Shafari and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Shafari and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 808 (7 May 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/3549

Re:Sher Shafai

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member D. J. Morris

Date:7 May 2019

Place:Melbourne

The decision under review is set aside and the matter is remitted to the Respondent with a direction that the Applicant satisfies section 24(3) of the Act.

....[sgd]..............................................................

Senior Member D. J. Morris

Catchwords

CITIZENSHIP – citizenship by conferral – delegate refused application for citizenship – not satisfied of identity of applicant – veracity of document provided – birthdate changed historically – other documents supportive of identity – Tribunal limited to review question before decision-maker – decision under review set aside and remitted with direction

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), s 37
Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth), ss 10, 21, 24

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Cases

Ahmadi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2017] AATA 1086
Beyan and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2015] AATA 256
Bramwell v Repatriation Commission (1998) 185 ALR 623
CDNB and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2018] AATA 747
Dhayakpa and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, Re [2015] AATA 310
Gjura and Minister for Home Affairs, Re [2018] AATA 4222

Hospital Benefit Fund of Western Australia Inc v Minister for Health, Housing and Community Services (1992) 39 FCR 234

Secondary Materials

Australian Citizenship Policy, Department of Immigration and Border Protection (1 June 2016), Chapter 13 - Identity

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member D. J. Morris

7 May 2019

  1. On 15 January 2014 Mr Sher Shafai applied for Australian citizenship by conferral.  On 19 June 2018 a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (the Minister) refused to grant Mr Shafai citizenship because the delegate found that Mr Shafai failed to satisfy the provisions of section 24(3) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)(the Act) and was not satisfied of Mr Shafai’s identity.

  2. On 26 June 2018 Mr Shafai applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision on the basis that the delegate erred in failing to be satisfied as to the Applicant’s identity.

  3. The hearing was held on 22 February 2019.  Mr Shafai was represented by Mr Manfred Ewikowski of Visa Assist Australia, assisted by Mr Nathan Willis.  Mr Adam Cunynghame of Sparke Helmore represented the Respondent.  Mr Shafai gave evidence and was cross-examined.  The Tribunal was assisted by an interpreter in the Hazaragi language.

  4. The Respondent lodged a volume of documents under section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)(‘T’-documents), which were entered into evidence. The Respondent also lodged a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 22 October 2018. The Applicant lodged a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 24 September 2018. The Applicant also lodged a letter from VicRoads to the Applicant’s legal representative (Mr Willis), dated 21 September 2018 (Exhibit A1); a statutory declaration of the Applicant dated 14 February 2019 (Exhibit A2); and three bundles…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Shafari and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 808
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for Australian citizenship by conferral made by Mr. Shafai, an Afghan citizen. The delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs refused the application, being unsatisfied as to Mr. Shafai's identity, primarily due to concerns about the authenticity of a provided Taskera (an Afghan official identity document) and discrepancies in his stated date of birth. Mr. Shafai sought review of this decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether it was satisfied of Mr. Shafai's identity for the purposes of section 24(3) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 1948* (Cth). This involved assessing the veracity of the documents provided by Mr. Shafai, particularly the Taskera, and considering the evidence relating to his date of birth, which had historically changed. The Tribunal's review was limited to the question before the original decision-maker.

