Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCA 1133

Citation: Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCA 1133
Parties: CLASUL PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 173 029), CHRISTINE ALBERTA HOSKING and PAUL RAYMOND BURNS & GLENN RAYMOND BURNS v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
File number: NSD 368 of 2013
Judge: GLEESON J
Date of judgment: 23 October 2014
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to amend originating application and statement of claim – where amendment raises new cause of action – where new cause of action is time-barred – whether new cause of action arises out of substantially the same facts as currently pleaded – leave granted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to amend statement of claim – whether amendment pleads material facts – leave granted  

Legislation: Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) ss 5B, 5C
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 59(2B) Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 8.03, 8.21, 16.02, 16.51, 16.53
Cases cited: Agtrack (NT) Pty Ltd (t/as Spring Air) v Hatfield (2003) 7 VR 63
Allonnor Pty Ltd v Doran [1998] QCA 372
Borsato v Campbell [2006] QSC 191
Brickfield Properties Ltd v Newton [1971] 1 WLR 862
Caltex Refineries (Qld) Pty Ltd v Stavar (2009) 75 NSWLR 649
Carter, in the matter of Spec FS NSW Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) [2013] FCA 1027
Charlie Carter Pty Ltd v SDAEA (WA) (1987) 13 FCR 413
Collins v Hertfordshire County Council [1947] KB 598
Darcy v Medtel Pty Limited(No 3) [2004] FCA 807
Darling Island Stevedoring & Lighterage Co Ltd v Long (1957) 97 CLR 36
Do Carmo v Ford Excavations Pty Ltd (1984) 154 CLR 234
Dornan v J.W. Ellis & Co Ltd [1962] 1 QB 583
Draney v Barry [2002] 1 Qd R 145
Hollis v Vabu Pty Ltd (2001) 207 CLR 21
McGrath v HNSW Pty Ltd (2014) 308 ALR 542
Motorcycling Events Group Australia Pty Ltd v Kelly [2013] NSWCA 361
New Cap Reinsurance Corporation v Reaseguros Alianza SA (2004) 186 FLR 175
New South Wales v Radford (2010) 79 NSWLR 327
Parker v Commonwealth (1965) 112 CLR 295
Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 589
Roe v Minister for Health [1954] 2 QB 66
Thomas v State of Queensland [2001] QCA 336
University of Sydney v ResMed Limited (No 5) [2012] FCA 232
Wardley Australia Ltd v Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514
Weldon v Neal (1887) 19 QBD 394
Weston v Publishing and Broadcasting Ltd (2011) 83 ACSR 206
Date of hearing: 3 September 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 82
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr Alec Leopold SC with Mr Declan Roche
Solicitor for the Applicants: Maurice Blackburn Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Robert Weber SC with Mr Scott Nixon
Solicitor for the Respondent: Ashurst Australia

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 368 of 2013

BETWEEN:

CLASUL PTY LIMITED (ACN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clasul Pty Ltd v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 1133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Clasul Pty Ltd and others sought leave to amend their originating application and statement of claim to include a claim against Mr Turner, a Regional Manager for New South Wales within the Department. The applicants sought to amend their pleadings to allege that Mr Turner was negligent in his role and responsibility over the management and operation of the Quarantine Station. The Commonwealth opposed the application on the basis that the proposed amendment raised a new cause of action which was time-barred, and that the new cause of action did not arise out of substantially the same facts as the current pleadings.

The court found that the proposed amendment did arise out of substantially the same facts as the current pleadings. The court held that the new cause of action arose out of the same episode, being the outbreak of equine influenza from the Quarantine Station, and the alleged wrongful omission or omissions were substantially overlapping. The court also found that the new facts pleaded were material to the applicants' case and would require findings about Mr Turner's roles and responsibilities, his actual and constructive knowledge and other matters necessary to decide whether he personally owed a duty of care to the applicants. The court held that the proposed amendment pleaded a material fact, namely Mr Turner's actual knowledge as to the operation of the Quarantine Station, which was within a very narrow compass.

The court granted leave to the applicants to amend their originating application and statement of claim to include a claim against Mr Turner. The matter was stood over to 29 October 2014 for argument on the question of the costs of the applicants' amended interlocutory application dated 21 August 2014.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be granted to the applicants to amend the further amended origination application in the form of annexure “MPW1” to the affidavit of Murray Patrick Watt affirmed on 8 August 2014.

