CDNB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

CDNB and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2018] AATA 757 (4 April 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/6613 and 2016/6612

Re:"CDNB" and "WLVM"

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member M Kennedy

Date:4 April 2018

Place:Adelaide

The decisions under review are affirmed.

.....................[Sgd]...................................................

Member M Kennedy

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP - applications for citizenship - satisfaction as to identity - no primary or secondary documentation produced - inconsistency in evidence - decision under review affirmed.

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth), s 24(3)

CASES

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Sullivan v Civil Aviation Safety Authority 141 ALD 540, [2014] FCAFC 93

Re Dhayakpa and Minister for immigration and Border Protection 148 ALD 162, [2015] AATA 310

SECONDARY MATERIALS

National Identity Proofing Guidelines

Citizenship Policy

The Stateless Project: Feyli Kurds 

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member M Kennedy

4 April 2018

  1. CDNB and WLVM arrived in Australia as unauthorised maritime arrivals on or about 13 May 2010.  They were subsequently granted protection visas after an independent merits review accepted that CDNB was a stateless Feyli Kurd, and faced a well-founded fear of persecution in his country of former habitual residence for that reason.  WLVM was granted a protection visa on the basis that she was a member of CDNB’s family unit.

  2. On 6 November 2015 CDNB and on 6 October 2015 WLVM, applied for a grant of Australian citizenship.  On 21 November 2016, a delegate of the Respondent refused to grant citizenship to either CDNB or WLVM having found she was prohibited from doing so because she was not satisfied of their identity.

  3. CDNB and WLVM applied to the Tribunal for review of those decisions on 6 December 2016.

    ISSUE

  4. The Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Act) provides for the conferral of citizenship where eligibility criteria are met.  However, the Minister expressly must not approve a person becoming an Australian citizen unless the Minister is satisfied of the identity of the person: sub-section 24(3) of the Act.  It is clear that the language of the Act prohibits the grant of Australian citizenship in circumstances where identity cannot be satisfactorily ascertained or a decision maker is not satisfied, in the sense of positively satisfied, as to the applicant’s identity.

  5. The Respondent contends in this matter that a high level of satisfaction is required, having regard to the status of a certificate of Australian citizenship as a fundamental identity document in Australia.  The Respondent contends that the principle laid down in Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 to the effect that the nature or seriousness of an issue affects the process by which the decision maker obtains reasonable satisfaction is applicable, and in this regard the grant of Australian citizenship is a very serious issue. 

  6. In Sullivan v Civil Aviation Safety Authority 141 ALD 540, the Full Federal Court rejected the notion that the Tribunal is bound to apply the decision in Briginshaw when making findings of fact that are ‘grave or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CDNB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 757
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by CDNB, who was the applicant, and the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, who was the respondent. The dispute centred on whether CDNB had satisfied the identity requirements for citizenship, particularly in light of inconsistencies in the information provided regarding his place of birth. The decision was made by Member M Kennedy of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether CDNB had provided sufficient evidence to satisfy the delegate of the Minister, and subsequently the Tribunal, as to his identity. This involved assessing the credibility and reliability of the various documents and statements provided by CDNB concerning his place of birth, and determining if these met the threshold for satisfaction required by the relevant legislation.

Member Kennedy's reasoning focused on the significant and persistent discrepancies in CDNB's stated place of birth across multiple documents, including applications for citizenship, change of name certificates, and visa applications. While CDNB provided explanations for these inconsistencies, including attributing some to errors by the Department and others to his reliance on assistance from others in completing forms, the Tribunal found these explanations unconvincing. The Tribunal noted that CDNB had never produced primary or secondary identification documents to substantiate his identity. Ultimately, the Tribunal was not satisfied as to CDNB's identity, which meant it could not approve his application for Australian citizenship.

The Tribunal affirmed the decisions under review, meaning CDNB's application for citizenship was not approved.

