Catchwords: MIGRATION – Review of decision by Immigration Assessment Authority – whether Immigration Assessment Authority’s decision affected by jurisdictional error – whether the Immigration Assessment Authority erred in its consideration of the complementary protection criterion in s.36(2)(aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – whether the Immigration Assessment Authority’s findings were open to it – no jurisdictional error – application dismissed.
Appeared in person with the assistance of an interpreter
Solicitors for the Respondents:
Ms Monica Perotti (Sparke Helmore)
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT SYDNEY
SYG 1856 of 2018
DLT18
Applicant
And
MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
First Respondent
IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
Second Respondent
EX TEMPORE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
By application, filed on 4 July 2018, the applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority dated 21 June 2018 (“the Authority”), affirming a decision of a delegate of the first respondent (“the Delegate”) not to grant the applicant a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa.
When the applicant’s application was filed he was legally represented. However, on 7 November 2018, in writing, the applicant dismissed the services of his lawyer in the following terms:
“I [applicant’s name]
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read DLT18 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:
The applicant, a citizen of Nepal, arrived in Australia as an unauthorised maritime arrival and was subsequently permitted to lodge an application for a Temporary Safe Haven Enterprise visa (SHEV). His application was refused by a delegate of the Minister, a decision which was then referred to the Authority for review. The Authority affirmed the delegate's decision, finding that the applicant did not meet the criteria for a refugee or for complementary protection. The applicant sought judicial review of the Authority's decision.
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Authority erred in its assessment of the applicant's claims for protection, specifically concerning the credibility of his evidence regarding past persecution and the likelihood of future harm if returned to Nepal. This involved examining the Authority's adverse credibility findings, its consideration of inconsistencies and omissions in the applicant's statements, and its evaluation of documentary evidence. The court was also required to determine if the Authority correctly applied the relevant provisions of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) concerning refugee status and complementary protection.
Emmett J considered the Authority's detailed findings, which included adverse credibility assessments based on the applicant's evidence being "evasive, vague and confused," and significant prompting required before claims of attack were made. The Authority found inconsistencies in the applicant's accounts of his employment, political affiliations, and past attacks, and placed little or no weight on documents provided by the applicant, such as an election identity card and a letter from an association, due to their lack of official standing, inconsistencies, or post-arrival dating. The Authority accepted only limited claims, such as the applicant's interest in politics and possible move to Kathmandu, but rejected claims of attacks, threats, detention, injury, or being a high-profile supporter of the King. Ultimately, the Authority concluded that the applicant had fabricated his claims and did not face a real chance of harm, thus not meeting the definition of a refugee or the criteria for complementary protection.
The application for judicial review was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
The background, the applicant’s claims and the Authority’s decision are accurately summarised in the submissions of the solicitor for the first respondent as follows:“Background 3. The applicant, a citizen of Nepal, arrived in Australia on 25 November 2012, as an unauthorised maritime arrival (Court Book (CB) 36 and 43).4. On 28 April 2016, an officer of the Minister's Department wrote to the applicant to advise him that the Minister had exercised the power under s 46A(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act) to permit him to lodge a valid application for a Temporary Safe Have Enterprise visa or SHEV.5. On 18 May 2017, the applicant applied for a SHEV (CB 23-73; see also CB 74). The applicant attended an interview with a delegate of the Minister on 8 March 2018 (CB 82 and 90) and on 6 April 2018, the delegate refused to grant the applicant a SHEV (CB 85-100).6. On 13 April 2018, the Minister referred the delegate’s decision to the Authority pursuant to s 473CA to the Act (CB 102). By a letter and accompanying information sheet of the same date, the Authority relevantly advised the applicant that he could provide new information in support of his case, but that the Authority could only consider such information in limited circumstances (CB 102- 108). The information sheet also informed the applicant that he could make a submission to the Authority about why he disagreed with the delegate’s decision and about any claim or matter that was not considered. However, no submission or further information was received from the applicant (CB 117, [4]).7. On 21 June 2018, the Authority affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the applicant the SHEV.The applicant’s claims8. The applicant’s claims for protection were initially set out in a statement accompanying his visa application and are summarised as follows (CB 66-68):(a) The applicant was born in Bagum and remained there until 2008.(b) He was employed by the Communist Party of Nepal as an area secretary from 1995 to 1997. In 1997, he was elected a member of the Lamjung District 2 Government Committee and was involved in community development work.