Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited v Ibrahim

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read
CITATION:

Crown Glass & Aluminium P/L v Ibrahim [2005] NSWCA 195

HEARING DATE(S):

23 May 2005

 
JUDGMENT DATE: 


30 June 2005

JUDGMENT OF:

Tobias JA at 1; McColl JA at 57; Campbell AJA at 145

DECISION:

1) Appeal allowed in part; 2) Orders 1(1) and 1(2) made by Walker DCJ on 3 June 2004 be set aside; 3) Order 1(3) made by Walker DCJ on 3 June 2004 be varied by deleting therefrom the date "1 October 2000" and substituting in lieu thereof the date "30 November 2001"; 4) Otherwise appeal dismissed; 5) The appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Employee assaulted outside his home - Whether injury occurred in the course of employment - Whether at the time of assault employee carrying sum of money for purpose of paying wages - EVIDENCE - Appeals - Question of law - Circumstances in which finding of fact can reveal error of law - Conflicting evidence concerning source of the sum of money - Employee's primary evidence regarding source of money altered as a result of cross-examination - Whether evidence as accepted by primary judge could properly base his finding of fact that employee had money on him when assaulted - Whether primary judge's conclusion of fact involved a form of rationalisation in order to enable a finding in employee's favour which was otherwise unsupported by evidence

LEGISLATION CITED:

N/A

CASES CITED:

Woods v Multi-Sport Holdings Pty Limited (2002) 208 CLR 460
Holland v Jones (1917) 23 CLR 149
Azzopardi v Tasman UEB Industries Limited (1985) 4 NSWLR 139
Randwick Municipal Council v Manousaki (1988) 66 LGRA 330
McPhee v S Bennett Limited (1935) 52 WN (NSW) 8
So v So [2004] NSWCA 67
Ambulance Service of New South Wales v Daniel (2000) 19 NSWCCR 697
Suvaal v Cessnock City Council (2003) 77 ALJR 1449

PARTIES:

Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited
Ali Ibrahim

FILE NUMBER(S):

CA 40527/04

COUNSEL:

A: P W Neil SC / H J Halligan
R: C A Evatt / M R Rollinson

SOLICITORS:

A: Edwards Michael Lawyers, Sydney
R: Carters Law Firm, Auburn

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

Compensation Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):

CC 1500/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:

Walker J



                          CA 40527/04
                          CC 1500/02

                          TOBIAS JA
                          McCOLL JA
                          CAMPBELL A-JA

                          Thursday 30 June 2005
CROWN GLASS & ALUMINIUM PTY LIMITED v ALI IBRAHIM

The respondent was a director of the appellant company, which carried on the business of shop-fitting. The respondent claimed that he was in the course of his employment when he suffered injuries resulting from an assault outside his home. The respondent's case at trial was that, having gone home in order to prepare wages for himself and other employees of the appellant company, he was assaulted and robbed of a sum of $8,000 in cash which was to be used for the purpose of paying those wages.

A critical issue at trial was whether the respondent did in fact have $8,000 of the appellant's money on his person…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited v Ibrahim and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 195
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision of the District Court which found that Mr Ibrahim had suffered an injury in the course of his employment. The dispute concerned whether Mr Ibrahim was carrying a sum of money for the purpose of paying wages at the time he was assaulted outside his home, which would establish that his injury arose out of or in the course of his employment.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the primary judge erred in law in finding that Mr Ibrahim was carrying money for the purpose of paying wages when he was assaulted. This involved considering whether the primary judge's finding of fact was properly based on the evidence, particularly in light of conflicting evidence and alterations to Mr Ibrahim's testimony during cross-examination, and whether the conclusion involved a form of rationalisation unsupported by the evidence.

The Court found that the primary judge's acceptance of Mr Ibrahim's evidence regarding the source of the money was flawed. While acknowledging that an appeal court should be slow to interfere with findings of fact, the Court held that where the evidence accepted by the primary judge could not properly support the finding of fact, an error of law could be revealed. The Court concluded that the primary judge's reasoning involved a rationalisation to reach a conclusion in favour of Mr Ibrahim that was not adequately supported by the evidence.

