Conservation Council of SA Inc v Chapman

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

CONSERVATION COUNCIL OF SA & ORS v CHAPMAN & ORS

[2003] SASC 398

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Gray and Besanko JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ:          I have had the advantage of reading the reasons prepared by Besanko J.

  2. I am content to rely on his comprehensive statement of the relevant facts and issues.  I propose to add some observations on some of the issues to be decided in this appeal.

    Publication No 6

  3. I agree with the conclusions of Besanko J.

  4. I will state my reasons for deciding that the publication was not one that concerned matters that attract Constitutional protection in the form of an extended defence of qualified privilege.  I do so because of the general importance of the topic.  I will also state briefly my reasons for agreeing with Besanko J that the finding of malice by the trial Judge be set aside, recognising as I do that such a finding is not lightly set aside.

  5. In Lange v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (1997) 189 CLR 520 the High Court said at 559:

    “Freedom of communication on matters of government and politics is an indispensable incident of that system of representative government which the Constitution creates…”

    The recognition and protection of that freedom of communication required some modification of the common law, because in some respects the common law of defamation restricted freedom of speech to an extent inconsistent with the constitutional requirement.  In particular, the constitutional requirement called for a relaxation of the common law approach that in other than exceptional cases a claim of qualified privilege was not available in respect of a communication to the general public: at 570.

  6. It is important to bear in mind that the constitutional requirement of freedom of communication is anchored in the text of the Constitution. As the court said (at 561):

    “However, the freedom of communication which the Constitution protects is not absolute. It is limited to what is necessary for the effective operation of that system of representative and responsible government provided for by the Constitution.” (footnote omitted)

    That led to the statement of principle set out below (at 571 – 572):

    “ Accordingly, this Court should now declare that each member of the Australian community has an interest in disseminating and receiving information, opinions and arguments concerning government and political matters that affect the people of Australia. The duty to disseminate such information is simply the correlative of the interest in receiving it. The common convenience and welfare of Australian society are advanced by discussion – the giving and receiving of information – about government and political matters. The interest that each member of the Australian community has in such a discussion extends the categories of qualified privilege. Consequently, those categories now must be recognised as protecting a communication made to the public on a government or political matter. It may be that, in some respects, the common law defence as so extended goes beyond what is required for the common law of defamation to be compatible with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Conservation Council of SA Inc v Chapman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 398
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Conservation Council of SA Inc v Chapman involved an appeal against an award of damages for defamation. The plaintiffs, Thomas Lincoln Chapman, Wendy Jennifer Chapman, and Andrew Lincoln Chapman, sought damages arising from eleven publications made by the Conservation Council of South Australia Inc, Margaret Bolster, Professor David Shearman, and Richard Owen. The trial judge had awarded damages to the plaintiffs for three specific publications, finding them defamatory, and dismissed the claims regarding the other publications. The defendants challenged the trial judge's conclusions, arguing errors in fact and law, particularly questioning the findings of malice.

The central legal issues were whether the publications were defamatory, the applicability of various defences such as justification, fair comment, and qualified privilege, and the determination of damages. Additionally, the appeal focused on the trial judge's findings of malice and the appropriateness of the awarded damages. The court had to evaluate the evidence presented and the arguments regarding the defamatory nature of the publications, the validity of the defences, and the quantum of damages awarded.

In ruling on the appeal, the court found that the trial judge had erred in some aspects of his reasoning and conclusions. The appellate court allowed the appeal, setting aside the original judgment and orders. It substituted a new judgment awarding damages to the first and second plaintiffs against the first, second, and fourth defendants, while dismissing the claims against the other defendants. The appellate court ordered that the first and second plaintiffs each receive $25,000 in damages. The court noted that it would hear the parties on the question of costs.

The final orders of the court included the allowance of the appeal, the setting aside of the original judgment and orders, the substitution of a new judgment awarding damages to the plaintiffs, and the dismissal of the claims against other defendants. The court also noted that it would consider the issue of costs separately.

