CPM17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
45 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
CPM17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 42
File number(s):
ADG 180 of 2019
Judgment of:
JUDGE LUCEV
Date of judgment:
20 January 2025
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Judicial review application – Immigration Assessment Authority decision - citizens of Sri Lanka – refused grant of a Safe Haven Enterprise visa – whether the Immigration Assessment Authority proceeded on the basis of a misunderstanding of, or failure to understand, the material in country information report and relevance of the material to the claims made – report concerning male sexual violence - whether Immigration Assessment Authority findings were illogical, irrational and lacked an intelligible justification in relation to death of an applicant’s friend and a bribe paid to cease harassment – whether material jurisdictional error
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CPM17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:
CPM17 and CPN17, citizens of Sri Lanka, sought judicial review of the Minister’s decision to refuse their application for a Safe Haven Enterprise visa. The applicants argued that the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) made errors in its assessment of their protection claims, leading to a refusal of their visa application. The applicants claimed that the IAA misunderstood the country information report and misapplied the evidence presented, particularly concerning the death of a friend and an alleged bribe paid to ensure safety.
The primary legal issue was whether the IAA made a material jurisdictional error in its assessment of the applicants' claims for protection. Specifically, the court had to determine if the IAA misunderstood or failed to understand the content of the country information report and the relevance of the evidence to the applicants' claims. This included assessing whether the IAA's findings regarding the death of an applicant's friend and the alleged bribe were illogical, irrational, or lacked an intelligible justification.
The court examined the IAA's handling of the country information report, specifically the International Truth and Justice Project report on male sexual violence in Sri Lanka, which the IAA deemed irrelevant to the applicants' claims. The court also scrutinized the IAA's findings on the death of the applicants' friend and the alleged bribe. The court found that the IAA's reasoning was not illogical or irrational, as it was based on the evidence presented and the applicable legal standards. The court concluded that the IAA's assessment of the applicants' claims was thorough and justified, and no material jurisdictional error was made.
As a result, the court dismissed the judicial review application, affirming the IAA's decision to refuse the applicants' visa application. The applicants' claims for protection were found to be overstated, and they did not meet the criteria under the Migration Act for a Safe Haven Enterprise visa. The court held that the IAA's findings were supported by the evidence and did not contain any material jurisdictional error.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
All references to the Migration Act in these Reasons for Judgment are to the provisions therein as they were at the time of the Second Authority Decision.PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND The relevant procedural background to the matter is as follows:(a)the Applicants are citizens of Sri Lanka, ethnically Tamils by ethnicity and of the Hindu religion: CB 18, 53, and 55;(b)the Applicants met in June 2007 and have lived together since September 2009: CB 46 at [10], and are now in a de facto relationship;(c)on 13 October 2012 the Applicants departed Sri Lanka and arrived in Australia as unauthorised maritime arrivals on 28 October 2012: CB 150;(d)the Applicants were held in immigration detention in various locations before their release in February 2014;(e)the Applicants’ applied for a SHE Visa on 16 August 2016: CB 5;(f)on 19 December 2016 the Delegate’s Decision to refuse to grant the Applicants the SHE Visa was made: CB 147;(g)pursuant to s 473CA of the Migration Act the Delegate’s Decision was referred to the Authority for review: CB 188;(h)on 24 May 2017 the Authority affirmed the Delegate’s Decision to refuse to grant the Applicants the SHE Visa (“First Authority Decision”): CB 351;(i)the Applicants applied to this Court (then styled the Federal Circuit Court of Australia) for judicial review of the First Authority Decision and on 27 March 2019 this Court (differently constituted) quashed the First Authority Decision, and by consent remitted the matter to the Authority to review anew the SHE Visa application according to law: CB 373; and(j)in the Second Authority Decision on 1 May 2019 the Authority affirmed the Delegate’s Decision to refuse to grant the Applicants the SHE Visa: CB 802 and 828.PROTECTION CLAIMS As identified in the Second Authority Decision, the Applicants’ protection claims (with deletions and minor edits to protect the identity of the Applicants) are as follows:(a)for CPM17 at CB 810-812 at [29]:•The first applicant is a Sri Lankan citizen of Tamil ethnicity and an adherent of the Hindu faith. He was born in … 1971 in …, in North-western Province of Sri Lanka. Soon after his birth, his family moved to the … district where he spent his youth. His father died in 1981. In 1990, some of his family went to live in India while he moved to … District in the Northern Province where he lived thereafter. He was in a de facto relationship with the second applicant.