QSNT and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 248 (22 February 2019)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number: 2018/0853
Re:QSNT
APPLICANT
AndMinister for Home Affairs
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Member C Edwardes
Date:22 February 2019
Place:Perth
Pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits the matter for reconsideration on the basis that the Tribunal is satisfied with the Applicant’s identity within the meaning, and for the purposes of, s 24(3) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth).
..........[Sgd]..............................................
Member C Edwardes
CATCHWORDS
CITIZENSHIP - Myanmar refugee - application for citizenship refused – no birth certificate – born in rural village - whether Tribunal satisfied of identity – consideration of country information – identity satisfied
LEGISLATION
Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) – ss 24(3) – 52(1)(b)
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) – s43(1)
CASES
Ahmadi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 4189
Beyan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 256
CDNB and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 757
Confidential v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] AATA 144
Dhayakpa v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 148 ALD 162Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Attorney-General Department’s National Identity Proofing Guidelines
Australian Citizenship Instructions – Instruction 5.27.1 - Instruction 5.27.2
Department of Immigration and Border Protection – Australian Citizenship Policy – Chapter 13
REASONS FOR DECISION
Member C Edwardes
22 February 2019
THE APPLICATION
The Tribunal is asked to review the Minister’s decision (the decision) refusing to approve the Applicant’s application for citizenship. The decision was made pursuant to s 24(3) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act) which provides that the Minister must not approve of a person becoming an Australian citizen unless the Minister is satisfied of the identity of the person.
The Application for review is made in accordance with s 52(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act, which allows applications to be made to the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of a decision to refuse to approve a person becoming an Australian citizen under s 24 of the Citizenship Act.
BACKGROUND
The Applicant arrived in Australia on 22 November 2012 on a Refugee visa (XB subclass 200) (T7, 125). She is a citizen of Myanmar.
The Applicant filed an application for citizenship dated 23 December 2016. (T6, 82-115)
The Applicant provided the following documents (T6, T7):
·Western Australian motor vehicle drivers licence.
·UNHCR identity card.
·Alinta energy account.
·Western Australian Licence and Motor Injury Insurance Policy.
·Document for travel to Australia.
·Change of Name Certificate.
·Two birth certificates for her children born in Malaysia.
·A marriage certificate issued by the Methodist Church.
·Form 1399 – Declaration of service.
·Form 80 – Personal particulars for assessment including character assessment.
·Statutory Declaration.
The Delegate wrote to the Applicant on 31 January…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read QSNT and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] AATA 248
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether QSNT satisfied section 24(3) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 1948* (Cth), which requires the Tribunal to be satisfied of the applicant's identity. This involved assessing the weight to be given to various forms of evidence, including statutory declarations from QSNT, her husband, her brother, and a friend, as well as official documents such as her UNHCR identity card, marriage certificate, and the birth certificates of her children. The Tribunal also had to consider the respondent's contentions regarding the expected documentation from Myanmar and the applicant's efforts to obtain such documents.
The Tribunal reasoned that while official documentation is important, it must also consider the applicant's life story and the circumstances of her origin. QSNT provided detailed statutory declarations explaining that due to her birth in a small, rural village in Myanmar, official birth registration and documentation were not customary or available. She explained that she and her family fled Myanmar due to persecution and that attempts to obtain documents from Myanmar authorities were met with refusal, with officials stating that because she "left the country illegally," no documents could be issued. The Tribunal found that the statutory declarations from her husband, brother, and friend, who all shared similar backgrounds and experiences, corroborated her account and provided strong evidence of her identity within their community. The Tribunal also noted that her brother, who had been granted Australian citizenship, had also lacked such documentation from Myanmar.