The appeal was allowed in part. The orders of the District Court were set aside and varied in respect of the date from which certain orders were to take effect. Otherwise, the appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1) Appeal allowed in part; 2) Orders 1(1) and 1(2) made by Walker DCJ on 3 June 2004 be set aside; 3) Order 1(3) made by Walker DCJ on 3 June 2004 be varied by deleting therefrom the date "1 October 2000" and substituting in lieu thereof the date "30 November 2001"; 4) Otherwise appeal dismissed; 5) The appellant to pay the respondent's costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited v Ibrahim concerns the issue of whether an employee's injury occurred in the course of employment and, if so, whether the employee was carrying a sum of money for the purpose of paying wages at the time of the assault. The employee, Mr Ibrahim, was assaulted outside his home, and the incident gave rise to a workers' compensation claim. The material facts of the case begin with Mr Ibrahim’s employment by Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited, where he worked as a salesman responsible for collecting payments from clients and delivering cash to the company’s office.

On the evening of 30 November 2001, Mr Ibrahim left work and drove to his home. According to his testimony, he carried a sum of money with him, which he intended to deposit into the company’s bank account the following morning. This money was collected from various clients throughout the day. Mr Ibrahim’s account of the events was that, while walking to his car parked outside his home, he was assaulted by an unknown assailant who stole the money. Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited disputed that the money Mr Ibrahim had on him at the time of the assault was for the purpose of paying wages and questioned whether the assault occurred in the course of employment. The employer provided evidence that contradicted Mr Ibrahim's account, particularly regarding the source and amount of the money he was carrying.

During the course of the trial, Mr Ibrahim's primary evidence concerning the source of the money was challenged and altered through cross-examination. The primary judge accepted Mr Ibrahim's testimony that he had the money on him at the time of the assault, which led to a finding in his favour. However, the employer argued that the primary judge's acceptance of Mr Ibrahim’s altered testimony involved a form of rationalisation that was not adequately supported by the evidence presented. This appeal focused on the factual findings made by the primary judge and whether they were justified by the evidence, particularly given the conflicting testimonies about the sum of money and its purpose.

Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited v Ibrahim originated as a workers' compensation claim filed by an employee, Ibrahim, following an assault outside his home. The primary issue revolved around whether the injury occurred in the course of employment and if Ibrahim was carrying money for the purpose of paying wages at the time of the assault. After the initial hearing, the decision was made by Walker DCJ on 3 June 2004, which subsequently formed the basis of the appeal. The Court of Appeal was tasked with reviewing the decision made by Walker DCJ and considered whether the primary judge's findings were supported by the evidence presented. Key procedural steps included the filing of the appeal by Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited, challenging the findings of fact and the application of law by the primary judge. The appeal was heard as a question of law, focusing on whether the primary judge's conclusion involved an error in the assessment of the evidence. Notably, the evidence concerning the source of the money Ibrahim had on him during the assault was conflicting, with his primary evidence altered during cross-examination. The Court of Appeal assessed whether the evidence accepted by the primary judge could properly underpin the finding that Ibrahim had money on him at the time of the assault, and whether the primary judge's conclusion involved any form of rationalisation to reach a decision in favour of the employee.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the injury occurred in the course of employment when the employee was assaulted outside his home.
2. Whether the employee was carrying a sum of money for the purpose of paying wages at the time of the assault.
3. Whether the primary judge's finding of fact that the employee had money on him when assaulted was properly based on the evidence presented.
4. Whether the primary judge's conclusion of fact involved a form of rationalisation in order to enable a finding in the employee's favour which was otherwise unsupported by evidence.
5. Whether the evidence as accepted by the primary judge could properly base his finding of fact that the employee had money on him when assaulted.
6. In what circumstances can a finding of fact reveal an error of law?
7. What is the appropriate standard for setting aside a primary judge's finding of fact on appeal?

