Coffey LPM Pty Ltd v The Contaminated Sites Committee

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   COFFEY LPM PTY LTD -v- THE CONTAMINATED SITES COMMITTEE [2014] WASC 504

CORAM:   CHANEY J

HEARD:   27 AUGUST 2014

DELIVERED          :   23 DECEMBER 2014

FILE NO/S:   GDA 4 of 2014

BETWEEN:   COFFEY LPM PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

THE CONTAMINATED SITES COMMITTEE
First Respondent

WA SEAFOOD EXPORTERS PTY LTD
Second Respondent

WESFARMERS KLEENHEAT GAS PTY LTD
Third Respondent

CALTEX AUSTRALIA PETROLEUM PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent

ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA
MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT
Interveners

FILE NO/S              :GDA 2 of 2014

BETWEEN              :COFFEY LPM PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

THE CONTAMINATED SITES COMMITTEE
First Respondent

WINEBERRY HOLDINGS PTY LTD
Second Respondent

WESFARMERS KLEENHEAT GAS PTY LTD
Third Respondent

WA SEAFOOD EXPORTERS PTY LTD
Fourth Defendant

ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA
MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT
Interveners

FILE NO/S              :GDA 3 of 2014

BETWEEN              :COFFEY LPM PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

THE CONTAMINATED SITES COMMITTEE
First Respondent

CITY OF STIRLING
Second Respondent

WESFARMERS KLEENHEAT GAS PTY LTD
Third Respondent

WA SEAFOOD EXPORTERS PTY LTD
Fourth Respondent

ATTORNEY GENERAL FOR WESTERN AUSTRALIA
MINISTER FOR ENVIRONMENT
Interveners

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  CONTAMINATED SITES COMMITTEE

Coram  :J MALCOLM CP AND OTHERS

File No  :CSC 19 of 2008

For File No               :  GDA 2 of 2014

Jurisdiction              :  CONTAMINATED SITES COMMITTEE

Coram  :J MALCOLM CP AND OTHERS

File No  :CSC 3 of 2013

For File No               :  GDA 3 of 2014

Jurisdiction              :  CONTAMINATED SITES COMMITTEE

Coram  :J MALCOLM CP AND OTHERS

File No  :CSC 4 of 2013

Catchwords:

Administrative Law - Contaminated sites - Nature of appeal against determination of Contaminated Sites Committee - Whether errors of law - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Criminal Code 1913 (WA)
Contaminated Sites Act 2003 (WA)
Contaminated Sites Regulations 2006 (WA)
Environmental Protection Act 1986 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA)

Result:

Appeals GDA 2 and 3 allowed
Matter remitted to Committee
Appeal GDA 4 dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

GDA 4 of 2014

Counsel:

Appellant:     Dr J T Schoombee

First Respondent           :     No appearance

Second Respondent       :     No appearance

Third Respondent         :     No appearance

Fourth Respondent        :     Mr C S Williams

Interveners                   :     Mr R M Mitchell SC & Mr F Sunderland

Solicitors:

Appellant:     SRB Legal

First Respondent           :     No appearance

Second Respondent       :     DLA Piper Australia

Third Respondent         :     Hardy Bowen

Fourth Respondent        :     Solomon Brothers

Interveners                   :     State Solicitor for Western Australia

GDA 2 of 2014

Counsel:

Appellant:     Dr J T Schoombee

First Respondent           :     No appearance

Second Respondent       :     No appearance

Third Respondent         :     No appearance

Fourth Defendant          :     No appearance

Interveners                   :     Mr R M Mitchell SC & Mr F Sunderland

Solicitors:

Appellant:     SRB Legal

First Respondent           :     No appearance

Second Respondent       :     Bradley Bayly Legal

Third Respondent         :     Hardy Bowen

Fourth Defendant          :     DLA Piper Australia

Interveners                   :     State Solicitor for Western Australia

GDA 3 of 2014

Counsel:

Appellant:     Dr J T Schoombee

First Respondent           :     No appearance

Second Respondent       :     No appearance

Third Respondent         :…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coffey LPM Pty Ltd v The Contaminated Sites Committee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] WASC 504
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Coffey LPM Pty Ltd v The Contaminated Sites Committee, the Court of Appeal of Western Australia addressed a dispute concerning the procedural fairness requirements applicable to the Contaminated Sites Committee when making decisions about responsibility for remediation under the Contaminated Sites Act 2003 (WA). Coffey LPM Pty Ltd, a respondent to a notice issued by the Committee, sought an oral hearing and the opportunity to cross-examine witnesses before the Committee made its decision on responsibility for remediation. The Committee declined this request, asserting that no statutory requirement mandated an oral hearing. The Court of Appeal was tasked with determining whether the Committee's refusal to hold an oral hearing constituted an error of law and whether it breached procedural fairness.

The legal issues before the Court included whether the statutory framework of the Contaminated Sites Act imposed any obligation on the Committee to conduct an oral hearing and provide an opportunity for cross-examination of witnesses. The Court examined the relevant provisions of the Act, including sections 34, 37, and 38, to ascertain the legislative intent regarding the Committee's decision-making process. Additionally, the Court considered the principles of procedural fairness and whether the absence of an oral hearing and cross-examination could result in a substantial injustice or practical unfairness to the parties involved.

The Court concluded that the Act did not mandate an oral hearing or the opportunity for cross-examination, and thus, the Committee was not required to hold such a hearing as a matter of law. The Court emphasized that the Act empowered the Committee to conduct its enquiries "in any manner it considers appropriate" and lacked provisions specifically addressing oral hearings or the compulsory attendance and examination of witnesses. Furthermore, the Court found that the applicant would not suffer substantial injustice or practical unfairness without an oral hearing, as the merits of expert opinions could be effectively addressed through written submissions. Consequently, the Committee's decision not to hold an oral hearing did not constitute an error of law or breach of procedural fairness.

