Liquidators of Uub Pty Ltd v NWO

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

LIQUIDATORS OF UUB PTY LTD & ANOR v NWO & ANOR

[2020] SASC 121

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

1 July 2020

FAMILY LAW AND CHILD WELFARE - THE FAMILY LAW ACT 1975 (CTH) AND RELATED LEGISLATION - JURISDICTION - EFFECT OF CROSS-VESTING LEGISLATION - PARTICULAR CASES - WHEN TRANSFER REFUSED

COURTS AND JUDGES - COURTS - JURISDICTION AND POWERS - CONCURRENT JURISDICTION OF DIFFERENT COURTS - TRANSFER OF PROCEEDINGS UNDER CROSS-VESTING LEGISLATION

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - LIQUIDATORS - DUTIES AND LIABILITIES - IN VOLUNTARY WINDING UP

The first and second defendants were married in September 2007 and separated in December 2017. They have matrimonial property proceedings pending in the Family Court. In their respective Schedule of Assets and Liabilities filed in those proceedings, the defendants list, as a principal asset, funds held in two term deposit accounts. The second plaintiff in these proceedings (the company) was placed into voluntary liquidation in April 2019. At the time of liquidation, the first defendant was the company’s sole director and shareholder. In July 2019, the first plaintiffs (the liquidators) were granted leave to intervene in the Family Court proceedings. In August 2019, the liquidators and the company commenced proceedings in this Court alleging that funds of the company have been applied to purchase a series of residential properties for the defendants and to cover their personal and household expenditure. The plaintiffs allege that these payments were unreasonable director related transactions and voidable pursuant to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). Alternatively, they allege that the defendants have been unjustly enriched. The plaintiffs seek declarations, inter alia, that they are entitled to trace the proceeds from the sale of two residential properties into the fixed deposits and that a third property is held on constructive trust for the plaintiffs. The first defendant has consented to judgment being entered against him in these proceedings.

The second defendant seeks that the matter be transferred to the Family Court. She contends that, first, the proceedings should be transferred pursuant to s 1337H of the Corporations Act in the interests of justice to avoid the conduct of parallel proceedings. Secondly, the proceedings are a matrimonial cause and the Family Court has exclusive jurisdiction. Thus, s 4 of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) does not apply, and thirdly, if the Court does have jurisdiction under s 4, it should decline to exercise that jurisdiction.

Held, per Parker J, dismissing the application:

1. The proceedings in this Court are “in relation to” the proceedings in the Family Court. There is “a connection or association between the two proceedings” in the sense referred to by Gibbs CJ in Perlman v Perlman (1984) 155 CLR 474. The liquidators’ claim is a “matrimonial cause” within the extended meaning given to that term by paragraph (f) of the definition in s 4 of the Family Law Act.

2. Section 4(1)(a) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (Cth) operates so…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Liquidators of Uub Pty Ltd v NWO and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 121
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Liquidators of Uub Pty Ltd v NWO involved a dispute between the liquidators of Uub Pty Ltd, the plaintiffs, and the husband and wife, NWO and NAO, the defendants. The liquidators sought to recover funds held in term deposits by the Westpac Bank, which were allegedly assets of the company. The second defendant argued that the proceedings should be transferred to the Family Court, asserting that the claims were part of a matrimonial cause and therefore within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Family Court.

The court was required to decide whether the proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court and the Family Court were related in a way that made it appropriate for the Family Court to assume jurisdiction. The court also had to determine whether the liquidators' claim was an abuse of process or if it was made in good faith to recover assets for the company's creditors.

The court found that the liquidators' intervention in the Family Court action was not an abuse of process and was made in the exercise of their statutory duties. The court held that the proceedings did not constitute a matrimonial cause as they were not between the parties to a marriage but between the liquidators and the company on one side and the husband and wife on the other. The court further found that the proceedings in the Federal Circuit Court were not in relation to the pending property settlement proceedings in the Family Court. Therefore, the court concluded that it was not in the interests of justice for the proceedings to be transferred to the Family Court.

