FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
CTF21 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FedCFamC2G 309
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CTF21 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2023] FedCFamC2G 309
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of CTF21 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involved an applicant, CTF21, whose visa application was denied by a delegate on the basis that he did not meet the criteria for a protection visa under the Migration Act 1958. The decision was subsequently reviewed by the Migration Review Tribunal (the Authority), which affirmed the delegate’s decision. The applicant sought judicial review of the Authority’s decision in the Federal Court of Australia. The primary issue before the Court was whether the Authority erred in law or failed to consider relevant material in making its decision to affirm the delegate’s refusal of the visa application.
The Court found that the Authority had considered the relevant material and applied the correct legal standards in affirming the delegate’s decision. The Authority had properly assessed the credibility of the applicant’s claims and had found that they were not credible. The Court also found that the Authority had properly considered the country information provided by the applicant and had correctly determined that it did not support the applicant’s claims. The Court further found that the Authority had properly assessed the risk of harm to the applicant if returned to Sri Lanka and had determined that the applicant did not face a real chance of serious harm. The Court held that the Authority’s decision was not flawed by any error of law or failure to consider relevant material. The Court dismissed the applicant’s appeal and affirmed the decision of the Authority.
The Court found that the Authority had considered the relevant material and applied the correct legal standards in affirming the delegate’s decision. The Authority had properly assessed the credibility of the applicant’s claims and had found that they were not credible. The Court also found that the Authority had properly considered the country information provided by the applicant and had correctly determined that it did not support the applicant’s claims. The Court further found that the Authority had properly assessed the risk of harm to the applicant if returned to Sri Lanka and had determined that the applicant did not face a real chance of serious harm. The Court held that the Authority’s decision was not flawed by any error of law or failure to consider relevant material. The Court dismissed the applicant’s appeal and affirmed the decision of the Authority.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
On 9 August 2017, the delegate refused the visa application (CB 164 to 182) and, on 11 August 2017, the matter was referred to the Authority for review (CB 183 to 185). The Authority’s decision On 29 August 2017, the applicant provided submissions to the Authority. Among other things, he commented on the delegate’s credibility findings and referred to country information that had not been before the delegate (CB 186 to 192). On 6 June 2018, the Authority affirmed the delegate’s decision (CB 197 to 225). In making its decision, the Authority: (a)in respect of the submissions provided on 29 August 2017, found that it could: (1) consider submissions about the delegate’s credibility findings as they were not “new information” (198 at [4]) and (2) not consider the country information as it was not satisfied that “the … report could not have been provided prior to the delegate’s decision”, the report “constitutes personal information” or “there are exceptional circumstances to justify” considering the report (CB 198 to 199 at [5]);(b)accepted: (1) “as credible” that the Applicant was forced to leave his home when the war intensified; and (2) “as plausible” that his family’s land was confiscated around 1989 or 1990 (CB 202 at [11]); (c)considered that the claims made by the applicant in his entry interview were “substantially different to subsequent claims”, and was not satisfied that his explanation was credible for not disclosing in his entry interview his “LTTE involvement, including the length of time he was trained by and served with the LTTE” (CB 203 at [13]); (d)noted “gaps in [the applicant’s] written statement of claims about his experience with the LTTE”, and was not satisfied that the evidence he gave at interview with the delegate “supports his claims of having been forcibly recruited by the LTTE, having been trained to fight with the LTTE, and of being engaged in a military capacity for the LTTE in the last phase of the war” (CB 203 at [13]);(e)was not satisfied that the applicant was “forcibly recruited by the LTTE, or that he was trained to fight and engaged in any military capacity for the LTTE” (CB 203 at [14] and 208 at [24]) for the following reasons:(i)it did “not consider plausible that, having been placed on the fighting line in a combat zone, he could have avoided using his weapon by withdrawing from fighting without any adverse consequences” and considered “unrealistic” his claim that there was “weak leadership resulting in withdrawal ‘every time there was action’” (CB 204 at [15]); (ii)considered it “highly implausible that the [applicant] would have been able to escape without any injury if he in fact was engaged in any military capacity” at the time of heavy fighting on the morning of 15 May 2009 and had “serious doubts about the veracity of the [applicant’s] claim that he and the 2 girls he was with at the time were