Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1806

File number: VID 1191 of 2018
Judge: O’CALLAGHAN J
Date of judgment: 6 November 2019
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – application made under s 545(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 by union and a worker alleging contraventions of the Act for breaches of the Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010 – hire of labour – nature of contract between labour hire company and worker – whether worker an employee of labour hire company – held that relationship was not one of employment, but one of principal and self-employed contractor – application dismissed
Legislation:

Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s 545(1)

Cases cited:

ACE Insurance Ltd v Trifunovski (2013) 209 FCR 146

Australian Mutual Provident Society v Chaplin (1978) 52 ALJR 407

Building Workers’ Industrial Union of Australia v Odco Pty Ltd (1991) 29 FCR 104

Fair Work Ombudsman v Ecosway Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 296

Fair Work Ombudsman v Quest South Perth Holdings Pty Ltd (2015) 228 FCR 346

Forstaff Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue (2004) 144 IR 1; [2004] NSWSC 573

Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 21

Odco Pty Ltd v Building Workers Industrial Union and others [1989] FCA 483

On Call Interpreters & Translators Agency Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (No 3) (2011) 214 FCR 82

Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd (t/as Tricord Personnel) v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union of Workers [2004] WASCA 312; 141 IR 31

Queensland Stations v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1945) 70 CLR 539

Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 16

Tattsbett Ltd v Morrow (2015) 233 FCR 46

Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Aplhapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165

Whitby v ZG Operations Australia Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1934

Date of hearing: 10 June 2019, 11 June 2019, 12 June 2019, 17 June 2019, 18 June 2019
Registry: Victoria
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 182
Counsel for the Applicants: M A Irving QC
Solicitor for the Applicants: S Catania of the Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union
Counsel for the First Respondent: J Blackburn SC
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Hotchkin Hanly
Counsel for the Second Respondent: M Felman
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Hall and Wilcox

ORDERS

VID 1191 of 2018
BETWEEN:

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MARITIME, MINING AND ENERGY UNION

First Applicant

DANIEL ROBERT MCCOURT

Second Applicant

AND:

PERSONNEL CONTRACTING PTY LTD

First Respondent

HANSSEN PTY LTD

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

O’CALLAGHAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 NOVEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding be dismissed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

