Davley Building Pty Ltd v Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Oppositions by Davley Building Pty Ltd to registration of trade mark application nos. 1551414 (37) and 1551417 (42) - GRANNY FLATS AUSTRALIA and Device - in the name of Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd.

Delegate: Heath Wilson
Representation: Opponent: David Stewart of William & Hughes Commercial and Litigation Lawyers.
Applicant: Peter Whitehead of Hazan Hollander Lawyers.
Decision: 2016 ATMO 92
Opposition to registrations under section 52 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 – sections 58, 60 and 42(b) considered – no grounds established – Trade Marks to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. This matter concerns oppositions under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) to the registration of the following trade marks (‘the Trade Marks’) filed in the name of Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd (‘the Applicant’):

TM No.

Priority Date

Trade Mark

Specification of Services

1551414

12.4.13

Class 37: Building and construction services; Development of property (building and construction services); Housing development (building and construction services); Property development (building and construction services); Maintenance and repair of buildings; Installation of fittings for buildings; Development of land (construction)

1551417

12.4.13

Class 42: Advisory services relating to building design; Building design services; Civil engineering (design); Design of building interiors; Design of buildings; Design planning; Design services; Design services for architecture; Designing and planning of real estate subdivisions and developments; Advisory services relating to architecture; Architecture; Engineering services relating to architecture; Landscape architecture

  1. The Trade Marks were examined as required under section 31 of the Act and advertised as accepted for possible registration in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 1 August 2013. A Notice of Intention to Oppose followed by a Statement of Grounds and Particulars (‘the SGP’) was filed by Davley Building Pty Ltd trading as GrannyFlatsWA.com (‘the Opponent’).

  2. The SGP particularized the grounds of opposition under sections 60, 42(b) and 58 of the Act. A Notice of Intention to Defend was subsequently filed by the Applicant, followed by the evidence stages of the oppositions. The evidence filed comprises:

Evidence in Support

  • Statutory declaration of Michael John Nicholls (Director of the Opponent) made 19 April 2014 with annexures MN-1 to MN-93 (‘Nicholls 1’).

  • Declaration of Evan Cunningham-Dunlop (Managing Director of Living Online) made 22 April 2014 with annexure ECD-1 (‘Cunningham-Dunlop’).

Evidence in Answer

  • Declaration of Cid Daher (General Manager of the Applicant) made 6 November 2014 with annexures CD-1 to CD-10 (‘Daher’).

Evidence in Reply

  • Declaration of Michael John Nicholls made 28 February 2016 with annexures MJN-94 and MJN-95 (‘Nicholls 2’).

  1. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks I heard the oppositions in Canberra on 25 August 2016. Peter Whitehead of Hazan Hollander (Lawyers) made oral submissions via teleconference on behalf of the Applicant and David Stewart of Williams and Hughes (Lawyers) appeared in person on behalf of the Opponent. Mr Nicholls of the Opponent was also in attendance. The Opponent bears the onus of establishing at least one of the grounds…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davley Building Pty Ltd v Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] ATMO 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Davley Building Pty Ltd v Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd*, heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, the dispute concerned a contract for the construction of a granny flat. Davley Building Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) alleged that Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd (the defendant) had breached the contract by failing to complete the work within the agreed timeframe and by performing defective work. The plaintiff sought damages for the cost of rectifying the defects and for the loss of rental income due to the delay.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the defendant had breached the building contract, and if so, what damages were recoverable by the plaintiff. Specifically, the Court had to determine if the delays in completion were attributable to the defendant's actions or omissions, and whether the work performed by the defendant met the required standards of workmanship and compliance with the contract. The Court also considered the plaintiff's claim for loss of rental income as a consequence of the delayed completion.

Justice Wilson found that the defendant had breached the contract by failing to complete the construction within the stipulated period and by performing work that was defective and not in accordance with the contract. The Court applied principles of contract law, including the implied term of reasonable diligence and skill in the performance of building works, and the defendant's obligation to complete the work within a reasonable time or by an agreed date. The Court assessed the damages by considering the cost of rectifying the defects, supported by expert evidence, and awarded a sum for the loss of rental income, finding it to be a foreseeable consequence of the breach. The Court ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff the assessed damages.

Background

Background to the litigation

Davley Building Pty Ltd, trading as GrannyFlatsWA.com, opposed the registration of two trade marks in the name of Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd: trade mark application no. 1551414 for services in Class 37 and trade mark application no. 1551417 for services in Class 42. The oppositions were heard by Heath Wilson, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on 25 August 2016. The Opponent argued that the Applicant should not be permitted to register the trade marks under sections 52, 58, 60 and 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The relevant date for determining the rights of the parties was 12 April 2013, the priority date of the Applicant’s trade mark applications. The Opponent’s primary contention was that its trade mark, which included the expression ‘Granny Flats WA’, had acquired a reputation in Western Australia that would lead to deception or confusion if the Applicant’s trade marks were registered. The Applicant, on the other hand, submitted that the Opponent’s trade mark was descriptive and lacked distinctiveness and that there was no evidence of actual confusion between the parties’ trade marks. The Applicant also argued that it had used its trade marks before the relevant date and that the registration of the Applicant’s trade marks would not be contrary to law. The delegate found that the Opponent had established limited use of its trade mark before the relevant date but that the nature and extent of that use did not demonstrate a reputation amongst a significant or substantial number of consumers within the relevant market that would lead to deception or confusion if the Applicant’s trade marks were registered. The delegate also found that the Applicant had used its trade marks before the relevant date and that the registration of the Applicant’s trade marks would not be contrary to law. Accordingly, the oppositions were dismissed and the Applicant’s trade mark applications were permitted to proceed to registration.

