Cini v Pets Paradise Franchising (SA) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

CINI & ORS v PETS PARADISE FRANCHISING (SA) PTY LTD & ORS

[2009] SASC 7

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Bleby

16 January 2009

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - CAVEATS AGAINST DEALINGS

Application for leave to lodge fresh caveats under Land Title Act 1994 (Qld) s 129 – caveats previously lodged by applicant removed pursuant to court order – in earlier proceedings, applicants conceded caveats should be removed due to misdescription of caveatable interests – whether serious question to be tried – uncontradicted affidavit evidence of duress in signing documents giving rise to claimed caveatable interest – whether balance of convenience favours lodging fresh caveats – respondents have changed position in such a way that they will suffer detriment if fresh caveats are lodged – substantial delay between removal of original caveats and application to lodge fresh caveats.

Application dismissed – balance of convenience favours respondents - no serious question to be tried with respect to respondent alleging duress.

Landlush Pty Ltd v Rutherford [2002] 1 Qd R 236; Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill (2006) 227 CLR 57; Beecham Group Ltd v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618, applied.
Cini v Pets Paradise Franchising (SA) Pty Ltd [2008] SASC 287; American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396, discussed.
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Ltd (2001) 208 CLR 199; Castlemaine Tooheys Ltd v South Australia (1986) 161 CLR 148, considered.

CINI & ORS v PETS PARADISE FRANCHISING (SA) PTY LTD & ORS
[2009] SASC 7

CINI & ORS v PETS PARADISE FRANCHISING (SA) PTY LTD & ORS

Civil

BLEBY J.

  1. This is an application for leave to lodge fresh caveats over two properties in Queensland, in circumstances where caveats previously lodged by the applicant have been removed pursuant to a court order.  It arises in the context of a broader dispute between eleven plaintiffs and five defendants. 

    Background

  2. The defendants are all related corporations.  The plaintiffs are either parties to franchise agreements with one of the defendants, parties to a guarantee and indemnity agreement relating to the performance of obligations of franchisees who are parties to franchise agreements with one of the defendants, or parties to a guarantee and indemnity agreement relating to the performance of the obligations of such franchisees under a supply agreement with one of the defendants.  The parties are currently engaged in proceedings in the Federal Court, concerning  the validity and enforceability of these agreements.

  3. The applicant for leave to lodge caveats is the third defendant, Pets Paradise Franchising (Queensland) Pty Ltd (“Pets Paradise”).  The respondents to this application are the eighth and ninth plaintiffs, Lynda Campbell and her mother Elizabeth Campbell.

  4. The two properties over which Pets Paradise seeks to lodge fresh caveats are situated at Burleigh Heads and Ipswich.  The Burleigh Heads property is owned by Lynda Campbell and her husband Karl Donnelly as joint tenants, while the Ipswich property is held as tenants…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cini v Pets Paradise Franchising (SA) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The present case involves Pets Paradise Franchising (SA) Pty Ltd, trading as Pets Paradise, which sought leave to lodge fresh caveats over two properties in Queensland. The respondents to the application are Lynda Campbell and her mother, Elizabeth Campbell, who hold interests in the Burleigh Heads and Ipswich properties. This application arose from a broader dispute between eleven plaintiffs and five defendants, with the parties currently engaged in Federal Court proceedings concerning the validity and enforceability of franchise agreements, guarantee and indemnity agreements, and supply agreements. Pets Paradise, the third defendant in the broader dispute, sought leave to lodge fresh caveats over the Burleigh Heads and Ipswich properties, which are owned by Lynda Campbell and her husband, Karl Donnelly, as joint tenants, and held as tenants in common by Elizabeth and Lynda Campbell and Karl Donnelly, respectively. The applicants rely on a guarantee and indemnity agreement executed by Elizabeth and Lynda Campbell to create a caveatable interest in their favour. The applicants had previously lodged caveats over various properties, including the Burleigh Heads and Ipswich properties, which were subsequently removed by court order due to misdescription of the caveatable interests.

The primary legal issues in this case were whether Pets Paradise had a serious question to be tried with respect to the alleged duress in signing the guarantee and indemnity agreement, and whether the balance of convenience favoured the lodging of fresh caveats. The court had to consider the substantial delay between the removal of the original caveats and the application to lodge fresh caveats, as well as the uncontradicted affidavit evidence of duress in signing the guarantee and indemnity agreement. The court also had to assess whether the respondents had changed position in such a way that they would suffer detriment if fresh caveats were lodged.

