Development Watch Inc v Sunshine Coast Regional Council & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Development Watch Inc v Sunshine Coast Regional Council & Anor [2022] QCA 6

PARTIES:

DEVELOPMENT WATCH INC
(applicant)
v
SUNSHINE COAST REGIONAL COUNCIL
(first respondent)
SH COOLUM PTY LTD
ACN 146 376 972
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 8019 of 2020
DC No D166 of 2018

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave Planning and Environment Court Act

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court at Maroochydore – [2020] QPEC 25 (Kefford DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

9 February 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

10 March 2021

JUDGES: 

Morrison and McMurdo JJA and Burns J

ORDERS:

1.   Grant leave to appeal.

2.   Allow the appeal.

3.   Set aside the decision of the Planning and Environment Court made on 15 June 2020 in Appeal No. D166 of 2018 to dismiss the appeal and to approve the development application, subject to conditions.

4.   The parties are directed to file and serve written submissions (not to exceed five pages) regarding:

a.   the terms on which each contends the case should be remitted to the Planning and Environment Court to be determined according to law; and

b.   the appropriate order as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – PLANNING SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS – QUEENSLAND – GENERALLY – where the primary judge constituting the Planning and Environment Court dismissed two submitter appeals against the respondent Council’s decision to approve an application for mixed use development in the Sunshine Coast region – where, under the relevant planning scheme, the height of buildings and structures in the proposed development was required to be consistent with the reasonable expectations of the local community – where, under the relevant planning scheme, regard was to be had to properly made community submissions about the proposed development – where there was a considerable number of properly made community submissions opposing the proposed development on grounds including the height of the buildings and structures in the proposed development – whether the primary judge erred in law by failing to have proper regard to the community submissions opposing the development because of the proposed height of buildings and structures – whether the judge erred in law by failing to find what the reasonable expectations of the local community were regarding the height of buildings and structures in the proposed development – where the relevant planning scheme had been amended by the time of the appeal to the Planning and Environment Court – whether the primary judge erred in law by deciding not to consider the version of the planning scheme current at the time of the appeal

Planning Act 2016 (Qld), s 45(2), s 60(3), s 63, s 64, s 311
Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld), s 43, s 45, s 47
Planning Regulation 2017 (Qld), reg 31(1)(f), reg 31(1)(g)
Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld)

Abeleda v Brisbane City Council (2020) 6 QR 441; [2020] QCA 257, cited
Acland Pastoral Co Pty Ltd v Rosalie Shire Council [2008] QPELR 342; [2007]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Development Watch Inc v Sunshine Coast Regional Council & An... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCA 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Development Watch Inc appealed against the Sunshine Coast Regional Council's decision to approve a mixed-use development application in the Sunshine Coast region. The primary judge dismissed the appeal and approved the development application, determining that the proposed development complied with the relevant planning scheme and that the height of the buildings and structures was consistent with the reasonable expectations of the local community. The appeal was brought by Development Watch, which had previously submitted objections to the development on the grounds that the height of the buildings and structures in the proposed development did not align with the reasonable expectations of the local community.

The legal issues in this case revolved around whether the primary judge erred in law by failing to have proper regard to the community submissions opposing the development due to the height of buildings and structures, and whether the judge erred in law by not finding what the reasonable expectations of the local community were regarding the height of buildings and structures in the proposed development. Another issue was whether the primary judge erred in law by deciding not to consider the version of the planning scheme current at the time of the appeal.

The court found that the primary judge did indeed err in law by not properly considering the community submissions opposing the development on the grounds of the proposed height of buildings and structures, and by not determining what the reasonable expectations of the local community were regarding the height of buildings and structures in the proposed development. The court also found that the primary judge erred in law by not considering the version of the planning scheme current at the time of the appeal. Consequently, the judgment below was affected by these errors of law, which could have materially affected the decision at first instance.

The court granted leave to appeal, allowed the appeal, set aside the decision of the Planning and Environment Court, and directed the parties to file and serve written submissions regarding the terms on which they contend the case should be remitted to the Planning and Environment Court to be determined according to law and the appropriate order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Grant leave to appeal.

2. Allow the appeal.

3. Set aside the decision of the Planning and Environment Court made on 15 June 2020 in Appeal No. D166 of 2018 to dismiss the appeal and to approve the development application, subject to conditions.

4. The parties are directed to file and serve written submissions (not to exceed five pages) regarding:

a. the terms on which each contends the case should be remitted to the Planning and Environment Court to be determined according to law; and

b. the appropriate order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the course of dismissing appeals brought by Development Watch and another submitter, and approving the development application, the learned primary judge determined that the proposed development complied with the code and, of importance to this application for leave to appeal, her Honour was satisfied that the height of the proposed buildings and structures was consistent with the reasonable expectations of the local community. Of relevance also to the leave application was her Honour’s finding that there was a planning need for the development. By the proposed appeal, Development Watch seeks to argue that her Honour’s conclusions in both respects were affected by errors of law warranting this Court’s intervention.Background The parcel of land that is the subject of the development application is located between David Low Way and Yaroomba Beach, a couple of kilometres from Coolum Beach. It occupies 18.5 hectares and was once part of the land holdings associated with the resort known as the Hyatt Regency Resort and, more recently, as the Palmer Coolum Resort. The land has a history of planning approvals dating back to the 1980s. Of particular importance to this application was a preliminary approval granted by the first respondent, Sunshine Coast Regional Council, in February 2007 which for ease of reference I shall refer to as the 2007 Approval. It had the effect of varying the then current planning scheme to establish the Coolum Hyatt Integrated Resort and Residential Community and it was in force when the subject development application was lodged. That remained the position at the time when the appeal was heard in the court below. The development application was lodged with the Council on 4 May 2017 on behalf of the owner, being the second respondent to this application, SH Coolum Pty Ltd. Public notification took place between November of that year and January of the next and over 12,000 submissions were received. In response to those submissions, a notice of change of development application was lodged with the Council on behalf of SH Coolum that significantly reduced the residential density under the proposal. Otherwise, it was planned that the land be developed over five stages, with the first stage involving the construction of a five-star resort incorporating a hotel, a shopping centre, multiple dwellings and associated facilities. These uses were proposed to be accommodated in a number of buildings, between five and seven storeys in height. Stages 2 to 5 were not laid out in detail but approval was sought to vary the effect of the categorising instrument[7] so that future applications to develop the balance of the land for a mix of residential dwellings (including houses and dual occupancy dwellings at two storeys in height and multiple dwelling units in buildings up to four storeys in height) would not be subject to the public notification process.[7]As to which, see below at paragraph [19]. The Council approved the application on 21 June 2018. As part of that approval, preliminary approval was granted for a material change of use to establish the Yaroomba Beach Master Plan along with development permits for Stage 1 by which a material change of use in the form of a 220-room hotel, shopping centre, 148 dwellings or places of short-term accommodation, an educational establishment, community use amenities and a utility installation were authorised as well as the reconfiguration of a lot.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