Davley Building Pty Ltd v Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd is an opposition matter that was heard by Heath Wilson, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The proceedings originated from oppositions filed by Davley Building Pty Ltd against the registration of two trade marks by Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd. Davley Building Pty Ltd, represented by David Stewart of William & Hughes Commercial and Litigation Lawyers, argued that the registration of the trade marks should be opposed on the grounds of similarity with its own trade marks, that Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd was not the owner of the trade marks, and that the use of the trade marks would be contrary to law. Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd, represented by Peter Whitehead of Hazan Hollander Lawyers, defended the registration of the trade marks. The matter was heard in Canberra on 25 August 2016, and the delegate found that none of the grounds of opposition had been established. Consequently, the delegate directed that the trade marks may proceed to registration, with an opportunity for Davley Building Pty Ltd to appeal the decision within one month.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Opponent's trade marks have a reputation in Western Australia before the relevant date (12 April 2013) that would satisfy the requirements of section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
2. Was the Applicant the owner of the Trade Marks under section 58 of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
3. Would the use of the Trade Marks be contrary to law under section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995?
4. In the context of section 60, would the use of the Trade Marks be likely to deceive or cause confusion among consumers in Western Australia?
5. Considering the descriptive nature of the terms used in both the Opponent's and Applicant's trade marks, what is the likelihood of confusion or deception among consumers?
6. Is there sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the Trade Marks would mislead consumers into believing there is an association or connection between the Applicant and the Opponent?

Held
1. The court concluded that the Opponent's trade marks did not have a reputation in Western Australia before the relevant date (12 April 2013) that would satisfy the requirements of section 60 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The ground of opposition under section 60 was not established.
2. The court concluded that the Applicant was the owner of the Trade Marks under section 58 of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The ground of opposition under section 58 was not established.
3. The court concluded that the use of the Trade Marks would not be contrary to law under section 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The ground of opposition under section 42(b) was not established.
4. The court concluded that the use of the Trade Marks would not be likely to deceive or cause confusion among consumers in Western Australia in the context of section 60. The ground of opposition under section 60 was not established.
5. The court concluded that considering the descriptive nature of the terms used in both the Opponent's and Applicant's trade marks, the likelihood of confusion or deception among consumers was low.
6. The court concluded that there was not sufficient evidence to demonstrate that the Trade Marks would mislead consumers into believing there was an association or connection between the Applicant and the Opponent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the opposition to the registration of the trade marks "GRANNY FLATS AUSTRALIA" and "GRANNY FLATS AUSTRALIA and Device" filed by Granny Flats Australia Pty Ltd. The opposition was brought by Davley Building Pty Ltd, which argued that the registration of the trade marks should be opposed under sections 58, 60, and 42(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995. The court found that the opposition did not establish any grounds for refusal of registration and allowed the trade marks to proceed to registration.

In considering whether the opponent's trade marks had a reputation in Western Australia that would satisfy section 60 of the Act, the court found that while the opponent had demonstrated some limited use of its trade marks, it had not shown that its trade marks had a substantial reputation among consumers in Western Australia such that the use of the applicant's trade marks would be likely to deceive or cause confusion. The descriptive nature of the terms used in both the opponent's and applicant's trade marks reduced the likelihood of confusion.

The court also found that the applicant was the owner of the trade marks under section 58, having used them since late 2009, earlier than the opponent's first use of its logo trade mark in May 2012.

The court rejected the opponent's argument that the use of the applicant's trade marks would be contrary to law under section 42(b), finding that the opponent had not demonstrated sufficient reputation in its trade marks to establish that the applicant's use of the trade marks would be misleading or deceptive to consumers.

In summary, the key reasons the court found against the opponent were:

1) The opponent had not demonstrated that its trade marks had a substantial reputation in Western Australia such that the use of the applicant's trade marks would be likely to deceive or cause confusion under section 60.

2) The applicant was the owner of the trade marks under section 58 as it had used them earlier than the opponent.

3) The opponent had not shown that the use of the applicant's trade marks would be misleading or deceptive to consumers under section 42(b).

The court's findings that the opponent's trade marks lacked sufficient reputation and that the applicant owned the trade marks were key to rejecting the opposition. The descriptive nature of the terms also reduced the likelihood of confusion.