Clarry & Anor v Brisbane City Council & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Clarry & Anor v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2024] QCA 39

PARTIES:

DANIEL CLARRY AND SARAH CLARRY
(applicants)
v
BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL
(first respondent)
4005 PROPERTIES PTY LTD
ACN 624 827 943
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 973 of 2023
P & E Appeal No 2616 of 2021

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave Planning and Environment Court Act

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court at Brisbane – [2022] QPEC 49 (Everson DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

22 March 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 August 2023

JUDGES:

Mullins P and Bond and Flanagan JJA

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal refused.

2.   Costs reserved to be determined on the papers.

3.   Any submissions that the parties wish to make on costs must be made in writing within 14 days of the date on which the reasons for judgment are published and must not exceed two A4 pages.

CATCHWORDS:

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – PLANNING SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS – QUEENSLAND – GENERALLY – where the applicants reside next to the second respondent’s proposed development site – where the Council approved the second respondent’s development application for a material change of use for a multiple dwelling on the site – where the applicants appealed unsuccessfully against the Council’s decision to the Planning and Environment Court (P&E Court) – where the primary judge gave effect to the qualitative provisions in the relevant overall outcome and performance outcome in the neighbourhood plan code concerning the height of the proposed building in priority to the quantitative provisions of the planning scheme – whether the primary judge erred in the construction of the planning scheme

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – PLANNING SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS – QUEENSLAND – GENERALLY – where the applicants reside next to the second respondent’s proposed development site – where the Council approved the second respondent's application for the proposed development – where the applicants appealed against the Council’s decision to the P&E Court – where the height of the proposed development is six storeys and 4.7m higher than the existing four storey multiple dwelling on the site – where the primary judge rejected the submitters’ expectations that the building height on the site would be limited to two to three storeys or four storeys as unreasonable – whether the primary judge failed to have regard to the community expectations when carrying out the impact assessment of the development application

ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – PLANNING SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS – QUEENSLAND – GENERALLY – where the Council approved the second respondent's application for the proposed development – where the applicants appealed against the Council’s decision to the P&E Court – where the primary judge accepted evidence, and found, that there is a community need and economic need for the proposed development, if it were found that there was some non-compliance with the planning scheme – whether the primary judge erred in making a finding of fact that there was a community need and economic need for the proposed development

Planning Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clarry & Anor v Brisbane City Council & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QCA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Clarry & Anor v Brisbane City Council & Anor involved a dispute concerning the Brisbane City Council's approval of a development application for a material change of use on a site adjacent to the applicants' property. The applicants, Clarry and another, had appealed the Council's decision to the Planning and Environment Court (P&E Court), contending that the primary judge had erred in several respects, including the interpretation of the planning scheme, the consideration of community expectations, and the assessment of the development's compliance with the Sunshine Coast Planning Scheme 2014. The appeal focused on the height of the proposed six-storey building, which was 4.7 metres higher than the existing four-storey multiple dwelling on the site.

The legal issues before the court included whether the primary judge correctly interpreted the Neighbourhood Plan Code (NPC), Local Development Regulation for Sunshine Coast (LMDRZC), and Moreton Bay Development Control (MDC) by prioritising qualitative provisions over quantitative height restrictions, and whether the primary judge failed to adequately consider the community's reasonable expectations regarding building height. Another key issue was whether the primary judge properly assessed the community and economic need for the proposed development, even in the context of potential non-compliance with the planning scheme.

The court found that the primary judge did not err in giving effect to the qualitative provisions of the NPC in priority to the quantitative provisions of the planning scheme. It was concluded that the primary judge correctly determined that the community expectations regarding the building height were not reasonable, particularly in the absence of specific quantitative limits in the planning provisions. The court also found that the primary judge had adequately considered the community and economic need for the proposed development, noting the importance of such factors even if there was some non-compliance with the planning scheme. The appeal was dismissed, with the court finding no basis for the asserted errors.

LEAVE TO APPEAL REFUSED. COSTS RESERVED TO BE DETERMINED ON THE PAPERS. ANY SUBMISSIONS THAT THE PARTIES WISH TO MAKE ON COSTS MUST BE MADE IN WRITING WITHIN 14 DAYS OF THE DATE ON WHICH THE REASONS FOR JUDGMENT ARE PUBLISHED AND MUST NOT EXCEED TWO A4 PAGES.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal refused.

2. Costs reserved to be determined on the papers.

3. Any submissions that the parties wish to make on costs must be made in writing within 14 days of the date on which the reasons for judgment are published and must not exceed two A4 pages.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There was no error of law in the primary judge’s construction of the NPC, the LMDRZC and MDC in giving effect to the qualitative provisions of OO3m and PO1b in priority to AO1 and the other provisions that specify a height restriction for building on the site.The conclusion that the community expectations were not reasonable The second asserted error overlaps with the first asserted error to a large extent as it is based on [39] of the reasons and the conclusion that the community expectations were not reasonable because there were no quantitative limits when consideration was given to the purpose, overall outcomes and performance outcomes of NPC and that those provisions of the NPC apply to the extent of any inconsistency in terms of any quantitative measure giving rise to such expectations. In view of the rejection above of the first asserted error, the only aspect of the second asserted error that remains to be considered is whether the primary judge failed to have regard to the common material (the properly made submissions) and other relevant matters (the lay witness statements of the submitters) when carrying out the assessment of the development application. Development Watch was concerned with the assessment of a proposed development against the assessment benchmarks in the Sunshine Coast Planning Scheme 2014 which included the Height of building and structures overlay code. The relevant provision of that code set out its purpose and overall outcomes and noted that the purpose of the code would be achieved through three overall outcomes including “the height of the buildings and structures is consistent with the reasonable expectations of the local community” (the relevant overall outcome). The quality of reasonableness was an express provision in respect of community expectations in that code. Under the heading “Maximum height of buildings and structures” in the assessment criteria relating to those overall outcomes, performance outcome PO1 was stated to be that the “height of a building or structure does not exceed the maximum height specified on a Height of Buildings and Structures Overlay Map” and the predominant maximum height on that map for the local plan area was 8.5 metres. Even though the number of submissions by itself is never determinative of a planning issue, the significance of height as an issue in respect of the development under consideration in Development Watch was indicated by the receipt by the relevant Council of 11,666 properly made submissions. The passage from Development Watch at [43] extracted by the primary judge (at [37] of the reasons) set out the steps that it was found should have been followed by the primary judge in Development Watch in considering whether there was compliance with the relevant overall outcome. The appeal was successful in Development Watch as Burns J (with whom Morrison JA agreed) found at [45] that the primary judge did not make a finding as to what the expectations of the local community were about the height of buildings and structures before proceeding to consider the reasonableness of those expectations in light of the planning provisions applying to the subject land. It was stated in Development Watch at [43] that it was only after the reasonable expectations were identified that the issue raised by the relevant overall outcome could be addressed as to whether the height of the buildings and structures was consistent with the reasonable expectations of the local community. McMurdo JA also noted (at [6] of Development Watch) that what was required in considering the development’s compliance with the relevant overall outcome was an assessment of whether the buildings and structures proposed by the development would be within the reasonable expectations of the local community. McMurdo JA considered (at [7]) that the primary judge’s finding that the community should also reasonably expect a development may be approved if it has a height of greater than two storeys but complies with the character and amenity requirements of the planning scheme did not answer the question which the judge had to consider in respect of the relevant overall outcome of whether the height of the buildings and structures in that development exceeded the reasonable expectations of the community.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.