O’CALLAGHAN J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an application made under s 545(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW Act) by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1806
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman and the Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (CFMMEU) applied to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia for orders against Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd (Personnel) and a worker, Mr McCourt, alleging contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) for breaches of the Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010. The applicants sought a declaration that Mr McCourt was an employee of Personnel and that therefore Personnel was liable to pay him unpaid wages, superannuation and other entitlements. They also sought orders against Personnel and Mr McCourt for contraventions of the Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010. The central issue in the proceeding was the nature of the contract between Personnel and Mr McCourt. The applicants submitted that Mr McCourt was an employee of Personnel, and that Personnel had contravened the Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010 by not paying Mr McCourt the applicable award wages and entitlements. Personnel submitted that Mr McCourt was not its employee but rather a self-employed contractor, and that the relationship between Personnel and Mr McCourt was one of principal and contractor. The Court found that the relationship between Personnel and Mr McCourt was not one of employment but one of principal and self-employed contractor. The Court found that the terms of the Labour Hire Agreement between Personnel and Mr McCourt, and the conduct of the parties, indicated that Mr McCourt was not an employee of Personnel but rather a self-employed contractor. The Court found that the agreement between Personnel and Mr McCourt was one of principal and contractor, and that Personnel was not liable to pay Mr McCourt unpaid wages, superannuation and other entitlements. The proceeding was dismissed. The Court made no orders against Personnel or Mr McCourt.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below, the proceeding, which was heard in Perth in June this year in conjunction with Fair Work Ombudsman v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1807, must be dismissed. The accessorial claims against Hanssen in this proceeding therefore do not arise.THE FACTS Construct is a company which organises for workers to work at the sites of its clients, under the supervision of the client. At any one time, Construct has about 1,000 workers on its books, and between 300 and 350 of its workers working at its clients’ sites. Hanssen is a client of Construct, and in the relevant year (2017) accounted for between 70 to 75 percent of all workers supplied to clients by Construct. The gist of the arrangement between Hanssen and Construct is that Hanssen places an order with Construct, which then arranges for workers it has listed on its register to present themselves at the work site and work under Hanssen’s supervision. Hanssen pays Construct, and Construct pays the workers for their hours worked. The amount Hanssen pays Construct varies according to how much the worker is paid, which can be negotiated between the worker and Hanssen. Construct and Hanssen’s relationship was (and is) governed by a Labour Hire Agreement (LHA), the relevant terms of which are set out at Annexure A. At trial, counsel for the applicants conceded that no contract could be said to exist, implied or otherwise, between Hanssen and Mr McCourt, and the pleaded case along those lines was abandoned. I turn now to deal with the not inconsiderable body of evidence adduced by the parties in respect of Mr McCourt. Key documents The ASA It is convenient to set out here the terms of the ASA in full. RECITALA.Construct is an administrative services agency operating essentially within the building industry, liaising between builders (or their contractors) (both described as “builders”) and self-employed contractors for the provision of labour by self-employed contractors to builders and supplying to the self-employed contractors financia1 administrative services.B.The Contractor requires Construct to keep the Contractor informed of opportunities for the Contractor to provide builders with labour services and to provide the Contractor with financial administrative support to enable the Contractor to concentrate on maximising the supply of quality labour to builders.IT IS AGREED1.Construct’s ResponsibilitiesConstruct shall(a)Use reasonable endeavours to keep informed of opportunities in the building industry for the Contractor to supply labour to builders identified by Construct;(b)Inform the Contractor when, and on what basis, an opportunity arises for the Contractor to supply labour to a builder;(c)Liaise between builders and the Contractor regarding the means by which the Contractor shall supply labour to such builders, including the duration that the builder requires such labour, the place at which labour is to be supplied, the daily hours of work during which labour is to be supplied and any other terms and conditions upon which labour is to be supplied by the Contractor to the builder;(d)Subject to performance by the Contractor of his or its obligations under this Agreement, underwrite payment to the Contractor, within 7 days of receipt of an invoice from the Contractor, of all payment rates payable by the builder in respect of the supply of labour to the builder by the Contractor, including payment rates negotiated by the Contractor directly with the builder;(e)Complete administrative forms and undertake necessary correspondence with Government authorities as may be required under any law of Western Australia relating to labour supplied to builders under this agreement, other than the completion by the Contractor of his taxation returns, including any instalment activity statement or business activity statements.2.Construct’s RightsConstruct shall be entitled to(a)Negotiate with any builder a payment rate for the supply by the Contractor of labour to the builder, provided