2. Leave be granted to the applicants to amend the third further amended statement of claim in the form behind tab 5 of the bundle of materials provided to the Court on 3 September 2014.

3. The matter be stood over to 29 October 2014 for argument on the question of the costs of the applicants’ amended interlocutory application dated 21 August 2014.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

There is a significant degree of commonality between the alleged negligence of Mr Turner, and Messrs Hankins and Hamid, in that each is alleged to have failed to do the following things:(1)Implement the “Live Horses Work Instruction” and the “Operations Manual for Horses” (“Operations Manual”) at the Quarantine Station;(2)Check and audit the requirements of the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual were being implemented at the Quarantine Station and or take all reasonable steps to ensure that that was occurring; and(3)To the extent that they were not already covered by the Live Horses Work Instruction and/or the Operations Manual, take all reasonable steps to ensure that strict procedures of a kind already pleaded were being implemented.Turner amendments: New and different facts The applicants contend that the only substantially different facts from those already pleaded concern Mr Turner’s actual knowledge as to the operation of the Quarantine Station (see proposed paragraph 147A(a)) and as to a November 2003 review of the “Live Animal Import offices” within the Department. The applicants submitted, and I accept, that these allegations are within a very narrow compass. Mr Turner’s alleged negligence comprises nine omissions, set out in paragraph 306A of the proposed statement of claim. As well as the three omissions set out in paragraph 54 above, it is alleged that Mr Turner failed to do the following things: (1)Take all reasonable steps to ensure the Manager and staff of the Quarantine Station were aware of, familiar with and trained in any procedures they were required to follow in respect of the live animal imports and post-entry animal quarantine program for horses;(2)Take reasonable steps to implement processes by which he could be assured that AQIS employees at the Quarantine Station knew what work instructions or standard operating procedures applied to their work;(3)Take reasonable steps to implement systems to ensure that operating procedures and work instructions were complied with at the Quarantine Station;(4)Take reasonable steps to implement systems to ensure that the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual were complied with at the Quarantine Station;(5)Take reasonable steps to ensure that appropriate officers were auditing compliance with operating procedures and work instructions at the Quarantine Station;(6)Take reasonable steps to ensure that appropriate officers were auditing compliance with the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual at the Quarantine Station;(7)Take reasonable steps to implement adequate processes to alert him of non-compliance with the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual at the Quarantine Station. The Commonwealth’s opposition to the Turner amendments emphasised the necessarily different elements of a claim based on vicarious liability. That is, the new case is based on allegations as to Mr Turner’s duty of care, Mr Turner’s breaches of duty and whether Mr Turner’s breaches caused the alleged loss. As to duty of care, the new case will require findings about Mr Turner’s roles and responsibilities, his actual and constructive knowledge and other matters necessary to decide whether he personally owed a duty to the applicants. The Commonwealth contended that a correct analysis makes plain that all of the critical elements of a claim of vicarious liability for alleged negligence of an employee involved consideration of matters unique to that employee. It was contended that the problem with the proposed amendments is of a “quite fundamental nature and inherently caught up with the very concept of vicarious liability”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As a matter of detail, the Commonwealth noted that unlike all the other Commonwealth employees whose negligence is alleged in the current statement of claim, Mr Turner did not work at the Quarantine Station. As Regional Manager for New South Wales within the Department, his responsibility was considerably wider than merely the Quarantine Station.Turner amendments: conclusion I am satisfied that the Turner amendments arise out of substantially the same facts as already pleaded. In my view, cases such as Allonor, Draney and Collins tend to support a conclusion that the question is to be determined at the level of generality submitted by the applicants, rather than the Commonwealth. Although I accept the correctness of the Commonwealth’s analysis as to the elements of the new case which the applicants seek to bring, I do not accept that the analysis precludes a conclusion that it arises out of substantially the same facts as the case currently pleaded. In my view, the new case does arise out of substantially the same facts being:(1)the harm suffered by the group members;(2)the outbreak of equine influenza from the Quarantine Station in August 2007, which is said to have resulted in that harm;(3)the circumstances of the management and operation of the Quarantine Station. Those latter circumstances include the very many factual matters relevant to whether one or more Commonwealth employees owed a duty of care to the applicants in connection with the management and operation of the Quarantine Station;(4)the alleged failure to implement the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual at the Quarantine Station;(5)the alleged failure to adopt, or to take all reasonable steps to ensure that, strict procedures were implemented of the kind alleged in the current statement of claim. In this case, the applicants’ case can be fairly characterised as arising out of a single episode, which is the outbreak of equine influenza from the Quarantine Station. The fundamental question is whether the Commonwealth is liable, directly or vicariously, in negligence for the applicants’ losses following the outbreak. In my opinion, the question whether the “overlap is so great that the new cause of action can fairly be said to arise out of substantially the same facts as the old cause of action” is determined by reference to main elements of the cause of action in negligence which are, as Wilson J said in Do Carmo, the wrongful act or omission and the consequent damage. In this case, the alleged damage is identical, and the old and new cases are substantially overlapping as to the alleged wrongful omission or omissions. There is an issue as to which Commonwealth employee or employees, if anyone, was responsible for the alleged wrongful omission or omissions. However, in this case, in my opinion, the introduction of new facts designed to establish the Commonwealth’s liability for all possible wrongdoers in respect of the same damage for the failure to prevent the outbreak of equine influenza in August 2007 does not detract from a conclusion that the overlap between new and old causes of action is so great that it can fairly be said that they each arise out of substantially the same facts.Discretionary factors

