Director of Public Prosecutions v Ali

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No 3793 of 2008

DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS FOR VICTORIA

Appellant

v

KHODI ALI

First Respondent

and

DOUNIA ALI

Second Respondent

---

JUDGES:

MAXWELL P, WEINBERG JA and KYROU AJA

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

11 May 2009

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

26 June 2009

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2009] VSCA 162

JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM:

[2008] VSC 167 (Smith J)

---

CRIMINAL LAW – Confiscation – Restraining order over property – Order lapsed following acquittal – Conviction of co-accused – Status of property as ‘tainted property’ established – Whether DPP can make fresh application for restraining order over same property – Whether DPP can rely on ‘reasonable suspicion’ when status of property as ‘tainted property’ already established – No bar to fresh application on that ground – Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic), ss 16, 18, 20, 24, 27, 37 and 38.

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – Statement of purposes – Statutory language clear and unambiguous – Whether open to court to read in words of limitation – Proposed limitation contrary to stated legislative purpose – Presumption against statutory interference with property rights – Whether applicable – Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic), s 35(a).

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors

For the Appellant

For the First Respondent

No appearance for the Second Respondent

Mr S G O’Bryan SC with
Dr P T Vout

Mr C G Juebner

Solicitor for Public Prosecutions

Victoria Legal Aid

MAXWELL P
WEINBERG JA
KYROU AJA:

Introduction and summary

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Trial Division refusing to make a restraining order over the rural property of the first respondent (‘KA’) at Knowsley (‘property’) and $6,500 cash seized from his home in Brunswick (‘cash’).[1] 

    [1]DPP v Ali [2008] VSC 167 (‘Reasons’).

  1. The unsuccessful application had been made by the appellant, the Director of Public Prosecutions (‘DPP’), under s 16(2)(a) of the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic) (‘Act’). That provision permits an application for a restraining order to be made where ‘a member of the police force suspects on reasonable grounds that the property is tainted property in relation to a Schedule 2 offence’.

  1. KA is the registered proprietor of the property and had possession of the cash.  The second respondent (‘DA’) is his wife. 

  1. The DPP had previously obtained a restraining order over the property when KA and three others were charged with conspiracy to traffick a commercial quantity of methylamphetamine, which is a Schedule 2 offence under the Act. That restraining order lapsed when KA was acquitted by direction following a ‘no case’ submission. The co-accused were convicted of another Schedule 2 offence, namely conspiracy to traffick a large commercial quantity of methylamphetamine. The drug was manufactured at the property.

  1. The trial judge decided that it was not open to the DPP to apply for a new restraining order in the circumstances of this case. He refused the application for three main reasons. First, s 16(2)(a) of the Act only applies prior to charges being laid. Secondly,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Director of Public Prosecutions v Ali and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] VSCA 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Director of Public Prosecutions v Ali, the Director of Public Prosecutions sought a restraining order over property, following an acquittal of the defendant. The legal issues were whether the Director of Public Prosecutions could make a fresh application for a restraining order over the same property and whether they could rely on a ‘reasonable suspicion’ when the status of the property as ‘tainted property’ had already been established. The court held that there was no bar to a fresh application on that ground and that the Director of Public Prosecutions could rely on a ‘reasonable suspicion’ when making a fresh application for a restraining order.

The court interpreted the relevant statutory language as clear and unambiguous, and found that it was not open to the court to read in words of limitation. The court also held that a proposed limitation would be contrary to the stated legislative purpose and that the presumption against statutory interference with property rights was not applicable in this case. The court relied on the Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic), s 35(a) to support its decision. The court found that the statement of purposes was clear and unambiguous and that there was no room for the court to read in words of limitation.

The Director of Public Prosecutions was permitted to make a fresh application for a restraining order over the same property. The court found that the Director of Public Prosecutions could rely on a ‘reasonable suspicion’ when making a fresh application for a restraining order, even when the status of the property as ‘tainted property’ had already been established. The court’s decision was based on the clear and unambiguous language of the relevant legislation and the presumption against statutory interference with property rights. The final orders were that the Director of Public Prosecutions could make a fresh application for a restraining order over the same property and could rely on a ‘reasonable suspicion’ when making such an application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the confiscation of property under the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic) in the context of criminal proceedings. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) initially applied for a restraining order over certain property based on a reasonable suspicion that it was tainted property. The property in question was linked to criminal activities involving the respondent, Ali, and his co-accused. Following a trial, Ali was acquitted of the criminal charges, resulting in the restraining order lapsing. Subsequently, the co-accused was convicted of the same criminal offences, and the property was determined to be tainted property. The DPP then sought to make a fresh application for a restraining order over the same property, raising questions about the possibility of such an application and the legal basis for it.

The matter came before the court following an application by the DPP for a restraining order over property suspected to be tainted. Initially, the restraining order was put in place after Ali was charged with criminal offences. Following Ali's acquittal, the restraining order lapsed. Subsequently, the co-accused was convicted of the same criminal offences, leading to the property being confirmed as tainted. The DPP then made a fresh application for a restraining order over the property. The court had to determine the legal validity and basis for this fresh application, particularly in light of the property's established status as tainted.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Can the DPP make a fresh application for a restraining order over the same property after the original order lapsed following the acquittal of Ali?
2. Can the DPP rely on a 'reasonable suspicion' when the status of the property as 'tainted property' has already been established following the conviction of the co-accused?
3. Is there a bar to the DPP making a fresh application for a restraining order on the ground that the property status as 'tainted' is already established?

Held
1. The court held that the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) can make a fresh application for a restraining order over the same property even after the original order lapsed following the acquittal of Ali.
2. The court held that the DPP cannot rely on a 'reasonable suspicion' when the status of the property as 'tainted property' has already been established following the conviction of the co-accused.
3. The court held that there is no bar to the DPP making a fresh application for a restraining order on the ground that the property status as 'tainted' is already established.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court commenced by examining the statutory language of the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic) and found it to be clear and unambiguous. It noted the legislative purpose was to prevent the use of property derived from criminal activities and that there was no explicit limitation in the statute that would prevent the DPP from making a fresh application for a restraining order after an acquittal. The court applied the principle of statutory interpretation that courts should not read in words of limitation unless necessary and found that the proposed limitation would be contrary to the stated legislative purpose.

Furthermore, the court considered the status of the property as 'tainted property' which had already been established by the conviction of the co-accused. It held that the DPP cannot rely on a 'reasonable suspicion' when such status has been established. The court reasoned that the statutory language required a higher standard of proof than 'reasonable suspicion', which aligns with the broader legislative purpose of ensuring certainty and fairness in criminal proceedings.

In relation to the third issue, the court concluded that there was no bar to the DPP making a fresh application for a restraining order. The court found that the fact the property status as 'tainted' had already been established did not preclude the DPP from seeking a restraining order. It reasoned that the legislative framework permitted the DPP to act to protect public interests in the face of potential ongoing criminal activity. The court's reasoning highlighted the importance of statutory interpretation in criminal law and the need to balance legislative intent with procedural fairness. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the statutory language of the Confiscation Act 1997 (Vic) does not preclude the DPP from making a fresh application for a restraining order even if the property status as 'tainted' has already been established, and that the DPP must rely on a standard of proof higher than 'reasonable suspicion' when seeking such an order.