•Due to the civil war, there were many difficulties in …. There was a strong military presence in the area he lived, and Tamils were routinely harassed and suspected of supporting the LTTE. He was interrogated and beaten on a number of occasions during this period.•The applicant’s friend and neighbour (F1) was shot and killed … [in] 2007. He [F1] was suspected of links to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Elam (LTTE). The applicant believes he was killed for this reason. The applicant helped to arrange his funeral.•Later the applicant was questioned by the Sri Lankan authorities about his own links to F1 and his involvement with the LTTE. [In] … 2008, he was required to attend a local army camp for questioning. He was accused of being an LTTE supporter and was threatened with death, like F1. He was required to report to the camp weekly thereafter.•[Three to four months later] … four men visited his home while he, the second applicant and his mother were present. Two men were wearing Army uniforms and two of the men were in civilian attire. One of the men was carrying a pistol. Upon seeing the weapon, the applicant ran away, fearing he would be shot. He hid at a friend’s home.•He and the second applicant feared harm from the Sri Lankan Army (SLA). [The next day] …, they sought assistance from the Sri Lankan Human Rights Commission (SLHRC). The SLHRC referred him to the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), who subsequently referred them back to the SLHRC. The SLHRC advised them they could not offer him protection, and took him to local police where he and the second applicant asked to be placed in protective custody for his own protection. He and the second applicant waited in the police station for a day, and where then taken before a court, where they petitioned a magistrate to be placed into protective custody.•The magistrate accepted that the applicants were fearful and they entered protective custody. Many other fearful persons were had also requested protection at this time. The applicants’ and other protected persons were separated and sent to different locations separated by gender. Males where housed in the … prison, and females were housed in another camp.•Whilst in protective custody, the applicant was required to attend court every fortnight to affirm that he wished to stay in protective custody. While in custody, the SLA visited his mother and told her that he should stop voicing complaints about the army.•He stayed in protective custody at the prison until … 2009 when he decided to return home (applicant 2 having previously decided to depart … [the previous month]). On the day of his release, he paid a 25,000 Sri Lankan rupee bribe to the army in order to ensure his safety. He was released into the custody of the Sri Lankan Police Criminal Investigation Division (CID) who subsequently took him to a nearby army base where he was interrogated. He was again questioned about his links to the LTTE. He signed documents in English which he describes as a confession for possession of weapons, though he was unable to read them. He was held overnight. He was released, but advised that he would be required to report to the Army when requested.•[Later that or the next year] … he approached the Australian and Swiss Embassies to enquire about seeking asylum. He subsequently submitted an application for asylum to the Swiss embassy, and was interviewed in Colombo. He did not proceed with an application for protection from Australia at this time. Around this time, he applied for and obtained a genuine Sri Lankan Passport in order to facilitate his travel to Switzerland.•The SLA visited his home and required him to report. This happened on two or three occasions. On each occasion, he would be asked about his LTTE connections.•He departed Sri Lanka by boat in 2012 before finding out whether he had obtained asylum in Switzerland. He travelled to Australia.•The applicant fears that if returned to Sri Lanka he would be of ongoing interest to the Sri Lankan Government, he believes he would be imputed as a supporter of the LTTE and would be harmed upon return.