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Weston v Publishing and Broadcasting Ltd (2011) 83 ACSR 206 at [592], Ward J expressed the view that the question whether a proposed “new cause of action” arises out of “substantially the same” set of facts is to be answered as a matter of general impression, rather than requiring precise similarity of factual circumstances and it is not necessary that all facts be material to each separate cause of action (citing Brickfield at 880). See also New Cap Reinsurance Corporation v Reaseguros Alianza SA (2004) 186 FLR 175 at [89] and [93].ConsiderationTurner amendments: The facts currently pleaded At a high level of generality, the case sought to be added arises substantially out of the facts currently pleaded. To adapt some of the language of the cases set out above, the story set up by the applicants is that they suffered losses from the outbreak of equine influenza in August 2007, as a result of the negligence of the Commonwealth in and about the operation of the Quarantine Station. That negligence allegedly includes negligence for which the Commonwealth is directly liable and negligence on the part of various Commonwealth employees in the course of their employment. To make out its case based on Mr Turner’s negligence, the applicants seek to rely on a great many of the facts already pleaded, particularly concerning matters going to the existence of a duty of care such as risk of harm, foreseeability and vulnerability, the actual events of the outbreak of equine influenza from the Quarantine Station and the harm allegedly suffered. There is a significant degree of commonality between the alleged negligence of Mr Turner, and Messrs Hankins and Hamid, in that each is alleged to have failed to do the following things:(1)Implement the “Live Horses Work Instruction” and the “Operations Manual for Horses” (“Operations Manual”) at the Quarantine Station;(2)Check and audit the requirements of the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual were being implemented at the Quarantine Station and or take all reasonable steps to ensure that that was occurring; and(3)To the extent that they were not already covered by the Live Horses Work Instruction and/or the Operations Manual, take all reasonable steps to ensure that strict procedures of a kind already pleaded were being implemented.Turner amendments: New and different facts The applicants contend that the only substantially different facts from those already pleaded concern Mr Turner’s actual knowledge as to the operation of the Quarantine Station (see proposed paragraph 147A(a)) and as to a November 2003 review of the “Live Animal Import offices” within the Department. The applicants submitted, and I accept, that these allegations are within a very narrow compass. Mr Turner’s alleged negligence comprises nine omissions, set out in paragraph 306A of the proposed statement of claim. As well as the three omissions set out in paragraph 54 above, it is alleged that Mr Turner failed to do the following things: (1)Take all reasonable steps to ensure the Manager and staff of the Quarantine Station were aware of, familiar with and trained in any procedures they were required to follow in respect of the live animal imports and post-entry animal quarantine program for horses;(2)Take reasonable steps to implement processes by which he could be assured that AQIS employees at the Quarantine Station knew what work instructions or standard operating procedures applied to their work;(3)Take reasonable steps to implement systems to ensure that operating procedures and work instructions were complied with at the Quarantine Station;(4)Take reasonable steps to implement systems to ensure that the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual were complied with at the Quarantine Station;(5)Take reasonable steps to ensure that appropriate officers were auditing compliance with operating procedures and work instructions at the Quarantine Station;(6)Take reasonable steps to ensure that appropriate officers were auditing compliance with the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual at the Quarantine Station;(7)Take reasonable steps to implement adequate processes to alert him of non-compliance with the Live Horses Work Instruction and the Operations Manual at the Quarantine Station.