(c) He refused to join the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoists) and as a result, they accused him of being a spy and reactionary. In 2004, Maoists attacked him at his home and broke his leg.(d) The applicant resigned from his employment because he became a supporter of the King. After the monarchy was abolished, he was targeted by Maoists and other supporters of the republic. They planned to attack him so he and his family moved to Kathmandu.(e) The applicant continued to receive threats in Kathmandu and different groups tried to attack him on two or three occasions.(f) The applicant sometimes went to India for his safety. He discovered that he was being followed there and as a consequence, did not feel safe in India because of the connections there with Nepalese political parties.Authority’s decision9. The Authority had regard to the material referred to it under s 473CB of the Act and noted that no further information had been obtained or received (CB 117, [3] – [4]).10. Having summarised the applicant’s claims (CB 117, [5]), the Authority accepted that the applicant was a citizen of Nepal of Gurung ethnicity who completed tertiary education, worked as a teacher and had a wife and three children who continued to live in Kathmandu (CB 118, [8]). The Authority noted that the applicant did not make claims to fear harm based on his ethnicity or religion, but rather his claims centred on his political affiliations and attacks and threats made against him as a result (CB 119, [9]).11. The Authority made detailed adverse credibility findings, finding that the applicant’s evidence was “evasive, vague and confused” (CB 119, [13] – [15]). It noted that the applicant needed significant prompting before he made claims of being attacked in his protection interview (CB 119, [14]). The Authority further noted that the applicant had little knowledge or understanding of the communist party or the monarchists, or the reasons why he joined them (CB 120, [16]). The Authority considered the applicant’s claim advanced during the protection interview that he had difficulty recalling evidence because of his depression. However, the Authority did not accept this explanation as there was no medical evidence to support it (CB 119, [13]).12. The Authority then turned to the inconsistencies it had identified in the applicant’s evidence. The Authority found that the applicant changed his evidence in relation to the 2004 attack in response to the delegate’s concerns and was not recounting a true event (CB 120, [17]). The Authority found that the applicant’s account of his employment was also inconsistent and on that basis did not accept as credible that he was without income or unemployed for 8 years prior to his departure from Nepal (CB 120, [20]).13. The Authority also found concerning the applicant’s failure at the arrival interview to raise the claim that he was attacked. The omissions and inconsistencies reinforced the Authority’s view that the applicant was not recounting true events (CB 121, [21]).14. The Authority observed that police clearance notes demonstrated that the applicant did not have an adverse record (CB 121, [23]). It had regard to the 1997 election identity card provided by the applicant, but noted that this was inconsistent with the applicant’s claims and did not appear on official letterhead or have any security features. In those circumstances, it placed little weight on this document (CB 121, [24]).15. Turning to the letter from the “Association of Sufferers from the Maoist Nepal”, the Authority noted this letter was dated after the applicant’s arrival in Australia, which led it to believe that it was obtained to enhance the applicant’s protection claims. The letter was also inconsistent with the applicant’s evidence. While the Authority placed little weight on the inconsistencies in the date of the applicant’s departure from Nepal, there were further inconsistencies in the letter and in those circumstances, and noting the prevalence of fraudulent documents, the Authority placed no weight on the letter (CB 121, [25]).The Authority accepted the following claims:(a) the applicant had an interest in politics and was employed at the government district committee until 2003 (CB 122, [27]);(b) he might have moved from Begam to Kathmandu in 2004/2005 when his job was dissolved by the government (CB 122, [28]);(c) the applicant’s political affiliations changed and he now supported the Democratic Party and not the Royalists (CB 122, [28]); and(d) he might have attended a protest (CB 123, [33]).17. The Authority otherwise rejected the applicant’s claims relating to attacks (CB 122, [29]), threats or targeting by Maoists in Kathmandu (CB 122, [30]), detention, arrests or injury during protests (CB 122, [32]), that he was a high profile supporter of the King (CB 123, [33]), or that he was unemployed or hiding to avoid harm (CB 123, [34]). The Authority concluded that the applicant fabricated his claims of threats and attacks and did not accept that he faced any harm from Maoists or other political parties or opposition groups (CB 123, [38]).18. The Authority did not accept that the applicant faced any harm as a result of his past pro Monarchy support or political affiliations (CB 124, [39]). Nor did it accept that the applicant would face a real chance of harm from Maoists or other groups or that he would be viewed as a spy or traitor. The Authority concluded that the applicant did not face a real chance of harm on the basis of “any reasons claimed or at all” (CB 124, [43]).19. The Authority therefore found that the applicant did not meet the definition of refugee in s 5H(1) and thus did not satisfy s 36(2)(a) of the Act (CB 124, [44]).20. The Authority also rejected the applicant’s claim for complementary protection under s 36(2)(aa) on the basis that there was no real risk that he would suffer significant harm if he were returned to Nepal (CB 125, [48]).”