•In 2014, some of the applicants’ details were released by the department during a Data breach. He believes that the Sri Lankan Government would know of his claims to asylum in this country and would infer that he had made claims against the Government. He fears he would be imputed with anti-regime political opinion. •He fears that his illegal departure and his claim of asylum in this country, would also lead him to be imputed with anti-regime political opinion. He fears harm on this basis. (b)for CPN17 at CB 812 at [30]:•The second applicant is a Sri Lankan citizen of Tamil ethnicity and an adherent of the Hindu faith. She was born in … 1983 in … District of the Eastern Province of Sri Lanka. In 1990, she travelled to India and lived as a refugee. She returned to Sri Lanka in 2007. She moved to …, with members of her extended family.•When she arrived in Sri Lanka, she registered with the Sri Lankan Government. She was told to report to an SLA camp. She was interviewed on camera and [w]as questioned about whether she had links to the LTTE. She was asked to attend further interviews on five to six occasions. She feared she would suffer from sexual harassment or abuse on these occasions since there were no other women present.•After the four men visited, she and the first applicant went to the SLHRC for protection. Like the first applicant, she was subsequently placed in protective custody in a camp for women. The camp was controlled by the SLA, and whilst there she was compelled to perform cleaning duties for the SLA. She was required to affirm to a magistrate each fortnight that she wished to stay in protective custody. In … 2009, she decided to leave protective custody, and returned to live in applicant 1’s family home in Jaffna.•She fears that she will face harm because of her gender if returned to Sri Lanka.•In 2014, some of her details were released by the Department during a Data breach. He [presumably CPM17] believes that the Sri Lankan Government would know of his claims to asylum in this country and would infer that he had made claims against the Government. He fears he would be imputed with anti-regime political opinion.•He fears that her illegal departure and her claim of asylum in this country, would also lead her to be imputed with anti-regime political opinion. She fears harm on this basis.•She fears harm as the de facto wife of a person suspected of being a member of the LTTE. SECOND AUTHORITY DECISION
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
As identified in the Second Authority Decision, the Applicants’ protection claims (with deletions and minor edits to protect the identity of the Applicants) are as follows:(a)for CPM17 at CB 810-812 at [29]:•The first applicant is a Sri Lankan citizen of Tamil ethnicity and an adherent of the Hindu faith. He was born in … 1971 in …, in North-western Province of Sri Lanka. Soon after his birth, his family moved to the … district where he spent his youth. His father died in 1981. In 1990, some of his family went to live in India while he moved to … District in the Northern Province where he lived thereafter. He was in a de facto relationship with the second applicant.•Due to the civil war, there were many difficulties in …. There was a strong military presence in the area he lived, and Tamils were routinely harassed and suspected of supporting the LTTE. He was interrogated and beaten on a number of occasions during this period.•The applicant’s friend and neighbour (F1) was shot and killed … [in] 2007. He [F1] was suspected of links to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Elam (LTTE). The applicant believes he was killed for this reason. The applicant helped to arrange his funeral.•Later the applicant was questioned by the Sri Lankan authorities about his own links to F1 and his involvement with the LTTE. [In] … 2008, he was required to attend a local army camp for questioning. He was accused of being an LTTE supporter and was threatened with death, like F1. He was required to report to the camp weekly thereafter.•[Three to four months later] … four men visited his home while he, the second applicant and his mother were present. Two men were wearing Army uniforms and two of the men were in civilian attire. One of the men was carrying a pistol. Upon seeing the weapon, the applicant ran away, fearing he would be shot. He hid at a friend’s home.•He and the second applicant feared harm from the Sri Lankan Army (SLA). [The next day] …, they sought assistance from the Sri Lankan Human Rights Commission (SLHRC). The SLHRC referred him to the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), who subsequently referred them back to the SLHRC. The SLHRC advised them they could not offer him protection, and took him to local police where he and the second applicant asked to be placed in protective custody for his own protection. He and the second applicant waited in the police station for a day, and where then taken before a court, where they petitioned a magistrate to be placed into protective custody.•The magistrate accepted that the applicants were fearful and they entered protective custody. Many other fearful persons were had also requested protection at this time. The applicants’ and other protected persons were separated and sent to different locations separated by gender. Males where housed in the … prison, and females were housed in another camp.