The Tribunal found that while the Taskera provided by Mr. Shafai was not an authentic document, as confirmed by Afghan authorities, this did not preclude a grant of citizenship. The Tribunal accepted Mr. Shafai's evidence that his original Taskera, obtained by his father in infancy, was lost in a fire and that he had not personally obtained a Taskera as an adult in Afghanistan. Furthermore, the Tribunal was satisfied that Mr. Shafai's corrected date of birth of 24 March 1961, based on his father's recollection of an inscription in the family's Holy Koran, was plausible and convincing. Taking into account Mr. Shafai's overall history, conduct in Australia, corroborative evidence, and the credibility of his testimony, the Tribunal concluded that he satisfied the identity requirements under section 24(3) of the Act.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the delegate's decision and remitted the matter to the Respondent with a direction that Mr. Shafai satisfies section 24(3) of the Act, with the Respondent to then consider the remaining requirements for citizenship.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At the conclusion of the hearing, the Tribunal directed the Respondent to provide a copy of the Taskera (i.e. the Afghani official identity document) provided to the Department of Home Affairs by the Applicant, and for both parties to make written submissions, which they did.Background Mr Shafai is from Afghanistan and is an Afghani citizen. He first arrived in Australia on 7 May 2009 as an unauthorised maritime arrival. On 16 September 2009 he was granted a Protection (Class XA) Subclass 866 visa (T6, p 52). The Department accepted that Australia’s international obligations were engaged in relation to Mr Shafai. A useful summary of the perilous situation for a Hazara Aghani (such as Mr Shafai) is set out by Deputy President Sosso in Ahmadi and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 1086 (Ahmadi), from [29] to [35]. On 18 August 2018 Mr Shafai was granted a Resident Return (subclass 155) visa, which he currently holds. On 15 January 2014, Mr Shafai applied for Australian citizenship by conferral (T13, p 138). On 14 March 2018, an officer of the Department wrote to Mr Shafai (T9, p 111) seeking a range of additional information relating to Mr Shafai’s apparent former residence in Pakistan, documents relating to a Pakistani tourist visa, his Afghan driver licence, and “any other paperwork or documentation that evidences your life story prior to your arrival in Australia.” By letter dated 16 April 2018, Mr Shafai’s legal representatives responded to the Department, provided a range of information and stated:To assist the Delegate in further verifying the Applicant’s identity attached copies of his travel documents and drivers licences have been supplied. We submit these documents satisfy the ‘identifying information’ definition of the Act s 3 and satisfy the s 24(3) need to establish identity (Budilay v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 508 at [6]).We advise that copies of Passports of the Applicant’s family members and Taskera documents for the Applicant’s family members are attached, together with translations. On 30 April 2018 an officer of the Department wrote to Mr Shafai (T7, p 42) and offered the opportunity for him to comment on adverse information that the officer said may lead to a decision to refuse his application to become an Australian citizen. Specifically, the Department advised Mr Shafai that, in respect of the Taskera provided as evidence of his identity, the Department had contacted the Afghanistan Central Civil Registration Authority (ACCRA) National Identity Verification Centre in order to determine if the Taskera was genuine. The ACCRA had advised that the information contained in the Taskera did not correspond with its records and that the Taskera was not issued by the Afghan Population Registration Directorate (APRD). In addition, the Department advised that the copies of Taskeras relating to Mr Shafai’s wife (but see below) and eight children had also been referred to ACCRA which had provided a similar response, that the information contained in these documents did not correspond to ACCRA’s records and that they were not issued by the APRD.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Ewikowski submitted that the Applicant’s identity was satisfied to the standard of the so-called ‘three pillars test’ set out in the Policy – Refugee and Humanitarian (The Protection Visa Guidelines), at the time Mr Shafai was granted a protection visa; and that the personal identifiers contained in his protection visa and subsequent identification documents have been accepted by government agencies, such as VicRoads and the Queensland Department of Transport and Main Roads, as being determinative of Mr Shafai’s identity.Evidence of the Applicant Mr Shafai was asked about the identity declaration included in his application for Australian citizenship (T15, p 148) and who had witnessed it. He said the witness was a bank manager who he had known for around two years, having opened a business account at his branch. He said in order to open the bank account he had provided a Queensland driver licence and a letter from a business. Mr Shafai was taken through testimonials he had provided to the Department. He said that Mr Eid Mohammad Baqeri (T7, p 65) is a friend he had known for around seven years who assists him when he needs help writing documents in English. Mr Branko Levak (T7, p 66) is his landlord, whom he has known for between three and five years. Ms Margaret Nagy (T7, p 68) is a lady to whom Mr Shafai had sold a car and who