Fair Work Ombudsman v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1807

File number: WAD 284 of 2018
Judge: O’CALLAGHAN J
Date of judgment: 6 November 2019
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – application by ombudsman alleging contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) for breaches of the Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010 – heard with VID 1191 of 2018 – hire of labour – nature of contract between labour hire company and worker – whether worker an employee of labour hire company – held that relationship was not one of employment, but one of principal and self-employed contractor – application dismissed
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
Date of hearing: 13 June 2019, 14 June 2019, 19 June 2019
Registry: Western Australia
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 103
Counsel for the Applicant: R J S French
Solicitor for the Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the Respondent: J Blackburn SC
Solicitor for the Respondent: Hotchkin Hanly Lawyers

ORDERS

WAD 284 of 2018
BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

PERSONNEL CONTRACTING PTY LTD

Respondent

JUDGE:

O’CALLAGHAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 NOVEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding be dismissed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

O’CALLAGHAN J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. This proceeding was heard in conjunction with proceeding no VID 1191 of 2018 (VID 1191).  The two proceedings concern the respondent and raise the same legal issues.  By agreement, opening submissions and evidence were heard in this proceeding after opening submissions and evidence in VID 1191.  Closing submissions were then made in turn in VID 1191 and then in this proceeding.  Mr J Blackburn SC appeared in both proceedings for the respondent (Construct).  Mr RJS French of counsel appeared for the applicant (FWO) in this proceeding.  Mr French was present in court at the commencement of VID 1191, and during the course of closing submissions in it.

  2. This procedure was agreed in order to minimise repetition, which it did.

  3. These reasons therefore assume familiarity with, and should be read together with, my reasons in VID 1191 of 2018 (Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 1806).

  4. In this proceeding, the FWO alleges, among other things, that Construct contravened s 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) by not paying three workers certain allowances and entitlements that he says were due to them as employees performing building work during the period 14 July 2016 to 14 October 2016 who were covered by the Building and Construction General On-Site Award (the Award).

  5. Like proceeding VID 1191, the critical question here is whether the relevant workers were employees. 

  6. The workers the subject of this proceeding are Ms Jessika Lee (née Robinson-Dernie), Ms Ieasha Kemp, and Mr Lyall James.  Ms Lee and Ms Kemp were 16…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1807
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman brought an application against Personnel Contracting Pty Ltd (Construct) in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia alleging breaches of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the Building and Construction General On-Site Award 2010. The case was heard together with VID 1191 of 2018. The central dispute was whether three workers, Jessika Lee, Ieasha Kemp, and Steven Kemp, were employees of Construct or independent contractors. This distinction was crucial as it determined whether the workers were entitled to protections under the Award, including minimum wage rates and conditions.

The court had to decide whether the nature of the contractual relationship between Construct and the workers was one of employment or that of a principal and a self-employed contractor. The Fair Work Ombudsman argued that the workers were employees, while Construct maintained that they were independent contractors. The determination hinged on various factors, including the terms of the Administrative Service Agreement (ASA), the degree of control exercised by Construct over the workers, and the workers' entitlement to negotiate for better terms and conditions.

The court found that the relationship between Construct and the workers was not one of employment but rather that of a principal and self-employed contractors. This conclusion was based on the express terms of the ASA, which identified the workers as independent contractors. The court also considered the lack of control by Construct over the workers, the absence of paid leave and other employee entitlements, and the workers' lack of business operations on their own account. The workers were unskilled labourers who had never set up a separate business, which aligned with the court's reasoning in a similar case (VID 1191 of 2018).