Ultimately, the Tribunal was satisfied of QSNT's identity. It found that the evidence, particularly the consistent accounts provided in the statutory declarations from multiple individuals who knew her from childhood in Myanmar and subsequently in Australia, sufficiently established her identity despite the absence of a birth certificate. The Tribunal concluded that the circumstances of her birth and flight from Myanmar explained the lack of official documentation, and that the provided evidence met the required standard of satisfaction for the conferral of citizenship.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Applicant has provided the following statutory declarations in support of this application (A2-A5):Statutory declaration of [QSNT]I [QSNT] of [Address], Ballajura, WA 6066 hereby make oath/declare that:1.I am the Applicant in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Case No.2018/0853.2.The facts deposed to in the statutory declaration are within my own personal knowledge and, in all material respects, true and correct.3.I was born on the [Date] 1975 in [Name] village, [Name] Township, Chin State in Myannmar.4.My parents are Mr U and Mrs U. I have a brother Mr S.5.On [Date] 1996 I married Mr Y in our village in Myannmar. My husband was born in the same village as me and we now have three children. I attach a copy of my Marriage certificate.6.[Name] village is small, with only about 50 houses and 150 people living there. We all knew each other because the village was so small.7.There was never a need for me to have a birth certificate or identity document to go to school or even to get married because everyone in the village knew each other and we could all identify each other.8.My husband and I were forced to flee from Myannmar in about 2008 because of the persecution by the Burmese government of the Chin people.9.I was never issued a Birth certificate after I was born because I lived in a rural village in a remote part of the country. I was only registered with the Burmese government during the census as a member of my Fathers' family and included on his "Family List."10.When I left Myannmar I had no opportunity to take a Birth certificate or other identity documents with me because I had never been issued with a Birth certificate or any other identity document. My husband and I fled to Malaysia and I approached the UNHCR for recognition as a refugee.11.We left Myannmar illegally because we were in danger of being tortured and persecuted. I did not have a passport and could not leave through official border posts.12.ln Malaysia I did not have any form of identity from Myannmar and all my documentation from the UNHCR was based on my marriage document and confirmed by my husband and people who knew me from the village who were also in Malaysia.13.ln 2012 my husband and I were accepted for resettlement in Australia under the Refugee and Humanitarian programme. I arrived in Australia on the [Date] 2012 on a subclass 200 Refugee visa. I attach a copy of my travel document (number E02xx) and visa used to enter Australia.14.ln Myannmar it was not usual to use a surname and so my travel document is in the name of [QSNT]. The same applies to my Marriage certificate.15.ln 2015 I decided to change my name to include a surname to avoid any further difficulties with documents and documentation in Australia. On [Date] 2015 my name was officially recorded in the records of the Registrar for Births, Deaths and Marriages, WA as [QSNT]. I attach a copy of my Change of Name certificate.16.I have tried to get a Birth certificate and Identity card from Myannmar. My parents still live in [Name] village but they have informed me that the local government officials have told them that they cannot issue any Birth certificate or Identity document because I "left the country illegally."17.ln 2014 the Burmese government conducted an official census of people living in Myannmar. I was not present at the time and have been excluded from the Family List of my Father. My husband was also out of the country so no new "Family List" was made to include me in my husbands' household.18.The policy of the Burmese government is that people who have left the country illegally are not given any documentation. I fear that if my family in Myannmar try to get documents for me it will place them in danger of prosecution or persecution by the Burmese government. I believe that I have been placed on a Burmese government “Black List” of people known to have left the country illegally.19.I have consistently used the name [QSNT] all my life (until I added [Name] as a surname in Australia), it appears on my Marriage certificate and the birth certificates issued to my children in Malaysia and I have supplied the evidence of my husband, my brother and a friend to confirm my identity.20.I have been out of my country of birth for about ten years. I have lived in Australia for nearly six years. I cannot return to Myannmar because I will face persecution there so it is not possible for me to go back and get any identity documents.Statutory declaration of Mr Y.I, Mr Y of [Address], Ballajura, WA 6066 hereby make oath/declare that:1.I am the husband of the Applicant in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Case No.2018/0853, [QSNT].2.The facts deposed to in the statutory declaration are within my own personal knowledge and, in all material respects, true and correct.3.I was born on the [Date] 1970 in [Name] village, [Name] Township, Chin State in Myannmar.4.My parents are Mr D and Mrs D.5.On [Date] 1996 I married [QSNT] (now [QSNT]) in our village in Myannmar. My wife was born in the same village as me and we now have three children. I attach a copy of my Marriage certificate.6.