The court dismissed the interlocutory application made by the second defendant, holding that it was not appropriate to transfer the proceedings to the Family Court. The court's decision was based on the finding that the liquidators' claims were made in good faith to recover assets for the company's creditors and that there was no evidence to support the second defendant's assertion that the liquidation was initiated to frustrate the Family Court proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I would dismiss the interlocutory application made by the second defendant. Background The first and second defendant, NWO and NAO, were married in September 2007 and separated in December 2017. On 24 September 2018, the second defendant commenced matrimonial property proceedings against the first defendant in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. On 18 February 2019, those proceedings were transferred to the Family Court of Australia (the Family Court proceedings). UUB Pty Ltd, the second plaintiff in these proceedings (the company), was placed into voluntary liquidation on 9 April 2019. At that time, Mr J was appointed as liquidator. On 3 July 2019, in accordance with a resolution adopted at a meeting of creditors, Mr J was removed as liquidator and Mr NC and Mr DC, the first plaintiffs in these proceedings (the liquidators), were appointed as joint and several liquidators of the company. On 23 August 2019, the liquidators and the company commenced proceedings in this Court seeking the relief referred to at [17] to [21] below. As at the date of liquidation of the company, the first defendant was the company’s sole director and shareholder. The liquidators depose that the company owes creditors in the order of $5 Million. That debt comprises some $4.5 Million owed to 211 unsecured creditors, $217,000 owed to one secured creditor and a further $239,000 owed to three employees. Ten of the unsecured creditors are each owed more than $100,000. Of those, the Australian Taxation Office is owed $148,000. Other significant creditors include Return to Work SA and ASIC. The liquidators reported to the creditors’ meeting that a local government authority in another State was claiming $3.2 Million from the company. The company had lodged a counterclaim for $932,000 together with a retention amount of about $300,000. This dispute was to be arbitrated. The liquidators also reported that the company had incurred losses in excess of $1.2 Million over the preceding 21 months. In December 2008, the first and second defendants purchased the A property. The plaintiffs alleged that that was a residential property which had no connection to the second plaintiff or its business. However, the second defendant alleges that this property was a display home. In March 2016, the first and second defendants purchased the B property. At that time, a mortgage in favour of the Westpac Banking Corporation was registered on the Certificate of Title for that property, as security for a loan for which the first and second defendants were liable. The B property was a residential property and, according to the plaintiffs, was purchased by the first and second defendants for their own occupation. The plaintiffs also allege that the B property had no connection to the second plaintiff or the business that it carried on. In June 2016, a mortgage in favour of Westpac was registered on the Certificate of Title of the A property as security for a loan to the first and second defendants.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I do not consider that the assertion by the second defendant in paragraph 3 of the interlocutory application that the liquidators’ claim is an abuse of process has any substance whatsoever. The liquidators have a statutory duty to identify and recover the assets of the company for the benefit of its many and substantial creditors. In that light, I am satisfied that the liquidators intervened in the Family Court action solely to ensure that, if necessary, they were able to pursue in that Court their claim to trace and recover company assets. Moreover, I have found that there is no evidence to suggest that the first defendant initiated the liquidation of the company in an attempt to frustrate the Family Court proceedings.Conclusion For the reasons stated at [106], I am not persuaded that it is more appropriate that the Family Court decide the claims made by the liquidator to recover the funds held in the term deposits. Thus, I find that it is not in the interests of justice under s 1337H(2) of the Corporations Act for these proceedings to be transferred to the Family Court. I dismiss the interlocutory application made by the second defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There is no evidence to support the second defendant’s claim that the initiation of the liquidators’ claim is for the purpose of frustrating the Family Court proceedings. The winding up of the company occurred seven months after the Family Court proceedings commenced and prior to the second defendant’s application in that Court for access to the Westpac fixed deposit accounts. Whatever the motives of the first defendant, the winding up occurred in circumstances where there are significant creditors of the company and little by way of assets. The liquidators assert that these proceedings were commenced in furtherance of their statutory duty to ascertain and recover assets of the company, including the contents of the fixed deposits, which they assert are assets of the company. Consideration Whether a matrimonial cause The second defendant contends that the present proceedings are a matrimonial cause and therefore within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Family Court. Although the second defendant had initially contended in her written submissions that the proceedings fell within paragraph (ca) of the definition of “matrimonial cause” in s 4 of the Family Law Act, that contention has not been pressed. Nevertheless, I will briefly deal with the point. Paragraph (ca) refers to certain classes of proceedings between the parties to a marriage. As the plaintiffs have correctly noted, the proceedings in this Court are not between the parties to a marriage but between the liquidators and the company as plaintiffs and the husband and wife as defendants. On that basis, paragraph (ca) of the definition of “matrimonial cause” is not relevant. It is therefore necessary to consider whether the proceedings fall under paragraph (f). Paragraph (f) of the definition of “matrimonial cause” relevantly refers to: any other proceedings … in relation to concurrent, pending or completed proceedings of a kind referred to in any of paragraphs (a) to (eb) … Save for one exception, paragraphs (a) to (eb) refer to matters such as divorce, annulment of marriage, maintenance and the like that are plainly not of present relevance. However, paragraph (ca) is potentially relevant. This paragraph refers to:proceedings between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties to the marriage or either of them, being proceedings:(i)arising out of the marital relationship;(ii)in relation to concurrent, pending or completed divorce or validity of marriage proceedings between those parties; or(ii)… There are proceedings on foot in the Family Court between the husband and the wife concerning the matrimonial property that arise out of the marital relationship. On that basis, I am satisfied that the Family Court proceedings fall within paragraph (ca). Thus, the further question is whether the proceedings in this Court are in relation to the pending proceedings for a property settlement in the Family Court. If so, the proceedings will fall within the ambit of paragraph (f) of the definition of “matrimonial cause” in s 4 of the Family Law Act.