WÄRtsilÄ Australia Pty Ltd v Primero Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

WÄRTSILÄ AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v PRIMERO GROUP LTD

[2020] SASC 185

Decision of The Honourable Justice Bampton

1 October 2020

COURTS AND JUDGES - COURTS - JURISDICTION AND POWERS - CONCURRENT JURISDICTION OF DIFFERENT COURTS - TRANSFER OF PROCEEDINGS UNDER CROSS-VESTING LEGISLATION

Application under the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (SA) to transfer this proceeding to the Supreme Court of Western Australian or alternatively to temporarily stay the proceeding – whether it is more appropriate that the proceeding be determined by the Supreme Court of Western Australia – whether it is otherwise in the interests of justice that the proceeding be determined by the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

HELD: Application dismissed – it is not more appropriate that the proceeding be determined by the Supreme Court of Western Australia, nor is it otherwise in the interests of justice to exercise the power to transfer under the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (SA).

Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (SA) s 5(2)(b); Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2009 (SA) s 13, s 22; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 12.1(2)(o), r 61.7, r 61.13, referred to.
BHP Billiton Ltd v Schultz & Ors (2004) 221 CLR 400; Cini v Pets Paradise Franchising (SA) Pty Ltd (2008) 102 SASR 177; Bankinvest AG v Seabrook (1988) 14 NSWLR 711, applied.
Garra Water Investments Pty Ltd v Ourback Yard Nursery Pty Ltd [2010] SASC 326; Dawson v Baker (1994) 120 ACTR 11; Australian Rail Track Corp Ltd v Mineral Commodities Ltd & Anor [2006] SASC 27, discussed.

WÄRTSILÄ AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v PRIMERO GROUP LTD
[2020] SASC 185

Civil:  Application

  1. BAMPTON J:     Primero Group Ltd (“Primero”) makes application to transfer this action to the Supreme Court of Western Australia pursuant to s 5(2)(b)(i) and (iii) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (SA) (“the Cross‑vesting Act”).

    Background

  2. Wärtsilä Australia Pty Ltd (“Wärtsilä”) is the Australian subsidiary of Wärtsilä Corporation, a global supplier and provider of energy solutions.  Wärtsilä was engaged by AGL Barker Inlet Pty Ltd under an engineering, procurement and construction contract to engineer, procure, and construct the Barker Inlet Power Station (“the project”).  Wärtsilä engaged Primero on 18 April 2018 to perform civil, mechanical, and electrical works, and supply of tanks for the project under a subcontract (“the subcontract”).  Wärtsilä and Primero are now in dispute regarding their respective entitlements arising under the subcontract.

    The payment claim

  3. On 2 March 2020, Primero served payment claim number 24 (“the payment claim”) under s 13 of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2009 (SA) (“SOP Act”) for the sum of $85,751,118 (ex-GST). A dispute ensued concerning the value of the works claimed in the payment claim and Wärtsilä contended that there was no available reference date to support the payment claim. Primero applied for adjudication of the payment claim pursuant to the SOP Act. On 27 April 2020,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read WÄRtsilÄ Australia Pty Ltd v Primero Group Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 185
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Wärtsilä Australia Pty Ltd v Primero Group Ltd involved an application by Primero to transfer the proceeding from the Supreme Court of South Australia to the Supreme Court of Western Australia or for an alternative temporary stay of the proceeding. The application was grounded on the argument that the Western Australian court was more appropriate to determine the dispute given the related proceedings and the common subcontract between the parties.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the proceeding should be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia or temporarily stayed, as it was argued to be more appropriate and in the interests of justice to do so. This involved a consideration of the cross-vesting legislation under the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (SA), which grants the court discretion to transfer proceedings to another court if it is more appropriate or in the interests of justice.

The court dismissed the application, finding that it was not more appropriate for the proceeding to be determined by the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The court noted that there had been no defining of the issues in dispute by the pleadings in either court, which made it difficult to identify the issues in dispute or the relevant evidence and witnesses. Additionally, there was no evidence that Wärtsilä had agreed to Primero not filing a defence in the South Australian proceeding. The court further noted that the parties had agreed to submit to the jurisdiction of the South Australian courts under the subcontract and that the project site was in South Australia. As such, the court concluded that the proceeding should remain in South Australia.