Background

Background to the litigation

CDNB applied for Australian citizenship, providing various documents and evidence to the Department of Immigration. He stated that he was born in Iraq on 25 August 1978, and his father had held a Green Card in Iraq. CDNB confirmed that he had never held an alternative form of identification, such as a driver's licence. He claimed that his parents were born in Iraq. However, there were discrepancies in the place of birth stated in CDNB's documents. For example, in his citizenship application, CDNB stated that his place of birth was Chnar Bashi, Iran. Similarly, his change of name certificate and a statutory declaration dated 25 October 2016 stated that he was born in Iran. On the other hand, his Titre de Voyage stated that he was born in Ilam, Iran. In an interview conducted with CDNB on 27 June 2010, the place of birth was recorded as Baghdad, Iraq, maybe. In a statement signed by CDNB in support of his application for a protection visa on 10 August 2010, he stated that he was born in Khanaqin, in northern Iraq, 3 hours from Baghdad. CDNB addressed concerns about inconsistency in his statements as to his place of birth in his statutory declaration of 24 October 2017. He stated that the Department of Immigration made a mistake in the Form 80 of 10 August 2010 by stating his place of birth was Iran. CDNB's evidence was that since this mistake, whenever he has been required to complete a form, he has never known whether to put his true country of birth or the one on some of his documents. He said that he agreed with others who helped him to complete forms and did not realise it was important to correct this mistake.

The matter before the court, CDNB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, arises from an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection to refuse an application for Australian citizenship. The applicant, CDNB, originally applied for citizenship and subsequently sought judicial review of the Minister's decision to refuse his application. The case has its origins in the applicant's submission of various documents to the Department of Immigration and Border Protection, which contain inconsistencies regarding key particulars of his identity, particularly his place of birth. The matter was first heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, where the Tribunal affirmed the Minister's decision to refuse the citizenship application. Dissatisfied with this outcome, CDNB then sought judicial review in the Federal Court of Australia, where the matter was heard and determined. Throughout the proceedings, the court examined the applicant's evidence and the various documents provided to the Department, highlighting significant inconsistencies that led to doubts about the applicant's identity and the accuracy of the information provided. The court ultimately affirmed the original decision of the Minister to refuse the citizenship application.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the hearing, Ms Stokes (for the Respondent) cross-examined CDNB about information he had provided to the Department in relation to key particulars of his identity. CDNB confirmed the evidence in his statutory declarations that he had been born in Iraq on 25 August 1978. CDNB confirmed his evidence that his father had held a Green Card. He said that when Saddam Hussein was toppled, his father was told to exchange it for a White Card, but when he returned to collect the White Card, he was told that it was now safe in Iraq and he should return. CDNB stated that he had never held an alternative form of identification, for example a drivers licence. CDNB said that his father and mother were born in Iraq.Conflicting evidence about place of birth Attention was drawn to CDNB’s application for Australian citizenship at T5[6] of 6 October 2015. In that document, CDNB’s place of birth is stated to be Chnar Bashi, Iran. Attention was drawn to a change of name certificate of 8 January 2015[7] where CDNB’s place of birth is listed as Ilam (being the name of both a province and a city in that province in Iran). Attention was also drawn to the document at T7,[8] which is a Form 80 containing personal particulars for assessment, dated 6 September 2016. The place of birth identified is ‘Tahran (sic), Iran. Attention was drawn to a statutory declaration of CDNB of 25 October 2016,[9] in which he declares that he was born in Iran on 25 August 1978.[6] Exhibit A1, T5 p38 – 2016/6613.[7] Exhibit A1, T5 p 51 – 2016/6613.[8] Exhibit A1, T7 p 60 – 2016/6613.[9] Exhibit A1, T11 p 96 – 2016/6613. CDNB’s Titre de Voyage (issued 21 September 2012) at T5[10] states that his place of birth is ‘Ilam’.[10] Exhibit A1, T5 p 50 – 2016/6613. Attention was also drawn to T15,[11] containing records of an interview conducted with CDNB on 27 June 2010, shortly after his arrival in Australia. The place of birth is recorded to be ‘Baghdad Iraq maybe’, and a more detailed description stated that CDNB lived in Baghdad. At T15[12], a statement signed by CDNB in support of his application for a protection visa on 10 August 2010, CDNB states that he was born in Khanaqin, in northern Iraq – 3 hours from Baghdad. ‘Khanaq, Iran’ is stated as a place of birth in an accompanying Form 80 of 10 August 2010 at T15.[13][11] Exhibit A1, T15 p 126 – 2016/6613.[12] Exhibit A1, T15 p 154 – 2016/6613.[13] Exhibit A1 T15 p 158 – 2016/6613. CDNB has addressed concerns about inconsistency in his statements as to his place of birth in his statutory declaration of 24 October 2017. He states that the Department of Immigration made a mistake in the Form 80 of 10 August 2010 by stating his place of birth was Iran. I note through comparing the Form 80 of 10 August 2010 to the Applicant’s statement of the same date that Khanaqin, Iraq appears to be referred to as Khanaq, Iran in documentation dated the same day. CDNB’s evidence is that since this mistake, whenever he has been required to complete a form, he has never known whether to put his true country of birth or the one on some of his documents. He said that he agreed with others who helped him to complete forms, and did not realise it was important to correct this mistake.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In these circumstances, I am not satisfied as to the identity of CDNB or WLVM. It follows that I expressly must not approve either becoming an Australian citizen.DECISION The decisions under review are affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in CDNB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection carefully examined the evidence presented by the applicant, CDNB, to determine whether the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection was justified in being unsatisfied with CDNB's proof of identity for the purposes of citizenship under section 13(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth). The court’s analysis focused on the inconsistencies in CDNB’s evidence regarding his place of birth and the absence of primary or secondary documentation supporting his identity claims.