Background

Background to the litigation

In March 1994, Binalong, a company involved in constructing a bridge, sought and obtained an ex parte injunction in the Federal Court against entities and persons involved in picketing and obstructing the bridge work. This injunction was continued against seven respondents in April 1994. Around the same time, the Aboriginal Legal Rights Movement sought protection of the proposed bridge site under the Heritage Protection Act 1988 (Cth), leading to an emergency declaration by the Federal Minister in May 1994, banning bridge construction work for 30 days. This declaration was extended for another 30 days in June 1994. A report prepared by Professor Cheryl Saunders under the Heritage Protection Act concluded that the bridge, if constructed, would affect a significant Aboriginal area, adjacent to a known Aboriginal site and crucial to the Ngarrindjeri people's reproduction and existence.

In July 1994, Thomas Lincoln Chapman, Wendy Jennifer Chapman, and their son Andrew Chapman initiated judicial review proceedings in the Federal Court against the Federal Minister’s decision to make a declaration under the Heritage Protection Act. The Federal Court set aside the Minister’s decision, and an appeal by the Minister to the Full Federal Court was dismissed. This led to the establishment of a State Royal Commission in June 1995 to investigate whether alleged secret "women’s business" was a fabrication. The Royal Commissioner reported in December 1995 that the secret "women’s business" was a fabrication intended to prevent the bridge's construction. In June 1995, the Federal Minister announced an independent enquiry into the significance of Hindmarsh Island to Aboriginal people, conducted by Justice Jane Matthews. This was followed by the enactment of the Hindmarsh Island Bridge Act 1997 (Cth) in March 1996, which was unsuccessfully challenged in the High Court in April 1998, allowing bridge construction to proceed. Construction began in late October 1999 and was completed on 4 March 2001.