brings her vehicle in for services to his auto-mechanic business. She states that she has known Mr Shafai for two and a half years. Mr Shafai said, when he obtained his Victorian driver licence, he provided his Afghani driver licence to VicRoads. He said that he had left his Afghani licence in Afghanistan when he left and that a friend had later brought it to Australia. He told the Tribunal that he had since lost the Afghani driver licence. In answer to a direct question from the Tribunal about what records were made of his birthdate at the time of his birth, Mr Shafai said that his date of birth was recorded in the family’s Holy Koran but that, later, their home was attacked by the Taliban and burnt. Mr Shafai said that his late father had told him that his date of birth had been registered at the local Taskera office. Mr Shafai said he could not remember what date he said he was born when he first arrived in Australia, but accepted that the Department had recorded it as 1 January 1965 at the time. He said that his father subsequently told him that the date 1 January 1965 was not his date of birth; Mr Shafai told the Tribunal that this date had been his estimation at the time he was interviewed on arrival. He said that when his father advised him that this was not his actual date of birth “we arranged for a person in Afghanistan to sort it out, and paid them by transferring the money” and obtained a Taskera. He said that his father had since advised him that his date of birth is 24 March 1961. Mr Shafai said that his father would read the Koran each morning and remembered his son’s date of birth recorded on the last page of the holy book. Mr Shafai was asked whether he was ever issued a Taskera while in Afghanistan, and he said he was when he was very young; his father obtained it, but that specific Taskera was destroyed when their family house was burnt.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, on balance I am satisfied that, taking into account the whole of Mr Shafai’s history, conduct in Australia, the corroborative evidence of that conduct, and the consistency and credibility of his evidence at the hearing, that he satisfies the requirements of section 24(3) of the Act in terms of his identity.DECISION The decision under review is set aside and the matter is remitted to the Respondent with a direction that the Applicant satisfies section 24(3) of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Accordingly, this consideration will be confined to whether the Tribunal is satisfied of Mr Shafai’s identity and, if so, the matter would be remitted to the Respondent with a direction to that effect. The Respondent would then consider the remaining requirements of the Act.CONSIDERATION In regard to of Mr Shafai’s birthdate, the Tribunal is satisfied that the date he originally provided of 1 January 1965 was an ‘estimation’ based on his knowledge of his approximate age and based on the fact that Mr Shafai grew up using the Solar Hijiri calendar rather than the Gregorian calendar as used in Australia. The Tribunal notes that Mr Shafai provided his corrected date of birth (24 March 1961) in his Personal particulars for assessment form (T12, p 120) as well as the earlier, erroneous, date of 1 January 1965 (T12, p 121). The Tribunal found the evidence of Mr Shafai that he corrected his date of birth to 24 March 1961 (in June 2010, T2, p 16) following a conversation with his late father, and his evidence that he based this date on what he, the Applicant’s father, recalled inscribing in the family Koran at the time of Mr Shafai’s birth, not only plausible but convincing. The recording of family birthdates in a family Holy book is a common practice in many cultures. The fact that Mr Shafai said that his father used to read from that copy of the Koran each morning added to the verisimilitude of this evidence. The Tribunal finds that Mr Shafai’s birthdate is 24 March 1961. In terms of the Taskera provided to the Department, the Tribunal finds that this is not an authentic document, based on the advice the Respondent received from the ACCRA that the document was not issued by the Afghani Government PRD. The Respondent noted that the delegate found that Mr Shafai ought to have been aware of the process for obtaining a Taskera. The Tribunal notes that the delegate wrote (T2, p 15) “Since you have already been through the process of obtaining a Taskera, I am disinclined to believe that you were unaware of how that process works.” As it turned out from the oral evidence at the hearing, this assumption by the delegate was an incorrect assumption. Mr Shafai had not, himself, previously obtained a Taskera. On his evidence, which the Tribunal accepts, his original Taskera was obtained by his father when he was an infant, aged between 2 and 3. The Tribunal considers that this would be reasonable practice for any parent to obtain a necessary identity document for a relatively new-born addition to the family. The Respondent did not contest the evidence of Mr Shafai that the original Taskera was lost when his family home was destroyed by fire, initiated by the Taliban. There was no evidence to support the assertion that Mr Shafai had obtained a Taskera as an adult when he was in Afghanistan, so therefore could be reasonably expected to know what the process was. The Tribunal notes that the Respondent accepted in submissions that the provision of a genuine Taskera is not a prerequisite for the grant of citizenship, and that the Tribunal needs to come to a state of satisfaction, standing in the shoes of the Minister, as to Mr Shafai’s identity, in order to determine whether section 24(2) of the Act is met.