More recently, in Gerlach v Clifton Bricks Pty Ltd,[72] Gaudron, McHugh and Hayne JJ explained:“In the course of a trial, and even before the trial commences, interlocutory orders may be made which affect the substantive rights of the parties. Rulings that are made in the course of trial about which evidence will be admitted are an obvious example. To adopt a rule that precluded challenging any interlocutory order except by an appeal against that order would provoke unnecessary multiplication and fragmentation of proceedings.”[73] [Emphasis added][72]Gerlach v Clifton Bricks Pty Ltd (2002) 209 CLR 478.[73]Gerlach v Clifton Bricks Pty Ltd (2002) 209 CLR 478, [4]. And see Menz v Wagga Wagga Show Society Inc [2020] NSWCA 65, [103]. It follows that, even if on case management grounds it was correct to require Development Watch to seek leave to add Version 18 as an issue to be considered in the court below, and then rule against it in that application, that ruling could be challenged, as it has been, in this Court. It is however unnecessary to determine that challenge because of the view I have taken that Version 18 was sufficiently raised as a contextual issue from the start of the hearing. Proposed Ground 3 – the finding that there was a planning need for the development The primary judge found that there was a planning need for both the hotel and residential components of the proposed development.[74] When doing so, her Honour rejected the evidence of the economist called on behalf of Development Watch, Mr Brown, and preferred instead the evidence of the economists called on behalf of the Council (Mr Ganly) and SH Coolum (Mr Duane). In written argument, Development Watch submitted that her Honour’s finding about the existence of need was in error because SH Coolum not only failed to adduce in evidence any quantitative analysis of need but, as the proponent of the development, it was obliged to do that in order to discharge its onus of proof. Thus, as part of this proposed ground of appeal, it was contended that her Honour misapplied the onus of proof.[74]Applying the principles summarised by Wilson SC DCJ (as his Honour then was) in Isgro v Gold Coast City Council [2003] QPELR 414, [20]–[30]. There is no substance to this proposed ground of appeal, and this no doubt explains why it was not supported by any oral argument at the hearing. The primary judge correctly found that the question whether there was a planning need for a proposed development was a question of fact to be determined having regard to all of the evidence in the case of relevance to that issue. In carrying out that exercise, the feature that her Honour preferred one body of opinion over another was unremarkable. Likewise, her Honour’s consideration of the evidence on this topic (including, but by no means limited to, the evidence of the three economists) was not only regular and appropriate, it left no room for thinking that the onus of proof was either misunderstood or misapplied.Conclusion and orders

Decision

Reasons for decision

There is no substance to this proposed ground of appeal, and this no doubt explains why it was not supported by any oral argument at the hearing. The primary judge correctly found that the question whether there was a planning need for a proposed development was a question of fact to be determined having regard to all of the evidence in the case of relevance to that issue. In carrying out that exercise, the feature that her Honour preferred one body of opinion over another was unremarkable. Likewise, her Honour’s consideration of the evidence on this topic (including, but by no means limited to, the evidence of the three economists) was not only regular and appropriate, it left no room for thinking that the onus of proof was either misunderstood or misapplied.Conclusion and orders The judgment below was affected by the three errors of law identified above.[75] Going as each did to a central question in the case below, that is to say, whether the proposed development complied with the Height of buildings and structures overlay code, they could have materially affected the decision at first instance, and the illustration earlier provided[76] highlights why that must be so.[75]At [45], [47] and [51].[76]At [51]. Leave to appeal should accordingly be granted, the appeal allowed, the decision below set aside and the case remitted under s 65 of the Planning and Environment Court Act2016 (Qld) to be determined according to law. As to that, the parties should have leave to make brief written submissions on the terms of the remitter. On one view, the issues determined by this appeal are within short compass when compared to the great bulk of the overall case determined in the court below, and none of which has been questioned in this Court. However, robust findings were made by the primary judge on the issues that have been successfully challenged and it may therefore be asking too much of her Honour to re-visit them. At the same time, the parties should be at liberty to advance submissions about the appropriate order for costs of the application for leave to appeal and the appeal in this Court. I would order as follows:1.Grant leave to appeal.2.Allow the appeal.3.Set aside the decision of the Planning and Environment Court made on 15 June 2020 in Appeal No. D166 of 2018 to dismiss the appeal and to approve the development application, subject to conditions.4.The parties are directed to file and serve written submissions (not to exceed five pages) regarding:a. the terms on which each contends the case should be remitted to the Planning and Environment Court to be determined according to law; andb. the appropriate order as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.