMARYANNE FIORE
Seventh AppellantMIA LEE FARINOSI
Eighth AppellantTINA ELIZABETH D'CASTRO (ACKERMAN)
Ninth AppellantJULIETTE CHLOE VIRGINIE WOOD
Tenth AppellantDEAN DAVID HOLM GRAHAM
Eleventh AppellantIAN ROBERT MICHEL REGNARD
Twelfth AppellantDANNIELLE DORISSE ELIZABETH BECKWITH
Thirteenth AppellantNIGEL KENNETH GILES
Fourteenth AppellantNEIL ALEXANDER GRANT
Fifteenth AppellantMARC DREXEL
Sixteenth AppellantROBYN LESLEY DREXEL
Seventeenth AppellantAND
THE OWNERS OF THE OLD SOAP FACTORY (STRATA TITLE PLAN 11175)
First RespondentRICHARD ASH BLACK
Second RespondentASH INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 007 949 395)
Third RespondentDREXEL LONDON (A FIRM)
Fourth RespondentCITY OF FREMANTLE
Fifth RespondentHALPERN GLICK PTY LTD (ACN 008 729 204)
Sixth Respondent
ON APPEAL FROM:
Jurisdiction : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Coram :TEMPLEMAN J
Citation :GOVE -v- BLACK & ORS [2006] WASC 298
File No :CIV 2375 of 1997, CIV 2370 of 1997, CIV 2371 of 1997, CIV 2373 of 1997, CIV 2374 of 1997, CIV 2376 of 1997, CIV 2377 of 1997, CIV 2378 of 1997, CIV 2381 of 1997, CIV 2382 of 1997, CIV 2398 of 1997, CIV 2411 of 1997, CIV 2412 of 1997, CIV…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Drexel London (a firm) v Gove (Blackman) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] WASCA 181
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the engineer assumed responsibility for the structural design of the balcony and if the architect shared that responsibility. It considered if the engineer's failure to identify deficiencies in the design and the architect's failure to observe the substitution of Oregon for Jarrah constituted negligence. The court also assessed whether the substitution of Oregon for Jarrah and the failure to eliminate or materially reduce the risk of moisture traps were reasonably foreseeable causes of the collapse. Furthermore, the court considered the statutory duty of the strata company under the Strata Titles Act 1985(WA) and the council's statutory and common law duties.
The court held that the engineer was liable for negligence due to the failure to identify critical structural deficiencies in the design of the balcony. The architect was also found liable for sharing responsibility in the structural design and failing to observe the substitution of Oregon for Jarrah. The strata company was found to have breached its statutory duty to maintain the common property in good and serviceable repair. The local council was found to have breached its statutory duty to inspect the building and certify its consistency with building plans and specifications. The court found that the council owed a common law duty of care to the visitors of the building, and its failure to identify the substitution of Oregon for Jarrah contributed to the collapse.
The court apportioned damages among the defendants based on their respective contributions to the collapse. The court also considered costs under Sanderson and Bullock orders, awarding costs to the plaintiff against the engineer, the architect, and the strata company. The council was ordered to pay costs to the plaintiff.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi