Brisbane City Council v YQ Property Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Brisbane City Council v YQ Property Pty Ltd [2020] QCA 253

PARTIES:

BRISBANE CITY COUNCIL
(applicant)
v
YQ PROPERTY PTY LTD
ACN 621 809 783
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 3757 of 2020
P & E Appeal No 1409 of 2019

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave Planning and Environment Court Act

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court at Brisbane – [2020] QPEC 2 (Everson DCJ)

DELIVERED ON:

17 November 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

27 August 2020

JUDGES:

Fraser and Morrison JJA and Henry J

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal refused.

2.   The applicant will pay the respondent’s costs of the application to be assessed on the standard basis if not agreed.

CATCHWORDS:

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – DEVELOPMENT CONTROL – MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY – GENERALLY – DISCRETION OF CONSENT AUTHORITY – where the respondent lodged a development application with the applicant Council to construct multiple townhouses in a low-density residential zone – where the application was properly made at a time where multiple townhouse developments were permitted in low-density residential zones under the Brisbane City Plan 2014 – where, after the conclusion of the hearing before the primary judge, but before judgment, the applicant Council resolved to amend the Brisbane City Plan 2014 to prohibit the development of multiple townhouse developments in low-density residential zones – where the learned primary judge allowed the respondent’s appeal and approved the development – where the applicant complains that the learned primary judge did not take the amendments into account as required by the principle in Coty (England) Pty Ltd v Sydney City Council (1957) 2 LGRA 117 – whether the learned primary judge properly considered the principle in Coty (England) Pty Ltd v Sydney City Council (1957) 2 LGRA 117 – whether the principle in Coty (England) Pty Ltd v Sydney City Council (1957) 2 LGRA 117 should be given determinative weight

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING – PLANNING SCHEMES AND INSTRUMENTS – QUEENSLAND – GENERALLY – where the development proposed by the respondent involved the removal of four native trees – where the learned primary judge characterised the four native trees as “unremarkable” – where the applicant Council complains that the learned primary judge’s description of the trees as “unremarkable” was made without evidence – where the applicant Council contends that the relevant provisions of the Biodiversity Overlay Code within the Brisbane City Plan 2014 should be interpreted to require the blanket protection of native trees – whether the learned trial judge erred by describing the trees as “unremarkable” – whether the learned trial judge erred by allowing the respondent’s appeal and approving the development notwithstanding the destruction of the four native trees

Planning Act 2016 (Qld), s 45, s 45(5)(a), s 45(5)(b), s 45(7), s 45(8), s 60, s 60(3)
Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld), s 46, s 63
Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) (repealed), s 326(1)(b)

Ashvan Investments Unit Trust v Brisbane…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Brisbane City Council v YQ Property Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QCA 253
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Brisbane City Council v YQ Property Pty Ltd, the Brisbane City Council appealed a decision of the primary judge in the Planning and Environment Court, which had approved YQ Property's development application for the construction of multiple townhouses in a low-density residential zone. The primary judge's approval was made despite the Council's subsequent resolution to amend the Brisbane City Plan 2014 to prohibit such developments in low-density residential zones. The Council argued that the primary judge had not properly considered the amendments and had wrongly approved the development.

The legal issues before the court were whether the primary judge had correctly applied the principle from Coty (England) Pty Ltd v Sydney City Council, which requires a consent authority to consider planning scheme amendments made after the hearing but before judgment, and whether this principle should have determinative weight. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the primary judge had erred in describing four native trees as "unremarkable" and in allowing the development despite the trees' removal, in contravention of the Biodiversity Areas Overlay Code within the Brisbane City Plan 2014.

The court found that the primary judge had properly exercised their discretion in approving the development, as the application was made within the permissible parameters of the then-current planning scheme. The court also held that the primary judge had not erred in describing the trees as "unremarkable" and had correctly balanced the need for development with the protection of the environment. The principle in Coty was considered, but the court determined that it did not compel a different outcome in this case. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

Accordingly, the orders of the court were that leave to appeal was refused and the applicant would pay the respondent's costs of the application to be assessed on the standard basis if not agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal refused.

2. The applicant will pay the respondent’s costs of the application to be assessed on the standard basis if not agreed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The application confronts the obstacle that the decision of the primary judge involved a reasoned exercise of discretionary decision-making, applying well settled principles. In its quest to avoid that obstacle, the Council ultimately attempted to deny the existence of any real discretion in respect of two aspects of decision-making below. The argument as to each is untenable. Leave to appeal should not be granted.Background YQ’s development application was properly made on 8 January 2019. It sought a development permit for a material change of use and building work involving the construction of multiple townhouses on four adjoining lots of residential land in Holland Park in a low-density residential zone. The Council refused the application on 17 April 2019. YQ appealed that decision to the Planning and Environment Court. The original proposal was to build 25 four-room townhouses on the site. That proposal appears to have been modified during the course of the appeal below, apparently after some intervention by the learned primary judge,[1] to a plan to build 23 four-room dwellings.[1]Applicant’s Amended Outline of Argument, [7]. A consequence of the modification was that three “significant trees” were retained instead of one “significant tree”. It remained contentious, in light of the relevant Biodiversity Areas Overlay Code, that four other significant trees would need to be removed in order for the development to proceed. The other contentious issue, relevantly to the present application, was the significance of foreshadowed changes to the applicable planning scheme. On 4 September 2018, prior to the lodgement of YQ’s development application, the Council resolved to amend its city plan to remove provisions allowing multiple dwellings in low residential zones. Nonetheless the planning scheme which applied for the purposes of the appeal before the primary judge remained version 13.00/2018 of the Brisbane City Plan 2014. It was the relevant scheme in force at the time YQ Property made its application on 8 January 2019.[2] The hearing before the learned primary judge concluded on 5 February 2020, with judgment reserved. Soon after the conclusion of the hearing, on 11 February 2020, the Council resolved to adopt the “Major H Planning Scheme Amendment”, also known as “Amendment Package H”. That amendment, once made, would have the effect of prohibiting multi-unit dwellings from being built in low-density residential zones. This was a relevant consideration in the appeal, pursuant to the so-called Coty principle, prompting the learned primary judge to entertain further written submissions.[2]YQ Property Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2020] QPEC 2, [14]. The learned primary judge recognised, and the applicant admits, that subsequent amendments to the “biodiversity overlay mapping” were insignificant: Applicant’s Amended Outline of Argument, [3]. In the upshot, despite the need for the removal of the trees and despite the resolution amending the planning scheme, the learned primary judge reasoned that the appeal should be allowed (subject to the imposition of appropriate lawful conditions).The application for leave

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The extreme submission of the Council is so obviously at odds with the statutory scheme as to be untenable.Conclusion While these reasons have necessarily ventilated the absence of merit in what the applicant would seek to advance if leave were granted this is not a case in which I would on that account grant leave but refuse the application. The applicant’s argument about the application of the Coty principle and the Biodiversity Areas Overlay Code complained of some features of the primary judge’s reasoning which clearly did not involve errors of law. This left the applicant in each instance relying upon extreme arguments to the effect that the Coty principle and the Biodiversity Areas Overlay Code are of inevitably determinative consequence when it was clear that could not be correct. Applications which are unable to advance a tenable ground of error or mistake in law ought not be granted leave. I would order:1. Leave to appeal refused.2. The applicant will pay the respondent’s costs of the application to be assessed on the standard basis if not agreed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established