that the Contractor shall be at liberty to negotiate with the builder an increase in the payment rate and any other terms and conditions upon which labour is to be supplied by the Contractor to the builder, subject to the Contractor properly performing his obligations under this Agreement;(b)Negotiate with the builder the basis upon which Construct is to be remunerated on a commission basis as a percentage of the agreed payment rate for the supply of services by the Contractor to the builder;(c)Negotiate with the builder for remuneration in respect of any increase in the payment rate negotiated directly by the Contractor with the builder;(d)Withhold from the Contractor payment of any monies reasonably required by Construct to compensate it for any claim made against Construct by the builder in respect of the supply of labour by the Contractor to the builder.3.The Contractor’s WarrantiesThe Contractor warrants that:(a)He has provided Construct with true and accurate information regarding his work experience and capability for the supply of labour to builders;(b)He is self-employed;(c)He does not require Construct to guarantee the Contractor work of any type or of any duration;(d)That he shall keep Construct fully informed of the outcome of negotiations with the builder by the Contractor in order to ensure that Construct is promptly and accurately informed of any higher rate of payment agreed by the builder and the value of any other terms and conditions agreed with the builder by the Contractor;(e)Construct shall not be liable to pay the Contractor any amounts in respect of annual leave, sick leave, long service leave or any other statutory entitlement required in an employer-employee relationship.4.The Contractor’s ObligationsThe Contractor shall:(a)Co-operate in all respects with Construct and the builder in the supply of labour to the Builder;(b)Ensure accurate records are maintained as to the amount of labour supplied to the builder by the Contractor;(c)Attend at any building site as agreed with the Builder at the time required by the Builder, and shall supply labour to the Builder (subject to notification under clause 5(c)) for the duration required by the Builder in a safe, competent and diligent manner;(d)Indemnify Construct against any breach by the Contractor of sub-paragraph 4(c) hereof;(e)Supply such tools of trade and equipment, for safety or other reasons, as may be required by the builder, in respect of which the Contractor is solely responsible;(f)Possess all statutory certification relevant to the supply of labour, and shall ensure that these certificates be both current and valid in Western Australia;(g)In the event that the Contractor reasonably considers that his safety is endangered by conditions on the building site, promptly report the unsafe conditions to Worksafe if unable to have the unsafe conditions rectified by the builder promptly;(h)Not represent himself as being an employee of Construct at any time or otherwise represent himself as authorised to act on behalf of Construct other than strictly under the terms of this Agreement.5.The Contractor’s RightsThe Contractor is entitled to:(a)Receive payment from Construct of all amounts negotiated with the builder by Construct and the Contractor within seven (7) days of the issue by the Contractor of a valid invoice delivered to Construct by the Contractor for the supply of labour to the builder by the Contractor;(b)Refuse to accept any offer of work from a builder;(c)Notify the builder and Construct on 4 hours notice that he is no longer available for the supply of labour under the terms of this Agreement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A number of witnesses were cross-examined, but no party suggested that any evidence or concession elicited during the course of it has any particular bearing on the central issue of the proper characterisation of the relationship between Mr McCourt and Construct. The facts set out below were largely uncontested, and are derived principally from the affidavit material.The evidence adduced by the CFMMEU and Mr McCourtEvidence of Daniel McCourt Prior to his arrival in Australia, Mr McCourt had worked in the UK part-time as a brick-layer and a food and beverage attendant at a kiosk, and full-time as a “bar associate” and in the kitchen at a pub at the Liverpool Airport, in England. In June 2016 he arrived in Melbourne on a working holiday visa, and found work for two weeks installing tablet computers in cabinets at a workshop and later at a stadium. He then left Melbourne to travel to Perth, where he arrived in July 2016. He then started looking for work. While looking for work, he obtained a “white card”, which he needed in order to work on construction sites. Mr McCourt was told by a friend that Construct was looking for workers, and he contacted Construct to express his interest. On 22 July 2016, Mr McCourt was invited to send a copy of his CV and his white card to Construct, which he did. He then received a text message from Mr van der Plas inviting him to attend an interview. On 25 July 2016, Mr McCourt attended Construct’s office for his interview with Mr van der Plas. At the interview, Mr McCourt says he told Mr van der Plas that he was prepared to do any construction labouring that he was capable of and to work on weekends; that he had his own means of transport to get to jobs; and that he was available to start work immediately. Mr van der Plas asked him whether he had a hard hat, steel-capped boots and hi-vis clothing, which he did, having purchased them in Perth in the hope of getting construction work, for less than $100. Mr McCourt says Mr van der Plas also told him he would be doing construction work, but that Construct could not guarantee any work. He told Mr McCourt the rate at which he would be paid, and provided to Mr McCourt the documents referred to above. Mr McCourt, in a second affidavit dated 22 May 2019, swore:The interview was about 20 minutes long, in which Leon van der Plas went through all of the interview documents. After the interview Leon left me alone for approximately 20 to 30 minutes. During that period I read all of the material and signed the interview documents. Mr McCourt