Ater and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

Ater and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 4677 (11 November 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:2018/1353           

Re:Makuei Madol Ater  

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member S Burford

Member S Barton

Date:11 November 2019

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision, being the decision of a delegate of the Respondent dated
26 July 2017, is affirmed.

...................................................................

Member S Burford

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – refusal of application for Australian citizenship by conferral – satisfaction as to identity – insufficient evidence regarding identity of the Applicant – limited primary documentation produced – reviewable decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) – ss 24, 24(3), 52(1)(b)

CASES

Ahamod and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] AATA 7

Beyan and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 256

Briginshaw and Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
CDNB and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2018] AATA 757

Confidential and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] AATA 144
Dhayakpa and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015]AATA 310

Gjura and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2018] AATA 4222
Mohsin and the Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 1999
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Shafari and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 808

Sinnathamby and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] AATA 2579

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Attorney-General’s Department, National Identity Proofing Guidelines, 2016

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Australian Citizenship Policy, 1 June 2016 – Chapter 13
Supplementary Explanatory Memorandum, Australian Citizenship Bill 2005 (Cth)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member S Burford

Member S Barton

11 November 2019

THE APPLICATION  

  1. This is an application for the review of a decision by a delegate of the Respondent
    made on 26 July 2017 (the Reviewable Decision). This decision refused the Applicant’s application for Australian citizenship by conferral under s 24 of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act) (Exhibit R1, T1, p 8). The application was refused because the Respondent was not satisfied of the Applicant’s identity for the purposes of
    s 24(3) of the Citizenship Act.

    BACKGROUND

  2. Mr Makuei Madol Ater (the Applicant) claims he was born on [redacted] in Rumbek, in Sudan. Rumbek is now in the Republic of South Sudan. The Applicant arrived in Australia on 15 November 2007 on a Global Special Humanitarian (subclass 202) visa in the company of his father and two brothers.

  3. On the Applicant’s arrival in Australia, he was using the name Moses Makuei Athontung; the Global Special Humanitarian (subclass 202) visa was issued to him under that name. On 24 September 2014 he changed his name to Makuei Madol Ater (Exhibit R1, T1, p 7).

  4. On 28 May 2016, the Applicant applied for Australian citizenship by conferral (Exhibit R1, T6). On 26 July 2017, the Department of Immigration and Border Protection
    (the Department) refused the conferral of citizenship in accordance with s 24(3) of the Citizenship Act,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ater and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 4677
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse the Applicant's application for Australian citizenship by conferral. The refusal was based on the delegate's dissatisfaction with the Applicant's identity, as required by section 24(3) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007* (Cth). The Applicant had arrived in Australia in 2007 under the name Moses Makuei Athontung and later changed his name to Makuei Madol Ater in 2014.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it could be satisfied as to the Applicant's identity, given the limited primary documentation provided. The Applicant had submitted an Australian Change of Name Certificate, an Australian driver's licence in his current name, and a Document for Travel to Australia issued in 2007 under a different name, which also identified a child. The Department had requested further documentation, including a birth certificate, Medicare or Centrelink card, proof of residential address, and specific forms, but the Applicant failed to provide all of these within the allotted time.