The court found that the application for leave to lodge fresh caveats must be dismissed due to the balance of convenience favouring the respondents, as well as the undue delay on the part of Pets Paradise. The substantial delay between the removal of the original caveats and the application to lodge fresh caveats could not be excused, and the applicants had not given notice of their intention to apply for leave to lodge further caveats to the Campbells. Additionally, in the case of Elizabeth Campbell, the court found that there was no serious question to be tried with respect to the respondent alleging duress. The court concluded that the applicants had not demonstrated that the balance of convenience favoured the lodging of fresh caveats, and therefore dismissed the application for leave to lodge fresh caveats over the Burleigh Heads and Ipswich properties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for leave to lodge fresh caveats over two properties in Queensland, in circumstances where caveats previously lodged by the applicant have been removed pursuant to a court order. It arises in the context of a broader dispute between eleven plaintiffs and five defendants. Background The defendants are all related corporations. The plaintiffs are either parties to franchise agreements with one of the defendants, parties to a guarantee and indemnity agreement relating to the performance of obligations of franchisees who are parties to franchise agreements with one of the defendants, or parties to a guarantee and indemnity agreement relating to the performance of the obligations of such franchisees under a supply agreement with one of the defendants. The parties are currently engaged in proceedings in the Federal Court, concerning the validity and enforceability of these agreements. The applicant for leave to lodge caveats is the third defendant, Pets Paradise Franchising (Queensland) Pty Ltd (“Pets Paradise”). The respondents to this application are the eighth and ninth plaintiffs, Lynda Campbell and her mother Elizabeth Campbell. The two properties over which Pets Paradise seeks to lodge fresh caveats are situated at Burleigh Heads and Ipswich. The Burleigh Heads property is owned by Lynda Campbell and her husband Karl Donnelly as joint tenants, while the Ipswich property is held as tenants in common by Elizabeth and Lynda Campbell and Karl Donnelly, each of whom have a one-third interest. Elizabeth and Lynda Campbell are the directors and shareholders of a company called Pampered Paws Connection Pty Ltd (“Pampered Paws”). Pampered Paws is a party to a franchise agreement with Pets Paradise. By a “Guarantee Indemnity and Acknowledgment” dated 15 November 2005, Elizabeth and Lynda Campbell guaranteed the performance of Pampered Paws’ obligations under the franchise agreement. The applicant relies on clause 3.11 of that document to create a caveatable interest in its favour. Clause 3.11 reads: The Guarantor hereby agrees to charge his/her property, both real and personal, and including any future property as security in favour of the Franchisor for any debt owing to the Franchisor by the Franchisee and authorises the Franchisor to register a caveat in respect of this charge over any such property.Previous application for removal of caveats The history of proceedings before this Court has some relevance to the present application. On 11 August 2008, the plaintiffs commenced proceedings seeking orders for the removal of caveats registered by the defendants in purported exercise of and in reliance upon an authority said to be created by a relevant agreement with each plaintiff. The defendants relied upon the terms of the agreements for the creation of a charge by the respective plaintiffs and, in some cases, for the express authority to the respective defendants to register a caveat. The caveats were registered over land in South Australia, Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland (including the Ipswich and Burleigh Heads properties), Western Australia and the Northern Territory.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BLEBY J
There is no explanation for the substantial misdescription in the original caveats which caused them to be removed. Likewise, there is no explanation for the substantial delay between 23 September 2008 and 6 November 2008 when the present application was made. Pets Paradise sought to excuse the delay on the basis that it could not decide whether to make the application until after I had handed down my decision in relation to the other caveats on 27 October. In my opinion, that does not excuse the delay in filing the application. There was nothing to prevent the application being filed immediately and notice of such application being given to the Campbells, even if Pets Paradise then sought a delay in resolution of the application pending my earlier decision. That at least would have put the Campbells on notice that they might enter into any other commitments relating to the land at their peril. Indeed, Pets Paradise was on notice from what the Campbells had said in their earlier affidavits that they desired access to their respective interests in the Queensland properties for the purpose of borrowing money. It cannot now be surprised that they took that opportunity when it became available. Not only was the application not made expeditiously, but no notice of the intention of Pets Paradise to apply for leave to lodge further caveats was given to the Campbells. The Campbells would therefore be unduly prejudiced by the lodging of a second caveat.Conclusion It is not necessary in the circumstances to address a further argument put by Mr Rochow based on issue estoppel, estoppel by conduct and estoppel by representation and I do not do so. It follows that, for reasons relating to the balance of convenience and undue delay on the part of Pets Paradise, its application for leave to lodge further caveats in respect of both plaintiffs must be dismissed. In the case of the plaintiff Elizabeth Campbell, there is a further ground on which relief should be refused, namely that there is no serious question to be tried.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: BLEBY J

Full text does not contain this section.