listed in his first affidavit various questions that Mr van der Plas “did not ask”, including whether he had assets or equipment to run a business; a business name; a building from which to run a business; “invoicing systems”; standard rates, terms or conditions of trade; payment or debt collection systems; budgeting or forecasting systems; and whether he was registered for GST or had an ABN. The next day, Mr Todd Marshall called Mr McCourt to tell him that there was work at a Hanssen site, that it would start the following day, and that it would likely run until at least Christmas. Mr McCourt confirmed with Mr Marshall that he was happy to commence work the next day. Mr McCourt then received the following text message:Daniel, The address of the job is ‘Concerto’ at 189 Adelaide Tce, East Perth. The site is next to/behind the old ABC building … Arrive onsite for induction at 6:45am. Make sure that you have steel capped boots, a hard hat and a high viz shirt/vest. Todd. Construct.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The same can be said of the absence of paid leave entitlements and other typical employee entitlements. As counsel for the applicants put it in oral closing submissions, and I agree, “the non-provision of annual leave and sick leave … benefits usually associated with employment are a function of a party’s understanding of whether or not the contract is one of employment. The understanding of the putative employer is partly relevant, but it shouldn’t be counted twice. The non-provision of annual leave and sick leave is not a separate, differently weighed consideration to the former, it’s just a consequence”.CONCLUSION As is clear from my consideration of the various indicia, as is often the case in contested matters of this sort, there are significant matters that point in opposite directions on the critical question of whether Mr McCourt was an employee. It is important to keep in mind when assessing the various criteria that in cases such as this courts are not involved in a box-checking exercise. “The ultimate question will always be whether a person is acting as the servant of another or on [their] own behalf and the answer to that question may be indicated in ways that are not always the same and which do not always have the same significance”. See Stevens v Brodribb Sawmilling Co Pty Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 16 at 37 (per Wilson and Dawson JJ). In addressing that ultimate question, it is always important to pay close regard to the way in which the parties have characterised their relationship. Compare Forstaff Pty Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue (2004) 144 IR 1; [2004] NSWSC 573 at [120] (per McDougall J). See also Fair Work Ombudsman v Ecosway Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 296 at [75] (per White J) (“The ‘label’ which the parties themselves place on their relationship is relevant but not conclusive. The parties cannot deem the character of their relationship to be something it is not … However, when the competing indicia are reasonably evenly balanced, the parties’ own understanding of their relationship may be decisive …”). As Woodward J said in Odco Pty Ltd v Building Workers’ Industrial Union of Australia [1989] FCA 483 at 76 the intention of the parties “is a very important consideration in most cases”. His Honour continued: … The only reason it is not as decisive in determining the nature of the contract as it is in determining its content is that the parties may intend to create one type of contract, but include in it provisions which require the law to classify it differently. Allowance must also be made for the fact that the expressed intention of the parties may be a sham, designed to achieve some taxation or other advantage; but in that case the real intention of the parties is to be ascertained from material other than their declared intentions; see, for example, Ferguson v John Dawson and Partners (Contractors) Ltd [1976] EWCA Civ 7; (1976) 1 WLR 1213; Massey v Crown Life Insurance Co (1978) 1 CR 590 at 594. However, where the parties are behaving honestly, and where the nature of their proposed relationship is such that it could become that of either employer/employee or principal/contractor, then it is open to them to mould their legal relationship in either form: DCT v Bolwell (1967) 1 ATR 862 at 868, per Lush J. See also Queensland Stations Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1945) 70 CLR 539 per Dixon J at 552. Their intentions will then tend to influence the details of their agreement, and any apparently contrary indicia would need to be closely examined against the background of the parties’ intentions. Beattie J, in Harker v Boon (1956) AR (NSW) 178 at 183 said, The important matter is to determine whether the intention of the contracting parties was to establish the relationship of employer and employee, and the facts of the particular case, looked at as a whole, may well negative the conclusion that the exercise of control by one party over the work of another flows from the relationship of master and servant. Denning LJ in Massey (above, at the page cited) after dealing with dishonest labels attached to contracts went on to say, On the other hand, if the parties’ relationship is ambiguous and is capable of being one or the other, then the parties can remove that ambiguity, by the very agreement itself which they make with one another. The agreement itself then becomes the best material from which to gather the true legal relationship between them. This is clearly seen by referring back to Inland Revenue Commissioner v Duke of Westminster (1936) AC 1.This statement was cited with approval by the Privy Council in Australian Mutual Provident Society v Chaplin (1978) 18 ALR 385 at 389, where the Privy Council also said of a clause in an agreement stating a relationship to be “that of Principal and Agent and not that of Master and Servant”, that Clearly cl 3 which, if it stood alone, would be conclusive in favour of the Society, cannot receive effect according to its terms if they contradict the effect of the agreement as a whole.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established