The court's decision was based on the lack of defining issues in the pleadings and the absence of evidence that Wärtsilä had agreed to the slowing down of the South Australian proceedings. The court found that there was no proper basis upon which it could identify the issues in dispute or the relevant evidence and witnesses. The court also noted that the parties had agreed to submit to the jurisdiction of the South Australian courts and that the project site was in South Australia. As such, the court concluded that the proceeding should remain in South Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, if it appears that the Supreme Court of Western Australia is the more appropriate court to determine the South Australian proceeding or it is otherwise in the interests of justice that the South Australian proceeding be transferred to the Supreme Court of Western Australia, I have no alternative but to transfer the proceeding.[8] The question of the exercise of discretion does not arise.[8] BHP Billiton Ltd v Schultz & Ors (2004) 221 CLR 400 at [14], [63], and [169].The evidence In support of its application, Primero relied on affidavits of it’s Executive Director and Chief Operating Officer, Dean Ercegovic, sworn 16 July 2020 and 20 August 2020, and an affidavit of its solicitor, Rachael King, sworn 20 August 2020 exhibiting a draft statement of claim. Wärtsilä relied on an affidavit of its solicitor, Jordan Schutz, sworn 12 August 2020. Primero objected to the admissibility of certain matters deposed to by Mr Schutz and Wärtsilä objected to the admissibility of certain matters deposed to by Mr Ercegovic. I have not taken into account any matter objected to by the parties.Primero’s submissions Primero’s application for transfer is grounded on several factors which it asserted demonstrate the Supreme Court of Western Australia is the appropriate forum to hear this claim. Primero contended that Wärtsilä has not pressed for pleadings in the Western Australian proceeding, nor has it taken steps to otherwise suspend or transfer the Western Australian proceeding. After the hearing of this application, on 24 September 2020, my chambers received an email from Primero’s solicitors stating that a statement of claim had been filed in the Western Australian proceeding. Within a day thereafter, my chambers received an email from Wärtsilä’s solicitors asserting that the email from Primero’s solicitors was sent to the Court without any warning or notice to them. Other than to note the fact of the filing, I make no further comment regarding the filing of the statement of claim as neither party has formally sought to make any further submissions regarding the application for transfer. It was submitted by Primero that it has always been clear that the attempts to resolve outstanding matters would be exhausted through the adjudication process prior to further litigation. It was submitted that the existence of the Western Australian proceeding and orders made therein show that Primero intended to litigate outstanding matters following the finalisation of the dispute resolution processes. Primero complained that Wärtsilä commenced the South Australian proceeding without notice, without demand and without warning. Primero asserted that the South Australian proceeding concerns its claims under the subcontract. It was submitted that Wärtsilä, in the South Australian proceeding, purports to determine the outstanding matters and, as a result, Wärtsilä makes claims as to the adjusted subcontract price and claim that Primero is obliged to reimburse to Wärtsilä the balance of the interim payment of $15 million. Primero asserted that it was Wärtsilä’s liquidated damages claims for delay that prompted Primero’s successful application for an interlocutory injunction in the Western Australian proceeding. It was submitted that, inevitably, the claim for liquidated damages must take in the claims for extension of time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Wärtsilä submitted that it assumed that Primero seeks a stay so as to provide for further rounds of executive negotiation under the subcontract. It further submitted that such a process would be entirely futile given the numerous rounds of previous negotiation between the parties, as identified in Mr Schutz’s affidavit and the fact that the subject matter of the claims articulated in its statement of claim have been the subject of extensive negotiations between the parties, including the processes relevant to the adjudicator’s determination on the payment claim under the SOP Act.The ‘nuts and bolts’ management decision I now turn to the “‘nuts and bolts’ management decision as to which court, in the pursuit of the interests of justice, is the more appropriate to hear and determine the substantive dispute”.[10][10] BHP Billiton Ltd v Schultz & Ors (2004) 221 CLR 400, 421 at [13], there citing Bankinvest AG v Seabrook (1988) 14 NSWLR 711 at 714 (Street CJ). Since the hearing of this application, the Court granted the application for judicial review and quashed the adjudication determination. Further, Primero has reported that it has filed a statement of claim in the Western Australian proceeding. It has not filed a defence in the South Australian proceeding. It is fair to say that, other than the parties’ respective submissions articulating what they each assert the issues to be, there has been no defining of the issues in dispute by the pleadings. As Debelle J stated in Australian Rail Track Corp Ltd v Mineral Commodities Ltd & Anor,[11] it is not desirable for applications to transfer to be made prematurely before the issues and all of the parties have been identified and that in “some proceedings it will, therefore, be preferable for an application to transfer the proceedings to be brought after the issues have been identified and the parties ascertained”.[12][11] [2006] SASC 27.[12] [2006] SASC 27 at [28]. In this matter, the absence of pleadings defining the issues in dispute in Western Australia and in this Court results in there being no proper basis upon which this Court can identify the issues in dispute between the parties in either proceeding, or the evidence that is relevant to the determination of the disputes, and/or the witnesses who will be required to give that evidence. There is no evidence demonstrating that Wärtsilä agreed to Primero not filing a defence to the South Australian proceeding. Wärtsilä contended that it has been agitating for a defence, that it agreed to the consent orders made by the Supreme Court of Western Australia but it did not agree to the slowing down of the South Australian proceedings. Mr Ercegovic’s evidence is to the effect that he will pursue any disputes remaining at the conclusion of the payment claim and adjudication process in the Western Australian proceeding. The South Australian proceeding and the Western Australian proceeding are related proceedings in that the subcontract is common to each of the proceedings. In entering into the subcontract, Wärtsilä and Primero agreed to submit to the jurisdiction of the courts of South Australia to resolve disputes concerning the project, the site of which is in South Australia. If, during the trial of Wärtsilä’s claim, the Court requires a view, that can be more easily accommodated in this jurisdiction.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.