Accordingly, the Fair Work Ombudsman's application was dismissed. The court held that since the workers were not employees of Construct, the Award did not apply to them, and therefore the allegations of breach and for damages made by the Fair Work Ombudsman did not arise. The court ordered that the proceeding be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In her 15 May affidavit, Mrs Kemp said the following:9.In my First Affidavit, at paragraphs 7 and 12, I said that each interview lasted about 30 minutes. By this, I mean the time that both Jessika and Ieasha were meeting with John one-on-one. I still believe this to be correct. However, if I included the time that John took to introduce himself to each of us, the time that we were in the Office might have been longer, perhaps 40 minutes.10.At the conclusion of each of the interviews, neither Jessika nor Ieasha were carrying any documents.Evidence of Ms Jessika Lee Ms Lee swore two affidavits, sworn 8 March and 15 May 2019 respectively. Ms Lee said that in August 2016, when she was 16 years old, Ms Lee asked her step-father, Mr Steven Kemp, if he could help her find a job. He arranged for an interview with Construct, and told Ms Lee that she would need a “white card”, which she obtained online on 7 August. She described her interview with John van der Plas relevantly as follows:15.At the start of the meeting, I recall that John explained the interview process to me. I cannot now recall exactly what he said but he said something like, “This is not a formal interview. You already have the job and we are just signing you off on the formalities.”16.During the interview (though I cannot now recall at what point), John showed me the following documents:(a) Administrative Service Agreement (ASA);(b) Construct – Frequently Asked Questions; and(c) Construct – Guide to Working at a Glance.…I was not given copies of these documents during or after the interview.17.I cannot now recall what John said to me about these documents but I do recall that he spoke about them very quickly. I also recall thinking that I did not know or understand any of what John was reading and I was not sure what the ASA was. I did not ask any questions about the documents as I was too scared and wanted to get the job.18.I also do not recall signing the ASA but I have now been shown a copy … by the Applicant’s lawyers in preparing this affidavit and recognise the signature as my own.19.During the meeting, I recall that John asked me in substance if I had a superannuation account. I did not know so he either left the room or opened the door (I cannot now recall) and asked my Mum. He then asked me to fill out a form for my superannuation.20.I also recall that John asked me about my tax file number but I did not have one at that time. I think he said to me something like, “You will need to get a tax file number within the first two weeks of working on site”… I recall only completing Section A of the form during the interview and I was not provided with a completed form after the meeting.21.To the best of my recollection, we did not speak about the job and what I would be doing on site during the meeting.22.The meeting finished after about 30 minutes. At the end of the meeting, I recall John saying to me something like, “I will text you with details about the job soon. On site you will have to wear high-vis, a hard hat and steel capped boots. You will get the hard-hat on site but need to purchase the other items.” I cannot now recall if John told me where to purchase these items.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The relevant legal principles are set out at VID 1191 at [115]-[129]. I will not repeat them here.CONSIDERATION The FWO did not dispute that Construct intended to engage each of the workers as independent contractors, and he, like the CFMMEU in VID 1191 disavowed any suggestion of sham or pretence. I will not repeat what I said in VID 1191 in relation to the express terms of the ASA, in particular, about the statements about the status of the workers as independent contractors. I will also not repeat what I said about the issues of control, ([134]-[147]), running a business ([148]-[157]), mode of remuneration ([158]-[159]), provisions of tools and equipment ([160]-[163]), integration into the organisation ([164]-[165]), the right to negotiate increases ([166]), taxation and superannuation ([167]-[168]) and the absence of paid leave and other employee entitlements ([169]). My observations and reasons in those paragraphs apply equally here, because, as I have observed, ultimately the FWO did not rely on any particular differences between his case and that involving Mr McCourt in VID 1191, other than those referred to above at [84]-[88]. In the end, the case put on behalf of the FWO was the same case advanced on behalf of the CFMMEU in VID 1191, save for the submissions recorded at [81]-[93] of these reasons. It may be accepted that the fact that Ms Lee and Ms Kemp were minors, and had never had a job before, is sufficient in the circumstances of this case to establish that neither of them was running their own business. But for reasons I have explained in VID 1191, it was obvious on the facts there that Mr McCourt also did not operate a business on his own account. He, like Ms Lee and Ms Kemp (and Mr James for that matter), was an unskilled labourer, who had never set up a separate business. In those circumstances, the fact that the workers, like Mr McCourt, did not operate a business on their own account is one indicator in the context of the multi-factorial approach, that he was an employee, for the reasons I explained in VID 1191 at [148]-[157]. To the extent that Mr French submitted that because all three workers were young and inexperienced, they were, as a matter of practical reality, unable to take time off when they wanted to, two things should be said. First, that is not consistent with the evidence concerning Ms Kemp, who asked for and was allowed time off to celebrate her 18th birthday. Secondly, even assuming the point to be a good one, it would weigh only slightly in the balance, and would not, and does not, cause me to reach a view different to the conclusions I expressed at [170]ff on my reasons in VID 1191. Further, as Mr Blackburn submitted, there is no evidence from any of the workers in this case that Construct (as opposed to Hanssen) exercised any relevant control over them. DISPOSITION For the reasons set out above, the workers were not employees of Construct. The Award does not apply to him, so the allegations of breach and for damages made in the proceeding by the FWO do not arise.