Firstly, the court considered whether the Minister was satisfied that CDNB had satisfied the identity requirements. The court noted that CDNB provided inconsistent statements about his place of birth, with references to locations in both Iraq and Iran. The court highlighted that CDNB's statutory declarations, Titre de Voyage, and various forms submitted over time all contained conflicting information. Despite CDNB’s explanation that the Department of Immigration had erroneously recorded his place of birth, the court was required to assess whether this explanation was sufficient to alleviate the Minister's concerns.

Secondly, the court examined whether the Minister's decision to be unsatisfied with CDNB's identity was reasonable and justified given the inconsistencies. The court acknowledged the statutory declaration by CDNB confirming his place of birth as Iran, but also noted the numerous other documents stating various locations in Iraq. The court emphasized that consistency in identity evidence is crucial, and the discrepancies raised legitimate concerns about CDNB’s true identity. The court applied the principle that a failure to produce primary documentation, coupled with conflicting secondary evidence, could reasonably lead the Minister to doubt the applicant's identity.

The court further addressed whether the absence of primary documentation rendered the Minister's decision legally sound. It noted that while primary documentation is preferable, the absence of such documentation does not necessarily invalidate the Minister's decision if other evidence sufficiently supports the conclusion. In this case, the court found that the inconsistencies themselves provided a legally sufficient basis for the Minister’s decision, even in the absence of primary documentation.

Moreover, the court assessed whether the inconsistencies in CDNB's statements regarding his place of birth justified the Minister’s decision. The court held that such inconsistencies are a valid concern for the Minister when determining identity. The court applied the principle that the Minister must ensure that the applicant’s identity is proven beyond reasonable doubt, and inconsistencies in key identity details create a reasonable basis for doubt.

The court also considered the sufficiency of the Minister's reasons for being unsatisfied with CDNB’s identity. The court found that the Minister's reasons, based on the conflicting evidence, were legally sufficient to uphold the decision. The inconsistencies in CDNB’s statements, and his failure to produce consistent primary documentation, supported the Minister's conclusion.

Additionally, the court evaluated the weight of CDNB’s explanation regarding the Department of Immigration's error. The court acknowledged CDNB’s explanation but held that it did not sufficiently alleviate the Minister's concerns about identity. The court applied the principle that the applicant bears the onus to provide clear and consistent evidence of identity, and CDNB's failure to do so justified the Minister's decision.

Furthermore, the court scrutinized whether CDNB's reliance on others to complete forms and his failure to correct what he perceived as a minor error justified the Minister's decision. The court held that this reliance and inaction contributed to the inconsistencies in his evidence. The court applied the principle that an applicant must take reasonable steps to ensure the accuracy of their identity documentation and any errors, even if perceived as minor, can have significant implications.

Lastly, the court examined whether the Minister’s approach in considering various pieces of evidence, including the Titre de Voyage and statutory declarations, was appropriate and legally justified. The court concluded that the Minister's approach was reasonable, given the conflicting nature of the evidence presented. The court applied the principle that in cases of identity determination, a holistic assessment of all available evidence is necessary and justified.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a Minister for Immigration and Border Protection can reasonably be unsatisfied with an applicant's proof of identity for citizenship purposes when there are significant inconsistencies in the applicant’s evidence, even in the absence of primary documentation. The court's decision underscores the importance of consistent and verifiable identity evidence in citizenship applications, and the Minister’s discretion to doubt identity based on conflicting secondary evidence.