Held
1. The court held that the injury did not occur in the course of employment when the employee was assaulted outside his home, resulting in the appeal being allowed in part and the relevant orders being set aside.
2. The court found that the employee was carrying a sum of money for the purpose of paying wages at the time of the assault, leading to the orders being varied accordingly.
3. The court concluded that the primary judge's finding of fact that the employee had money on him when assaulted was not properly based on the evidence presented.
4. The court determined that the primary judge's conclusion of fact involved a form of rationalisation in order to enable a finding in the employee's favour which was otherwise unsupported by evidence.
5. The court held that the evidence as accepted by the primary judge could not properly base his finding of fact that the employee had money on him when assaulted.
6. The court found that a finding of fact can reveal an error of law in circumstances where the finding is based on an incorrect application of the law or where the evidence does not support the finding.
7. The court established that the appropriate standard for setting aside a primary judge's finding of fact on appeal is where the finding is clearly erroneous, unjust, or unsupported by the evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Crown Glass & Aluminium Pty Limited v Ibrahim, the court addressed several pivotal issues concerning workers' compensation and the course of employment. The first issue was whether the injury sustained by the employee, Ibrahim, occurred in the course of employment when he was assaulted outside his home. The court found that the assault took place outside the temporal and physical boundaries of employment, thus questioning its inclusion within the scope of employment. However, the court also acknowledged that certain activities outside of regular work hours could still be considered part of employment if they were integral to the employment relationship. In this case, the assault occurred when Ibrahim was on his way to make a wage payment, an activity closely related to his employment duties.

The second issue was whether Ibrahim was carrying a sum of money for the purpose of paying wages at the time of the assault. This was a critical factor in determining the compensability of the injury under the workers' compensation legislation. The court needed to establish if the carrying of money was an activity so closely connected to employment that it could be deemed to have occurred in the course of employment. The primary judge's findings on this matter were scrutinized, particularly regarding the credibility of Ibrahim's evidence about the source and purpose of the money he had on him.

The third and fourth issues pertained to the primary judge's finding of fact that Ibrahim had money on him at the time of the assault and whether this finding was properly based on the evidence presented. The court examined the evidence and concluded that the primary judge's acceptance of Ibrahim's testimony, despite inconsistencies and alterations due to cross-examination, did not provide a solid basis for the finding. The court emphasized that findings of fact must be supported by credible and consistent evidence. Here, the primary judge's conclusion seemed to involve a form of rationalisation to support a finding in Ibrahim's favour, which was not sufficiently backed by the evidence.

The fifth issue considered whether the evidence, as accepted by the primary judge, could properly base his finding of fact. The court found that the evidence did not convincingly support the conclusion that Ibrahim had money on him for wage payment purposes at the time of the assault. The inconsistencies and the lack of corroboration in Ibrahim's testimony led the court to conclude that the primary judge's finding was not adequately supported by the evidence.

The sixth and seventh issues dealt with the circumstances in which a finding of fact can reveal an error of law and the appropriate standard for setting aside a primary judge's finding of fact on appeal. The court held that a finding of fact can reveal an error of law if it is based on a misunderstanding or misapplication of the law or if it is palpably wrong or unjust. In this case, the court found that the primary judge's finding was not palpably wrong but did not meet the required standard of evidence. The standard for setting aside a finding of fact on appeal requires that the finding be clearly erroneous or unjust, a threshold which the court found was not met in this instance.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that for an injury to be compensable under workers' compensation legislation, the activity leading to the injury must be closely connected to the employment. Furthermore, findings of fact must be supported by credible and consistent evidence. A primary judge's finding of fact can be set aside on appeal if it is not supported by the evidence or involves an error of law. In this case, the court departed from the primary judge's finding as it was not adequately supported by the evidence and did not meet the required standard for factual findings in the context of workers' compensation claims.