The Tribunal considered the Applicant's explanation that he was born in South Sudan during a civil war, where birth certificates were not issued, and that his parents were illiterate. While acknowledging the difficulties in obtaining documentation from his country of origin, the Tribunal noted that country information reports indicated processes for obtaining identity documents and that South Sudan had begun issuing certificates of nationality. The Tribunal found that while some weight could be given to the Document for Travel, the Applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to satisfy the requirement of reasonable satisfaction as to his identity, particularly in light of the requests for further documentation that remained unfulfilled.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse the application for Australian citizenship by conferral.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, the Tribunal considers that given the particular significance of the consequences that flow from of the grant of citizenship, the Tribunal must be persuaded to a degree of reasonable satisfaction as to the Applicant’s identity, having regard to his particular circumstances. EVIDENCE AS TO IDENTITY In his application for the conferral of Australian citizenship, lodged 28 May 2016,the Applicant provided the following documents to address proof of identity requirements:·an Australian Change of Name Certificate, dated 25 September 2014;·an Australian driver’s licence in the name of Makuei Madol Ater; and·a Document for Travel to Australia issued by the Australian Government in 2007 in the name of Athontung Mabor Marier and identifying Moses Makuei Athontung as his child (Document for Travel) (Exhibit R1, T6, pp 99 – 101). On 29 August 2016, the Department requested the Applicant provide further documentation (Exhibit R1, T8, p 121;[5] Exhibit R2, pp 1 – 2), specifically:·copy of birth certificate;·copy of Medicare card or Centrelink concession card;·copy of evidence of the Applicant’s current residential address (e.g. Utilities or rates notice, rental contracts, bank statement);·Original Form 1195 – with original endorsed photograph/s; and ·Original Form 1399.[5] The Respondent’s submissions refer to the date of this email as 26 August 2019, a date which also appears in the Reviewable decision, however the email provided in the Department’s file appears to have been sent on 29 July 2016 with a follow-up email sent on 16 September 2016. As nothing turns on the date of the email the Tribunal places no weight on this discrepancy. The correspondence indicated that these supporting documents were required before the Applicant could be booked for a citizenship appointment. The Applicant replied to the Department on 21 September 2016 as follows (Exhibit R2, p 2, paragraph [8]; Exhibit R1, T8, pp 119 – 120):I would like to inform you that I have filled out all the basic information in the online forms on 29 May 2016 except form 1195. I will soon fill it out and send it to you.I do not have any birth certificates though as they were not provided in the villages during the time I was born. I will also send my rental contract agreement documents as well as medicare card. In response the Department asked whether the Applicant had “any documents in your possession from your birth country” and noted that the original Declaration of Service Form (Form 1399) was also required (Exhibit R1, T8, p 119). According to the Reviewable Decision and the records before the Tribunal, the Applicant failed to supply these documents to the Department in the allotted time period (Exhibit R1, T1, p 13, T8, p 119, T9, 133). While some weight was placed on the Document for Travel to Australia as a primary identity document, the delegate was satisfied the Applicant had not provided the Department with the full facts about his identity and was therefore not satisfied of the Applicant’s identity.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is an application for the review of a decision by a delegate of the Respondent made on 26 July 2017 (the Reviewable Decision). This decision refused the Applicant’s application for Australian citizenship by conferral under s 24 of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Citizenship Act) (Exhibit R1, T1, p 8). The application was refused because the Respondent was not satisfied of the Applicant’s identity for the purposes of s 24(3) of the Citizenship Act.BACKGROUND Mr Makuei Madol Ater (the Applicant) claims he was born on [redacted] in Rumbek, in Sudan. Rumbek is now in the Republic of South Sudan. The Applicant arrived in Australia on 15 November 2007 on a Global Special Humanitarian (subclass 202) visa in the company of his father and two brothers. On the Applicant’s arrival in Australia, he was using the name Moses Makuei Athontung; the Global Special Humanitarian (subclass 202) visa was issued to him under that name. On 24 September 2014 he changed his name to Makuei Madol Ater (Exhibit R1, T1, p 7). On 28 May 2016, the Applicant applied for Australian citizenship by conferral (Exhibit R1, T6). On 26 July 2017, the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (the Department) refused the conferral of citizenship in accordance with s 24(3) of the Citizenship Act, because the delegate was not satisfied as to his identity (Exhibit R1, T1, p 20). On 19 March 2018, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the decision (Exhibit R1, T1, p 1).JURISDICTION The application for review is made in accordance with s 52(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act, which allows applications to be made to the Tribunal for the review of a decision made under s 24 of the Citizenship Act. THE ISSUE The issue to be addressed is whether the Tribunal is satisfied as to the Applicant’s identity.MATERIAL BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The hearing took place on Tuesday, 20 August 2019. The Applicant appeared in person and was self-represented. The Respondent was represented by Mr Arran Gerrard from the Australian Government Solicitor, who appeared in person. The Applicant gave oral evidence and was cross-examined. The Applicant called Mr Kedir Gose as a witness, who gave evidence by telephone. The Applicant also indicated he wanted to call his brother however three attempts to contact him during the hearing were unsuccessful. The Respondent made oral submissions. The Tribunal admitted the following documents into evidence at the hearing:(a)Statutory Declaration made by the Applicant, dated 25 October 2018(Exhibit A1);(b)Identity declaration (Form 1195), dated 3 September 2018 (Exhibit A2);(c)Declaration of service (Form 1399) undated, filed with the Tribunal on 21 August 2018 (Exhibit A3);(d)copy of the Applicant’s Medicare card (Exhibit A4);(e)copy of a Residential Tenancy Agreement, dated 5 October 2017 (Exhibit A5);(f)copy of an invoice and water bill, dated 26 June 2018 (Exhibit A6); (g)copy of a Marriage Certificate issued on 12 May 2017 (Exhibit A7); (h)T documents (T1 – T10, pp 1 – 135) (Exhibit R1);(i)Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, dated 15 February 2019 (Exhibit R2);(j)copy of a page from the Republic of South Sudan Passport of Mapet Athontung Mabo Marier, identified as the Applicant’s brother (Exhibit R3);(k)copy of a page from the Republic of South Sudan Passport of Aluel Manuer Khok Kich, identified as the Applicant’s mother (Exhibit R4);(l)Refugee and Special Humanitarian Proposal (Form 681) completed by Athontung Mabor Marier, identified as the Applicant’s father, dated 21 February 2011 (Exhibit R5);(m)Application for an Offshore Humanitarian Visa (Form 842) completed by Aluel Manuer Khok Kich, identified as the Applicant’s mother (Exhibit R6);(n)LandInfo Report on Documents in Somalia and Sudan, dated 5 January 2009 (Exhibit R7);(o)Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) Country Information Report Sudan, dated 27 April 2016 (Exhibit R8); and(p)DFAT Country Information Report South Sudan, dated 5 October 2016 (Exhibit R9). RELEVANT LEGAL PRINCIPLES