able to escape from the fighting line as they feared the intensity of the war and that they were able to find shelter in the house of an LTTE soldier at that time” (CB 204 to 205 at [16]); (iii)did “not consider the [applicant’s] account of having been forcibly recruited, trained and engaged in a military capacity by LTTE during the final months of the civil war to be credible” and, further, was “not convinced that the [applicant] was engaged in any military capacity for the LTTE”. The Authority also considered that if he had “encountered SLA on the front line … it is more likely he would have been taken as a prisoner of war rather than as a displaced person” (CB 205 at [17]); (iv)accepted that the applicant’s father was killed as claimed (CB 206 at 18); (v)having regard to country information, accepted as plausible that the applicant was placed in “an IDP” camp with other civilians at the end of the war” (CB 206 at [19]); (vi)in contrast to what the applicant claimed, it did “not consider it plausible that the applicant would have been able to avoid being placed in the LTTE group [at the camp] if there were any suspicions at that time that he was involved in the LTTE” (CB 206 at [20]); and (vii)if the applicant was suspected of having fought for the LTTE: (1) he would not have been able to avoid “being placed with the LTTE group for any reason” at the “Puliyankulam camp” (CB 207 at [22] and 208 at [24]) or “further detention and interrogation at his IDP camp at Menik farm”; (2) he would not have been able to escape from the Menik farm camp (CB 208 at [24]); and (3) it is likely he would have been “held in administrative detention under the Prevention of Terrorism Act” (CB 208 at [24]); (f)accepted the applicant travelled to India in July 2009 and returned to Sri Lanka in June 2012 without incident but found that, if he was “a person of any adverse interest to authorities on account of any LTTE connections”, it was not plausible that he would have been able to obtain a passport or leave the airport in Sri Lanka at that time, or “bribe his way out of the airport”. The Authority was also not satisfied that he “was of any adverse interest to authorities upon his return to Sri Lanka in 2012 because of any suspected LTTE connections” (CB 209 to 210 at [26] to [28]); (g)found that the applicant was not a person of any adverse interest to the Sri Lankan authorities on his return to Sri Lanka in 2012 (CB 210 at [29]) . While it accepted his two uncles “were suspected of being in the LTTE and targeted as claimed”, it was satisfied that he was not a person of interest to authorities (CB 210 to 211 at [30]); (h)did not accept that the CID or any Sri Lankan authorities “came to his house in search of him” after he left Sri Lanka in 2012 (CB 212 at [32]); (i)was not prepared to accept the applicant’s “very general claim of imputed family profile” in respect of two of his father’s sisters having been “caught by the army” (CB 212 at [33]); (j)was not satisfied that the applicant “is or would be perceived to be active in post-conflict Tamil separatism or that he would be identified as a person who constitutes a threat to the Sri Lankan state” (CB 213 at [36]) and, given country information does not support there being “systemic targeting of the Tamil population in general”, was not satisfied he “has a profile that would attract any adverse attention from the Sri Lankan authorities now or in the reasonably foreseeable future” (CB 214 at [40]);(k)was not satisfied that the applicant faces a real chance of serious harm “on the basis of his Tamil ethnicity, or because of his residence in a former LTTE controlled area in the North, or because of his male gender or his age as a young able-bodied Tamil male, or because of his experiences in Sri Lanka as the civil war was ending, or because he had fled to and lived in India after the war ended or any combination of these factors” and was not satisfied he has a profile that “would be considered a threat to the integrity of the Sri Lankan state or would otherwise be of concern to the Sri Lankan authorities” (CB 216 at [46]); (l)was not satisfied “there is a real chance of harm to the applicant arising because he is returned to Sri Lanka from Australia which is perceived to be a wealthy country” (CB 216 at [47]); (m)in respect of the applicant returning to Sri Lanka as a failed asylum seeker, it was not satisfied that he has “a profile that would place him at risk of mistreatment upon return to Sri Lanka or that he is a person of any adverse interest to authorities” (CB 218 at [51]) for reasons including because: (1) he does not have a profile as posing a credible and ongoing threat to national security (CB 218 at [52]); and (2) he previously returned to Sri Lanka from India in 2012 “without any adverse attention from authorities” (CB 218 at [55]); (n)in respect of the applicant having departed Sri Lanka illegally, it was: (1) “satisfied that he will not be treated differently to any other returnee with no adverse profile” (CB 219 at [59]; (2) “not satisfied that the totality of treatment that the applicant may experience on return, including being questioned and detained for several hours at the airport, then potentially being detained on remand for up to a few days in overcrowded and unsanitary conditions, and having to pay a fine, amounts to serious harm” (CB 220 at [62]); and (3) any such treatment would, in any event, be pursuant to a law of general application (CB 220 at [63]); and (o)was not satisfied the applicant met the criteria in s 36(2)(a) or 36(2)(aa) of the Act (CB 220 to 221 at [65] to [71]). First EOT application
Ratio Decidendi