The Court of Appeal upheld the decision of the Contaminated Sites Committee, affirming that no legal error was committed in declining the request for an oral hearing. The Court's decision clarified the procedural requirements under the Contaminated Sites Act, emphasizing that the statutory framework does not necessitate oral hearings or cross-examination as part of the decision-making process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 38 specifies the matters to be taken into account by the Committee in making a decision as to responsibility for remediation. It provides:38.Matters to be taken into account in making a decision as to responsibility for remediation (1)A decision as to responsibility for remediation is to be made in accordance with Division 1 and the section which empowers the decision to be made. (2)In making a decision as to responsibility for remediation the committee is to take into consideration ‑ (a)the contents of any notice given by the committee under section 37; and (b)any submission made to the committee referred to in section 37(e) and any information or documents provided in support of the reasons given in that submission, and may take into consideration any other matters the committee considers relevant. By s 39, the Committee is required to give notice of a decision as to responsibility for remediation specifying as to who is responsible for remediation and to what extent, the section of the CS Act under which the decision is made, the reasons for the decision and advise of the right to appeal under s 77. Section 40 provides a right of appeal in accordance with s 77. As has already been noted, s 77 provides for a right of appeal to the Supreme Court on a question of law. It imposes a time limit of 21 days for the commencement of appeal after the notice under s 39. Provision is made for the court to extend time. Section 77(4) specifies that no appeal lies against the decision as to remediation except on a question of law. I note in passing that neither the CS Act nor a decision of the Committee as to responsibility for remediation affects any liability in contract or tort in respect of contamination of the land concerned.[8][8] Contaminated Sites Act 2003 (WA) s 9(4). The WASE decision commences with a recitation of the background to the proceedings. It recites that the WASE site was classified under the CS Act as 'contaminated ‑ remediation required' on 7 May 2008. It recites that notice was given under s 37 of the CS Act on 21 March 2012 to all relevant parties being WASE, WKG, Caltex (the previous operator of the site) and Coffey. Submissions were received from WASE, WKG and Coffey on 26 April 2012. It then recites previous proceedings whereby Coffey sought prerogative relief in relation to the s 37 notice.[9] Those proceedings were unsuccessful and the Committee then sought and received further submissions from Coffey, WKG and WASE before making its final decision on 27 August 2013.[9] Coffey LPM Pty Ltd v Contaminated Sites Committee [No 2] [2013] WASC 98. The Committee then outlined the history of the occupation and use of the site. It found that a service station has been operating on the site since 1973. WASE purchased the site on 27 July 1988, at which time Caltex Properties Ltd was operating the service station as it had been for some years. In January 1999, Caltex Properties Ltd was deregistered and Caltex Australia Petroleum Pty Ltd took over the leasehold responsibilities until 31 July 1999 when WKG commenced leasing the site. New tanks and pipes were installed in May and June 1999, at which time soil investigations had been carried out and the newly installed pipes and tanks had been integrity tested.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

His Honour continued at [56] to [57]:In this case there are a number of aspects of the statutory context which are inconsistent with any requirement that the committee is required to hold an oral hearing before giving an applicant a notice under s 37. First, as noted earlier, neither the Act nor the regulations confer power on the committee to compel witnesses to attend for examination or cross-examination. The committee would therefore only be able to carry out an oral hearing of the kind sought by the applicant if the persons who the applicant wishes to cross-examine attended voluntarily and agreed to answer the questions which the applicant wishes to pose. Secondly, the committee has no power to administer oaths or affirmations to witnesses: See s 6 of the Oaths, Affidavits and Statutory Declarations Act 2005 (WA). Thirdly, the committee is constituted as an administrative committee that may, but is not required to, include a person with legal qualifications. Fourthly, the fact that s 37 refers only to the making of written submissions after a s 37 notice is given tends to suggest that the process as a whole is not one intended to include oral hearings.Where legislation does not mandate an oral hearing, or contemplate such a hearing occurring as a matter of course, a right to such a hearing may be less readily inferred as being required by the rules of procedural fairness. A requirement to provide an oral hearing will be more readily inferred where the statute provides the necessary framework for such a hearing to occur: NAHF v The Minister for Immigration (2003) 128 FCR 351 [34]. In my view,•the absence of any provisions in the Act or the Regulations specifically dealing with an oral hearing;•the absence of any power to require witnesses to answer questions, or to compel attendance;•the power to require the provision of information being limited to written requests; and•s 34 of the Act which requires the Committee to conduct its enquiries 'in any manner it considers appropriate',inexorably lead to the conclusion that the requirements of procedural fairness so far as they apply to the Committee do not require the holding of an oral hearing and an opportunity to cross‑examine witnesses. I note in passing that s 34 of the CS Act might be contrasted with s 32 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) which contains a specific requirement to provide parties with an opportunity to examine, cross‑examine and re‑examine witnesses. As Hall J observed in Coffey LPM Pty Ltd v Contaminated Sites Committee [No 2]:[12]It is not apparent in this case that the applicant would suffer a substantial injustice or practical unfairness or be denied the opportunity to challenge the conclusions reached by Mr Sims if an oral hearing was not conducted. The relative merits of the competing expert opinions rely on the thoroughness, consistency and logicality of the reports. These are matters which can be addressed in written submissions; indeed, they are likely to be better addressed in that manner with evidence of this type which depends less on demeanour and more on questions of accuracy and intellectual rigour.[12] Coffey LPM Pty Ltd v Contaminated Sites Committee [No 2] [2013] WASC 98 [62].