[Name] village is small with only about 50 houses and 150 people living there. We all knew each other because the village was so small.7.I knew my wife in the village from when we were young children.8.My wife and I were forced to flee from Myannmar in about 2008 because of the persecution by the Burmese government of the Chin people.9.I was never issued a Birth certificate after I was born because I was born and lived in a small rural village in a remote part of the country. There was no government office in or near our village where births could be registered or identity documents given and most people in the village went all their lives without any birth certificate or other formal identity documents. I was only registered with the Burmese government as a member of my Fathers' family and included on his "Family List" after a census was done by the government.10.When I left Myannmar I had no opportunity to take a Birth certificate or other identity documents with me because I had never been issued with any such documents. My wife and I fled to Malaysia and I approached the UNHCR for recognition as a refugee.11.While the Applicant and I lived in Malaysia we did not have any official identity documents such as passports or birth certificates or National Identity cards.12.We left Myannmar illegally because we were in danger of being tortured and persecuted. I did not have a passport and could not leave through official border posts.13.ln 2012 my wife and I were accepted for resettlement in Australia under the Refugee and Humanitarian programme. I arrived in Australia on the [Date] 2012 on a subclass 200 Refugee visa. I attach a copy of my travel document (number E02xx) and visa used to enter Australia.14.ln 2015 my wife decided to change her name to include a surname to avoid any further difficulties with documents and documentation in Australia. On [Date] 2015 her name was officially recorded as [QSNT].15.I have tried to get a Birth certificate and Identity card from Myannmar. My parents still live in [Name] village but they have informed me that the local government officials have told them that they cannot issue any Birth certificate or identity document for me because I "left the country illegally."16.ln 2014 the Burmese government conducted an official census of people living in Myannmar. I was not present at the time and have been excluded from the Family List of my Father. No new "Family List" has been created for me and my family as we no longer live in Myannmar.17.The policy of the Burmese government is that people who have left the country illegally are not given any documentation. I fear that if my family in Burma try to get documents for me it will place them in danger of prosecution or persecution by the Burmese government. I believe that I have been placed on a Burmese government "Black list" of people known to have left the country illegally.18.I have been out of my country of birth for about ten years. I have lived in Australia for nearly six years. I cannot return to Myannmar because I will face persecution there so it is not possible for me to go back and get copies of my identity documents.19.My wife and I are part of the Daichin ethnic community in Perth. We worship regularly at the [Name] Church which is situated at [Address] Perth and we are well-known in our community.20.My wife's brother, Mr S, and his family also live in Perth and are part of our community. We regularly socialise with each other. He came with me to the airport to meet his sister (the Applicant) when she arrived in Perth in November 2012. I knew my brother-in-law when we lived in [Name] village in Myannmar.21.I also know Mr P in Perth. He was from [Name] village in Myannmar. He was also forced to flee Myannmar and we met again in Malaysia. He also came to the airport to meet the Applicant when she arrived in Australia for the first time.22.I confirm that the Applicant is the same person I knew from [Name] village in Myannmar and the same person I married in 1996 and then fled to Malaysia with. I confirm that we lived in Malaysia for about 4 years while we waited to be resettled as refugees somewhere in the world and that the Applicant is the same person who joined me in Australia in [Date] 2012 and the same person who applied for Australian citizenship, which application was refused on 31st January 2018.Statutory declaration of Mr P.I Mr P of [Address], Westminster, WA 6061 hereby make oath/declare that:1.I know the Applicant in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Case No.2018/0853, [QSNT] and make this declaration to assist in proving her identity.2.The facts deposed to in this statutory declaration are within my own personal knowledge and, in all material respects, true and correct.3.I was born on the [Date] 1978 in [Name] village, [Name] Township, Chin State in Myannmar, the same village where the Applicant, her brother and her husband were born.4.