Beyan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

[2015] AATA  256

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/5256

Re

Bebe Beyan

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member CR Walsh

Date 24 April 2015
Place Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

........(Sgd) CR Walsh................................................................

Senior Member CR Walsh

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – whether Tribunal is satisfied of the identity of the Applicant – whether Applicant of “good character” – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 – s 21(2)(h) – s 24(1) -s 24(3)

Migration Act 1958 – s 107

CASES

Al Temimi v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] AARA 97

Confidential v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] AATA 144 at [34]

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Irving v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1996) 139 ALR 84

Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298; [1959] ALR 367

Lachmaiya v Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 19 AAR 148

Re Perring and Australian Postal Corp (1933) ALR 367

Prasad v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs [1994] AATA 326

Tacalan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2014] AATA 767

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Citizenship Instructions – Chapters 5 and 10

Explanatory Memorandum, Australian Citizenship Bill 2005

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member CR Walsh

24 April 2015

INTRODUCTION

  1. The Applicant seeks a review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister), on 16 August 2013, to refuse the Applicant’s application for Australian citizenship under s 24(1) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Citizenship Act) because he was not satisfied of the Applicant’s identity for the purposes of 24(3) of the Citizenship Act and that the Applicant was of “good character” for the purposes of s 21(2)(h) of the Citizenship Act.

    FACTUAL BACKGROUND & EVIDENCE

    Background to the Applicant’s permanent residence

  2. On 8 January 2007, the Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Department) received an application for a Refugee and Humanitarian (Class XB) visa (Visa Application) naming Ms Yassah Beyan as the “main applicant” (Main Applicant).

  3. The Visa Application states that the Main Applicant was born in Monrovia, Liberia on 26 July 1978 and that her parents are Gayduo Beyan (mother - deceased) and Quaqua Sackie Beyan (father - deceased).

  4. The “proposer” (or sponsor) of the Visa Application is stated (at Question 16 of the Visa Application) as being Mr Moriba Beyan (Moriba Beyan) who was born in Liberia on 15 March 1973, is the Main Applicant’s half-brother and was living in Mile End, South Australia, at the time of the Visa Application.

  5. The following seven additional applicants to the Main Applicant are included on the Visa Application (in Question 3 of “Part A – Summary of people included in this application”, under the heading “Give details of all other people included in this application”):

    (i)Mr Alphonso Beyan, - who is described as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Beyan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 256
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Beyan v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection involved the Applicant, who was seeking to have his Class XB visa cancelled. The Applicant had applied for a visa under the name of Bebe Beyan, but there were discrepancies in the information provided about his identity. The decision to cancel the visa was made by a delegate of the Minister, who found that the Applicant had not complied with the requirement in s 101(b) of the Migration Act to provide correct answers in a visa application. The Applicant sought judicial review of the decision to cancel his visa.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal was correct to affirm the decision of the Minister to cancel the Applicant’s visa. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the Tribunal was satisfied of the Applicant’s identity and whether he was a person of good character. The court also needed to consider whether the Applicant had provided correct information in his visa application.

The court found that the Tribunal was satisfied of the Applicant’s identity, despite the discrepancies in the information provided. The court held that the Applicant’s evidence was credible and that the discrepancies were due to the Applicant’s family members using their influence over other family members to prevent them from telling the Applicant that the man identified as Bebe Beyan was not in fact Bebe Beyan. The court also found that the Applicant was a person of good character and that the decision to cancel his visa was not supported by the evidence. The court held that the delegate of the Minister had erred in finding that the Applicant had not provided correct answers in his visa application. The court remitted the matter to the Tribunal for reconsideration.

The final orders of the court were that the decision of the Tribunal to affirm the decision of the Minister to cancel the Applicant’s visa be set aside and that the matter be remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around the identity and background of the Applicant, whose name is Moma Sumo Bebe Bannah, who claims to have been born on 12 April 1990. The Applicant adopted the name Bebe BEYAN out of respect for his aunt Gayduo, who passed away. He claims to have lived with his aunt for a long time and considers himself one of her sons. The Applicant is the cousin of Yasser and Alphonso, who are the Main Applicant in the Visa Application. According to the Applicant, his parents are Mary SUMO and Amos BANNAH, who are in a refugee camp along with his siblings. The Applicant states that he spoke to his parents since arriving in Australia, and they are aware that he is in Australia. The real Bebe BEYAN, however, is unknown to the Applicant, who does not know if he is in contact with anyone.

In 2009, the Applicant was interviewed by Ms Wittenbaker, where he provided information about his background. However, the Department could not locate any recording of this interview. Ms Wittenbaker's contemporaneous notes state that the Applicant provided details about his family, including his parents and siblings. There was also mention of Moriba BEYAN, who filled out the forms and sent them in, although it is not clear if he was aware of the substitution. The Applicant claims that he had been known by the same name as the real Bebe BEYAN, and since the real Bebe BEYAN could not be found, his photo was used for interviews and medicals.

The decision of the Minister regarding the cancellation of the Applicant's Class XB visa was made on 9 August 2011. The delegate of the Minister noted that the Applicant's parents, as named by the Applicant in his interview with Ms Wittenbaker on 30 April 2009, were different from the Main Applicant's parents as stated in the Visa Application received on 8 January 2007. Based on this, the delegate found that the Applicant had not complied with the requirement in s 101(b) of the Migration Act to provide correct answers in a visa application.

Ms Wittenbaker, who conducted an inquiry into the Applicant's identity in December 2008, filed and served a Statutory Declaration in relation to this application. This was tendered as Exhibit R4 (Ms Wittenbaker's Declaration). Ms Wittenbaker also gave verbal evidence at the hearing. The case involves the review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister regarding the cancellation of the Applicant's Class XB visa. The matter came before the court to determine whether the Tribunal is satisfied of the identity of the Applicant and whether the Applicant is of "good character."