This matter is an appeal against the trial judgment in Conservation Council of SA Inc v Chapman, in which the plaintiffs claimed damages for defamation arising from eleven publications. The trial judge awarded damages against the defendants, finding that publications 6, 7, and 11 were defamatory, and dismissed claims relating to all other publications. The judge also rejected the defences of justification, fair comment, common law qualified privilege, and extended qualified privilege, and found that the defendants were motivated by express malice. On appeal, the defendants challenged many aspects of the judge's reasons and conclusions, contending that the judge made errors of fact and law and that his findings of malice were not open on the evidence. This appeal followed a judicial review application in the Federal Court, which set aside the Federal Minister's declaration under the Heritage Protection Act. The decision was upheld on appeal to the Full Federal Court. The matter also involved a State Royal Commission and an independent enquiry conducted by Justice Jane Matthews, as well as legislative intervention and a High Court challenge to the Hindmarsh Island Bridge Act 1997 (Cth). The construction of the bridge eventually proceeded, with work commencing in late October 1999 and completion on 4 March 2001.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I agree with the reasons given by Besanko J in relation to this publication.Conclusion I would allow the appeal. I would set aside the judgment and orders made at trial. I would order that there be substituted a judgment for the first and second plaintiffs in the sum of $25,000 against the first, second and fourth defendants, and an order that otherwise the claims made by the plaintiffs against the defendants be dismissed. It will be necessary to hear the parties on the question of cost.GRAY JIntroduction This is an appeal against an award of damages for defamation. The plaintiffs, Thomas Lincoln Chapman, Wendy Jennifer Chapman and Andrew Lincoln Chapman claimed damages for defamation arising from eleven publications. The claims were made against the Conservation Council of South Australia Inc, Margaret Bolster, Professor David Shearman and Richard Owen. On 30 September 2002 a judge of this court ordered that Mrs Chapman recover $20,000 from the Conservation Council and Mr Shearman in respect of a publication described as “publication 6”, that Mr Chapman and Mrs Chapman each recover $25,000 from Ms Bolster, Mr Owen and the Conservation Council in respect of a publication described as “publication 7”, and that Mr and Mrs Chapman each recover $30,000 from the Conservation Council in respect of a publication described as “publication 11”. The claims involving all other publications were dismissed. The learned trial judge concluded that publications 6, 7 and 11 were defamatory. The defences of justification, fair comment, common law qualified privilege and extended qualified privilege were rejected.[1] The judge found that the defendants were motivated by express malice.[1] Lange v Australian Broadcasting Commission (1997) 189 CLR 520. The judge ordered that Mr and Mrs Chapman recover costs fixed at $50,000. The Conservation Council and Mr Shearman were held to be jointly and separately liable for $10,000; the Conservation Council, Ms Bolster and Mr Owen jointly and severally liable for $20,000, and the Conservation Council liable for an additional $20,000. On appeal counsel for the defendants challenged many aspects of the judge’s reasons and his conclusions. Most issues raised during the trial were reventilated on appeal. It was contended that the judge made errors of fact and law. It was said that his findings of malice were not open on the evidence. The PartiesThe plaintiffs Mr and Mrs Chapman are husband and wife. Andrew Chapman is their adult son. Mrs Chapman had an extensive involvement in public affairs. She was a former Lord Mayor of Adelaide. She was made a Member of the Order of Australia in 1986 for services to local government and the community. Mr Chapman was an experienced land developer. He too had extensive involvement in public affairs. He had been a prominent figure in service organizations and had served as the president of the National Council of Independent Schools. All claims brought by Andrew Chapman were dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In March 1994 Binalong sought and obtained an ex parte injunction in the Federal Court pursuant to section 45D of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the TPA”) against persons and entities involved in picketing and obstructing bridge work. In April 1994 the Federal Court continued an interlocutory injunction against seven of the ten respondents.Heritage Protection Act Declarations In April 1994 the Aboriginal Legal Rights Movement sought protection of the proposed bridge site under the Heritage Protection Act 1988 (Cth). In May 1994 an emergency declaration was made by the Federal Minister under section 9 of the Heritage Protection Act. This declaration had the effect of banning bridge construction work for 30 days. In June 1994 the declaration was extended for a further 30 days. Professor Cheryl Saunders prepared a report pursuant to the Heritage Protection Act at the request of the Federal Minister. The report concluded that, if constructed, the bridge would affect a significant Aboriginal area. It was said that the immediately surrounding area was adjacent to a known Aboriginal site, skeletal remains, known and anticipated were present in the area; and that the proposed bridge site was within an area regarded by Ngarrindjeri women as crucial to the reproduction of the Ngarrindjeri people and their continued existence.Judicial Review Proceedings In July 1994 Mr and Mrs Chapman and Andrew Chapman commenced proceedings in the Federal Court for judicial review of the Federal Minister’s decision to make a declaration pursuant to the Heritage Protection Act. His decision was set aside by the Federal Court. An appeal to the Full Federal Court by the Minister was dismissed. State Royal Commission In late 1994 through to mid 1995 considerable media debate continued. In June 1995 the State government announced that a Royal Commission would be established to enquire into and report about whether alleged secret “women’s business” was a fabrication. A Royal Commissioner was appointed. The commissioner reported in December 1995 that the whole of the secret “women’s business” was a fabrication. The commissioner was of the view that the purpose of the fabrication was to obtain the declaration under the Heritage Protection Act to prevent the construction of the bridge.Federal Inquiry In June 1995 the Federal Minister advised that there would be an independent enquiry into the significance of Hindmarsh Island to Aboriginal people. This enquiry was to be conducted by Justice Jane Matthews. In December 1995 following the dismissal of the Full Federal Court appeal, the Federal Minister announced that procedures had been set in train for the preparation of a further report under the Heritage Protection Act by Justice Matthews. Challenges were initiated in the High Court concerning the appointment of Justice Matthews. Legislative Intervention and High Court Challenge There was a change of Federal government in March 1996. The Hindmarsh Island Bridge Act 1997 (Cth) was enacted. This legislation was challenged unsuccessfully in the High Court in April 1998. The construction of the bridge could now proceed. Work commenced in late October 1999 and the bridge construction was completed on 4 March 2001.Conclusions