•Whilst in protective custody, the applicant was required to attend court every fortnight to affirm that he wished to stay in protective custody. While in custody, the SLA visited his mother and told her that he should stop voicing complaints about the army.•He stayed in protective custody at the prison until … 2009 when he decided to return home (applicant 2 having previously decided to depart … [the previous month]). On the day of his release, he paid a 25,000 Sri Lankan rupee bribe to the army in order to ensure his safety. He was released into the custody of the Sri Lankan Police Criminal Investigation Division (CID) who subsequently took him to a nearby army base where he was interrogated. He was again questioned about his links to the LTTE. He signed documents in English which he describes as a confession for possession of weapons, though he was unable to read them. He was held overnight. He was released, but advised that he would be required to report to the Army when requested.•[Later that or the next year] … he approached the Australian and Swiss Embassies to enquire about seeking asylum. He subsequently submitted an application for asylum to the Swiss embassy, and was interviewed in Colombo. He did not proceed with an application for protection from Australia at this time. Around this time, he applied for and obtained a genuine Sri Lankan Passport in order to facilitate his travel to Switzerland.•The SLA visited his home and required him to report. This happened on two or three occasions. On each occasion, he would be asked about his LTTE connections.•He departed Sri Lanka by boat in 2012 before finding out whether he had obtained asylum in Switzerland. He travelled to Australia.•The applicant fears that if returned to Sri Lanka he would be of ongoing interest to the Sri Lankan Government, he believes he would be imputed as a supporter of the LTTE and would be harmed upon return.•In 2014, some of the applicants’ details were released by the department during a Data breach. He believes that the Sri Lankan Government would know of his claims to asylum in this country and would infer that he had made claims against the Government. He fears he would be imputed with anti-regime political opinion. •He fears that his illegal departure and his claim of asylum in this country, would also lead him to be imputed with anti-regime political opinion. He fears harm on this basis. (b)for CPN17 at CB 812 at [30]:•The second applicant is a Sri Lankan citizen of Tamil ethnicity and an adherent of the Hindu faith. She was born in … 1983 in … District of the Eastern Province of Sri Lanka. In 1990, she travelled to India and lived as a refugee. She returned to Sri Lanka in 2007. She moved to …, with members of her extended family.•When she arrived in Sri Lanka, she registered with the Sri Lankan Government. She was told to report to an SLA camp. She was interviewed on camera and [w]as questioned about whether she had links to the LTTE. She was asked to attend further interviews on five to six occasions. She feared she would suffer from sexual harassment or abuse on these occasions since there were no other women present.•After the four men visited, she and the first applicant went to the SLHRC for protection. Like the first applicant, she was subsequently placed in protective custody in a camp for women. The camp was controlled by the SLA, and whilst there she was compelled to perform cleaning duties for the SLA. She was required to affirm to a magistrate each fortnight that she wished to stay in protective custody. In … 2009, she decided to leave protective custody, and returned to live in applicant 1’s family home in Jaffna.•She fears that she will face harm because of her gender if returned to Sri Lanka.•In 2014, some of her details were released by the Department during a Data breach. He [presumably CPM17] believes that the Sri Lankan Government would know of his claims to asylum in this country and would infer that he had made claims against the Government. He fears he would be imputed with anti-regime political opinion.•He fears that her illegal departure and her claim of asylum in this country, would also lead her to be imputed with anti-regime political opinion. She fears harm on this basis.•She fears harm as the de facto wife of a person suspected of being a member of the LTTE. SECOND AUTHORITY DECISION
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the Second Authority Decision the Authority: (a)set out the background to the Authority’s review: CB 803 at [1]-[3];(b)said it had had regard to the information properly before it, with some new information accepted and some rejected under s 473DD of the Migration Act: CB 803-810 at [4]-[27];(c)in relation to a September 2018 International Truth and Justice Project report entitled “Unsilenced: Male survivors speak of conflict-related sexual violence in Sri Lanka” (“ITJP Male Sexual Violence Report”): CB 524-549, says, for the purposes of determining whether to consider the ITJP Male Sexual Violence Report as new information under s 473DD of the Migration Act, at CB 809 at [23] that:The 2018 ITJP [Male Sexual Violence] Report relates to the