[Name] village is small with only about 50 houses and 150 people living there. We all knew each other because the village was so small. I am not related to the Applicant but we have known each other and have been friends since we were children and lived in the village in Myannmar.5.I was forced to flee from Myannmar because of the persecution by the Burmese government of the Chin people.6.I was never issued with a Birth certificate after I was born or given any other form of official identity document. There was no local government office in the village or nearby which could issue such documents and most of the people in the village spent their entire life without any birth certificate or identity document. Like most people, at census time I was registered with the Burmese government as a member of my Fathers' family and included on his "Family List."7.When I left Myannmar I fled to Malaysia and I approached the UNHCR for recognition as a refugee.8.In Malaysia I met the Applicant again after she and her husband arrived in Malaysia after fleeing from Myannmar.9.In 2012 I was accepted for resettlement in Australia under the Refugee and Humanitarian programme. I arrived in Australia on the [Date] 2012 on a subclass 200 Refugee visa.10.I do not believe it will be possible for me or the Applicant to get a birth certificate or identity document from Myannmar. The policy of the Burmese government is that people who have left the country illegally are not given any documentation. I fear that if my family in Burma try to get documents for me it will place them in danger of prosecution or persecution by the Burmese government. I believe that I have been placed on a Burmese government "Black list" of people known to have left the country illegally.11.I confirm that I have no doubt whatsoever that the Applicant is the same person I knew from [Name] village in Myannmar, the same person I met again in Malaysia and the same person who came to Australia in November 2012. I went with her brother and husband to the Perth International airport to meet the Applicant when she arrived in Australia. The Applicant is the same person who applied for Australian citizenship, which application was refused on 31st January 2018.12.We are all part of the Daichin ethnic community in Perth. We speak the same language we spoke in Myannmar. We socialise with each other regularly at the [Name] Church at [Address] where we worship on a Sunday. We also visit each other's homes.Statutory Declaration of Mr S.I, Mr S of [Address], Ballajura, WA 6066 hereby make oath/declare that:1.I am the biological brother of the Applicant in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Case No.2018/0853, [QSNT]. I have known her all my life as my older sister.2.The facts deposed to in the statutory declaration are within my own personal knowledge and, in all material respects, true and correct.3.I was born on the [Date] 1982 in [Name] village, [Name] Township, Chin State in Myannmar.4.My parents are Mr U and Mrs U.5.[Name] village is small with only about 50 houses and 150 people living there. We all knew each other because the village was so small.6.I knew husband of my sister, Mr Y, in the village from when we were young children.7.I was never issued a Birth certificate after I was born because I lived in a rural village in a remote part of Myannmar. There was no government office in the village or close by which could issue birth certificates or other identity documents. To the best of my knowledge most people in our village never had a birth certificate or identity document for their whole life. I was registered, after a census, with the Burmese government as a member of my Fathers' family and included on his "Family List."8.There was no real need for any identity documents because we all knew each other and could confirm each other's identity. When marriages took place they usually involved a couple from the village and the priest and community knew them well so there was no need to produce a birth certificate or identity document to prove who you were.9.There is nothing unusual in my sister having no birth certificate or identity documents as a person from a remote village in Myannmar.10.I was forced to flee Myannmar to avoid persecution by the Burmese government and when I left Myannmar I had no opportunity to take a Birth certificate or other identity documents with me because I never had any. I fled to Malaysia and I approached the UNHCR for recognition as a refugee.11.I left Myannmar illegally because I was in danger of being tortured and persecuted. I did not have a passport and could not leave through official border posts.12.ln 2008 I was accepted for resettlement in Australia under the Refugee and Humanitarian programme. I later brought my fiancée to Australia on [Date] 2011 and we married at the offices of the Registrar of Births, Deaths and Marriages on [Date] 2011. I attach a copy of my travel document D01xx.13.ln 2015 my sister decided to change her name to include a surname to avoid any further difficulties with documents and documentation in Australia. On [Date] 2015 her name was officially recorded as [QSNT].14.I confirm that the Applicant is my biological sister and the same person I knew from [Name] village in Myannmar and the same person who came to Australia in November 2012 and the same person who applied for Australian citizenship, which application was refused on 31st January 2018.15.I went to Perth International Airport in November 2012 with my brotherin-law Mr Y to meet my sister.16.We are all part of the Daichin ethnic community in Perth. We speak the same language we spoke in Myannmar. We socialise with each other regularly at our homes. My children refer to the Applicant as "Ni Ni" which means "Aunt" in our language and culture.17.I see my sister and her family regularly at the [Name] Church at [Address] where we worship on a Sunday.18.I am an Australian citizen. I was granted citizenship by conferral on [Date] 2013. I attach copies of my Citizenship Certificate and my Australian passport biodata page.19.I believe it will be inconsistent for my sister to be refused Australian citizenship because of lack of identity documents from Myannmar when I have been granted Australian citizenship with the same lack of documentation as my sister.HEARING