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This evidence is considered further below. Statutory Declaration – No Birth Certificate In his Statutory Declaration dated 25 October 2018 (Exhibit A1, p 3), the Applicant states:I was born in Rumbek, South Sudan on August 15, 1990, in a little village within Rumbek known as Mathiang, at the time of civil war when birth certificates were not provided. So I am declaring that I have no birth certificate. In the Applicant’s evidence before the Tribunal, he contended that he was born during the civil war at home to parents who could not read or write. The Applicant further contended that his home birth, civil war and the Sudanese government’s indifference towards the people in his region were all contributing factors to him not being issued a birth certificate or any other form of documentation. He stated that the first official identity documentation he received was a ration card issued to him when he was in a refugee camp in Uganda. The Tribunal notes that the LandInfo Report for Somalia and Sudan reported that while the percentages of births registered in Sudan is high, “[w]here no midwife is in attendance, the duty to register [the birth] is only met to a limited extent and the number of children registered is much lower” (Exhibit R7, p 12). Moreover, as the DFAT Country Information Report for Sudan observes, “[l]ong-term instability in Sudan has had a detrimental impact on reliable identification documentation” (Exhibit R8, p 27). The Applicant stated, in oral evidence and in an email dated 21 August 2018 to the Tribunal accompanying his Declaration of Service, that he had contacted South Sudanese posts in India and Ethiopia to retrospectively obtain identity documents (Exhibit A3). The Applicant stated that, to the best of his recollection, he may have also telephoned the post in India and emailed the post in Ethiopia but neither approach was successful. The Applicant has not provided the Tribunal with any documentary record of these efforts. The Applicant indicated he did not seek documents from the Sudanese Embassy in Australia. The Applicant told the Tribunal that, given he knows they would not have any records of him, there would be little point in doing so. The Respondent’s submissions (Exhibit R2, p 4) drew the Tribunal’s attention to both the LandInfo Report on Documents in Somalia and Sudan and the DFAT Country Information Report for Sudan. The former outlines a process by which persons, like the Applicant, can contact the Sudanese Department of Statistics’ Birth and Death Register to confirm their birth is unregistered. The DFAT Country Information Report for Sudan also advises that birth certificates and other identity documents can be requested and issued. The DFAT Country Information Report on South Sudan indicates that the South Sudanese Government has started issuing certificates of nationality which are often in the form of a national identity card (Exhibit R9, p 25, [5.23]-[5.24]). The report further notes:… Certificates of nationality can be issued to an individual of any age and are issued on the basis of information provided, with no supporting documentation required at the time of application.DFAT understands that some South Sudanese Embassies have issued ‘Sudan People’s Liberation Movement (SPLM) Identity Cards’. SPLM Identity Cards are issued on the basis of information provided and DFAT understands that authorities rarely test the accuracy of this information.