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 30 April 2009, Ms Wittenbaker interviewed the Applicant. The Main Applicant and Meo Beyan accompanied the Applicant at this interview. The Department was unable to locate any recording of this interview. However, Ms Wittenbaker’s contemporaneous notes of that interview state:At interview “Bebe BEYAN” stated the following:· His full name is Moma Sumo Bebe BANNAH and his date of birth is 12 April 1990;· There are two persons with the name of Bebe BEYAN.· He had adopted the name Bebe BEYAN out of respect for his Aunt (Gayduo dec) who he had gone to live with. He stated that he had lived with everyone in the compound for a long time and considered himself one of her sons.· Gayduo is the mother of Yasser (sic.)[i.e. the Main Applicant in the Visa Application] and Alphonso.· He is the cousin of Yasser (sic.) [i.e. the Main Applicant in the Visa Application] and Alphonso and the rest of the family that came to Australia.· His mother is Mary SUMO and his father is Amos BANNAH and claims they are in a refugee camp (Mamu) along with his siblings. · Siblings are1. Sienneh (f)2. Joanna (f)3. Tarnue (m)4. Junior (m)5. Sackie (m)6. Daniel (m)· The family were unable to find the “real” Bebe BEYAN and as he was known by the same name his photo was used and he attended the interviews and had the medicals.· A definite answer as to whether Moriba BEYAN was aware of the substitution was not given Bebe claimed that he [i.e. Moriba] filled out the forms and sent them in [so] he [i.e. Moriba] should have known. I explained that Moriba had not seen Bebe since he was a small child and he relied on the family to provide him with the correct information. There was no response.· “Bebe” has spoken to his parents since he arrived in Australia and they are aware he is in Australia.· In regards to the real Bebe BEYAN, I was told that he does not know where he is and if he is in contact with anyone.Decision of the Minister regarding cancellation of the Applicant’s Class XB visa In a document titled “Record of Decision of Whether to Pursue Cancellation Under Section 109 of the Migration Act 1958”, dated 9 August 2011, a delegate of the Minister noted that the Applicant’s parents (as named by the Applicant in his interview with Ms Wittenbaker on 30 April 2009) were different to the Main Applicant’s parents as stated in the Visa Application (received on 8 January 2007), as follows:Was the visa holder the brother of Yassah? On the application form, Yassah declared her father as Quaqua Sackie Beyan and her mother as Yassah Gbawae Beyan. The visa holder now declares that his father is Amos Bannah and his mother is Mary Sumo. The visa holder and Yassah do not have the same parents. I consider that the visa holder is not the natural brother of Yassah. I consider that the answer “brother” to question 3 was incorrect. On this basis, the delegate of the Minister found that the Applicant had not complied with the requirement in s 101(b) of the Migration Act to provide correct answers in a visa application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Wittenbaker filed and served a Statutory Declaration, dated 15 December 2014, in relation to this application which was tendered as Exhibit R4 (Ms Wittenbaker’s Declaration). Ms Wittenbaker also gave verbal evidence at the hearing. Ms Wittenbaker’s verbal evidence before the Tribunal was that in about December 2008 she was asked by the Department to conduct an inquiry into the identity of the Applicant as a result of information which had been received by the Department concerning the Applicant. Ms Wittenbaker explained that, as part of that inquiry, on 7 January 2009 she interviewed Moriba Beyan, the “proposer” (or sponsor) on the Visa Application, at his residence in Perth. According to Ms Wittenbaker, Ms Daphne Cuthbertson of Centrecare and another person (whose name she could not recall) also attended that interview. Ms Wittenbaker’s Declaration states that during her interview of Moriba Beyan on 7 January 2009, Moriba Beyan stated the following:4.1 Moriba arrived in Australia on 17 September 2004.4.2Moriba’s siblings contacted him in February 2005. This was the first time he had contact with his family since they had been forced to flee the family home in 1990.4.3Moriba’s siblings contacted him via his mobile number. They obtained this mobile number from a ‘Sam’ who Moriba had befriended when they were both in a refugee camp in Conakry, Guinea.4.4After being contacted by his siblings, Moriba contacted the Department of Immigration to initiate visa application processes for his siblings, and supported his siblings by renting them a house in Conakry, paying for their food and bills, and sending them a camera to allow them to provide photographs that were required as part of the visa application process. 4.5Moriba’s siblings sent him the photographs they had taken for visa applications. Moriba was not able to identify the man in the photograph that his siblings identified as a photograph of Bebe Beyan because Moriba had last seen Bebe when Bebe was less than two years old. However, Moriba believed that the man in the photograph that his siblings identified as a photograph of Bebe Beyan was Bebe.4.6On 26 December 2008, after his siblings has been granted visa and arrived in Australia, they told Moriba that the man who had been granted a visa under the name of Bebe Beyan was not their brother Bebe, but was in fact Oman, a cousin of Moriba’s siblings Yassah and Alphanso (their mother’s older sister’s son). Oman had applied for a visa under the name of Bebe Beyan because the real Bebe was too far away for a photo to be obtained.4.7Moriba believes that his siblings Alphanso, Mulbah and Yassah used their influence over the other family members to prevent them from telling Moriba that the man identified as Bebe Beyan was in fact not Bebe Beyan. Moriba also believes that Alfonso, (sic.), Mulbah and Yassah told the other siblings that if they told Moriba that the visa applicant who identified himself as Bebe Beyan was not in fact Bebe, they would not be able to come to Australia.