use of sexual violence against male prisoners in Sri Lanka by the security forces after 2009. … [CPM17] has not made any claims of this kind. In the circumstances, I am not persuaded this document has any particular relevance to … [CPM17’s] claims. I have not considered it. (d)identified the Applicants’ claims for protection: CB 810-812 at [28]-[30] (see [5] above);(e)accepted that the Applicants, being in a long-standing de facto relationship, were likely to be viewed as a married couple by the Sri Lankan authorities: CB 813 at [32]; (f)accepted CPM17s claim that, between 1996 and 2008 he had been harassed by agents of the Sri Lankan authorities, and that during this harassment he was mistreated and that this resulted in physical harm, but did not consider that this was anything but “essentially random” arising from his proximity to the “security incidents” involving the LTTE, not to CPM17’s specific profile or “any specific suspicions against him personally”: CB 814 at [38];(g)was not persuaded that the death of “F1” (CPM17’s friend and neighbour) had heightened CPM17’s profile in the eyes of the Sri Lankan authorities as a person with links to the LTTE: CB 814-815 at [39]-[43], and in particular at [41]-[43] said as follows: 41.According to the first applicant there were witnesses to the shooting (not him) but they were too intimidated to come forward. He has not identified the witnesses. Afterwards, the first applicant assisted F1’s family to arrange the funeral for F1. Sometime later, he was questioned by the SLA about whether he knew who was responsible for the shooting. The applicant denied any knowledge. The SLA indicated to the applicant that they believed that F1 was shot because of his financial support for the LTTE. The applicant believes that the Sri Lankan authorities were responsible for the death of F1.42.As evidence of his claims, the applicant has provided a death certificate for F1 and a translation. It indicates that F1 was shot and killed on 14 August 2007 by unidentified Gunman. I accept that F1 was shot and killed in August 2007 as claimed. However, I note that the certificate does not provide any support for the claim that he Sri Lankan authorities were responsible for his death. On his own evidence, the applicant did not witness the shooting. He has not provided any convincing independent evidence to support his attribution of the death to the Sri Lankan authorities. I find the applicant’s claim about Sri Lankan Government responsibility to be speculative.43.There is a wealth of credible country information before me to indicate that throughout the period of civil war there were many armed factions operational in Sri Lanka. Thousands of civilians were killed during this period. However, like the delegate, I am not persuaded that the Sri Lankan Government can be ascribed responsibility for the death of F1. (h)otherwise accepted that CPM17 was questioned about the death of F1, that the Applicants’ home was searched in the wake of the event, and the Applicants went into voluntary protective custody for six months thereafter: CB 816 at [51] and 818 at [59];(i)as to a purported 25,000rp bribe CPM17 had claimed to pay to the Sri Lankan Army (“SLA”) to ensure his safety, found as follows at CB 817 at [52]:52.The surrendered person report makes reference to a 15,000-rupee bond paid by the applicant at the time of his release. But there is no indication of the purpose of the bond. I note that in his Protection Visa Interview, and in submissions, it has been argued that the first applicant paid a 25,000 Rupee bribe and that this payment was made to the SLA so that his “problems with the SLA and the State apparatus could be resolved”. However, the surrendered person report does not indicate that he paid a 25,000 bribe; rather it says he paid a 15,000-rupee bond. In this context, it is worth noting that the surrendered person report does indicate that the second applicant paid a 25,000-rupee bond at the time of her release. However, when questioned by the delegate she denied that this occurred, and explicitly stated that no money had been paid. On the whole, I am not satisfied that the applicant did pay a 25,000 bribe as he claims. (j)considered the other elements of the Applicants’ claims and concluded, at CB 818 at [60], that I am not satisfied that either applicant was of any interest to the Sri Lankan Government after the final interview, sometime in early 2010. I do not accept that … [CPM17] signed a confession or was threatened with weapons charges. I do not accept that … [CPN17] would be imputed to be the wife of an LTTE member or former LTTE member. On the evidence before me, the applicants have significantly overstated the risks they faced from the authorities in Sri Lanka. I conclude they have done this in order to enhance their claims for protection. (k)rejected the Applicants’ claims and found that they did not satisfy s 36(2)(a) or (aa) of the Migration Act: CB 826 at [98] and 827 at [105].CONSIDERATION OF THE FURTHER AMENDED JUDICIAL REVIEW APPLICATIONThe requirement for material jurisdictional error